I Phone or Blackberry

Dec 29, 2008
311
1
18
I am getting my work cell phone replaced and am debating whether to get an I Phone or BB. Any advice? Will be used mostly as a cell phone, but also to check and send emails when away from the office. Also, where can I get a good deal on either product? (Boss does not want to sign a contract).
 
I am getting my work cell phone replaced and am debating whether to get an I Phone or BB. Any advice? Will be used mostly as a cell phone, but also to check and send emails when away from the office. Also, where can I get a good deal on either product? (Boss does not want to sign a contract).

Sounds like Blackberry if it's only for email and phone calls. I'd recommend installing an app called Quickpull when you get it. Blackberries suffer from memory leaks which will eat your email (usually older ones first).

Quickpull will perform a reset on a specific time every day, clearing your Blackberry's caches.

As for finding the best price on a brand new Blackberry without contract, try Craigslist and Howard Forums.
 
Sounds like Blackberry if it's only for email and phone calls. I'd recommend installing an app called Quickpull when you get it. Blackberries suffer from memory leaks which will eat your email (usually older ones first).

Quickpull will perform a reset on a specific time every day, clearing your Blackberry's caches.

As for finding the best price on a brand new Blackberry without contract, try Craigslist and Howard Forums.

I have to agree with djk, BB's are the best for email. Especially when you are typing a lot. I tried typing on the iPhone for a couple of months and hated it. Also when you are hooked up to a Blackberry Enterprise Server or Blackberry Professional Server and rely on Outlook to run your life it syncs up everything for me.
 
i would go with a BB. my gf has an iphone which she loves and i have a bb so i could be bias. but the only thing i didnt like about the bb was the lack of videogames. but really...any game on iphone or bb isnt spectacular so no big deal there. i find the bb much better for work and for texting, email and so on. plus its a canadian product =)
 
BB is the best email phone, but the PIM sucks.... if contacts and calendar are important to you (along with a choice of 100,000 apps) then you might want to get an iPhone. I wouldn't decide on the price of the phone as it's the service that is expensive.

OTB
 
I am getting my work cell phone replaced and am debating whether to get an I Phone or BB. Any advice? Will be used mostly as a cell phone, but also to check and send emails when away from the office. Also, where can I get a good deal on either product? (Boss does not want to sign a contract).

The iPhone is a much more future-friendly device.

I do still get a few text-based emails, but more and more they contain links or attachments which the BB can "almost" handle. The iPhone, on the other hand, does much better with multimedia.

And there are applications available for iPhone to give you a "direct connect" to various information, making it much simpler to use.

Unfortunately, you will pay a lot for an iPhone without signing up for a 3-year contract. Although you may be able to find "jailbroken" iPhones they may pose a danger to your business: there are no assurances that spyware or other malware is not added in the process of "jailbreaking" them, and there are many reports of users having their data hacked on such jailbroken devices.

Blackberries have advantages of the popularity of the physical keyboard, but I haven't missed the keyboard since I moved to the iPhone, and the autocorrect features save me from backspacing when the on-screen keyboard does pick up a wrong letter. Still, cursor placement (to correct spelling, or to insert a missed word) with the BB scroll is exact, while the iPhone cursor placement can be frustrating at times.

I'd have a hard time going back to a BB from my iPhone.
 
Don't have either but have been doing a ton of work with folks having difficulties with computer/iphone problems.
 
I have both and both have their +/-'s as noted by many here. I'm not loyal to either company. BB is company issued and obviously for work, while iPhone got for my own use.

iPhone is amazing for play. But it crashes, nowhere near as reliable as my BB which I don't think has ever hung on me. Email works as it should on BB no screwing around here. RIM built its reputation on reliable email service regardless of your provider. Battery life is much better on a BB too which is of importance for business use I believe. Email on an iPhone is a topic on its own, it depends who you use and how you use it.

Web surfing, music, video watching, apps. No contest here. Iphone owns. Maybe Bold 9700 is as good but I doubt it.

Speed. Now this depends on the person of course, but I can do almost anything faster on an iphone. Whether its open a webpage, navigate a webpage, send an email, listen to a song, take a picture and send it, make a phone call, calculator, etc it's all easier and faster on iPhone. I used to be slow on the touch keyboard but now I'm actually faster than I am on a BB.

No syncing problems for me with iPhone.
Biggest problem for iPhone is battery but it does last a day easily, you just can't leave it uncharged for a few days like you can with a BB.
 
People always say that BB batteries last better than iPhone batteries. If you check the specs, you'll find that the iPhone battery lasts just as long as the BB. The difference is that you do much more browsing, apps running, and other multimedia tasks on an iPhone compared to a BB. What do most people do on a BB? Talk, text and email. If you only did those things on the iPhone, it would last just as long.

Now the question is, would you prefer to have a phone with a battery that only lasted a day (easily a full day, unless you're playing games all day long, or you spent hours and hours of talking each each day....but then again, the BB battery wouldn't last any longer if you talked for hours per day!), but allowed you the ability to use 100,000 different apps (yes, there are plenty of useless apps, but there are plenty of really good ones too), browse the web like no other device on the market, and play games if you felt like it, or would you prefer to have a phone that had a battery that lasted a couple of days, but this was because you couldn't really do much more than text, email and talk?

Me, I choose to have the ability to do much much more, and if I choose to do that much more, I understand that the battery has to be charged at bed time! If I choose to just text, email and talk, then my iPhone's battery would last just as long as a BB.

I have the 3GS, and I absolutely love it! I just discovered this really cool app called "Whatsapp" (what a great name!) that allows you to text for free to anyone who has an iPhone or iTouch that has the app installed. It allows me to not have to sign up for an SMS texting plan, and most of my friends have iPhones and the app installed now, so we can all text each other for free unlimited. It uses the data plan (each text uses hardly any data) and circumvents SMS texting services. You don't have to have the app running, as you get Push notification when you receive a text. And the best part, the app is free, like thousands of others on the iTunes App store!
 
Can't speak directly for 3GS since I don't have it, but I have a 3G and a Blackberry 8900 (used to have Bold 3G too).

Push notification on iPhone drains battery for me since I use it for gmail (and for business you'd probably want Push On for email). HEAVY email usage alone (not surfing or games) does drain the battery faster than a BB. Further, I get way way more emails on my BB (hundreds) than I do with my iphone, respond to many more of them as compared to iPhone and the BB still lasts longer.

Remember, OP is talking about a device for work usage where talk, text, are email are probably the most important things, not surfing. And if you're on the run you can't charge it intraday as easily

Love my iPhone but from my experience I would not choose an iPhone for business use if putting food on the table relied on it.
 
As long as you're just going to be pure email and text user, a Blackberry will suffice.

That being said, there's so many tools and apps available for the iPhone that may make it more valuable. I use a bunch of apps on the iPhone for daytrading that I could not get on the Blackberry when I had it.

There's other apps that I use daily that have completely changed everything for me.

NetNewsWire - Before I was stuck to reading my RSS at home. Since I subscribe to some high traffic feeds, when real life takes over I'd end up with a backlog of unread items. Sometimes the backlog would be so large, I'd feel the need to skip over some posts or read them quickly. Now I'm able to browse and read feeds with ease and at my pace.

Instapaper Pro - If I stumble across some lengthy article online, I'd bookmark and eventually get to it. If I remembered it. With Instapaper, I click a little bookmarklet in my browser and boom. It's sent to my Instapaper account, parsed and formatted for my iPhone's screen. I can read it whenever I have some downtime during the day. Set it as a personal favorite. And my entire history of articles is archived (unless I delete it from there) so I can always reread them later.

Things - Great task manager. I follow GTD and this app really helps me stay on top of all the tasks, chores and other challenges life and work throws at you.

Tweetie - Great twitter app. I have a bunch of saved searches for different stocks I'm eyeing or currently own. It's great to get another person's perspective. As well, I follow about 40+ different day traders and news feeds. Tweetie's interface and usability makes using Twitter simple and effortless.

Mobile Safari - When I had a Blackberry, I was sick of being told "no you can't do that" because of it's shitty browser. Sites wouldn't format properly. I couldn't use rich internet applications. Sites heavy on AJAX and Javascript took forever, if they loaded at all. On my iPhone, unless the site is completely done in flash, I can surf and use it just like I would on my desktop.

Various games - Great to unwind and relax with.
 
Get a motorola droid, good for both.

The droid is only available in CDMA right now. Which means you'll need to get your CDMA carrier to load the ESN into their system for it to work.

As well as program the data programming with the correct information.

I'd wait for when the droid comes out in GSM. Just get it unlocked and get the APN's online from a site like Howard Forums. You'll be good to go.