Its an interesting point. However, i think the reasoning falls apart with the "How would it harm the rest of us" part of the argument. A brother and sister, unlike two gay men or two gay women, can biologically produce an offspring. That offspring is at serious risk for a wide range of mental and physical disabilities caused by in-breeding. At that point, its hard to argue that a third party has not been harmed by the social acceptance of incest.
Also: Eww.
^^^^ this.
With emphasis on Ewwww
(Remember this is just an academic exercise -- the original point being that the well-publicized arguments in favour of legalizing gay marriage apply equally to incest marriage.
There is no serious suggestion (not by me anyway) that incest marriage be legally recognized.).
So you would bar them by law from marrying, just on the grounds that they might have bad babies?
Of course, barring couples from marrying does not bar them from having babies. Presumably incest couples, now, have bad babies.
If you, as a potential lawmaker, really do want to legislate against at-risk babies, you could legislate that incest couples
must be homosexual. (You could really really guard against bad babies if you prohibited all but homosexual couples from having sex.)
Another thing: I really don't like your "Eww" comment. It sounds as if you think it relevant to someone's legal rights, that you (and I) regard what they do as revolting and perverted, That is NOT even slightly a good reason to make them criminals.
IMO, the law's protection of human rights should
focus first on the perverts. The more execrable the person in the eyes of society, the more I want us to see to it that that person is treated failrly and respectfully, and their rights are legally protected.
IIMO, the rest of us can only feel secure if we can see that (even) the perverts are protected and free to enjoy their perversions.
If they (or anyone) cause recognizable harm, of course let them be prosecuted and punished for that, according to law. And, let the harshness of the punishment reflect nothing other than the (potetnial) harm.
But absent any recognizable harm, I want my Canada to make a point of leaving perverts alone and free to practice their perversions -- the
more so because many of us have this Eeww reaction.