Is fish good for you?

OddSox

Active member
May 3, 2006
3,143
2
36
Ottawa
There's always lots of advice freely given that eating fish is good for you.

But the details seem to be missing. I mean is a, chunk of cod slathered in batter and deep fried along with a big serving of fries and gravy - really healthy?

I like lots of sardine sandwiches and pickled herring - do they have Omega3? Nobody seems to know.

Is sardnes packed in water healthier than sardines in oil? Maybe the oil has Omega3, or maybe it has saturated fats - who knows?

Help me.
 
Yes, fish is good for you. Some are better than others, you will have to do a check on the internet to see what is best for you. Fresh is better than canned. Stay away from the fat, butter, fries and battered fish.
 
But the details seem to be missing. I mean is a, chunk of cod slathered in batter and deep fried along with a big serving of fries and gravy - really healthy?
No, of course not. It's also probably not cod either since that fishery is pretty much gone. The added crap more than out weighs the benefits.

I like lots of sardine sandwiches and pickled herring - do they have Omega3? Nobody seems to know.
Most cold-water fish are loaded with Omega 3 Fatty Acids. So yes...

Is sardnes packed in water healthier than sardines in oil? Maybe the oil has Omega3, or maybe it has saturated fats - who knows?
Healthier packed in water. The oil is typically vegetable oil i believe...

Generally fish is good for you, although you should limit the amount of Great Lakes fish since they contain heavy metal, and some known carcinogens in small amounts, especially apex fish... salmon, trout etc.

On the other hand, worldwide, fisheries are terribly threatened... Tuna is damn near an endangered species, and many fishing practices are extremely harmful to the environment.

You can also get Omega 3s from flax and some nuts...
 
A chunk of fish battered and fried is generally not good for you. Aside from the fat calories from being cooked in grease, the carbohydrates aren't doing a person any favors. Fish should be broiled, grilled or poached, not fried in oils.

Sardines and herring have VERY HIGH LEVELS of omega threes. Also, because they are lower on the food chain, tend to have less mercury in them than bigger fish. The mercury builds up in the bigger fish because they eat the little fish (like sardines) and then the mercury becomes concentrated in the body of the big fish. Little fish tend to live off of vegetation, and so build up less mercury.

Sardines packed in water is healthier than packed in oil, simply due to the reduction in calories by being packed in water. The only oils that have Omega 3s are fish oils and flax oil as well as in some nuts (in smaller amounts) as the poster above stated. Flax is highly unsaturated and tends to go rancid easily, and so it is not generally used in food preparation. Other oils that are good for you are the ones that contain unsaturated fatty acids, or polyunsaturated fatty acids such as Olive oils and Canola oils. The oil in Flax does not contain Omega 3s, but does contain the necessary molecules that our body can convert to Omega 3s.

Oils and fats are a massive subject in nutrition, there is so much to know and the information can be confusing. Generally speaking, though, unsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids are where it's at in terms of healthy fats.

Fish that contain good amounts of Omega 3s: Salmon, sardines, herring, mackerel

Flax contains alpha linolenic acid that your body can convert to Omega 3s.

Good oils contain polyunsaturated or unsaturated fats, and are LIQUID at room temperature: Olive oils, sunflower oil, canola oil

Fried foods are terrible for your health.
 
Last edited:
Excellent info here. True dat there is so much to learn, can get confusing.

For example, a dozen eggs cost $2. Now Omega 3 eggs cost double $4. People love buying them.
But is it not true that if you heat an item, it kills Omega 3? So unless you're Rocky Balboa who drinks raw eggs every morning, no point in paying double for Omega 3, cause most people either boil or fry eggs which needs heating.

Now yes, fried food is bad. Question is.........if a guy who buys Big Mac everyday for lunch switches to Filet -O-Fish.......I think thats a improvement don't you think?
 
^supposedly Omega3 eggs have less ldl cholesterol, so even if the omega3 breaks down, it's still a better egg.

fish can be great for your diet... just gotta be smart with what kinds you are eating and how it is prepared. I have salmon steaks every Friday... and I enjoy other 'pink' flesh freshwater fish such as trouts.

smelts, sardines and herring are good, but I wouldn't be able to stomach them more than once a month each.
 
Fish is good for you, but some fish are not. I read about a study in the US where they found that a lot of poor people ate a lot of frozen fish sticks because it was cheap and convenient. Not only was the fat and breading bad for your health, but very often people would burn the fish sticks and the black charred crumbs became a source of carcinogen that increased the risk of cancer. They also found that poor people ate a lot of baloney and hot dogs which contain a lot of fat, salt and nitrates that also increase the risk of cancer.
 
Generally speaking seafood is very good for you... provided it is lightly seasoned, NOT breaded or battered and cooked properly.

Prepared and served the way it was suggested in the OP... IS NOT!

I would also buy wild caught vs farm raised........

OTB
 
it depends on whether you are eating the fish or the fish is eating you
 
I keep reading nothing but good things about Wild Alaskan Pink Salmon. Not only is Salmon very good for you but the Alaskan Wild is supposed to be "least contamiated". I am trying to work it into my diet in salads with Bumble Bee Premium Wild Alaskan Pink Salmon.
 
I've read that most fresh salmon served in restaurants or sold in stores is farmed while generally canned is ocean caught wild salmon which is preferable to farmed.

I usually have two or three tins of salmon in the cupboard for a sandwich but why not buy a bottle of codliver oil pills if you want omega 3's?
 
I any of you have a link to the studies showing farmed fish not being as good as wild I'd be interested to read it. To me, it seems that the opposite should be true. Many have stated here that wild fish build up chemicals and mercury whereas farmed fish are fed a strict tightly controlled diet and their environment is also controlled.

As for the Big Mac eater switching to filet o fish: that's like playing russian roulette with an automatic then switching to a revolver. Both will kill you, just one is guaranteed to kill you quicker......
 
Ah I thought I'd read somewhere that they were fed a feed made up of concentrated fish. The study makes sense if the feeder fish are contaminated then the farmed fish would be more so.

Guess our polluting the environment so extensively is coming back to bite us in the ass eh?

For those in their 50s do youremember the videos in school of the pulp and paper mills, steel mills, and chemical plants spewing millions of gallons of toxic waste out of their 60" outlet pipes untreated directly into the great lakes?

For the life of me I still can't fathom how anyone, or any company, could think of that as a reasonable way to dispose of their waste.
 
I usually have two or three tins of salmon in the cupboard for a sandwich but why not buy a bottle of codliver oil pills if you want omega 3's?

Believe it or not, you can actually overdose on cod liver oil. The reason for this is that it is extremely high in vitamin A, a fat soluble vitamin. Unlike water soluble vitamins which are excreted via the kidneys when in excess, fat soluble vitamins are stored in fat cells. When a fat soluble vitamin is taken in excess, the symptoms of overdose can be a long time in appearing, and a very long time in disappearing because it takes a long time for your fat cells to release the vitamin to be processed by your liver.

A better bet than cod liver oil, if you want to take Omega 3s, is to buy Salmon oil. It is body oil, not liver oil, and contains nothing besides EPA and DHA, the two fractions of Omega 3s that are responsible for good health (plus carrier oils on occasion). There are many really good Salmon oil supplements on the market today, which are moleculary distilled and ultra purified to be free from contaminants.

I recommend getting a super concentrated form of Omega 3 supplement, more bang for your buck and you have to take less pills. In some of the studies I read regarding Omega 3s and mental health, upwards of a gram of EPA per day was needed to show results. Since most supplements contain 180mg of EPA and 120 of DHA, you would need to take at least five pills a day. There are some Omega 3 supplements in stores now containing 500mg of EPA per capsule, which is really amazing.

If I had to give up every supplement I take and only choose one for the rest of my life, I would choose an Omega 3 like Salmon oil. It is so beneficial, and we don't take nearly enough or get enough in our daily diets. I read in a health magazine that the increase in mental illnesses can be directly traced to the industrialization of the food chain (ie, processing foods). We are processing ourselves into the grave, literally.

Omega 3s are good for every major system in your body: cardiovascular, brain, blood, endocrine...every cell is made up of a phospholipid bilayer, adding good fats literally feeds your body at a cellular level.

Omega 3s cured my seasonal depression...For this reason I am a big advocate.
 
Just an aside here...I firmly believe that products fortified with Omega 3s are not worth the extra money. They are twice as expensive as the original product, and often the amount of Omegas contained within is negligible. A better buy is a bottle of Salmon oil.

Just my 0.02 on that.