Important Question about Canadian citizenship: Please read

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
I'm in the process of obtaining my Canadian passport, and there's this one question that really worries me. The question is: "Did you acquire citizenship of another country before February 15, 1977?" If you choose "YES", you must indicate how you got it: 1)Birth or 2)Naturalization.


Yes, I did obtain citizenship of another country. I was born a few years before 1977 in Canada, and I was given citizenship from the country my parents are from. They applied for my other citizenship when I was born. So I obtained that citizenship via birth.

I am rather apprehensive of saying that I did so, as I heard that prior to 1977, if you obtained citizenship of another country, your Canadian citizenship will be forfeited, as dual citizenship was not allowed.

I am thinking of just checking "NO", and hope that they won't look into the records to see that I do.

Does anyone know if it is ok to have two citizenships by birth before 1977? I know for a fact that if you naturalized as another citizen, you will definitely not have Canadian citizenship, even if you were born here. But what if your parents applied on your behalf for becoming a citizen of their country when you were born?


(edited to clarify details)
 
That's an interesting question and I'd suggest you contact an immigration lawyer.

The wording is very important because you really didn't "acquire" citizenship, you were automatically a citizen because you were born there.

Just like I didn't acquire Canadian Citizenship, it can automatically with my birth.......
 
tboy said:
That's an interesting question and I'd suggest you contact an immigration lawyer.

The wording is very important because you really didn't "acquire" citizenship, you were automatically a citizen because you were born there.

Just like I didn't acquire Canadian Citizenship, it can automatically with my birth.......


Yes, but I obtained my Canadian citizenship by being born in Canada, and "acquired" my other citizenship via birth (through "blood" and not place of birth). Sorry for the confusion....
 
There are lots of dual citizens that have passports. It should not be a problem.
 
hunter001 said:
There are lots of dual citizens that have passports. It should not be a problem.


Yes, it is not a problem now, since the law was changed in 1977. However, prior to that, it was not. Any Canadian who became a citizen of another country was stripped of their Canadian citizenship....
 
I too would spend the money on an immigration lawyer. But if, as I'm guessing, you were born in Canada and registered as a Canadian baby, and you were given a second citizenship because your parents' place of birth had a policy that all children born to parents of that country, anywhere on earth, are automatically granted citizenship of the parents' country, (whew), you were still born in Canada and given a Canadian birth certificate as well, weren't you? If that's the case, they can hardly take your Canadian citizenship away from you (one would think). On the passport, your place of birth must be noted - are you not listing a Canadian city?

Plus, its an offence to lie on a passport application. If you were born in Canada, I would check "naturalization" as the method of obtaining dual citizenship, since your parents would have had to submit paperwork to get you your second citizenship. If you were born abroad, though, the question is moot since your place of birth has to be listed.

But, bear in mind my only professional training is as an economist, not a lawyer. Call one, or call the passport office itself to talk through the birth issue.
 
If I remember correctly, the above situation doesn't apply to you.

First of all, Canada allows dual citizenship. It is your original country you should check with.

Secondly, obtained citizrnship before 1977 by birth got nothing to do with forfeiting your Canadian citiznship, in fact, you are not even a Canadaian yet.

That part is for some Canadians were born abroad, and those who never officially claim their Canadian citizenship. As a result, before they turn to 28(I believe, don't really remember the exact age), they must claim their citizenship, otherwise, it will be gone.

So, you, as an immigrant applying for the Canadian citizenship, should receive no effect from that.

I hope I've made myself clear on this matter. If you check Government Canada website. It has more compreshensive and more official explanation there. In any case, you should report honestly(IMHO).
 
CapitalGuy said:
I too would spend the money on an immigration lawyer. But if, as I'm guessing, you were born in Canada and registered as a Canadian baby, and you were given a second citizenship because your parents' place of birth had a policy that all children born to parents of that country, anywhere on earth, are automatically granted citizenship of the parents' country, (whew), you were still born in Canada and given a Canadian birth certificate as well, weren't you? If that's the case, they can hardly take your Canadian citizenship away from you (one would think). On the passport, your place of birth must be noted - are you not listing a Canadian city?

Plus, its an offence to lie on a passport application. If you were born in Canada, I would check "naturalization" as the method of obtaining dual citizenship, since your parents would have had to submit paperwork to get you your second citizenship. If you were born abroad, though, the question is moot since your place of birth has to be listed.

But, bear in mind my only professional training is as an economist, not a lawyer. Call one, or call the passport office itself to talk through the birth issue.


As I understand it, naturalization is applying for citizenship that you are not inherently entitled to. Those two "inherent methods" are via blood (your parent's citizenship), and birth (where you were born).

Indicating that I obtained my other citizenship via naturalization would definitely raise some eyebrows, I would think....
 
stinkynuts said:
Yes, it is not a problem now, since the law was changed in 1977. However, prior to that, it was not. Any Canadian who became a citizen of another country was stripped of their Canadian citizenship....

http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/resources/publications/you-asked/section30.asp

Your right it sounds like you might have a problem. Better to call them and find out.

Since 1977, Canadian citizens have been allowed to hold dual nationality. They will not lose their Canadian citizenship if they become a citizen of another country. Before February 15, 1977, a Canadian citizen who became a citizen of another country ceased to be Canadian, except in rare circumstances.
 
cyyz said:
If I remember correctly, the above situation doesn't apply to you.

First of all, Canada allows dual citizenship. It is your original country you should check with.

Secondly, obtained citizrnship before 1977 by birth got nothing to do with forfeiting your Canadian citiznship, in fact, you are not even a Canadaian yet.

That part is for some Canadians were born abroad, and those who never officially claim their Canadian citizenship. As a result, before they turn to 28(I believe, don't really remember the exact age), they must claim their citizenship, otherwise, it will be gone.

So, you, as an immigrant applying for the Canadian citizenship, should receive no effect from that.

I hope I've made myself clear on this matter. If you check Government Canada website. It has more compreshensive and more official explanation there. In any case, you should report honestly(IMHO).

I am not an immigrant... :) I was born in Canada...
 
The key word is 'acquire'. If you obtained citizenship of your parents' country of origin at birth under the laws of that country, then you at no time 'acquired' it. My Webster defines 'acquire' as 'to gain by one's own efforts'.

There are millions of Canadians (it wouldn't surprise me if the number is more than ten million) who are citizens of the country/countries of their ancestors and don't even know it.
 
I am not going to risk being deported. The risk is too great. I will just check the "NO" box and see what happens.
 
Well, if you were born here, lived here all your life, and never lived anywhere else, and didn't actively pursue citizenship of another country (I take it your parents did this after you were born?) I see no problem getting a passport but I'd still spend $100.00 and talk to a lawyer. He'd be able to confirm if you have a problem in that first hour.....

Come to think of it, this is really odd. Yippie makes a good point: I know many if not all my friends growing up around little italy were born in the old country and yet had Canadian Citizenship. In fact, many had, and their parents had, Canadian Passports because they were constantly going back home to visit famly. I know this for a fact because I saw some of them (the passports, not the family back home lol)

I don't know, do immigrants who came here before '77 have to renounce their original citizenship????
 
stinkynuts said:
I am not going to risk being deported. The risk is too great. I will just check the "NO" box and see what happens.

So your gonna lie, they'll deport you for sure if you do.
 
stinkynuts said:
I am not going to risk being deported. The risk is too great. I will just check the "NO" box and see what happens.
They actually check things at the passport office. Falsifying an application may not be the smartest thing to do.
 
YellowDog said:
My nephew was born in 1974. He was born in the US to two Canadian Citizen parents. He is a dual citizen and holds passports from both countries.


Hmm... If he was born in the US, and first had his American citizenship, and then later his parents applied for Canadian citizenship for him, then it may not have been a problem, as the US recognized dual citizenship at that time...

But when his parents applied for Canadian citizenship for him, then I'm surprised Canada didn't make them renounce the American citizenship first...
 
stinkynuts said:
I am not going to risk being deported. The risk is too great. I will just check the "NO" box and see what happens.

Your question is complicated. It's not a simple one, or I would answer it. I know a lot about immigration law, and I don't know this one. You need to speak to a lawyer.

Lie about it ONLY if the alternative is nasty. I am betting there is a process for you, whereby you aren't deported, and it gets sorted out.

Speak to a lawyer. A quick consultation should nail this one down. Note, lawyer, NOT "immigration consultant".

Lying to immigration is a bad plan as lying to immigration is grounds for PERMANENT removal if you are indeed not a citizen. That said, you can probably get away with the lie if you have NEVER made use of your other citizenship. You could plausibly say you had no idea about it, for example.

If you carry a passport of that other country, or you have travelled there and dodged visas based on your status there, then obviously your plausible deniability is out the window and you should deal with this properly.
 
stinkynuts said:
Hmm... If he was born in the US, and first had his American citizenship, and then later his parents applied for Canadian citizenship for him, then it may not have been a problem, as the US recognized dual citizenship at that time...

But when his parents applied for Canadian citizenship for him, then I'm surprised Canada didn't make them renounce the American citizenship first...
They were Canadian citizens who were living in the US at the time. Because he was born in the US he is a US Citizen. Because his parents were both canadians at the time of his birth he is also a canadian.