Inboard vs Outboard

Hangman

The Ideal Terbite
Aug 6, 2003
5,593
3
0
www.fark.com
Looking at getting a 16-18 foot runabout for weekend use up in cottage country.

I've heard lots of people say outboards are better for Muskoka lakes/Georgian Bay, yet others swear by inboards.

What are the pros and cons of inboard vs outboard engines?
 
You might mean Inboard/outdrive. Most true inboard engines are on larger boats like cabin cruisers. They are also used on some water-ski specific boats like the Mastercraft or the Ski Nautique which locate the engine in the center of the boat to reduce the wake. Most runabouts have I/Os.

So, for this conversation I am going to assume you mean I/O.


Outboards, especially the new ones will be a lot more fuel efficient, in lots of cases they are more versatile too. For example if you are thinking of going into a beach area the outboard will tilt higher up that an I/O.

I/o are generally quieter but with today's technology the 4 stroke outboards are almost as quiet.

Outboards are always in the way, I/O s are tucked away and almost out of sight.

I/os being in the water sometimes offer more torque, outboards are better for water skiing as the boat generally throws smaller wake.

Because you mentioned Georgian Bay.... I/O suffer more damage when hitting rocks. (I know) If you plan on boating G bay, the best advice I could give you is buy a good GPS with the local charts downloaded into it. Mine is priceless.

Have fun and ........ when you're on the bottle, stay off the throttle.
 
i'll add just one thing: if you get the smaller size, be aware of the weight of a 4-stroke. 20 lbs more is a lot. and see if the motor is certified for use with any gas. even 10% methyl. old motor's aren't.
 
I grew up in a cottaging family. We had a little fishing boat, a ski boat with a big outboard, then an inboard/outboard. Nothing recent, though.

What is your budget, and what do you want to do with the boat? Are you going to be on the big water in the great lakes, or in a shallow little lake, never more than 500M offshore? Are you going to float it all summer, or trailer it on weekends?

Inboards are generally the best if you can afford to splurge, but probably offer less value for money. They're good for waterskiing, cruising, and deep-water fishing. They are quieter, better on gas(unless things have changed), and more reliable. They also feel much more luxurious, more like an automobile.

If you're going for a lot of horsepower, an inboard puts the centre of gravity in the centre of the boat, instead of hanging it off the stern.

Inboards are probably more convenient, while outboards can be more versatile. I think a young guy would probably have more fun with an outboard.

If you're 50 years old, have money to burn, and you want to spend Sunday afternoons cruising on Georgian Bay with clients or relatives, a big inboard would be nice. If you're 25 and you want to ski and hotdog, or even fish the shallows for bass, an outboard would be more fun.
 
As long as you're exploring options, jetboats and sterndrives might be worth considering, too.
 
A boat is a hole in the water that you throw money into.
 
Inboards are generally the best if you can afford to splurge, but probably offer less value for money. They're good for waterskiing, cruising, and deep-water fishing. They are quieter, better on gas(unless things have changed), and more reliable. They also feel much more luxurious, more like an automobile. .

my 4.3 ltr. v6 gm block ( 228 hp ) with it's merc outdrive burn 1 1/2 times the gas my buddy's 200 hp 4 stroke yamaha outboard
 
my 4.3 ltr. v6 gm block ( 228 hp ) with it's merc outdrive burn 1 1/2 times the gas my buddy's 200 hp 4 stroke yamaha outboard

i have the 4.3 in a 16.5 cadorette..great engine, takes the boat to 60 mph. There is next to NO maintenance on these babies other than oil changes. If you can afford a boat, plus a cottage to plunk it at, as well as the gas to get to and from cottage country every weekend, plus insurance etc. etc, the fuel consumption figures or price of gas should not be an object preventing you from enjoying your fossil fuel burner.
 
Looking at getting a 16-18 foot runabout for weekend use up in cottage country.

I've heard lots of people say outboards are better for Muskoka lakes/Georgian Bay, yet others swear by inboards.

What are the pros and cons of inboard vs outboard engines?

Based on the size you mention you want outboard
 
Thanks for all the advice. It helped me for sure.


A boat is a hole in the water that you throw money into.

This is a very funny and topically-appropriate thing to have said, and it was very helpful. It also made me laugh out loud, or "LOL."

I grew up in a cottaging family. We had a little fishing boat, a ski boat with a big outboard, then an inboard/outboard. Nothing recent, though.

What is your budget, and what do you want to do with the boat? Are you going to be on the big water in the great lakes, or in a shallow little lake, never more than 500M offshore? Are you going to float it all summer, or trailer it on weekends?

Inboards are generally the best if you can afford to splurge, but probably offer less value for money. They're good for waterskiing, cruising, and deep-water fishing. They are quieter, better on gas(unless things have changed), and more reliable. They also feel much more luxurious, more like an automobile.

If you're going for a lot of horsepower, an inboard puts the centre of gravity in the centre of the boat, instead of hanging it off the stern.

Inboards are probably more convenient, while outboards can be more versatile. I think a young guy would probably have more fun with an outboard.

If you're 50 years old, have money to burn, and you want to spend Sunday afternoons cruising on Georgian Bay with clients or relatives, a big inboard would be nice. If you're 25 and you want to ski and hotdog, or even fish the shallows for bass, an outboard would be more fun.

Well, I'm going with a 90 HP Mercury outboard 4-stroke. It has power-trim, so the weight distribution can be mitigated somewhat. I'm going to be on Georgian Bay, but in the islands, not the open water. Lots of shallow areas in there, so being able to lift the motor counts for a lot. We'll want to fish and occasionally tow a tube around, so this makes the most sense.
 
Well, I'm going with a 90 HP Mercury outboard 4-stroke.
You might wish to give some consideration to twin outboards. On a large body of water like Georgian Bay the same logic as on an aircraft, however the smaller the boat the less practical this becomes.
 
90hp! 4-stroke! the hull will come with a plate telling you max legal HP. i suggest going to a boat retailer and looking/talking.
 
I could never truly get sailing. Took lessons 3 times and belong to the Barrie Yaught and Sailing Club.
 
I started out looking at jetboats. The problem with jetboats is that you lose maneuverability at low speeds, making docking them more of a challenge, especially in windy conditions. They look fun as hell, but they're not what I need.

@larry - I'll likely do what you've suggested. I just wanted to have done my homework first
 
http://www.seadooforum.com/showthread.php?21142-Help!-Driving-a-Jet-Boat.

i know anyone can use an outboard right away. docking is not trivial but certainly not as difficult as the seedooforum guys say jet boats are. i'd say if you're going to use it a lot and get good, consider a jet-type-boat. if you'll use it infrequently and other family members will be sitting at the wheel sometimes, go low-tech and get an outboard. now might be the time to consider how you'll winter it too. in your driveway? will you do the winterizing?

a boat is a job. i set aside a day to put in and up to 2 days to take out given winterizing and cleaning. most family members are not keen to help either. funny about that. how could bugs in the spring and tiring clean/wax in the cold fall not be enticing?
 
After seeing what happened in the white/dark thread, I thought this thread might be about motorboating, just sayin'.