Is America a failed state?

oil&gas

Well-known member
Apr 16, 2002
17,168
3,459
113
Ghawar
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Global_Economy/LA20Dj02.html

Jan 20, 2010
by Spengler

Barack Obama won the Democratic nomination and then the presidency by
offering the same program that Peter Pan gave the Darling children:
Close your eyes, think happy thoughts, and you will be able to fly. "Yes
we can" in the meantime has changed to "No he can't," as America lost
five million jobs in 2009 and its effective unemployment rate, including
so-called long-term discouraged workers, rose to 22%, a level unseen
since the Great Depression.

Within 24 hours, the voters of Massachusetts may turn the freshly-baked
president into a prematurely lame duck, by electing an obscure Republican
to the senate seat held for a generation by Ted Kennedy. If that occurs,
Obama's veto-and-filibuster-proof
majority in the senate will disappear and faint hearts in his own party
will hedge their bets on the proposed public healthcare program. The
Republicans should be careful what they wish for: no one is voting for
the opposition, for the Republican party has no economic program and no
unifying theme except its objection to Obama. The voters are protesting
a radical change in their status for the worse, and will penalize whoever
has the misfortune to be in power.

During December, more than 600,000 workers disappeared from the
official count of the American labor force, erasing the illusion
that the employment situation would recover. But the voters knew that
before the economists. The most reliable index of economic sentiment
is the president's deteriorating approval rating. For a by-the-numbers
explanation of why the US economy will not recover, see my October 6,
2009, essay, Obama's permanent depression.

America is the world's most successful state, and the one with the
greatest longevity in its present constitutional form. But neither of
the major parties is presently capable of governing it. The Republicans
have been hoping that rage against Obama's failed economic policies
would carry the party through the November congressional elections. But
it is entirely conceivable that the Obama presidency will implode as
quickly as the Obama campaign metastasized during the 2008 primaries,
and that the electorate will call the Republicans' bluff.

Americans understood well enough in early 2008 that the traditional
leadership of both parties had led them into a dead-end. As I wrote in
January 2008 (Obama bin lottery) after Obama's surprise landslide in
the South Carolina Democratic primary:

People of modest means do not understand the stock market,
but they are sly: they can read the panic in the eyes of their
leaders. After assuring them for months that all was well,
Washington last week offered an emergency interest rate cut for
the first time since September 11, 2001, and an emergency economic
package which will send a small check to every American family earning
less than a certain threshold. Both President George W Bush and [Bill]
Clinton proposed essentially the same program. If that is "managerial
ability", thought the voters of South Carolina, we might as well
buy the lottery ticket.

That is why at that time, January 2008, I believed America was going
for Obama: "America faces not a dip in the business cycle, but the end
of a 25-year run of wealth creation. Rising home prices were supposed
to provide America's retirement nest egg, the substitute for the savings
that Americans never amassed ... Despite massive evidence to the contrary,
they still cling to the delusion that 20 years from now, everyone will
retire by selling his home to his neighbor at double the price. It is
like the passengers on the Titanic selling each other annuities."

Obama appealed to the voters' bottom-dollar hope that a new face in the
White House would reverse the tide of misery. He did not have to offer
specific promises: he only needed to give the voters the opportunity to
kid themselves, which they were eager to do considering the unpleasant
taste of the alternative.

The electorate is like Archilochus' hedgehog, which knows one big thing,
rather than the fox, which knows many things, in the classical aphorism
cited by Russian-British philosopher and historian, Sir Isaiah Berlin. In
2008, the voters knew that the capital gains and home equity cushion
gleaned during the Ronald Reagan boom were at risk, and that the likes
of presidential candidate John McCain as well as former candidate, now
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, would not make things different. A
vote for Obama under these circumstances had no downside from the vantage
point of the ordinary household, and they held out the hope that Obama
actually might have a magic wand up his sleeve. The voters were not
entirely misguided, for the current economic situation almost certainly
would have been just as bad under a McCain administration.

The big thing that the American electorate has learned during 2009 is
that Obama is all talk. There are many little things that annoy voters:
special treatment for trade-union health plans, a Treasury secretary who
seems to have given special treatment to Goldman Sachs in the rescue of
the insurance giant AIG, and a confusing foreign policy. But the idling
of one-fifth of the population overwhelms every other issue. Tens of
millions of families that only two years ago felt affluent and secure
are now anxious and impoverished. And Obama can do nothing about it.

When Reagan took office in 1981, the baby boomers were in their 20s and
30s, America had a 10% savings rate, the current account was in surplus,
and America was the world's largest net creditor nation. Reagan was able
to cut taxes and finance an enormous budget deficit because the world's
demand for US Treasury securities was correspondingly large. In 2010,
the baby boomers are in their 50s and 60s, America has saved nothing for
a decade, the current account remains in severe deficit and the world
is choking on the existing supply of Treasury securities. Cutting taxes
to stimulate the economy is not as simple this time round.

Professor Reuven Brenner and I argued in the December 2009 issue of
First Things that fundamental changes in American economic policy
are required to emerge from the Great Recession. We proposed that the
United States fix the dollar to the Chinese yuan and other currencies
in order to re-orient trade flows to the developing world. We added,
"We have been borrowing in order to consume; we need now to save in order
to invest. We need to shift the tax burden, moving it away from savings
and investment and toward consumption. We should replace individual and
corporate income taxes with consumption-based taxes."

Americans need to be told that they will need to invest before they can
consume, and that the cure will take years rather than months to take
effect. It's not a happy message, and no one in politics is willing to
deliver it - if indeed anyone in politics understands it.
 
No, America is not a "failed state". The policy disagreements and wrangling at the government level have not interrupted the functioning of the major organs of the state. The courts, the police, the schools, the banks, the military, all continue to function. People may have suffered some loss of income, but people are not starving, the hospitals are working, more or less. In fact, Americans continue to enjoy a higher standard of living than most people in the developed world, and even if that falls, it won't fall to developing nation levels--it might fall, in the extreme worst case, to Italian levels.

It would be wrong to confuse a policy logjam with a collapse of the institutions of the state, which have continued on perfectly fine throughout many policy logjams in the United States.
 
fuji, just wondering if you are an American citizen.
 
Is America a failed state?

"Barack Obama won the Democratic nomination and then the presidency by
offering the same program that Peter Pan gave the Darling children:
Close your eyes, think happy thoughts, and you will be able to fly."


"America is the world's most successful state, and the one with the
greatest longevity in its present constitutional form."

"The big thing that the American electorate has learned during 2009 is
that Obama is all talk. There are many little things that annoy voters:
special treatment for trade-union health plans, a Treasury secretary who
seems to have given special treatment to Goldman Sachs in the rescue of
the insurance giant AIG, and a confusing foreign policy. But the idling
of one-fifth of the population overwhelms every other issue."


"Professor Reuven Brenner and I argued in the December 2009 issue of
First Things that fundamental changes in American economic policy
are required to emerge from the Great Recession. We proposed that the
United States fix the dollar to the Chinese yuan and other currencies
in order to re-orient trade flows to the developing world. We added,
"We have been borrowing in order to consume; we need now to save in order
to invest. We need to shift the tax burden, moving it away from savings
and investment and toward consumption. We should replace individual and
corporate income taxes with consumption-based taxes."

Americans need to be told that they will need to invest before they can
consume, and that the cure will take years rather than months to take
effect. It's not a happy message, and no one in politics is willing to
deliver it - if indeed anyone in politics understands it."
LOL well one might be forgiven for thinking so if they based their knowledge of the U.S. upon what is posted here on TERB.

A few grains (posted above) amidst the chaff, and a quixotic monetary proposal.
 
yes, america is run by the similar people who ran GM and chrysler.....

and we all know how they ended up !
 
No, but the conclusion is correct, we need more domestic savings and less consumption.

OTB
 
No, but the conclusion is correct, we need more domestic savings and less consumption.

OTB

As usual and as expected you totally ignore and give a free pass the many crooked Bankster bastards that are still in charge! These thieves should have been tried in court, then given the RED Chinese sentence of a bullet in the head, or at least be in be in prison with their pal Madoff.

A Law & Order guy you are NOT bottie.....:cool:
 
No, but the conclusion is correct, we need more domestic savings and less consumption.
OTB

This is a straaaaange statement from someone who leans to the right. Do you mean save "cash" when the US Government prints it faster? Where is all that cash the gov is printing faster if no one can save it? Where is it......WAIT! I know!

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Far from a "failed" sate but definitely a state in decline. It all started with rent control in the Bronx about 60 years ago.
 
This is a straaaaange statement from someone who leans to the right. Do you mean save "cash" when the US Government prints it faster? Where is all that cash the gov is printing faster if no one can save it? Where is it......WAIT! I know!

Gyaos Baltar.

I think citizens should save money - I have no expectations that the Congress will follow.....

OTB
 
Far from a "failed" sate but definitely a state in decline. It all started with rent control in the Bronx about 60 years ago.

LMAO.....

Productivity was up 8% in Q3.... sad that I know that actually.....

OTB
 
But, it is up from 80 year lows. The decline of the U.S. started about 60 years ago with the inception of welfare payments 16 year old single moms.

That is complete and utter nonsense.

Even if the US was not in decline, which it surely is, it has still failed to
provide for the weakest members of it's society. That is a failure no matter
how prosperous the society ON AVERAGE is.
 
There are a few politicans and business men and women, on the left ,and the right...and in the middle...who truly care about the future of the United States.The rest are greedy whores who will do anything for power and are slowly bringing about the decline of western civilization.I agree with carlin.They're just circling the bowl.
 
it has still failed to provide for the weakest members of it's society.

Why do we always avoid the hard question of why they are the "weakest" members of society? There are generations of families who view welfare as a normal way of life. My friend said that Koreans come here and in one generation they achieve upper middle class status. Meanwhile there are 2nd to 10th generation locals on welfare.
 
Why do we always avoid the hard question of why they are the "weakest" members of society?

You and your kind are the only ones that avoid the question. The answer is well known. Most civilized
countries have implemented a solution to the problem.

If there was a reasonable welfare system, the children of disadvantaged members of society would have if
not an equal chance as the more priviledged, then at least a chance of succeding in society. Why anybody
(like you) think it is reasonable to punish children for their parent's shortcomings or disadvantaged status
in life, is beyond me.
 
LMAO.....

Productivity was up 8% in Q3.... sad that I know that actually.....

OTB

Sadder still that it's an indication of how many people are out of work and that even with the stimulus dollars employers still aren't hiring. They're simply asking their current employees to do more because they see this as temporary. No doubt it helps your personal bottom line. LMAO.....
 
If there was a reasonable welfare system, the children of disadvantaged members of society would have if not an equal chance as the more priviledged, then at least a chance of succeding in society.

Sir, what do you consider a "reasonable" welfare system? How many Portuguese, Chinese, East Indian, Korean, Filipino immigrant families do you see on welfare? Do you know that the top 10% of graduating high students is virtually entirely populated by students from Asian immigrant families?
 
But, it is up from 80 year lows. The decline of the U.S. started about 60 years ago with the inception of welfare payments 16 year old single moms.

Bet you learnt that baloney listening to El Rushbloe!
You sound like a full blown dittohead, no?.....:p
 
Ok, does anybody here support 16 year old unmarried girls having babies? Let's hear it.

Call me whatever you like but I feel that 16 year old girls should finish their education and start a career before entertaining any thoughts of having children. Come on, start your name calling.