I was deeply saddened...

toughb

"The Gatekeeper"
Aug 29, 2006
6,730
0
0
Asgard
as I watched all the guys that were being laid off at GM tell their heart felt stories of no money, not going to be much of a Christmas and didn't know how they would meet their obligations as they downed their beers and burgers in a restaurant/bar.:rolleyes:
 
Hate to see people lose jobs, but if they don't have money then they need to take some money management classes while out of work. This has been coming for years. If they aren't prepared, then they just weren't paying attention. I am a US citizen and would not buy an American car. It's a culture or poor management and manufacturing. They should be allowed to go bankrupt like the airlines. People kept flying and they will keep buying US cars. That argument is BS. Any CEO who flies to beg for money in a private jet should have been fired.
 
Why do people resent the auto workers and not the fat cats that really have it made?

Like the CEO's who ran the companies for crap but still make tens of millions of dollars each year. Those auto workers don't make that much for their hard work. Most have to stand, be on their feet for the 8-10 hour shifts, not sure today but in the past the plant's had no A/C, they were loud, dirty. Sure they have it better that the Wal Mart workers...that doesn't mean the auto workers should get paid less-it means the Wal Mart workers should be paid more :cool:
 
Two things...

S.C. Joe said:
Why do people resent the auto workers and not the fat cats that really have it made?

Like the CEO's who ran the companies for crap but still make tens of millions of dollars each year. Those auto workers don't make that much for their hard work. Most have to stand, be on their feet for the 8-10 hour shifts, not sure today but in the past the plant's had no A/C, they were loud, dirty. Sure they have it better that the Wal Mart workers...that doesn't mean the auto workers should get paid less-it means the Wal Mart workers should be paid more :cool:
*********
"CEO's who ran the companies for crap but still make tens of millions of dollars each year." = They're living the American dream.

"Most have to stand, be on their feet for the 8-10 hour shifts, not sure today but in the past the plant's had no A/C, they were loud, dirty." Basic salary is $28/hr. plus benefits to a total cost to mfg. of $70 plus per hour. = They're being paid to the level of their incompetents.
 
The CEOs were willing to accept a one dollar annual salary and selling their jets as a condition of the bailout. Another condition of the bailout was wage reductions all around, which the union refused to accept. So the bailout won't happen and instead of a reduced wage the workers get zero wage. They did it to themselves.
 
Sorry, I hope I didn't give the impression that I dislike auto workers. I wish them the best. And you are right, there's a lot of CEO's aren't worth the dynamite to blow them to hell with. But the US auto industry is bad from top to bottom. Getting paid 95% of wages when they don't work? I don't blame them, but they had to see ths day coming. Just hpe they saved a lo of that 95% for this rainy day. And got new job training over the past 10 years.

Like I said, I wouldn't buy a US car. I have a Toyota bouilt n the US. If they improve, bankrupt or not, I'd buy one.
 
toughb said:
as I watched all the guys that were being laid off at GM tell their heart felt stories of no money, not going to be much of a Christmas and didn't know how they would meet their obligations as they downed their beers and burgers in a restaurant/bar.:rolleyes:

These GM workers have been working for 20-30 years - so that's a good run. They must've saved up at least a couple 100 grand, so of course they can afford to live a little and take some time off - until they find another full time job -

it isn't that bad, for them.

and of course - with a couple 100 grand in their accounts - they can have the christmas off with their families and still afford to buy them stuff.

geeze.
 
qwertyuio said:
The CEOs were willing to accept a one dollar annual salary and selling their jets as a condition of the bailout. Another condition of the bailout was wage reductions all around, which the union refused to accept. So the bailout won't happen and instead of a reduced wage the workers get zero wage. They did it to themselves.


Hold on....you REALLY believe they work for $1 a year....come on..read the fine print...those $1 a year salaries are a lie...they land up still making millions of dollars each year.

And there was no vote among the auto workers not to take a pay cut, it was the union leaders (who also make millions) who refuse on behave of the workers.
 
While I feel for people that have lost their jobs, and some of them have no money, are not going to have a happy Chistmas, may loose their homes. I can not help but to think........these bunch of shmucks are highly paid, and have lived high off the hog for a long time. They believe that the gravy train will never cease to arrive in the station every day bringing loads of money to them. It is the unions that are partioaly to blame for this fiasco, along with the changing world economic situation.
Ask these same workers that are laid off if they would make some concessions to take less benefits or lower pay and they will say: NO! They are just speeding up the process where jobs are shipped overseas. These highly paid workers never saved a dime because they believed that it was their God given right to get paid an outragious hourly wage. Wake up guys, the Japanese have eaten your lunch. To make an analogy of what will happen in the future, The Chinese auto worker will take that 16 oz. steak from that GM worker in Oshawa and make chow mein out of it to feed his family of 6. These GM workers were not listening in kindergarten when the teacher was telling the story of the butterfly and the bumble bee.
 
No, I don't believe it would actually work out to $1, but it still would have been a significant reduction. At least it showed that they were willing to make sacrifices.

I don't know much about unions, but I assume that the union leaders have to be elected, do they not?
 
Terminator2000 said:
These GM workers have been working for 20-30 years - so that's a good run. They must've saved up at least a couple 100 grand, so of course they can afford to live a little and take some time off - until they find another full time job -

i.


Many did save but in their 401 accounts in GM or Ford stock...the companies were matching their dollars...if they brought $10,000 of GM stock, the company would match it...sounded very good...if I was working for GM I would have done the same thing...sure stocks go down in price but who would have thought years ago the stocks would be almost worthless today?
 
I am not sure how those union leaders get their jobs but I wish the auto workers could have voted on taking a pay cut for the bailout cash...I have to believe they would have pass it...a pay cut is better than no job at all.


Over at American Axle those workers voted for a big pay cut in order to go back to work. Now they might lose their jobs too cause of what a few union leaders decided down in Washington.
 
I hate seeing those guys lose their job too. But at the same time I hate American cars. I used to own a Cavalier and it was a piece of shit. Now I drive a Jap car and it runs incredible. Big difference.

I like to blame a lot on those union leaders. Greedy scumbags.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Many did save but in their 401 accounts in GM or Ford stock...the companies were matching their dollars...if they brought $10,000 of GM stock, the company would match it...sounded very good...if I was working for GM I would have done the same thing...sure stocks go down in price but who would have thought years ago the stocks would be almost worthless today?

How could putting 100% of your 401K into one stock sound good to anybody. :confused:
 
S.C. Joe said:
Why do people resent the auto workers and not the fat cats that really have it made?

Like the CEO's who ran the companies for crap but still make tens of millions of dollars each year. Those auto workers don't make that much for their hard work. Most have to stand, be on their feet for the 8-10 hour shifts, not sure today but in the past the plant's had no A/C, they were loud, dirty. Sure they have it better that the Wal Mart workers...that doesn't mean the auto workers should get paid less-it means the Wal Mart workers should be paid more :cool:

The original Forbes article has gone missing but a couple of other websites have referenced it
http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2007/07/uaw-pricing-themselves-out-of-market.html
http://www.findmall.com/read.php?52,862419,862509

According to Forbes:

Labor cost per hour, wages and benefits for hourly workers, 2006.

Ford: $70.51 ($141,020 per year)

GM: $73.26 ($146,520 per year)

Chrysler: $75.86 ($151,720 per year)

Toyota, Honda, Nissan (in U.S.): $48.00 ($96,000 per year)

According to AAUP and IES, the average annual compensation for a college professor in 2006 was $92,973 (average salary nationally of $73,207 + 27% benefits).

Bottom Line: The average UAW worker with a high school degree earns 57.6% more compensation than the average university professor with a Ph.D. (see graph above, click to enlarge), and 52.6% more than the average worker at Toyota, Honda or Nissan.




Even if benefits are 25-30% of those amounts, nobody doing direct labour is worth $50/hr.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Hold on....you REALLY believe they work for $1 a year....come on..read the fine print...those $1 a year salaries are a lie...they land up still making millions of dollars each year.

And there was no vote among the auto workers not to take a pay cut, it was the union leaders (who also make millions) who refuse on behave of the workers.


The plan as I recall was to give options to the management in addition to the $1 a year.
If the management was able to save the company and make it viable the stock price would rise and they would make millions. I think in Lea Iaccoca case this worked quite nicely.
If he had not been successful, the options would have expired worthless and $1 would have been his take home.
So lots of reward for a turn-around, but he also risked not getting more than $1 for what was probably the most intense and difficult year of his life.

Fair? I would think so

The autoworkers elected the leaders to speak for them and they paid these weasels millions.
If in fact the majority of membership would have taken a cut to save their jobs and the big 3 fail, then members should deal with their leaders and in a very harse way. (Tar / Feathers- just kidding)

That would be such a shame, as it is not only the UAW members who will suffer, but the additional part supplier employees who may now lose their jobs
 
Did they ever hear of Enron?

S.C. Joe said:
Many did save but in their 401 accounts in GM or Ford stock...the companies were matching their dollars...if they brought $10,000 of GM stock, the company would match it...sounded very good...if I was working for GM I would have done the same thing...sure stocks go down in price but who would have thought years ago the stocks would be almost worthless today?

I think you only need to look back at the Enron story to get away from that strategy.
 
Hornet said:
Even if benefits are 25-30% of those amounts, nobody doing direct labour is worth $50/hr.



That means you see no SP's :p
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by S.C. Joe
Many did save but in their 401 accounts in GM or Ford stock...the companies were matching their dollars...if they brought $10,000 of GM stock, the company would match it...sounded very good...if I was working for GM I would have done the same thing...sure stocks go down in price but who would have thought years ago the stocks would be almost worthless today?
JEFF247 said:
I think you only need to look back at the Enron story to get away from that strategy.
is that as bad as a pyramid scheme!?
 
qwertyuio said:
The CEOs were willing to accept a one dollar annual salary and selling their jets as a condition of the bailout. Another condition of the bailout was wage reductions all around, which the union refused to accept. So the bailout won't happen and instead of a reduced wage the workers get zero wage. They did it to themselves.

Uh, only the Chrysler CEO was willing to accept a buck a year. To quote Ford and GM, "we're fine where we are"

If you made 15 million bucks last year like Wagoner did, it's not going to fuck you up to work for a buck.

If you made 70 grand last year, working for a buck isn't really fucking possible.