Is fish good for you?

Just an aside here...I firmly believe that products fortified with Omega 3s are not worth the extra money. They are twice as expensive as the original product, and often the amount of Omegas contained within is negligible. A better buy is a bottle of Salmon oil.

Just my 0.02 on that.

Or eat salmon...

I totally overhauled my diet 4 years ago (March 29th 2006). I cut out ALL processed foods, eat whole grain breads/ cereals, low fat dairy, lots of fresh fruits and veggies, and meats that are high in protein (you may recognize the 4 food groups), and try and eat fish once or twice a week... a bit more often in the summer. I also exercise daily... and don't take vitamins or pharmaceutical drugs of any kind...

I dropped 60 lbs, and look and feel like a changed man... on top of which, I haven't been sick since.

Coincidence? I think not...
 
The only oils that have Omega 3s are fish oils and flax oil as well as in some nuts (in smaller amounts) as the poster above stated.
Great posts randygirl! Excellent and informed information. But I believe you forgot to mention hemp oil. It too is rich in Essential Fatty Acids/Omega 3.
 
Great posts randygirl! Excellent and informed information. But I believe you forgot to mention hemp oil. It too is rich in Essential Fatty Acids/Omega 3.

Yeah, hemp is good stuff! Really good stuff. I believe chia seeds have it, as well.

I stick to fish, though. Or flax, but not flax oil, freshly ground flax. The oil of flax gets too rancid when it's out of the seed, period. I can't stomach it.

Cycleguy pointed out that eating fish is important, as well. I totally agree. But for the amount of Omega 3s I include in my diet, it would be impossible to get it solely by eating fish without dying of mercury poisoning.

He also pointed out that cutting out processed foods overhauled his health. I believe that a good diet is absolutely essential to good health, and a great place to start is to cut out the white: white flour, white sugar and white rice. You can up your consumption of Omega 3s simply by switching to whole grain breads with seeds in them.

Whole wheat bread even tastes processed to me now!
 
Ah I thought I'd read somewhere that they were fed a feed made up of concentrated fish. The study makes sense if the feeder fish are contaminated then the farmed fish would be more so.

Guess our polluting the environment so extensively is coming back to bite us in the ass eh?

For those in their 50s do youremember the videos in school of the pulp and paper mills, steel mills, and chemical plants spewing millions of gallons of toxic waste out of their 60" outlet pipes untreated directly into the great lakes?

For the life of me I still can't fathom how anyone, or any company, could think of that as a reasonable way to dispose of their waste.

Remember the old photos in Time Magazine of U.S. Navy sailors dumping drums of nuclear waste into the Atlantic Ocean? I remember it quite well, as the photo caption said "the nuclear waste is enclosed in specially made drums that will keep it contained for at least 50 years". Great. I think that issue was in 1962...
 
If you don't consider fresh filets, which would be safer to eat in large quantities - canned tuna or canned salmon?
Do they have equal levels of mercury in them?
 
Canned salmon would have less mercury in it than tuna. The bigger the fish, the higher levels of mercury. Tuna is bigger than salmon, and so would have more mercury.

Generally. As per a previous post, apparently if it's farmed salmon being fed fish meal, then levels are higher...yuck.

As with everything...in moderation is the best advice.
 
A better bet than cod liver oil, if you want to take Omega 3s, is to buy Salmon oil. It is body oil, not liver oil, and contains nothing besides EPA and DHA, the two fractions of Omega 3s that are responsible for good health (plus carrier oils on occasion). There are many really good Salmon oil supplements on the market today, which are moleculary distilled and ultra purified to be free from contaminants.

randygirl, can you shed some light on what EPA and DHA are? You mentioned that they are components of Omega 3. Someone else told me EPA is Omega 3 and DHA is Omega 6.
I recommend getting a super concentrated form of Omega 3 supplement, more bang for your buck and you have to take less pills. In some of the studies I read regarding Omega 3s and mental health, upwards of a gram of EPA per day was needed to show results. Since most supplements contain 180mg of EPA and 120 of DHA, you would need to take at least five pills a day. There are some Omega 3 supplements in stores now containing 500mg of EPA per capsule, which is really amazing.
I am familiar with a supplement that 520mg of EPA and 8mg of DHA, a ratio of 6.5 to 1. I am told that this is far superior than normal fish oils that contain a much lower ratio.

Omega 3s cured my seasonal depression...For this reason I am a big advocate.
What dosage of DHA and EPA did you take to overcome your seasonal depression, if you don't mind sharing that information?
 
randygirl, can you shed some light on what EPA and DHA are? You mentioned that they are components of Omega 3. Someone else told me EPA is Omega 3 and DHA is Omega 6.

EPA stands for eicosapentanoic acid, and DHA stands for docosahexanoic acid. They are the two components of fish oil, but are chemically different and have slightly different properties. Fish oil contains both, so when fish oils supplements are made they contain both in differing amounts depending on the manufacturers choice. Don't let the names throw you off, they are just named to reflect nomenclature in chemistry of fats. I believe the names refer to length of the strand of fatty acids. They are both Omega 3s, but have differing lengths, EPA has two less carbon atoms than DHA (20 and 22, respectively) Omega 3s are polyunsaturated, long chain fatty acids. The names of fatty acids, Omega 3 and 6, refers to the double bond in the molecule, and where it's located...Omega 3s double bond is located in the third carbon position, 6s at the sixth carbon position.

I had never heard that DHA is Omega 6! I don't believe that is a correct statement, but someone correct me if I'm wrong. Omega 6s are also known as linoleic acid, and are generally known to be converted to inflammatory molecules in the body (like prostaglandins...the molecule that taking tylenol or aspirin blocks). By the way, we all get waaaayyyyy too many Omega 6s in our diets. Omega 3s compete with Omega 6s for receptors in the body, and crowd them out. A popular theory is that a higer Omega 6 to 3 ratio causes disease.

I am familiar with a supplement that 520mg of EPA and 8mg of DHA, a ratio of 6.5 to 1. I am told that this is far superior than normal fish oils that contain a much lower ratio.

I firmly believe this statement! Seeing as fish oil is an oil, it is very difficult to overdose on. If we take a look at all the other fats in our diet, typically we get upwards of thirty grams a day or more, yet most people only supplement with a gram or so of Omega 3s. In my opinion, if you are only willing to take a gram of Salmon oil per day, and are expecting results, you should save your money.

As for EPA concentrated supplements, the studies I perused regarding mental health and Omega 3s stated that only EPA was active in reducing symptoms of mental illness. Many of the new "emotions" Omega 3s supplements contain very high levels of EPA and very low levels of DHA. In general, EPA is more active in the body than DHA, but I'm not sure why that is.


What dosage of DHA and EPA did you take to overcome your seasonal depression, if you don't mind sharing that information?

I will be honest here, and say that my regime is not for everybody! I was taking fully one third of my fat calories from Omega 3s at one point. Ten or more pills a day, ten grams of oil, roughly two grams of EPA, one gram of DHA. When I started taking fish oil way back when, there were no concentrated supplements.

With the advent of the 500mg EPA supplements, I'm in fish oil heaven! I take about five pills a day now, for a total of 2500mg or 2.5 grams of EPA.

My seasonal depression was very severe, and clinical. In my late teens and early twenties I used to go to bed in January and not wake up until the end of March! It has been six or seven years since I've had seasonal depression like that. I also know that it was the fish oil that helped, as when I started supplementing, Omega 3s were the only thing I was on.

The research is finally catching up to my experience, and there are tons of studies regarding Omega 3s and mental health. They are VERY GOOD for the brain! Omega 3s have even been shown to lessen the severity of symptoms in schizophrenia, one of the most debilitating mental diseases. How cool is that?

Omega 3s have made a dramatic impact on my health and well being.
 
Last edited: