I need help finding a solid investment counsellor

The best person to manage your money is you. If you can't be bothered to learn about finance then other people will rip you off.

Yup, one of the major tests of your manhood is the ability to manage your own money. Another major test is never pay retail for anything.
 
. I need help finding a solid investment counsellor

Hard to find a good one you can trust.

Need as many references as possible as the person will be in my pocket.

And I want someone that keeps my pocket full :)

What do you mean by a "solid" investment counsellor? Are you projecting your financial goals/risk profile or just a Terbite recommendation? Someone good at getting good or amazing returns or good at keeping the principal relatively safe while earning a return above the GIC/savings rate? (coincidently, I checked earlier today, CIBC yields around 5.2% currently)?
 
Last edited:
be sceptical about them bragging about their short term results.

most should have achieved an overall aror of about 40% this year. it was a great year for investments.
 
Great advice, studying ETF's is an excellent way to learn and you avoid the higher fees associated with other funds.

ETF is a mutual fund that is traded on the stock market correct?

Why is it such a good investment ?
 
It is a good investment because it holds many companies (diversification), can be traded immediately (liquidity) unlike a mutual fund, and has low expense ratios (the money you pay to have someone manage and hold your money). Also, you can pick various sectors that interst you like energy, financials, emerging markets etc.
 
It is a good investment because it holds many companies (diversification), can be traded immediately (liquidity) unlike a mutual fund, and has low expense ratios (the money you pay to have someone manage and hold your money). Also, you can pick various sectors that interst you like energy, financials, emerging markets etc.

Let me think:

{, !#$@$#W%E^&%*&^(*&)(*_((*&&^%^$1231234}

That was me thinking :)

Gotta go slow

ETF are special mutaul funds that are traded on the market so you can sell in minutes and normal mutaul funds takes days

OK got that

You say they have lower expenses but I cant see why as someone still has to manage them, besides,
to buy and sell them cost money like any stock does it not ?

The value of the ETF might be less than its book value !!!!!!!! NO?????

Why would its value ever be more than its book value ???


How do I know its book value before I buy and where can I go to get this info on all the ETFs ?

THX
 
Just to be clear - ETFs and mutual funds both settle in Trade date + 3 days (same as a stock) - so if you sell at any time today (during market hours), you get your money 3 business days from now.

ETFs are great if all you want is the market (or market sector) - where most mutual funds differ is by adding a manager who actively trades the stocks. The theory behind the practice is that active management will give you better returns. The problem behind the theory is that too often the manager doesn't make up the difference between his comparable index and the fees he's charging, so you lag the index. All mutual fund performance numbers reported in Canada are net of fees, so you can do some research to see if a manager has outperformed over various periods of time. I'd suggest looking at longer term numbers because anything less than a year or two can be misleading - different styles perform better in different markets (i.e. growth vs. value) and also a manager can get really lucky (or unlucky) with one stock pick and greatly affect his shorter term numbers.

If you don't have a lot of time to do it yourself, I'd still suggest using an advisor. But remember even with an advisor, most investors tend to do exactly the wrong thing at exactly the wrong time - I heard an interesting story about the Trimark fund - over a 14 year period from the late 70's to the early 90's, the fund made better than 10%/year, but the average investor lost money over the same time frame. Why? Because they invested when things were good and panicked and sold when things were bad.

The simplest thing to do is not always the easiest. Find a decent fund (or funds or ETF) and put your money into it and don't take it out unless there's a material change in your financial situation or a material change in the investment of the fund. I'd suggest a long term Canadian Dividend fund like Standard Life Canadian Dividend Growth, PH & N Canadian Dividend or Stone & Co.'s Dividend fund - all excellent performers, with reasonable fees and you never really have to worry about them again.

Timbit
 
Just to be clear - ETFs and mutual funds both settle in Trade date + 3 days (same as a stock) - so if you sell at any time today (during market hours), you get your money 3 business days from now.

ETFs are great if all you want is the market (or market sector) - where most mutual funds differ is by adding a manager who actively trades the stocks. The theory behind the practice is that active management will give you better returns. The problem behind the theory is that too often the manager doesn't make up the difference between his comparable index and the fees he's charging, so you lag the index. All mutual fund performance numbers reported in Canada are net of fees, so you can do some research to see if a manager has outperformed over various periods of time. I'd suggest looking at longer term numbers because anything less than a year or two can be misleading - different styles perform better in different markets (i.e. growth vs. value) and also a manager can get really lucky (or unlucky) with one stock pick and greatly affect his shorter term numbers.

If you don't have a lot of time to do it yourself, I'd still suggest using an adviser. But remember even with an adviser, most investors tend to do exactly the wrong thing at exactly the wrong time - I heard an interesting story about the Trimark fund - over a 14 year period from the late 70's to the early 90's, the fund made better than 10%/year, but the average investor lost money over the same time frame. Why? Because they invested when things were good and panicked and sold when things were bad.

The simplest thing to do is not always the easiest. Find a decent fund (or funds or ETF) and put your money into it and don't take it out unless there's a material change in your financial situation or a material change in the investment of the fund. I'd suggest a long term Canadian Dividend fund like Standard Life Canadian Dividend Growth, PH & N Canadian Dividend or Stone & Co.'s Dividend fund - all excellent performers, with reasonable fees and you never really have to worry about them again.

Timbit

Thx Timbit

I am still confused

ETF are a group of stocks from a sector as are a lot of mutual funds and a lot of funds do minimal trading so what is the difference other than ETF are a stock in themselves so they can be bought or sold immediately unlike mutual funds which trade at the close

So why are they surperior ?

You even have to pay a trading fee to buy and close no ?

ETF must always trade around their net worth no ?

What is a stock called that rises and falls in value with a sector or average but is not actually an investment in a company ?
 
Companies that sell mutual funds always have some funds that outperform the market...or almost always. That is because they have enough different types of funds (and some that are "opposite" to others...) that some will do better just by chance if nothing else. But...an investor has no way to predict which of these will outperform. Past performance is a poor indicator, because often they outperform only because they are invested in something dissimilar to the index. If an investor could predict which might "outperform" they wouldn't need to be in a fund anyway...it would be better to invest directly.

What you should do is compare a companies total basket of funds to the index (or indexes)...and then I will guarantee than they will underperform the market by approximately their management expense ratio. In other words...they always make their money, and you will pay.

With an ETF, on the other hand, the investment decision is dictated by the make up of the index they are duplicating, and so they can charge a lot less for this management...and in fact most are less than 1% - on average probably 1/5th of the cost for a mutual fund. So if you want to at least match a particular index you can come very close with these.

ETF's trade just like stocks. Contrast that to many mutual funds where you need to give notice, you may have hidden sales fees (deferred sales charges for example), etc. With some of the mutual funds, and sales set ups...the sales person/agency will get as much as 6% as an up front commission for "selling you"...because the fund you buy locks you in effectively with deferred sales charges and MER's. Whereas if they sell you an ETF they get their trade comission if they are a broker...and that's it. Same as a stock.

So the way I see it...ETFs are an ok way to diversify, and to play various sectors or countries or markets, at a very affordable cost. Of course to do that you need to know what you want to buy or sell. But even picking ETF's at random would be better than picking mutual funds at random.

Over time I think mutual funds will come down to more reasonable cost levels. Mostly as people bail out. At some time in the future they may offer enough benefits to justify their costs...but I have not seen it yet.
 
Hmmm. The three funds I mentioned - PH &N - Management Expense Ratio (MER) 1.11%, Standard Life - MER - 2.01%, Stone & Co - MER - 2.86%. Out performance over the last 15 years (since inception) of the Standard Life fund, when compared to the S&P/TSX 60 total return index is about 125% (net of fees) and the PH & N fund is even better. Active management, especially when the various exchange sectors get screwy always helps - remember when Nortel made up over 30% of the index? Those ETF funds would have really done well there (not) - at least with a disciplined active management, you'll get a manager who might think that they don't want a 30% exposure to one stock.

As for your questions Big Rig - in theory ETFs should trade at a par to Net Asset Value, but that doesn't always happen - there are often trading discrepancies which can affect the value of an ETF. But yes, to differentiate, they can be trades like a stock during the day, so if you ask your investment company to sell or buy you an ETF, you get the trade done at the price of the moment, rather than waiting for the final bell, when mutual funds are priced. And yes, you pay a commission to buy or sell an ETF whereas you may or may not pay a commission to buy or sell a mutual fund. I, for instance, only buy my clients' mutual funds on a front end, zero commission basis, meaning they don't pay either to buy or sell. The only commission that they may be charged is if they sell a fund within the short term trading period as outlined by a fund company in their prospectus (usually 2 or 3 months) - this is to prohibit investors from speculating on mutual funds.

As for your last question, I don't understand what you mean.

Timbit
 
Be careful out there. Money does strange things to people's ethics. Me, I manage my own money (what little I have). Simple really, buy some ETF's and GIC's. No need to complicate things.


SORRY RS... buyt advising a guy who appears to be somewhat inexperienced in the market into buying ETF's? No way. Many of these products (especially leveraged ones) are really not meant to be for the casual intro investor. They are commonly misunderstood for thier simplicity, which is certainly not the case. Mutual funds and GIC's... yes... not ETF's.

That coming from a guy who personally manges my own ETF's but not for everyone for sure.
 
Companies that sell mutual funds always have some funds that outperform the market...or almost always.

Mutual fund companies play the averages. Therefore, they create 100 funds. They create this many funds because the law of averages says not all 100 will be losers. Let say 5 are winners and 95 are losers. The 5 winners are all you will hear about during RRSP season. Then they will quietly kill the 95 losers and create another new 95 funds as a replacement.
 
there are as many opinions here as there are SP's....
 
there are as many opinions here as there are SP's....

Remember the golden rule. Investment advisors and mutual funds companies are in business to make money ---- for themselves. It is expensive sending their kids to private school and then later Harvard law school.
 
SORRY RS... buyt advising a guy who appears to be somewhat inexperienced in the market into buying ETF's? No way.

If he is really an investment virgin then perhaps cut his teeth on principal protected notes. His downside i zero (unless the issuer goes insolvent) and his upside is greater, maybe much greater, than the 2% interest on a GIC.
I hate mutual funds:mad:. Wouldn't even recommend them to my enemies (of course, I have none).