Is God right wing?

Peace4u said:
Through scriptures you can see Jesus being God died on the cross for our sins

Yep, that's what the scriptures say -- but as someone educated in the Catholic school system, while I can't speak authoritatively as to the mystical reasons why Jesus "died on the cross," I can speak to the _practical_ reasons.

Jesus died on the cross because the temple authorities viewed him as a threat and lobbied the government, the "powers that be," to deal with him. And they went further, to spin doctoring ("the son of god") and propagandizing (bribing the people in the street with silver to demand the release of Barabas, the murderer).

Sound like anyone we know? Like maybe the evangelical right in the US today????

What's totally obscene is that the "Christian right" exploits Jesus' name. Let's face it: when Jesus walked the earth, he didn't aspire to politics or government or law enforcement or even to temple heirarchy. No. He walked among the common people and never sought to place himself above them. He served them, ministering and counseling. Jesus never sought to enact human social law to enforce his vision. Jesus never judged (except maybe that one time, with the "money changers" -- precursors of the "corporate interests"?? -- in the temple).

Those who invoke Jesus' name and yet who choose methods shunned by Jesus are suspect. Wasn't there something about Satan adopting the facade of the righteous man to deceive us?

..c..
 
WoodPeckr said:
God is definitely a left winger and neutral politically, remember JC was the original Hippy.

That being said religion in gereral is an OK concept. The problem arises when too many people just take it too damn seriously!

Our founding fathers realized this. It was a main reason for leaving Europe, to get away from those religious zealots and this was central in their keeping Church and State separate.....as it should be.

We don't need Dubya playing the role of Oliver Cromwell along with his Roundheads (Rove included).

LOL, a real student of history here.

Just what God would want, casual religion and belief.

What an idiot.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Jesus Christi was asked: Of all commandments which is the first?
He said: Love thy neighbor as you love yourself for the love of God.
And who is your neighbor...?

Read on. Who amongst you that is without sin throw the first stone.

Jesus Christi is the God of Love, of forgiveness, of acceptance.
He transcended the decalogue. There are two Gods: that of the
Old Testament and the New Testament.

Being loving is not being casual. It is following the lead of JC.
Don't ever question the religious beliefs of those that have a
different view than you. Your not a member of the Trinity.
I would agree with you on almost all of what you said.But the God of the old and new testament are one in the same.Love is the greatest comandment,even to love your enemies.
 
Originally posted by WoodPeckr
God is definitely a left winger and neutral politically, remember JC was the original Hippy.

That being said religion in gereral is an OK concept. The problem arises when too many people just take it too damn seriously!

Our founding fathers realized this. It was a main reason for leaving Europe, to get away from those religious zealots and this was central in their keeping Church and State separate.....as it should be.

We don't need Dubya playing the role of Oliver Cromwell along with his Roundheads (Rove included).


onthebottom said:
LOL, a real student of history here.

Just what God would want, casual religion and belief.

What an idiot.

OTB

Ahhh, OTB don't go acting as one of Oliver Cromwell's strident puritanical Roundheads of yore............:p

Yes I have dabbled in history a bit. History is really quite fascinating, teaches one quite a bit about the past in the hope that the mistakes of the past will not be repeated. Dad of Dubya had a far superior grasp of history than his poor son, Dim-Witted Dubya (just how the hell 'W' got through Yale is beyond me....oh yes that legacy thingy).

Anyways history is a far better study, as one learns how various countries, religions, political systems, philosophies, ethical models and systems evolve and develop throughout time. Studying history gives one a better perspective to view the world and what goes on in it than say, Economics, where all you learn is fuzzy math and how to manipulate stats., faulty logic and false assumptions in a manner to make an invalid model look valid. Perfect case in point is Dubya's economic policy of the past 4 years that can only be graded as a complete failure and utter disaster for the USA.

I know, I know Rush Limbaugh speaks glowingly about Bush's economic policy and how wonderfully it is coming along......but we all know it's not Rush talking, it's the OXYCONTIN talking.......

Honestly I can't see anyone taking Rush seriously anymore.
The Far-Left Wing Libs had that LSD infested Timothy Leary preaching to the hippies.
The Far-Reich Wing GOP has that OXYCONTIN infested Rush Limbaugh tooting his flute to his mindless lemmings as they scurry along behind ingesting his droppings as Rush leads them to that fabled river.......Wish Rush could quicken his pace a bit.......
 
JoyfulC said:
....Jesus died on the cross because the temple authorities viewed him as a threat and lobbied the government, the "powers that be," to deal with him. And they went further, to spin doctoring ("the son of god") and propagandizing (bribing the people in the street with silver to demand the release of Barabas, the murderer).

Sound like anyone we know? Like maybe the evangelical right in the US today????

What's totally obscene is that the "Christian right" exploits Jesus' name. Let's face it: when Jesus walked the earth, he didn't aspire to politics or government or law enforcement or even to temple heirarchy. No. He walked among the common people and never sought to place himself above them. He served them, ministering and counseling. Jesus never sought to enact human social law to enforce his vision. Jesus never judged (except maybe that one time, with the "money changers" -- precursors of the "corporate interests"?? -- in the temple).

Those who invoke Jesus' name and yet who choose methods shunned by Jesus are suspect. Wasn't there something about Satan adopting the facade of the righteous man to deceive us?

Excellent points.
The more things change, the more they remain the same. Those who don't study history and condemned to repeat it.

A strong case can be made for Bush being the Anti-Christ mentioned in the Bible.
 
DonQuixote said:
There is no far left Timothy Leary preaching to hippies.

DQ,
Was just pointing out what happened in the past during that 'flower child' era. I said back then the Far left had Timmy Leary as their head Guru.
 
Originally posted by bbking
It's the certainty that they are right that makes
born again Christians so wrong. There is no such
thing as blind faith in fact basic Christianity
teaches free will which is kind of hard to have
when you're blindly playing follow the leader.

This is the crux of the issue (no pun intended). What really sets
aside the monotheistic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) is the
fact that they all about 'the monopoly on being right' or righteousness.
They are all structured as messages/prophecies revealing The One (and
only) True God. People will say 'The Devil', but not usually 'The God'...
This is because you are supposed to know there can only be one.

It is this premise, that there is a monopoly on righteousness,
that produces the response of self-certainty in the religious among us.
First, you convince yourself that there is only one Truth, which is
objective, and is known and intended by 'The God' (who is omniscient &
omnipotent). Then you describe how this Truth is revealed to you (usually
involves a prophet although sometimes the medium is the message- see Jesus
Christ). Presto! One rigid, unipolar moral universe....I think screwge
mentions 'moral absolutes'. Anyway, imagine the reaction if you were to say:
"Actually, I understand that you are following the advice of your God on this
one, but I happen to have it, on good authority, that your God, in fact,
is completely out to lunch on this one, and so, you too, it seems, are,
regrettably, mistaken." Galileo, I feel for thee: It's finally safe
after hundreds and hundreds of years to admit that you may have been
onto something with the whole 'planets revolve around the sun' thing...
(screwge beats me to this point too, heh.)

William S. Burroughs said something like: "Never do business with a religious
man. He figures God is on his side, so he'll have no trouble screwing you in
the bargain..."

Where this all gets very messy is when you realize how beliefs define identity-
that is how we become attached to some ideas and make them Our beliefs/ Our values...

Originally posted by JoyfulC
Wasn't there something about Satan adopting the facade of the righteous man to deceive us

Ah, the wolf-in-sheep's clothing. Similarly, what would a fascist enterprise,
posing in the guise of a democracy look like?

Anyway:

Perhaps it is the flaws in the parts that reveal the perfection of the whole...
Perhaps it is the flaws in the Whole that reveal the perfection of the parts...
Perhaps it is the perfection of the parts that reveal the flaws in the whole...
Perhaps it is the perfection of the whole that reveal the flaws in the parts...
 
Winston said:
... not a construct made to fit into our view of how things should be.

We have been given freedom of thought, and freedom of choice. We are clearly chosing to decide that God shares Christian values. But I wonder if that is at all true.

You have to remember God is a man-made construct in the first place. Sort of a mystical 'wish-fulfillment.' That is why God varies so much from one culture to the next, all the result of human freedom of thought and freedom of choice.

If there was one God he would be universal in design, all people would see God in the same way. This has never been the case so people define God as they would wish He were, relative to their peculiar cultures.

If you choose the construct of a 'perfect' God then you are stuck with being unable to explain the 'problem of evil.' Chosing an 'imperfect' God reduces God to a glorified superhero, hardly a satisfying alternative. This debate has been ongoing for a few thousand years.
 
bbking said:
You know Wood, I might agree with you if you called a Church a man made construct - but for a God that believes in free will as the God of the children of Abraham does, that God would never be of universal in design. But this is an argument that no-one can win on either side and is a matter of faith but I suggest to you that where your point of view comes from is the doctrine of various religions and churches which are most definately man-made.

bbk

I feel God and Church are a man made construct. The free will argument is just an attempt to do an end around, the 'problem of evil' and in the end fails. It fails because it fails to explain both, natural disasters, hurricanes, floods, earthquakes, etc., and diseases, the black death, cancer, malaria, aids, birth defects, etc. That God of Abraham is just that a God the children of Abraham constructed to fit their model of what God ought to be and as such is different from the God of Tibetians, Aztecs, Polynesians or the Maoris of New Zealand. People have always searched for the one universal God and ended up with thousands of Gods.

Faith then becomes that 'fall back' postion and a very dangereous one at that. Once people are willing to follow on faith, they are open to all kinds of exploitation as has been shown throughtout history from Hitler who used it, to Bush jr., who uses it now. I prefer what the late Dr.Carl Sagan, renowned scientist and philosopher said, "I'd rather know than believe." I had posted earlier on page 6 of this thread his article on this point. Here is the link to that very interesting article on how Bush would rather have you follow him by 'faith' rather than 'knowledge':

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4454.htm

Agree with you on the point this is a no-win argument. After all it has been going on for a few thousand years.