Illness brought down early human rival

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Published 07.07.09 10:00

Infectious disease carried by Homo sapiens was responsible for the demise of the Neanderthal, according to a new theory Scientists seeking to uncover the mystery of what happened to the Neanderthals should look to the modus operandi of another great...

Scientists seeking to uncover the mystery of what happened to the Neanderthals should look to the modus operandi of another great die-off 30,000 years later, argues a Danish expert in an article submitted to the Journal of Archaeological Science.

In the article, professor emeritus Bent Sørensen of the University of Roskilde wrote that disease carried by Homo sapiens migrating out of Africa was responsible for the gradual extinction of our prehistoric cousins in the same way that European illnesses ravaged Native American populations in the sixteenth century.

‘Modern humans brought illnesses they could survive themselves, but for Neanderthals they were deadly,’ Sørensen said.

Sørensen’s article challenges the leading theories about why Neanderthals disappeared from Europe 30,000 years ago.

Those theories suggest that the stockier Neanderthals were unable to adapt to a changing climate or that they were killed off as humans encroached on their territory. But according to Sørensen, skeletal remains show no conclusive evidence that Neanderthals had been killed as a result of violence caused by humans.

He hopes efforts currently underway to map the DNA from the remains of a 38,000 year-old Neanderthal found in Croatia can uncover evidence to support his theory.

Similar methods, he said, have been used to identify tuberculosis in 5,000 year-old remains discovered in Egypt.
 
vsailor said:
Welcome back...:)

So all that 'BYE' stuff and surprising numerous follow ups was what?


Having asked the question, now your observation works on many level with respect to the New World native cultures. My only counter point might be where did the H. sapiens get their resistance and I don't mean Africa? That aspect plus, better mobility, more varied diet, more development in certain ares of the brain, and better weapons played a large part in the eventual down of others.

Yet, veeerrry interesting.
 
I don't know what the big deal is, us so called "modern" humans have been driving species to extinction ever since we learned to walk upright.
 
tboy said:
I don't know what the big deal is, us so called "modern" humans have been driving species to extinction ever since we learned to walk upright.

Now if we could get rid of that pestiferous species the politician...........
 
blackrock13 said:
where did the H. sapiens get their resistance ...


The same place Europeans got theirs. They were immune because they had livestock. As the virus carried from animals to humans the Europeans developed immunity. The American Indians never had cows, sheep esp pigs ie the swine flu


One theory is we are the Neanderthals ( which were a bright race) as they bread with homosapiens

Is this theory dead?
 
Big Rig said:
The same place Europeans got theirs. They were immune because they had livestock. As the virus carried from animals to humans the Europeans developed immunity. The American Indians never had cows, sheep esp pigs ie the swine flu


One theory is we are the Neanderthals ( which were a bright race) as they bread with homosapiens

Is this theory dead?


My understanding (!) is that the current theory is that Homo Sapioens
replaced the Neanderthals, although they coexisted for centuries.
 
danmand said:
My understanding (!) is that the current theory is that Homo Sapioens
replaced the Neanderthals, although they coexisted for centuries.


If they coexisted then it was not germs and viruses carried by sapiens that killed them was it?

Neanderthals were strong, intelligent and well adapted IE their big noses allowed them to breath in a lot of oxygen. If anything they should of killed us

That we bread into one is still a viable theory as far as I know but I do not know very far ....


I thought everyone came from Africa anyways where Lucy was found. Did human-like species develop completely separately?

BTW Neanderthal is the region in Germany where they were first discovered
 
Big Rig said:
If they coexisted then it was not germs and viruses carried by sapiens that killed them was it?

Neanderthals were strong, intelligent and well adapted IE their big noses allowed them to breath in a lot of oxygen. If anything they should of killed us

That we bread into one is still a viable theory as far as I know but I do not know very far ....


I thought everyone came from Africa anyways where Lucy was found. Did human-like species develop completely separately?

Dirt and germs plays a large part in good health. It's been a known fact that farm kids tend to be healthier than their city raised counterparts.

BTW Neanderthal is the region in Germany where they were first discovered


Richard Leakie's Lucy is now just a stepping stone backward. At 3.5 million years old she once was the oldest known hominid. The timeline now stretches back 12 million years.

Large noses and nostrils tend to be a function of breathing air in and out and cooling the bloor more easily through blood vessels in the sinuses and noses while losing less moisture/water vapour. Better quality oxygen/breathing is more a function of lung efficiency. Two separate solutions have evolved. The natives of the Andes have proportionately larger lung capacity. The natives of the Himalayas have greatly improve efficiency in oxygen exchange.
 
blackrock13 said:
Richard Leakie's Lucy is now just a stepping stone backward. At 3.5 million years old she once was the oldest known hominid. The timeline now stretches back 12 million years.

Large noses and nostrils tend to be a function of breathing air in and out and cooling the bloor more easily through blood vessels in the sinuses and noses while losing less moisture/water vapour. Better quality oxygen/breathing is more a function of lung efficiency. Two separate solutions have evolved. The natives of the Andes have proportionately larger lung capacity. The natives of the Himalayas have greatly improve efficiency in oxygen exchange.

Thx for interesting response.

If we go back far enough did all humanoid like creatures fall from the same tree or did some evolve completely independent of one another ?
 
Big Rig said:
Thx for interesting response.

If we go back far enough did all humanoid like creatures fall from the same tree or did some evolve completely independent of one another ?

The answer is yes.

Convergent and divergent evolution discussions have been around for eons. Pick your side and go for it. I've chosen convergence over the years. The first mention of Divine Intelligence gets you 30 lashes with a cane.
 
blackrock13 said:
The answer is yes.

Convergent and divergent evolution discussions have been around for eons. Pick your side and go for it. I've chosen convergence over the years. The first mention of Divine Intelligence gets you 30 lashes with a cane.

All species of hominides evolved separately until the Giant Spaghetti Monster brought them together, tugging at them with his great noodley appendage.

:D
 
dreamblade said:
All species of hominides evolved separately until the Giant Spaghetti Monster brought them together, tugging at them with his great noodley appendage.

:D

Yaaahhh! We all knew that.

47!!
 
The Incredible Human Journey

Excellent BBC documentary.

It states that the Neanderthal were wiped out by Homos.

The last survivors were to be found in caves in Gibraltar, some 25k years ago.
 
danmand said:
Published 07.07.09 10:00

Infectious disease carried by Homo sapiens was responsible for the demise of the Neanderthal, according to a new theory Scientists seeking to uncover the mystery of what happened to the Neanderthals should look to the modus operandi of another great...

Scientists seeking to uncover the mystery of what happened to the Neanderthals should look to the modus operandi of another great die-off 30,000 years later, argues a Danish expert in an article submitted to the Journal of Archaeological Science.

In the article, professor emeritus Bent Sørensen of the University of Roskilde wrote that disease carried by Homo sapiens migrating out of Africa was responsible for the gradual extinction of our prehistoric cousins in the same way that European illnesses ravaged Native American populations in the sixteenth century.

‘Modern humans brought illnesses they could survive themselves, but for Neanderthals they were deadly,’ Sørensen said.

Sørensen’s article challenges the leading theories about why Neanderthals disappeared from Europe 30,000 years ago.

Those theories suggest that the stockier Neanderthals were unable to adapt to a changing climate or that they were killed off as humans encroached on their territory. But according to Sørensen, skeletal remains show no conclusive evidence that Neanderthals had been killed as a result of violence caused by humans.

He hopes efforts currently underway to map the DNA from the remains of a 38,000 year-old Neanderthal found in Croatia can uncover evidence to support his theory.

Similar methods, he said, have been used to identify tuberculosis in 5,000 year-old remains discovered in Egypt.

Err, proof for this theory? Or is this just another "shocker" attention grab to sell a book?!