I was deeply saddened...

Hornet said:
The original Forbes article has gone missing but a couple of other websites have referenced it
http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2007/07/uaw-pricing-themselves-out-of-market.html
http://www.findmall.com/read.php?52,862419,862509

According to Forbes:

Labor cost per hour, wages and benefits for hourly workers, 2006.

Ford: $70.51 ($141,020 per year)

GM: $73.26 ($146,520 per year)

Chrysler: $75.86 ($151,720 per year)

Toyota, Honda, Nissan (in U.S.): $48.00 ($96,000 per year)

According to AAUP and IES, the average annual compensation for a college professor in 2006 was $92,973 (average salary nationally of $73,207 + 27% benefits).

Bottom Line: The average UAW worker with a high school degree earns 57.6% more compensation than the average university professor with a Ph.D. (see graph above, click to enlarge), and 52.6% more than the average worker at Toyota, Honda or Nissan.




Even if benefits are 25-30% of those amounts, nobody doing direct labour is worth $50/hr.

For the love of gawd, if one more dummy quotes these figures I'm going to puke.

Auto workers don't make 70 bucks an hour. They make between 28 and 32 bucks an hour.

That BS figure of 70 or so an hour includes all pension payments made to existing retirees, all legacy costs, etc. all added on top of what Blue Collar Bob gets paid an hour.

Nice propaganda though and so many fools are buying it.

BTW, a University professor in Canada with Tenure does make far more than 96 grand a year. You can go to the ministry of Finance's website and see for yourself as they list every gov't employee who makes more than 100 grand a year. And bear in mind your typical prof teaches about 6 hours a week. (Though I know that the do do research as well.)
 
james t kirk said:
That BS figure of 70 or so an hour includes all pension payments made to existing retirees, all legacy costs, etc. all added on top of what Blue Collar Bob gets paid an hour.
What is your figure as to what a UAW line worker at one of the three "domestic" manufacturers makes per hour in pay and benefits, and what does the company pay per hour in costs to manufacture an automobile or light truck?
 
james t kirk said:
For the love of gawd, if one more dummy quotes these figures I'm going to puke.

Auto workers don't make 70 bucks an hour. They make between 28 and 32 bucks an hour.

Alright then perhaps I was mistaken when I read this in Fords Annual report
Page 16


Quote:
Entry-Level Wage Structure. Certain newly-hired UAW-represented hourly employees (not to exceed at any time 20%
of the total number of our UAW-represented employees, subject to certain exceptions discussed below) would have wage
and benefit levels below those we are currently paying existing UAW-represented employees. These entry-level wage
and benefit levels would be in the range of $26 to $31 per hour, which is about 50% of current levels (excluding retiree
health care benefit costs)
, and are intended to be competitive with those provided by Japanese-based manufacturers to
employees at their U.S. plants.
 
There is a good book called "Rivet Head" by Ben Hamper who worked on one of the big 3's lines. Pretty sad culture.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Why do people resent the auto workers and not the fat cats that really have it made?
I think people resent both. I certainly have no sympathy for any unionized autoworker (or teacher or TTC driver, etc), they are no better than the CEOs and other management types who have recently made North America uncompetitive and uninnovative. Who have bled their companies dry. Sure there is scale involved, but the end result is the same from both groups of people. Maybe this recession will be the wake up call to get rid of unions.
 
vsailor said:
Are you also deeply saddened by the thousands of other people who have lost their jobs and weren't making the megabucks the auto workers are?


Are you deeply saddend by the thousands of people who are self employed who's business are going down the crapper and they've had to sell everything they own to stay afloat?

Or just the guys earning megabucks with mega benefits for 35 hour weeks making shitty cars?
*********
The domino effect is a fact of life. Not controlled by anyone. That said those that are loosing their jobs in the supply sector can thank the mismanagement of the "big 3" and the greed of the unions.

I worked for a major supplier to the construction company for many years. We could save 4% of our salary and the company matched it dollar for dollar. That was great and sensible. No cap is stupid for all parties.
 
S.C. Joe said:
...that doesn't mean the auto workers should get paid less-it means the Wal Mart workers should be paid more

Not just Wal-Mart workers, but we should all be paid more. I'm not greedy, I would gladly settle for $161MM for 7 years like that baseball player.
 
I am one of these people who lost my job from GM a few months ago.

All I can say is that it was a good run while it lasted, now back to the real world. I don't understand why *almost* everyone is either against the union or management, there are a ton of factors for the collapse.

-Management choosing bad product lines
-Unions with their bully mentalities
-High Canadian Dollar
-Collapse of U.S. housing market
-High vehicle transportation costs
-Dependable 4 cylinder Imports
-Price of gas
-*Uneducated* workforce who does not understand what a job is worth
-The mentality that a giant like G.M. could never fail
-Slow reaction to the changing economy
-The feelings of worker 'and management' entitlement
-Years of substandard quality
-Bad 'perceived' quality of the vehicles
-Inefficient production methods
-Workforce unwilling to change

That being said, there are a ton of good people who work for the company, and those are the people I feel for. The ones who go in every day and work their asses off, and who understand that they worked for the 'Golden Goose". The rest of them... well... Such is life.
 
a 1 player said:
Bad 'perceived' quality of the vehicles

Cars are also lasting longer then they did in the past.

With all this news about how crappy the cars are made by the big 3, I don’t know how they are going to survive in the future. Who wants to by a crappy car that know body wants.
 
What about $4 to $5 a US gallon gasoline cost the USA had all summer long...now its back to $1.50 in my town. The sky high cost of gasoline drove down the prices of used SUV's that were coming back from lease and GM took big loses on them.

That had nothing to do with unions. GM was the one who decide to build so many SUV's, not the union or the workers. GM stop leasing them way too late.
 
a 1 player said:
I am one of these people who lost my job from GM a few months ago.

All I can say is that it was a good run while it lasted, now back to the real world. I don't understand why *almost* everyone is either against the union or management, there are a ton of factors for the collapse.

-Management choosing bad product lines
-Unions with their bully mentalities
-High Canadian Dollar
-Collapse of U.S. housing market
-High vehicle transportation costs
-Dependable 4 cylinder Imports
-Price of gas
-*Uneducated* workforce who does not understand what a job is worth
-The mentality that a giant like G.M. could never fail
-Slow reaction to the changing economy
-The feelings of worker 'and management' entitlement
-Years of substandard quality
-Bad 'perceived' quality of the vehicles
-Inefficient production methods
-Workforce unwilling to change

That being said, there are a ton of good people who work for the company, and those are the people I feel for. The ones who go in every day and work their asses off, and who understand that they worked for the 'Golden Goose". The rest of them... well... Such is life.


That was one of the more balanced posts on this hottly debated subject.
There is no doubt, I have been very critical of the unions and have probably understated the degree to which management has contibuted to the collapse of this industry.
Others have taken the complete opposite point of view, indicating the blue collar worker is entitled to their contract stipulated excessive wage and benefits, while management is a bunch of overpaid morons who's every move has been a disaster.

There is no doubt there is blame enough to go round

There is a lot at stake here for the UAW, Management, Shareholders, supplier companies, thier employees, the economy and for taxpayers. Unless major structural changes are made and made very quickly it will turn out badly for all parties.

It is time for all parties to dig deep to see if it is at all possible to save this industry

The part I do not understand is the UAW stead fast refusal to even consider a wage cut despite all the evidence indicating one is required (along with management cuts) and dispite the overwhelming evidence they could lose most if not all of the jobs if costs are not cut.
While they stand to lose the most, this inflexibility will cost others many jobs and taxpayers a lot of $. While this should be obivious to them they do not appear to be concerned about this fact
If this industry does collapse, the UAW will be the bad guy in the publics view
 
Yep the UAW contract comes up again in 2011...they could have agree to take the pay cuts temporally but then ask for the higher wages back in 2011.

But how many leaders decided it, likely 1 to 3 guys..they are the jerks, not the whole union.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Yep the UAW contract comes up again in 2011...they could have agree to take the pay cuts temporally but then ask for the higher wages back in 2011.

But how many leaders decided it, likely 1 to 3 guys..they are the jerks, not the whole union.
******

I wouldn't worry about the 2011 contract for GM. I don't think they'll be around.

Chrysler will because their owners don't want to loose their shirts.(read capital investment)

Ford is relatively well managed in comparison to the others and is the most likely to survive.
 
JohnLarue said:
That was one of the more balanced posts on this hottly debated subject.
There is no doubt, I have been very critical of the unions and have probably understated the degree to which management has contibuted to the collapse of this industry.
Others have taken the complete opposite point of view, indicating the blue collar worker is entitled to their contract stipulated excessive wage and benefits, while management is a bunch of overpaid morons who's every move has been a disaster.

There is no doubt there is blame enough to go round

There is a lot at stake here for the UAW, Management, Shareholders, supplier companies, thier employees, the economy and for taxpayers. Unless major structural changes are made and made very quickly it will turn out badly for all parties.

It is time for all parties to dig deep to see if it is at all possible to save this industry

The part I do not understand is the UAW stead fast refusal to even consider a wage cut despite all the evidence indicating one is required (along with management cuts) and dispite the overwhelming evidence they could lose most if not all of the jobs if costs are not cut.
While they stand to lose the most, this inflexibility will cost others many jobs and taxpayers a lot of $. While this should be obivious to them they do not appear to be concerned about this fact
If this industry does collapse, the UAW will be the bad guy in the publics view
You hit the proverbial nail on the head regarding 'the bigger picture'. I couldn't have said it better, myself. But, no one wants to lose any of thier ground, which is the cause of the potential impasse. I fear that that could sound the death knell of the domestic auto industry, and the economy as we know it.