Intrusive??

buttercup

Active member
Feb 28, 2005
2,564
11
38
This from a buddy in UK.

It's for maintaining your membership in a British professional society. The questions marked with a star are mandatory, others optional.

Diversity

The x x x Regulation Board is committed to promoting equality and diversity. It is important to us that our services are accessible to you. The information you provide will help and be used in accordance with the Data Protection Act 1998. The information will be treated as confidential, stored in a secure system accessible to authorised persons only and will be disposed of in accordance with our data disposal policy.

The information will help us undertake regular analysis and evaluation of our policies, procedures and processes to ensure that they promote equality of opportunity and do not unlawfully discriminate.

Please note this page will only appear on your first visit to the x x x site, if you wish to update this data at any stage in the future please do so by visiting Your Account page.

*Ethnicity
Asian or Asian British
- Bangladeshi
- Indian
- Pakistan
- Any other Asian background
Black or Black British
- African
- Caribbean
- Any other black background
Chinese
Mixed
- White and Asian
- White and Black African
- Any other mixed background
Other ethnic background
White
- British English
- British Northern irish
- British Scottish
- British Welsh
- British Other
- Irish
- Roma/Gypsy
- Traveller of Irish Heritage

*Religion or Belief
Buddhist
Christian
Hindu
Jewish
Muslim
Sikh
No religion
Other

*Gender
Male
Female

*Sexual Orientation
Bisexual
Gay Man
Heterosexual / Straight
Lesbian / Gay Woman

Is your gender the same as the gender you were assigned at birth? (optional)
Yes
No

Do you consider yourself to be disabled as defined by the Equality Act 2010? (optional)

The Equality Act 2010 gives the definition of disability as ''a person has a disability if they have a physical or mental impairment, and the impairment has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities''.

If you have a disability and require any reasonable adjustments when communicating with us, for example if you require communication in large print or Braille, please fill in this box. If you do not have a disability, leave the box blank. Our reasonable adjustment policy is here and if you need any further requirements please contact us.
 
Rather depends upon whether is is anonymous or not, it certainly is far more through in breaking out ethnicity than most such surveys in North America.
 
I don't think it's intrusive because if you're going to have a census, you may as well be accurate. Having said that, I struggle with the word 'ethnicity' because the dictionary definition is pertains to one's culture, but most people interpret it as race.

Let's say you have someone that was raised in Canada (culturally Canadian), born in the Caribbean, and is of mixed Indian and white race. Oh, and not religious, though baptized a Christian. What is his ethnicity? How is he supposed to answer something like this?
 
It's not a survey, and it's not anonymous. It's from a professional regulating body.

It's not doctors, but imagine being a doctor. In order to mainatin your name on the register of doctors (without which you cannot practice), you have to fill in this form. With your name on. It goes into your record. All the labels you give yourself remain on your record. You can change your labels later, but then the new labels will remain on your record.

It would be just the same if it was electricians -- imagine if you had to fill in a form like this, in order to continue to be qualified as an electrician. Or a plumber, or a dentist, or anything.

The regulators are demanding that Jews, for example, must label themselves as such, in their official professional record! How do you explain to people who cannot see it for themselves, just how offensive that is?

Hard to believe there is no-one here as outraged as I am, by this.
 
Why is Chinese the only Asian ethnicity that is specified? What if you are Korean or Japanese?

Why are British/Irish the only white ethnicities mentioned? What if you are German or Dutch? Or Serbian?
 
It's not a survey, and it's not anonymous. It's from a professional regulating body.

It's not doctors, but imagine being a doctor. In order to mainatin your name on the register of doctors (without which you cannot practice), you have to fill in this form. With your name on. It goes into your record. All the labels you give yourself remain on your record.
In that case it is indeed intrusive. I'm not sure why they need all this information linked to your name.

Then again this is one of those North American differences we are not nearly so complacent about giving answers like this as those on the other side of the pond.

Same thing with DNA samples, can you imagine the outrage if the OPP or New York State Police asked every man in a 80 km/50 mile circle to give a DNA sample? Yet this has been done several times even in the U.K. let alone on the Continent.