To be honest, Jim, Salvatores is good but you are right it is glitzy.Your area needs much more than just a good seafood restaurant. It needs a good restaurant period.
I went to Salvatore's by the way. (Based on your recommendation.)
Key - Rist, what a whacked out restaurant. Maniquins all over the damn place, sparkle light ceilings, gawd awful. Washrooms were very clean though.
Food was fair. Not good, not bad.
Would not recommend, would not repeat.
Myself I am a huge tavern and diner fan. You can not beat good old fashioned cooking. We do however lack sorely in seafood.