If the industry was smart....

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,804
5,488
113
The would do some fund raising through Maggies and build a war chest for the constitutional challenge to come. They can then say they will fund a challenge for the first person charged under Bill C36 who wishes to mount a constitutional challenge, that will fire a shot across the bow of the govt and let them know a challenge is funded and will happen FAST.
 
Absolutely. I would say that the agencies or spas should collect funds in a self-insurance pool. Everyone pays in, and the first to get charged gets the funds for defence costs.

We know it's coming, so it just makes sense.

(I'll just wait for the owners to stop laughing at this suggestion and then we can have a serious discussion....)
 
ww2.jpg
 
I would pay a little extra towards that goal, providing I am certain the money would go towards that cause....
 
They can have a fundraiser. Call it "FUCK C36!!" and take $10 off on Mondays and contribute $10 to the fund. That will drive business on their slow day and give to the cause
 
The would do some fund raising through Maggies and build a war chest for the constitutional challenge to come. They can then say they will fund a challenge for the first person charged under Bill C36 who wishes to mount a constitutional challenge, that will fire a shot across the bow of the govt and let them know a challenge is funded and will happen FAST.

The agencies would never, ever think of that by themselves, would they, Notty?

And if they did, you would be the very first person they would tell and give the details to.
 
They can have a fundraiser. Call it "FUCK C36!!" and take $10 off on Mondays and contribute $10 to the fund. That will drive business on their slow day and give to the cause

Honestly, if I knew that an extra $10 of door fee would go toward a constitutional challenge, I would pay it! And, I am a self-confessed cheapskate.

The problem is in the organisation and execution of such an idea. Who would step up to lead?
 
Last edited:
The agencies would never, ever think of that by themselves, would they, Notty?

And if they did, you would be the very first person they would tell and give the details to.


Apparently, they wouldnt. And they would laugh at the mere suggestion.
 
That seems a roundabout way to to do things.
The NDP has the right idea - send the bill directly to the SCC and have them rule on it.

http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...refer_prostitution_bill_to_supreme_court.html

The NDP is joining the calls for the government to send the newly tabled prostitution bill directly to the Supreme Court of Canada for an opinion on its constitutionality.
NDP justice critic Françoise Boivin took up a challenge by lawyer Alan Young, an Osgoode Hall Law School professor who said prostitutes should be spared the cost, risk and uncertainty of trying to litigate protections for their health and safety all over again in the courts.

It could take up to six years for another challenge to wend its way up to the country’s top court.
The bill brings in sweeping new changes aimed at ending demand for prostitution by targeting clients, inspired by similar laws in Scandinavian countries . But several provisions are so broad that critics are convinced it will not pass constitutional muster and turns its back on the Supreme Court’s findings last December that the law should not place prostitutes further at risk. It was Young who represented three women at the top court in what became known as the Bedford case.
 
That seems a roundabout way to to do things.
The NDP has the right idea - send the bill directly to the SCC and have them rule on it.

http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...refer_prostitution_bill_to_supreme_court.html


That would be the pragmatic thing to do, and quash all (most?) doubt. But think about it from their perspective. They're under no legal obligation to refer to the SCC, and it arguably sets a bad precedent. The gov't is chock full of lawyers, and they usually get external subject-matter "experts" (which they purportedly did in this case). Their line is (not surprisingly) our bill IS charter compliant. LOL.
 
That seems a roundabout way to to do things.
The NDP has the right idea - send the bill directly to the SCC and have them rule on it.

http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...refer_prostitution_bill_to_supreme_court.html

The govt has already refused to do this, in case you have not heard, and since they have a majority, there is NOTHING the NDP can do to force them. Knowing full well that the industry is financed and organized and could possibly deliver them a SCOC defeat close to the next election cycle may weaken their resolve as it would make them look pretty fucking stupid yet again.
 
Some things we dont think of. The hotel hospitality industry is already lobbyinging against. Will kill hotels and Toronto Vancouver Montreal tourism and convention bjz.

Newspapers on their last legs are lobbying for free speech for escort ads. Will also kill their biz.

This industry is bigger than the auto industry. Slowly the Tories will figure out it is a major hit on the economy.

Agine joe much government could make at $5 a trick? Taxing it. Bingo no deficit.

Look at LCBO casinos tobacco.
 
Honestly, if I knew that an extra $10 of door fee would go toward a constitutional challenge, I would pay it! And, I am a self-confessed cheapskate.

The problem is in the organisation and execution of such an idea. Who would step up to lead?
$10??? ..
 
A constitutional challenge would be successful (because bill C36 does endanger women), but this would only lead to the government criminalizing prostitution altogether (something that the SCC has already said would be constitutional). I think further constitutional challenges are only going to cause further problems. Alan Young has done enough for us already.
 
A constitutional challenge would be successful (because bill C36 does endanger women), but this would only lead to the government criminalizing prostitution altogether (something that the SCC has already said would be constitutional). I think further constitutional challenges are only going to cause further problems. Alan Young has done enough for us already.

so what should we do then?
 
so what should we do then?

We shouldn't do anything. We should lay low, as we were until Bedford and her crew came along. Hopefully, the police will continue to focus on traffickers and underaged prostitutes rather than us.

Bill C36 actually isn't that bad. Women can set up their own websites, pay webprogramers, booking agents, bodyguards, drivers, etc. commercial reasonable rates without breaking any laws. All that the current agencies need to do is re-organize their structure to make it clear that they are working for the escorts (ie. as webprogramers, booking agents, etc.) rather than the escorts working for them.

It is true that we (men) are at risk of being charged under C36, but I don't think that this is a significant risk. I can't see the Toronto police thinking it is worthwhile to pretend to be an adult woman with a website in a sting operation.

In any case, the main thing is that we will be far worse off with full blown criminalization of prostitution and that this will be the ultimate political outcome of a court challenge. At that point, women will be too scared to enter the industry and the curtain will come down.