Incest Marriage?

"No union is more profound than marriage, for it embodies the highest ideals of love, fidelity, devotion, sacrifice, and family. In forming a marital union, two people become something greater than once they were. As some of the petitioners in these cases demonstrate, marriage embodies a love that may endure even past death. It would misunderstand these men and women to say they disrespect the idea of marriage. Their plea is that they do respect it, respect it so deeply that they seek to find its fulfillment for themselves. Their hope is not to be condemned to live in loneliness, excluded from one of civilization’s oldest institutions. They ask for equal dignity in the eyes of the law. The Constitution grants them that right.
The judgment of the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit is Reversed.
It is so ordered.”



I hear ya ! But lets just take one step at a time although i'm positive this would go through like butter in the deep south !
 
You weren't asking for reasonable accommodation, you were asking for biblical precedent. Which I provided. But now you have suddenly decided that nope, we're no longer interested in biblical precedent but contemporary laws and interpretations. So suddenly we're no longer playing cricket, you've just brought out a tennis racket and have won the game. Well congratulations.
Original premise was that the case for the incest can made be based on a Biblical text. It cannot. The story of Lot, or Adam and Eve are not precedents. Eating shelfish was legal until the time of Moses. Adam and Eve could eat shelfish, so did Abraham. After Moses it was no longer legal. After Paul it changed again(for Christians). Some Christians call this Progressive Revelation. You just don't understand how religious law operates in a Judeo or Christian traditions, that's all. Common enough mistake.
 
There are limits. If it results in more harm than good (i.e., incest, or plural marriages) then it ain't on. But by all means, if you have a problem with gay marriage, please tell us what harm it results in.

I don't have a problem with gay marriages, but the OP brings up the topic of incest marriage which I'm totally against that.
 
I don't have a problem with gay marriages, but the OP brings up the topic of incest marriage which I'm totally against that.
Glad to hear it. The "more harm than good" argument is a good filter to use when people propose slippery slope arguments about gay marriage. Good, but not perfect: the idea of same-sex incestuous marriage may slip by this filter. Other than creeping people right the fuck out, what societal harm would there be from incestuous marriages with no offspring?
 
Its an interesting point. However, i think the reasoning falls apart with the "How would it harm the rest of us" part of the argument. A brother and sister, unlike two gay men or two gay women, can biologically produce an offspring. That offspring is at serious risk for a wide range of mental and physical disabilities caused by in-breeding. At that point, its hard to argue that a third party has not been harmed by the social acceptance of incest.

Also: Eww.

^^^^ this.
With emphasis on Ewwww
 
"The opinion is couched in a style that is as pretentious as its content is egotistic. If, even as the price to be paid for a fifth vote, I ever joined an opinion for the Court that began: 'The Constitution promises liberty to all within its reach, a liberty that includes certain specific rights that allow persons, within a lawful realm, to define and express their identity,' I would hide my head in a bag. The Supreme Court of the United States has descended from the disciplined legal reasoning of John Marshall and Joseph Story to the mystical aphorisms of the fortune cookie."

Justice Scalia's Dissent

With the greatest of respect to Justice Scalia, he should realize that "bad facts make bad law" - or in this case, fuzzy-cuddly feelgood law. Every other western legal system now accepts gay marriage and this concept has to be accommodated, even if there is no framework of constitutional analysis which cleanly encompasses it. Hence, vague, grandiose statements and a lot of fuzzy-cuddly, "we all know this is right, don't we?" rhetoric.

Fact is, same-sex has arrived; everybody else does it; and it's dumb for the USA not to do it too. So write a judgment that protects it and move on to the next damn case. And if Scalia wants to grandstand about how juridically superior his own legal reasoning is, we'll keep our eye-rolling to ourselves.

You sit around here and you spin your little webss and you think the whole world revolves around you and your decisions. Well it doesn't Mr Scalia. In. The whole vast configuration of things. I'd say you were nothing but a scurvy little spider
 
This[referring to the folk-belief that children of incest are certain to be defective].

However, two women can produce a child. Two eggs can create a baby. Sperm is not needed, although the offspring can only be female.


http://www.dnaindia.com/lifestyle/report-planet-of-the-women-1700432
And their child, like the offspring of brother and sister (or other incestuous pair) are at no greater risk of inherited disabilities than any baby of parents who spawn without genetic advice. A child of incest would be certain to inherit any characteristic — good or bad — carried by both parents, but that's true of all babies. So too for traits dominant in one parent and recessive in the other. As any horse or animal breeder can tell you, the only thing that differs with incestuous breedings is predictability. It's better with closer kin. But that's science.

This thread's actually about law, after same sex-marriage was at last 'legalized' by their Supreme Court. The real question is how (or actually, if) any government ever imagined it had the power to make many marriage legal or illegal. People attach themselves to whomever they choose; always have always will, irrespective of whether their mechanics of fucking are approved or not, and government has never managed to stop them. Although the pea-brained among the citizenry have always demanded they do so, often by inflicting cruel and unusual suffering.

Where governments have a perfectly proper role is ensuring orderly transfers of property and responsibility (especially for the incapable at both ends of life) within and between families. So they have always had a role in the registering and recognition of the assumption of the contractual bond we call marriage that established and perpetuated families. Absolutely nothing but elements of leftover religious witchcraft and ignorant prejudice ever stood in the way of government recognizing that same sort of bond between any adults of sound mind with the sincere intention to become a family. Whatever their gender. It's just taken us forever to admit to that last bit of common-sense.

So now we inevitably move onto blood relationship. But being human, we focus on the fucking part whenever we talk about it. Who says there has to be any fucking? Why shouldn't siblings register and receive the same legal rights and benefits of partnership, decision-making, joint responsibility and survivorship as any two strangers can?

In fact what the idiots who enacted DoMA missed, was that what America needed was a declaration that all marriage is a matter of entirely personal choice, to be solemnized by whomever and however the participants might choose, but having no legal force. Then to legislate that any and all people wishing any sort of legal recognition of their joint relationship, rights and responsibilities, must enter into state-sanctioned contracts of civil union. There could be no reason to restrict such contracts beyond the bounds of free, competent adult choice. And all the legal advantages and disadvantages of family would finally be available to everyone.

France and much of Europe has operated that way since the Enlightenment, although just as unenlightened as everyone else towards any but conventional pairings.

But there's always hope we'll at last get to where, "Let me not to the marriage of true minds admit impediment" is more than pretty poetry, and we can get the last prurient vestiges of the state outta our bedrooms.
 
And their child, like the offspring of brother and sister (or other incestuous pair) are at no greater risk of inherited disabilities than any baby of parents who spawn without genetic advice. A child of incest would be certain to inherit any characteristic — good or bad — carried by both parents, but that's true of all babies. So too for traits dominant in one parent and recessive in the other. As any horse or animal breeder can tell you, the only thing that differs with incestuous breedings is predictability. It's better with closer kin.


Very true. But I would imagine two women wanting to have a child together would not likely be closely related.

With all due respect, you added what someone else said when quoting me. "This [referring to the folk-belief that children of incest are certain to be defective]." was not said by me. I agreed with geeky that there would be a serious risk but did not say it was certain that they would be defective. There is no certainty except death and taxes. ;) lol
 
I do not see why two consenting adults who are related cannot get married. It took years for gay marriages to be accepted and if two family members want to get married why not. Yes there would be risks with pregnancy but maybe these people would not want kids or adoption is also an option.
 
Very true. But I would imagine two women wanting to have a child together would not likely be closely related.

With all due respect, you added what someone else said when quoting me. "This [referring to the folk-belief that children of incest are certain to be defective]." was not said by me. I agreed with geeky that there would be a serious risk but did not say it was certain that they would be defective. There is no certainty except death and taxes. ;) lol
It's also quite certain that I'll hastily misinterpret someone else's point in my eagerness to trumpet my own. My apologies; once again I resolve to try harder and do better.

What is certain about laws against incest is that none of them do say why these relationships are forbidden. All the stuff about birth-defects is supposition supplied after the fact by people trying to supply an objective rationale for laws they support because of the subjective Eeeuww! Factor. For that eugenics rationale to be persuasive, we'd have to be making all sorts of other anti-birth defect/healthy conception laws for non-incestuous parents, and I see no signs that we are.

Leaving Eeuuw! as the only anti-incest argument still standing.
 
Its an interesting point. However, i think the reasoning falls apart with the "How would it harm the rest of us" part of the argument. A brother and sister, unlike two gay men or two gay women, can biologically produce an offspring. That offspring is at serious risk for a wide range of mental and physical disabilities caused by in-breeding. At that point, its hard to argue that a third party has not been harmed by the social acceptance of incest.

Also: Eww.

^^^^ this.
With emphasis on Ewwww

(Remember this is just an academic exercise -- the original point being that the well-publicized arguments in favour of legalizing gay marriage apply equally to incest marriage.
There is no serious suggestion (not by me anyway) that incest marriage be legally recognized.).

So you would bar them by law from marrying, just on the grounds that they might have bad babies?
Of course, barring couples from marrying does not bar them from having babies. Presumably incest couples, now, have bad babies.
If you, as a potential lawmaker, really do want to legislate against at-risk babies, you could legislate that incest couples must be homosexual. (You could really really guard against bad babies if you prohibited all but homosexual couples from having sex.)


Another thing: I really don't like your "Eww" comment. It sounds as if you think it relevant to someone's legal rights, that you (and I) regard what they do as revolting and perverted, That is NOT even slightly a good reason to make them criminals.

IMO, the law's protection of human rights should focus first on the perverts. The more execrable the person in the eyes of society, the more I want us to see to it that that person is treated failrly and respectfully, and their rights are legally protected.

IIMO, the rest of us can only feel secure if we can see that (even) the perverts are protected and free to enjoy their perversions.

If they (or anyone) cause recognizable harm, of course let them be prosecuted and punished for that, according to law. And, let the harshness of the punishment reflect nothing other than the (potetnial) harm.
But absent any recognizable harm, I want my Canada to make a point of leaving perverts alone and free to practice their perversions -- the more so because many of us have this Eeww reaction.
 
What is certain about laws against incest is that none of them do say why these relationships are forbidden. All the stuff about birth-defects is supposition supplied after the fact by people trying to supply an objective rationale for laws they support because of the subjective Eeeuww! Factor.

Exactly. Canada's incest laws prohibit carnal relations between adopted siblings who are genetically unrelated.
 
Its an interesting point. However, i think the reasoning falls apart with the "How would it harm the rest of us" part of the argument. A brother and sister, unlike two gay men or two gay women, can biologically produce an offspring. That offspring is at serious risk for a wide range of mental and physical disabilities caused by in-breeding. At that point, its hard to argue that a third party has not been harmed by the social acceptance of incest.

Also: Eww.


Further to what you said, a brother and sister, or sister and sister, or brother and brother, already share a special union that is thicker than water - FAMILY.
 
(Remember this is just an academic exercise -- the original point being that the well-publicized arguments in favour of legalizing gay marriage apply equally to incest marriage.
There is no serious suggestion (not by me anyway) that incest marriage be legally recognized.).

So you would bar them by law from marrying, just on the grounds that they might have bad babies?
Of course, barring couples from marrying does not bar them from having babies. Presumably incest couples, now, have bad babies.
If you, as a potential lawmaker, really do want to legislate against at-risk babies, you could legislate that incest couples must be homosexual. (You could really really guard against bad babies if you prohibited all but homosexual couples from having sex.)


Another thing: I really don't like your "Eww" comment. It sounds as if you think it relevant to someone's legal rights, that you (and I) regard what they do as revolting and perverted, That is NOT even slightly a good reason to make them criminals.

IMO, the law's protection of human rights should focus first on the perverts. The more execrable the person in the eyes of society, the more I want us to see to it that that person is treated failrly and respectfully, and their rights are legally protected.

IIMO, the rest of us can only feel secure if we can see that (even) the perverts are protected and free to enjoy their perversions.

If they (or anyone) cause recognizable harm, of course let them be prosecuted and punished for that, according to law. And, let the harshness of the punishment reflect nothing other than the (potetnial) harm.
But absent any recognizable harm, I want my Canada to make a point of leaving perverts alone and free to practice their perversions -- the more so because many of us have this Eeww reaction.


Why do we have to entertain (if not agonize over) this academic debate when it's not even an issue?
 
I kind of think this academic debate may turn out to be
a herald of debates over extension of equality that
comes with gay marriages to non-gays
living together. For instance can two siblings be entitled to
the same benefits enjoyed by a gay couple? I presume gay
partners can turn their RRSP accounts into one spousal
RRSP account. Would it be fair for an elder brother to
open a spousal RRSP account with his younger brother so
he can enjoy the tax benefits beyond the age of 70? It seems
only fair for the younger brother to inherit his elder brother's
wealth with the same advantage of married couples (gay or straight).
 
I kind of think this academic debate may turn out to be
a herald of debates over extension of equality that
comes with gay marriages to non-gays
living together. For instance can two siblings be entitled to
the same benefits enjoyed by a gay couple? I presume gay
partners can turn their RRSP accounts into one spousal
RRSP account. Would it be fair for an elder brother to
open a spousal RRSP account with his younger brother so
he can enjoy the tax benefits beyond the age of 70? It seems
only fair for the younger brother to inherit his elder brother's
wealth with the same advantage of married couples (gay or straight).
I don't see why not. What is it in marriage vows that should entitle two people to certain privileges and responsibilities, and why should they not be available to any two (or more) adults of sound mind willing to take those vows?
 
Exactly. Canada's incest laws prohibit carnal relations between adopted siblings who are genetically unrelated.

Not so, master bones. S.155 of the criminal code:
155(1) Every one commits incest who, knowing that another person is by blood relationship his or her parent, child, brother, sister, grandparent or grandchild, as the case may be, has sexual intercourse with that person.
 
Saying, "if you allow gay marriage, what's to stop incestuous marriage, or marriage between people and animals" is absurd. (The old slippery slope argument, which does not apply.)

Homosexuals are a definable group of people based on their sexual orientation. As such, our system forbids discrimination against them much like we forbid discrimination against religion, race, creed, etc. Denying the right of marriage to homosexuals is denying of rights of this group of people based purely on their sexual orientation. Simple as that. Unless homosexuality is a criminal offense (which it is not) , you cannot deny the right of consenting adults to marry (by extension).

A brother and sister getting married is not a sexual orientation, nor is it discriminating against a group of people. It's quite simply forbidding blood relations from marrying. As discussed at length above, there are many biological reasons as to why siblings should not be allowed to procreate (though I suppose you could argue that homosexuals cannot procreate). No need for me to duplicate what has already been posted with respect to the biological impacts of brother and sister conceiving a child.

It is estimated (rightly or wrongly) that 10% of the population is homosexual. They are a specific group of people (or a subset of the universal group if you like) that are defined based on sexual ORIENTATION. Incest is not defined as a sexual orientation, it is a sexual choice. Allowing all humans to marry whomever they choose (of the opposite or the same sex) is a basic human right and the legal caveat can easily be defined to state so long as it is not with a blood relation (since incest is illegal and it is not an orientation which defines a group of people.)
 
Not so, master bones. S.155 of the criminal code:
155(1) Every one commits incest who, knowing that another person is by blood relationship his or her parent, child, brother, sister, grandparent or grandchild, as the case may be, has sexual intercourse with that person.

You are correct. It is marriage that is prohibited between adopted siblings.