I need some help on an old Judgement

sibannac

New member
May 9, 2009
248
0
0
In 1995 I got into a squabble with my former employer over a debt. Well I lost and a judgment was issued by the Courts

I waited and waited for them to act but I never received even a phone call from them let alone them putting on the my Credit Bureau report so needless to say I didn't pay. Now after 14 years they are calling. I haven't returned the calls, nor do I have any intentions of doing so.

I know about the new Ontario Limitations Act but that pertains to going to Court over a dispute and doesn't include past judgments.

I can't find out on the net how long they can try to enforce this judgment. I thought it was 10 years and am hoping that some smart Terbite can help solve this for me.
 
check with the court that issued it.
 
papasmerf said:
check with the court that issued it.


Can't don't have the document anymore. Perhaps Osgood Hall but I was hoping not to make that visit. I tried CANLII but found nothing.
 
Unless you know the laws of the issuing jurisdiction you can figure you are on the hook.
 
papasmerf said:
Unless you know the laws of the issuing jurisdiction you can figure you are on the hook.

Ok it's Ontario Canada ... I think this I was asking question ... to see if anyone has had some experience with this. If I knew the law I wouldn't be asking.
 
Long weekend on a Saturday is a bad night to ask, someone should know eventually. I think there is limitaions on everything or the courts would be tied up forever. Let them do all the work, however the bottom line is, I don't know.
 
Collection agency's probably go through cold files thinking they could get money from you. I think there is a statatory limitation on this type of thing.
You can consult with a lawyer for a half hour for free if you call Upper Canada law society, I would suggest you do.


You may find out they dont have a leg to stand on, it cant hurt to find out for sure.
 
I thought that court judgements had to be renewed every seven years but don't quote me on that.
 
Judgments for a monetary payment do not expire. The statute of limitations is for bringing a claim.


It sounds like the judgment was in the Superior Court. In that case, since more than six years have passed they will need to get leave to bring any enforcement proceedings, e.g. a writ or a garnishment.

You need legal advice. Talk to a lawyer, not people on this board, and you need to provide them with more details. For example, if they already issued a writ or garnishment against you (despite not colelcting the money), all they would have to do is renew it.


The relevant provisions are found in rule 60 of the rules of civil procedure. Assuming they get permission from the court, they can still get their money from you.
 
Judgments

It is common for judgments to be enforceable for a period of time, then, unless renewed including notice of renewal to the debtor, to cease being enforceable. Any lawyer in the jurisdiction where the judgment was entered will know those facts. So will the clerks at the courthouse and you can go and ask them. It should be a no fee request for the info from a local lawyer; we all know the rule. In CA where i practice, it's 10 years and renewable for 10 more. Simple.
 
Master Muse said:
It is common for judgments to be enforceable for a period of time, then, unless renewed including notice of renewal to the debtor, to cease being enforceable. Any lawyer in the jurisdiction where the judgment was entered will know those facts. So will the clerks at the courthouse and you can go and ask them. It should be a no fee request for the info from a local lawyer; we all know the rule. In CA where i practice, it's 10 years and renewable for 10 more. Simple.

The OP has indicated that the judgment was entered here in Ontario.
 
BallzDeep said:
Let them do all the work,

I like this advice. If they waited 14 years to try and collect, then they probably lack initiative. and organizational skills.

The onus for collecting on a judgment is on the receiver. He has to fill out new forms, and apply for garnishments, and so on. It's time-consuming, and a pain in the butt. And the Sheriff's office is unlikely to proceed if the time statutes are timed-out.

Chances are, they'll just fade away like they did last time, or in a worst case, you'll simply get more paperwork, probably in the form of a garnishee order from the courts and you can deal with it down the road. The phone calls you can continue to ignore.
 
Obviously it sounds like substantial amount of money if its in superior court. If the plaintiffs can prove fraud, no statue of limitations the law suit is valid. If you transferred assets to others, or had gone bankrupt during this law suit and find out you did for the purpose of avoiding this law suit! They can get a section 38 of the bankruptcy act to deal with the fraudulent transfersing of assets. Then a Meriva injunction to go back and examine all banking, contracts, assets yours and family during your working life!
 
I wouldn't sweat it if I were you. They are probably just trying to see if you will capititulate without a fight. They could keep after you but they would have to take you through the courst system again. I somehow don't think they will bother, seeing as they have taken so long to get round to this.

I have some experience from the other side. The odd client has owed me money and refused to pay, even though we have had a written contract. After a few correspondences my lawyer always advises to forget about it and move on.
 
Are you certain that this new dispute has something to do with the old dispute?

What happened after 14 years for them to bother tracking you down? Has your public profile been raised? How did they get your phone number?

It just seems really odd that after 14 years, they suddenly decide to start chasing you again.
 
Maybe the recession caused them their business and they need money, they need money for something and are seeing how they can get it.
 
BallzDeep said:
Maybe the recession caused them their business and they need money, they need money for something and are seeing how they can get it.

In that case they are unlikely to want to launch into expensive legal proceedings. It's also possible that they've sold off the debt to a collector in which case the collector is newly on the case and may be willing to pursue it.
 
check and make sure the person/ business who won the judgement is still around, if it is a recent bankrupcy the reciever may be the one chasing the money. There is a chance this is a collection agency working on spec they will go away if they don't get an answer more trouble than its worth.
 
MichaelZzzz said:
This is pretty much the correct answer, but a few additional thoughts.

I am assuming that this is NOT a small claims court matter, if it is, then the process is different but the general principles are basically the same.

Judgments are findings of fact, they are statements, they do not expire.

The writs of enforcement are subject to expiration and renewal.



So, get a copy of your credit report ($50 on line or free by mail), and go to the Atrium on Bay and do a writ search (about $10).


Thank you Michael, I did a little further research and came up with pretty much the same answer. The Bureau is clean. I checked with Trans Canada. In fact the debt in question is still paid as agreed.

As for morals, well considering the fight I have no problem with it. Believe me it cost me more than it will cost them.

Some additional information is that they never registered the Judgment and I think it may have expired after 10 years. I've never received a writ of enforcement or a renewal. I found the following and think it maybe relevant, if not please let me know. So I think this is a dead issue.

http://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/english/Statutes/Repealed/e9-101.pdf

Again thanks a lot Michael and all the other people that helped me out here.