Illegal migrants crossing tripled, Quebec asking for help.

Conil

Well-known member
Apr 12, 2013
4,631
1,446
113
Canada needs to pull out of any agreements with the UN, not all countries take them in.

Quebec has warned Ottawa that it has reached the limit of its capacity to process undocumented asylum seekers entering Canada through Quebec.
Heurtel said projections suggest there will be up to 400 crossings a day this summer, compared to 250 in 2017.


MONTREAL — The Quebec government says it is facing the prospect of even more asylum seekers entering the province from the United States this year and wants the federal government to come up with a plan to deal with the influx.

The number so far this year has tripled to 6,074 from about 2,000 during the same period in 2017 and is forecast to increase significantly this summer, Immigration Minister David Heurtel said Monday.

“Even the numbers we’re getting from the federal government show us that the situation is different, there’s going to be more asylum seekers, so we need a new plan,” he said.

Heurtel said projections suggest there will be up to 400 crossings a day this summer, compared to 250 in 2017.

He noted that the ball is in Ottawa’s court and that he will meet with federal officials Wednesday to discuss the matter.

The province said in addition to front-line services, there are other costs like health care and education that are stretched thin.

“This is not about money, this is about saying that Quebec can do its part, but our resources are completely saturated and we can’t do more,” Heurtel said.

Quebec is maintaining its request for additional funds to cover $146 million in unprecedented expenses from last year irregular border crossers, with this year’s price tag yet to come.

Federal Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen said he is awaiting a detailed proposal from Quebec.

“We’re waiting for Quebec to provide us concrete proposals on what they want us to do,” he said in Ottawa.

“And we haven’t received that yet. And we haven’t received the proposals that we need to receive in order to find out exactly what more Quebec wants us to do.”

Heurtel noted 25,000 asylum seekers entered Quebec through legal and illegal means in 2017, accounting for 50 per cent of all asylum cases in Canada.

Several senior Quebec ministers joined Heurtel to announce the province has only 1,850 spots for asylum seekers in Montreal and that more than 70 per cent of the places are already occupied.

When that number hits 85 per cent, Quebec will no longer place any illegal crossers in any of the four temporary shelters in the city in order to leave room for people who enter the province by regular means.

Heurtel said asylum seekers this year are coming from various countries and, based on anecdotal evidence, there seems to be an organized system where people land in the United States and immediately head for a popular irregular crossing at Roxham Road along the Quebec-New York border.

Many don’t have any interest in staying in Quebec for a long time.

“We’ve had certain days when we’ve had people come to our centres and sometimes upwards of 40 per cent say were saying their intent was to go elsewhere in Canada,” Heurtel said.

“If an asylum seeker already (says) from the beginning that his final destination is somewhere else in Canada, maybe the federal government should take notice of that and act on it.”

Last year, the influx of border crossers was linked to the end of a U.S. government program that granted Haitians so-called “temporary protected status” following the massive earthquake that struck their homeland in 2010.

Jean-Nicolas Beuze, UN Refugee Agency representative in Canada, said 20,000 of the 50,000 who entered Canada last year crossed by irregular means — the vast majority of them in Quebec.

Meanwhile, 30,000 entered with a proper visa at the border or airport.

Speaking to reporters in Ottawa, Beuze noted that two-thirds of asylum seekers are recognized as refugees.

“Not even one per cent of the people arriving through irregular means in Canada were detained by police on suspicion of criminal activity, which really shows we were facing a situation where people were genuinely coming to Canada to look for a solution to their plight,” he said.

“Even if people come in increased numbers over the summer, we are very much confident that with the additional funding, the measures that have been taken over the last nine to 10 months by the authorities at the border, at the immigration offices, Canada is very well equipped to respond.”

http://torontosun.com/news/local-ne...says/wcm/80c45f48-5a84-4762-ba29-8b7b04083d06
 
Canada needs to pull out of any agreements with the UN, not all countries take them in.

Quebec has warned Ottawa that it has reached the limit of its capacity to process undocumented asylum seekers entering Canada through Quebec.
Heurtel said projections suggest there will be up to 400 crossings a day this summer, compared to 250 in 2017.


MONTREAL — The Quebec government says it is facing the prospect of even more asylum seekers entering the province from the United States this year and wants the federal government to come up with a plan to deal with the influx.

The number so far this year has tripled to 6,074 from about 2,000 during the same period in 2017 and is forecast to increase significantly this summer, Immigration Minister David Heurtel said Monday.

“Even the numbers we’re getting from the federal government show us that the situation is different, there’s going to be more asylum seekers, so we need a new plan,” he said.

Heurtel said projections suggest there will be up to 400 crossings a day this summer, compared to 250 in 2017.

He noted that the ball is in Ottawa’s court and that he will meet with federal officials Wednesday to discuss the matter.

The province said in addition to front-line services, there are other costs like health care and education that are stretched thin.


“This is not about money, this is about saying that Quebec can do its part, but our resources are completely saturated and we can’t do more,” Heurtel said.

Quebec is maintaining its request for additional funds to cover $146 million in unprecedented expenses from last year irregular border crossers, with this year’s price tag yet to come.

Federal Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen said he is awaiting a detailed proposal from Quebec.

“We’re waiting for Quebec to provide us concrete proposals on what they want us to do,” he said in Ottawa.

“And we haven’t received that yet. And we haven’t received the proposals that we need to receive in order to find out exactly what more Quebec wants us to do.”

Heurtel noted 25,000 asylum seekers entered Quebec through legal and illegal means in 2017, accounting for 50 per cent of all asylum cases in Canada.


Several senior Quebec ministers joined Heurtel to announce the province has only 1,850 spots for asylum seekers in Montreal and that more than 70 per cent of the places are already occupied.

When that number hits 85 per cent, Quebec will no longer place any illegal crossers in any of the four temporary shelters in the city in order to leave room for people who enter the province by regular means.

Heurtel said asylum seekers this year are coming from various countries and, based on anecdotal evidence, there seems to be an organized system where people land in the United States and immediately head for a popular irregular crossing at Roxham Road along the Quebec-New York border.

Many don’t have any interest in staying in Quebec for a long time.

“We’ve had certain days when we’ve had people come to our centres and sometimes upwards of 40 per cent say were saying their intent was to go elsewhere in Canada,” Heurtel said.

“If an asylum seeker already (says) from the beginning that his final destination is somewhere else in Canada, maybe the federal government should take notice of that and act on it.”

Last year, the influx of border crossers was linked to the end of a U.S. government program that granted Haitians so-called “temporary protected status” following the massive earthquake that struck their homeland in 2010.

Jean-Nicolas Beuze, UN Refugee Agency representative in Canada, said 20,000 of the 50,000 who entered Canada last year crossed by irregular means — the vast majority of them in Quebec.

Meanwhile, 30,000 entered with a proper visa at the border or airport.

Speaking to reporters in Ottawa, Beuze noted that two-thirds of asylum seekers are recognized as refugees.

“Not even one per cent of the people arriving through irregular means in Canada were detained by police on suspicion of criminal activity, which really shows we were facing a situation where people were genuinely coming to Canada to look for a solution to their plight,” he said.

“Even if people come in increased numbers over the summer, we are very much confident that with the additional funding, the measures that have been taken over the last nine to 10 months by the authorities at the border, at the immigration offices, Canada is very well equipped to respond.”


http://torontosun.com/news/local-ne...says/wcm/80c45f48-5a84-4762-ba29-8b7b04083d06

Still not seeing a crisis. Numbers are nowhere near what they are in Europe, the Feds are going to help Quebec with inter-governmental funding - which is what this really about - and most of the asylum seekers are genuine refugees.

No other Western country is going to pull out of the UN Charter on refugees. Canada won't either. It's a pretty big deal.
 
Are you kidding? 400 a day is 12,000 a month or 144,000 a year. This is getting way out of hand.
 
- and most of the asylum seekers are genuine refugees.
.

We went over this before, USA is a safe country. The real refugees can stay in the US, there is no persecution. Most of the illegals are economic migrants trying to get in as refugees. The Syrians we took in were genuine refugees, not the ones coming from the US..
 
They're not illegal unless they stay after their refugee claim is denied (which IMO most should as the US is a safe third country).
 
They're not illegal unless they stay after their refugee claim is denied (which IMO most should as the US is a safe third country).

They're still considered illegals, the way they cross is illegal, if they crossed at customs they would be turned back immediately because of the 3rd safe country. This is why they're arrested immediately fingerprinted and photographed.
 
They're still considered illegals, the way they cross is illegal, if they crossed at customs they would be turned back immediately because of the 3rd safe country. This is why they're arrested immediately fingerprinted and photographed.

You remember the long discussion we had the last time you posted about this and I told you that they are entitled to a screening hearing in Canada to decide if they are caught by the Safe Third Country rule. You seem to have forgotten everything I posted in that thread. They get that screening hearing regardless of whether they cross at the border point or wander across the border between CBS checkpoints.

You don't know anything about this.
 
We went over this before, USA is a safe country. The real refugees can stay in the US, there is no persecution. Most of the illegals are economic migrants trying to get in as refugees. The Syrians we took in were genuine refugees, not the ones coming from the US..

Not according to Federal Government statistics. The very link you just posted says 2/3 are accepted as genuine.
 
Are you kidding? 400 a day is 12,000 a month or 144,000 a year. This is getting way out of hand.

That's like saying Kendriss Morales hit 3 home runs today. At this rate, he will hit almost 200 a year and break every record in MLB.

The influx of refugee claimants has ebbs and flows and peaks and valleys. There are busy weeks and slows months.

The very link that Conil posted says that there have been about 6,000 refugee claims so far this year in Quebec. You guys should READ your own link FFS!
 
You remember the long discussion we had the last time you posted about this and I told you that they are entitled to a screening hearing in Canada to decide if they are caught by the Safe Third Country rule. You seem to have forgotten everything I posted in that thread. They get that screening hearing regardless of whether they cross at the border point or wander across the border between CBS checkpoints.

You don't know anything about this.

The problem is a loophole in the law that says if they arrive this way they are entitled to a hearing. This loophole should be closed to match what happens at all border crossings with regards to safe 3rd nations.

We changed the laws in the early nineties because of false claims costs. Time to update to reflect new realities.
 
We really need to start a bus service from TX,AZ,NM and CA
 
You remember the long discussion we had the last time you posted about this and I told you that they are entitled to a screening hearing in Canada to decide if they are caught by the Safe Third Country rule. You seem to have forgotten everything I posted in that thread. They get that screening hearing regardless of whether they cross at the border point or wander across the border between CBS checkpoints.

You don't know anything about this.

The problem is a loophole in the law that says if they arrive this way they are entitled to a hearing. This loophole should be closed to match what happens at all border crossings with regards to safe 3rd nations.

We changed the laws in the early nineties because of false claims costs. Time to update to reflect new realities.

You get it, Oagre is confused LOL and doesn't know nothing about this, despite saying he's an immigration lawyer. God help those that hire him. LOLOL

Here, let me post this so you can understand :

OTTAWA — Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel wants to see the entire Canada-U.S. border designated as an official port of entry to help stop the flow of illegal migrants.

Concerns have boiled over in Quebec this week over the challenges posed by the thousands of asylum seekers crossing the border at unofficial entry points in Quebec and Ontario.

Some officials are projecting up to 400 people a day could cross the border into Quebec through forest paths this summer to claim asylum in Canada — a situation Rempel is calling a crisis.

Rempel wants the federal government to make the entire border as an official border crossing, closing a loophole in the so-called “safe third country” agreement that encourages would-be refugees in the U.S. from claiming asylum in Canada.

The Liberal government says it is working to ease pressures caused by the surge in asylum claims, including $74 million earmarked to help reduce extensive backlogs in refugee claims processing.

But Canada’s Immigration and Refugee Board is warning concentrated surges in refugee claims and appeals could negate any gains it makes in reducing backlogs — last year, a 20 per cent improvement in processing was swallowed by a 40 per cent increase in cases.

http://ottawasun.com/news/national/...ntry/wcm/2becbe90-d63c-4124-b6b7-af3a40e05ac9
 
You get it, Oagre is confused LOL and doesn't know nothing about this, despite saying he's an immigration lawyer. God help those that hire him. LOLOL

Here, let me post this so you can understand :

OTTAWA — Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel wants to see the entire Canada-U.S. border designated as an official port of entry to help stop the flow of illegal migrants.

Concerns have boiled over in Quebec this week over the challenges posed by the thousands of asylum seekers crossing the border at unofficial entry points in Quebec and Ontario.

Some officials are projecting up to 400 people a day could cross the border into Quebec through forest paths this summer to claim asylum in Canada — a situation Rempel is calling a crisis.

Rempel wants the federal government to make the entire border as an official border crossing, closing a loophole in the so-called “safe third country” agreement that encourages would-be refugees in the U.S. from claiming asylum in Canada.

The Liberal government says it is working to ease pressures caused by the surge in asylum claims, including $74 million earmarked to help reduce extensive backlogs in refugee claims processing.

But Canada’s Immigration and Refugee Board is warning concentrated surges in refugee claims and appeals could negate any gains it makes in reducing backlogs — last year, a 20 per cent improvement in processing was swallowed by a 40 per cent increase in cases.

http://ottawasun.com/news/national/...ntry/wcm/2becbe90-d63c-4124-b6b7-af3a40e05ac9

Oagre gets it. He just prefers to have the loophole in place and then make it seem like there is nothing that can be done.

The fix is easy. And I doubt would cost the govt any political capital either.
 
Conil is correct. I haven't done immigration law for a couple of decades and had to go and look up the details of the US-Canada safe third country agreement. I would add that no one "hires me as an immigration lawyer", since I practise Family Law. So Conil's insult goes nowhere.

Here is the issue. The loophole hasn't been a factor up until now. Refugee claims have fallen dramatically in the last few years. They were far higher under Harper than Trudeau. As I pointed out in another of Conil's threads, Canada needs immigrants and refugee claimants are a small % of immigrants and are easily absorbed into the system.

The only people who get worked up about the refugee process are extreme righties like Conil, who - much as he denies this - really, really doesn't like immigrants.

The number of refugee claimants is spiking because of Trump's clear hostility to immigrants. Some US asylum programs have been terminated and refugee claimants in the US feel - probably correctly - that they will not get a fair refugee hearing in the US. Refugee hearings have always been "political" in the US as the State Dept involves itself in the process. When I DID practise refugee law in the 1980's, it was notorious that ALL people claiming to be refugees from the Sandinista govt in Nicaragua would be easily accepted in the US - so State could pad its statistics about how oppressive the Sandinista government was. Conversely, ALL Salvadorean refugee claimants in the US would be denied - regardless of the merits of their claims - because State supported the regimes in those countries who were killing and torturing the people attempting to flee the regime and become refugees.

No Canadian government is going to withdraw from the US Charter of Refugees, no matter how many articles are written about it. No Western government has ever withdrawn from the UN Charter. It's not do-able if the government is going to stay respected in the community of nations.

It the spike continues and increases, the Trudeau government MAY attempt to amend the Safe Third Country agreement. Know what?.... You have to get the Americans to agree as well. It's an "agreement". So it would take time and the Americans may not cooperate.

The spike would have to be pretty dramatic and continue to the point it threatens to swamp the entire refugee determination process, before anyone is going to do anything about it. As mentioned, immigrants are absorbed in large numbers into Canada every year and however they arrive, they are generally considered to be useful. So the amount of time and effort spent tinkering with the system isn't worth it unless the system is clearly broken.

I would add that the Safe Third Country agreement is overdue for a Charter challenge because of the points I made above about the faulty US refugee determination system and this might be exactly what happens if Trudeau DOES apply the STC rule to people who wander in across country and avoid ports of entry.



https://www.cpj.ca/safe-third-country-agreement-faq

https://ipolitics.ca/2018/01/09/rempel-calls-trudeau-close-safe-third-country-loophole/

http://ccrweb.ca/en/refugees-entering-us-and-safe-third-country-faq
 
The problem is a loophole in the law that says if they arrive this way they are entitled to a hearing. This loophole should be closed to match what happens at all border crossings with regards to safe 3rd nations.

We changed the laws in the early nineties because of false claims costs. Time to update to reflect new realities.

The problem is the fact that we have borders at all! Canada is a very wealthy country that can easily afford and, indeed, wants to take in, lots of migrants.
 
The problem is the fact that we have borders at all! Canada is a very wealthy country that can easily afford and, indeed, wants to take in, lots of migrants.

When you have a welfare state it is imperative that immigration is balanced. We take in what we need.

And that's it.

Fortunately we have three oceans and the USA below us. Always good to have a moat.
 
Conil is correct. I haven't done immigration law for a couple of decades and had to go and look up the details of the US-Canada safe third country agreement. I would add that no one "hires me as an immigration lawyer", since I practise Family Law. So Conil's insult goes nowhere.


What insult? What you called Big Sleazy in the Roger Waters thread was an insult. I see your "feedback" is gone, not surprised.
 
What insult? What you called Big Sleazy in the Roger Waters thread was an insult. I see your "feedback" is gone, not surprised.

Are you going to respond to the facts that I wrote in my post?

Or just snarl at me?

Let's talk about your sig pic. Remember that entire thread we did on that topic a couple of months ago? The one where I researched a bunch of links that said as follows:

1. ALL countries have difficulty tracking and surveilling returning ISIS volunteers.
2. While there is a genuine risk of those returning ISIS assholes doing mischief, it is too expensive and demanding in terms of state security resources to surveille them all.
3. It is impossible to present war crimes prosecutions against rank and file ISIS members due to the practicalities of finding out who was where at what time doing what shit and producing credible evidence from Syrian and Iraqi witnesses.
4. It is contrary to the Charter of Rights to simply lock them up indefinitely on Baffin Island. A judge will simply issue Habeas Corpus and free them.
5. Many of them can in fact - believe it or not there are studies and stats on this! - be "reached" by outreach and counselling programs and "move on" from their ISIS ideology and cease to be committed to radical Islam.
6. That Trudeau's program of outreach for ISIS returnees is actually smart and several other countries are doing exactly the same thing.

Awaiting comments?