In court for speeding ticket

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
I was in court to plead guilty to a speeding ticket today. I made a deal with
the prosecutor, but had to show up anyway.

What I wanted to post is:"Forget about the policeman not showing up". There
were 9 policemen in the court, probably a dozen cases.
 
there are probably a few dozen speeding tickets given out each day... so a dozen cops aren't much really
 
That all depends. If it's Opp you've got no chance.

It used to be worth playing that game, but now with all the deals going on, it's not worth it. Make a date with the JP, they take off the points and lower your fine.
 
I always fight the ticket, always get someone to show up for me the first time (to request an adjournment). and I've gotten off the hook at least a half dozen times because the cop didn't show.
 
The Houdini said:
Make a date with the JP, they take off the points and lower your fine.

I knew the JPs could lower or waive the fine, but I didn't know they could do anything about the points :confused:
 
also, the days of getting charges dropped do to no show cops are coming to an end in March.
 
I think Inferno is right. The JP can't do anything about the points. Also, from an insurance point of view, a conviction is a conviction - the offense does not matter. Your premium is influenced by the number of convictions.
 
BAMan 55 said:
I think Inferno is right. The JP can't do anything about the points. Also, from an insurance point of view, a conviction is a conviction - the offense does not matter. Your premium is influenced by the number of convictions.

I've had points taken off by the JP in T.O and York Regional. It is true that the ticket will go against you in your abstract.
 
21pro said:
also, the days of getting charges dropped do to no show cops are coming to an end in March.

Say what??? How is that supposed to work? How can they convict you if the only source of Crown testimony is absent?
 
danmand said:
I was in court to plead guilty to a speeding ticket today. I made a deal with
the prosecutor, but had to show up anyway.

What I wanted to post is:"Forget about the policeman not showing up". There
were 9 policemen in the court, probably a dozen cases.

Why would you have to go to court to plead guilty to a speeding ticket, can't you just pay it.

OTB
 
The Houdini said:
I've had points taken off by the JP in T.O and York Regional. It is true that the ticket will go against you in your abstract.

I went to court, having made a deal beforehand with the prosecutor to
lower the charge from 30 over to 25 over.
 
The Houdini said:
I've had points taken off by the JP in T.O and York Regional. It is true that the ticket will go against you in your abstract.

That makes no sense to me.

JP's are there to take a guilty plea, and have some discretion as to fine and time to pay. Points are not discretionary -- if you get a conviction, you get the points. Period.

What happens with speeding tickets in court is that the prosecutor exercises their discretion to lower the charge to speeding 15km/h over the limit, which carries no points. JPs are not prosecutors, and do not have that discretion.
 
I fought a couple speeding tickets in my time... one the Crown attorney offered to lower the charge for me (which I graciously accepted) and the other I got totally railroaded by the crown attorney and the cop and I had to pay the whole ticket... The cops showed up in both cases.

On the flip side, I fought a "careless" charge on the hopes I would get it dropped to following too close... (What happened was I was following a cab, and the cab slammed his breaks- had no break lights and I didn't/ couldn't react in time... The cop charged me due to the circumstances and TOLD me to fight it...) Anyway- this time I hired one of those POINTS guys, and as it turned out my POINTS guy (ex-cop) was a friend of the cop that charged me, and the cop remembered the situation so he went to speak to the Crown Attorney and together they dropped the charge altogether! Cost me $300, but it was worth it! :)

Now, maybe things have changed since all then (happened 15 yrs ago at least), but I was under the impression that the Crown Attorney is the deal maker in these sorts of things...
 
JohnFK said:
You should have done a search on defending your position before you chose to go to trial as this topic has been discussed over and over again.

I've done this myself, in fact but could've referred you to a fairly reasonable paralegal firm.

If the case was in Toronto, chances are your trial might have been delayed beyond 8 months and if over 10, you stood a good chance of having it indefinitely stayed as a result of the Crown's violation of Section 11(b) of the Charter for infringing on your rights to a prompt trial.

To do it, you file a motion or Form 4F being Notice of Constitutional Question pleading your case before the trial begins, served on the court and the Attorney Generals of Ontario and Canada at least 15 days before the trial.

Here's a link to help you in case you need to do this in the future:

http://www.magma.ca/~fyst/

p.s. I've used this defence 3 times and got off the 1st time as the cop didn't show up, the 2nd and 3rd time the cop was there but my motion prevailed and the Prosecution claimed that 'they have no evidence against the defendant' - in other words, they didn't want others to hear my defence lest they throw more cases out of court - sneaky eh?

It was in Brantford, and as I stated in the first post, there were more policemen there than defendants.
There were two paralegals there, and they got the same deal for their clients as I did, namely a reduction in speed to 29 over (I got 25 over).

I decided that a) chance of the policeman not showing up was slim, and that
b) I would not be able to get a reduction in speed from 30 over to 15 over,
so I made a deal on 25 over. (16 to 29 over gives the same points)

I am happy with the result, I was speeding and I am willing to pay for it, I was just
not willing to plead guilty to 30 over, when the policeman clocked me at 130 in a 100 zone.
 
I heard that if you get a ticket for $100 and plead not-guilty and take it to court, if you end up being convicted they can end up fining you more than the actual ticket due to the fact that you are using(and have to end up paying)the cops and courts time. Is there any truth to this?
 
Inferno said:
I always fight the ticket, always get someone to show up for me the first time (to request an adjournment). and I've gotten off the hook at least a half dozen times because the cop didn't show.

When we all go out, you're not driving!

Unless we're late and in a hurry.....
 
EntertainmentMan2000 said:
I heard that if you get a ticket for $100 and plead not-guilty and take it to court, if you end up being convicted they can end up fining you more than the actual ticket due to the fact that you are using(and have to end up paying)the cops and courts time. Is there any truth to this?


In the USA it happen to me once but the judge was a jerk (he fine a railroad company big bucks and they had to appeal his ruling.


Why go to court to plea guilty..well to get a reduce charge :cool: I always fought my tickets, now I seem to be able to make good time but don't get stop, things are different here, it matters what time it is and were you are at.
 
EntertainmentMan2000 said:
I heard that if you get a ticket for $100 and plead not-guilty and take it to court, if you end up being convicted they can end up fining you more than the actual ticket due to the fact that you are using(and have to end up paying)the cops and courts time. Is there any truth to this?

I think it is a scare tactic. It says so on the back of the ticket, but I don't
think it normally happens.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
the other I got totally railroaded by the crown attorney and the cop and I had to pay the whole ticket.
Railroaded because you had to pay the full ticket? :confused: