I just drove half loaded..

moresex4me said:
As Drunk Driving is not covered by the HTA, then how does this show it is illegal?

Seems logical that you are correct More4. I think cyclists have to follow the "rules of the road" but this is something beyond that.
 
needinit said:
From what I understand, when riding a bike (on the street) you must act in the same way as if you are driving a car - ie fully obeying road rules, stopping at stop lights and so on.

This would mean drink driving rules as well!

Correct, but the HTA specifies "motor vehicles and vessels" in the clauses for DUI, bicycles (non-motorized) are classified only as "vehicles". Mind you, if you were weaving all over the place the officer could probably cite you for careless driving and/or public drunkenness instead.

needinit said:
If you are on a dedicated bike track I am not so sure.

I'm betting whomever owned the track wouldn't knowingly let you peddle while intoxicated as I imagine their insurance would be void if you got hurt or hurt others.

needinit said:
If you are out for a casual ride (without ID) how would they go about charging you?

If they ask your address you are legally required to tell them (Sec 218). Of course you could lie but it wouldn't be much fun if you got caught.....
 
BallzDeep said:
on my bicycle, is that illegal?


I know that if you did it in Bermuda you could get 6 months and a $1000 fine for doing it. I have no idea about Canada, but I am sure they would only find out about it if you caused some kind of accident.


Thanks



Nicole
 
Bicycles over a certain size are considered road vehicles. You're supposed to obey all the rules of the road; stops speed and the like. Yes you can be stopped and charged. How they penalize you, don't know?
 
Dancebabe, is that you Aurora from the Rail???

You kinda look like her from behind ;)
 
blackrock13 said:
Bicycles over a certain size are considered road vehicles. You're supposed to obey all the rules of the road; stops speed and the like. Yes you can be stopped and charged. How they penalize you, don't know?

Highway Traffic Act includes bikes. Criminal Code does not.
 
All of this raises an interesting double standard... I have a friend who got a speeding ticket while riding his bike (big hill, residential street, 40 KPH limit, clocked at 60) and I seem to recall that it cost him demerit points against his drivers license and he had a hassle from his insurance company who were all set to up his premiums for his automobile insurance.

But what if an individual doesn't have a drivers license? Can't give them demerit points, can't suspend their license, no insurance company to deal with. I'd be sorely tempted to deny having a drivers license if I ever got pulled over while riding a bike.
 
LurkingInMyTent said:
But what if an individual doesn't have a drivers license? Can't give them demerit points, can't suspend their license, no insurance company to deal with. I'd be sorely tempted to deny having a drivers license if I ever got pulled over while riding a bike.

When I was 20 or 21 I didn't have a drivers license and I got stopped once for cycling the wrong way on a one-way street. When the officer found out I didn't have a drivers license he just stopped writing the ticket, got in his car, and drove away.

Not worth his time.
 
LurkingInMyTent said:
All of this raises an interesting double standard... I have a friend who got a speeding ticket while riding his bike (big hill, residential street, 40 KPH limit, clocked at 60) and I seem to recall that it cost him demerit points against his drivers license and he had a hassle from his insurance company who were all set to up his premiums for his automobile insurance.

But what if an individual doesn't have a drivers license? Can't give them demerit points, can't suspend their license, no insurance company to deal with. I'd be sorely tempted to deny having a drivers license if I ever got pulled over while riding a bike.


When they run your name etc they can check IF you have a currrent or suspended DL.
 
I knew of a guy in another province that got dui while riding a bicycle. Many years ago too.
 
masterchief said:
Technically under the law, a bicycle is a motorized vehicle. The operator performs the function of the motor.

No. Technically under the law a bicycle is a "vehicle", not a motor vehicle. Any vehicle that is propelled exclusively by muscular power is specifically excluded from the definition of motor vehicle.
 
Under the criminal code section, it has to be a "motor vehicle". So I think that you are ok.
 
oagre said:
Under the criminal code section, it has to be a "motor vehicle". So I think that you are ok.

Well okay as far as it being illegal.... riding a bicycle after drinking significant quantities of alcohol is idiotic.

I say this having done it once when I was a teen. I was an idiot for doing so.
 
Driving half loaded? Do you lose the other half of your load? lol

By law, you should have your load secure at all times. :)
 
moresex4me said:
Guys, I thought the DUI laws in Ontario were for driving a MOTOR vehicle, and I was right. It is covered under the Criminal Code in Canada

There may be separate legislation in the Highway Traffic Act that deals with bicycles, but it would not be a criminal offense in that case.

http://www.lawyers.ca/duilaws/Ontario/dui.htm
It depends upon how motor vehicles are defined. In a number of jurisdictions (as has already been mentioned) bicycles are subject to all motor vehicle regulations.
 
Moraff said:
if you were weaving all over the place [on a bicycle] the officer could probably cite you for careless driving and/or public drunkenness instead.
If the definition of motor vehicle does not include bicycles, then doubtless then this is what would occur.
 
Aardvark154 said:
If the definition of motor vehicle does not include bicycles, then doubtless then this is what would occur.

In Ontario a bicycle is not a motor vehicle. Note that the consequences of "public drunkenness" are pretty minimal. It's not a criminal charge (so no criminal record) and does not result in points off your license. You get an overnight stay in jail to sober up and pay a fine.
 
DanceBabe said:

A bicycle, especially with 24 inch wheels, is regarded as a vehicle under the Highway Traffic Act. Therefore, you can't drive one hammered/pissed/juiced/etc.

An e-bike and a normal bicycle are considered in Ontario to be one and the same, bicycles.

here is a story about a moron who rode his e-bike while impaired.

http://www.thefountainpen.com/cgi-bin/showstory?id=7529

I should also hasten to point out that it is the Canada Criminal Code that is applicable to impaired operatino of a vehicle.

Impaired driving, which means driving while your ability is affected by alcohol or drugs, is a crime under the Criminal Code of Canada. If convicted, you can lose your licence, be fined, or spend time in jail. Your vehicle does not even have to be moving; you can be charged if you are impaired behind the wheel, even if you have not started to drive.

http://www.momentumplanet.com/legal-brief/tonight-we-drink-tomorrow-we-ride

Tonight we drink, tomorrow we ride

By David Hay​



Now that we are through the looking glass, and many people rely on their bicycles as their primary or sole means of transportation, many questions arise as to what the cyclist can do and not do within the confines of the law. We know from the Criminal Code that one commits an offence if one:
operates a motor vehicle or vessel or operates or assists in the operation of an aircraft or of railway equipment or has the care or control of a motor vehicle, vessel, aircraft or railway equipment, whether it is in motion or not:
(a) while the person’s ability to operate the vehicle, vessel, aircraft or railway equipment is impaired by alcohol or drugs;
or
(b) having consumed alcohol in such a quantity that the concentration in the person’s blood exceeds 18 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood.


​
If you are accustomed to riding your bicycle drunk, you will be pleased to see no reference in the foregoing provision of the Criminal Code to cyclists or bicycles of any variety. Before you pull the cork and celebrate, there are a number of reasons why drinking and riding will land a cyclist in hot legal water. Obviously, any activity that carries risk and requires a reasonable reaction time is best carried out sober. Beyond this simple piece of common sense, it is also noteworthy that cycling under the influence carries a number of legal consequences.
First, there is the catch?all provision in the Criminal Code called “criminal negligence.” Criminal negligence is defined in the Criminal Code as being associated with “doing anything” or “omitting to do anything” that it is one’s duty to do, if while acting or omitting to act one shows “reckless disregard for the lives or safety of other persons.” Riding recklessly through a crosswalk while impaired would obviously invite the application of this section in the event of a serious injury to another person.

More commonly, and more germane to my experience, is consideration of impairment as a factor in contributory negligence in cases involving serious injuries to cyclists when involved in collisions with motor vehicles.

A very recent B.C. Supreme Court case involved an impaired cyclist. Jamie Potts, a 19-year-old plaintiff, said he consumed a 40-ounce bottle of beer with an alcohol content of 8.5 per cent on an essentially empty stomach around noon on the day of the accident. He said he ate nothing and drank nothing further that day before the collision, which occurred at approximately 9:30 pm. An expert in blood alcohol analysis came to a different conclusion based on her review of his blood alcohol content. She testified he would have had to consume 13.88 glasses of beer at 5 per cent alcohol to reach his level by 9:40 pm. She gave further evidence that he was too impaired to operate a bicycle at the time of the collision.
Her report stated:

“This individual does not possess the proper judgment, reaction time, balance, co?ordination, vision, comprehension, or fine motor control to attempt to safely bicycle across a busy street.”
In particular, she testified that vision is one of the first senses to be affected by alcohol, and that alcohol impairs one’s ability to recover from glare such as oncoming headlights or bright street light. The expert also gave opinion evidence that alcohol reduces distance judgment, speed judgment, depth perception, and the ability to perceive danger.

The facts of the accident were relatively simple. The cyclist was crossing the street outside of a crosswalk in Langley. He alleged the defendant had time to avoid him and should have seen him prior to the accident. The defendant alleged that the plaintiff entered the roadway
from behind a parked van suddenly and at a high speed, and that there was no time to react.
After hearing a large volume of evidence from numerous witnesses, including independent eyewitnesses, the plaintiff and defendant, reconstruction experts, and alcohol experts, the court rendered its decision. The court noted that despite the fact that the cyclist was essentially “jaywalking” across the street in circumstances where he did not have the right of way in respect to ongoing traffic, the motorist still had an obligation to avoid a collision. Both the cyclist and motorist had respective duties, and each needed to prove that the other was in breach of his duty.

The cyclist’s speed became characterized as a “crucial fact” in the assessment of whether or not the defendant reacted reasonably to the presence of the cyclist in the roadway. Unfortunately for the cyclist, because he was found to be impaired by alcohol, anything he told the court or anything he told his reconstruction expert in relation to his own speed was found to be not entirely reliable. The judge stated that, “the credibility of the plaintiff’s evidence must be carefully assessed in light of his obvious state of impairment.”
Ultimately, the plaintiff’s impairment had a domino effect. The judge found that given his significant impairment by alcohol it was unlikely the plaintiff checked for traffic before crossing the street, and that he traversed the roadway in a diagonal manner thereby “increasing the chances of being hit.” The judge made a further finding that owing to his impairment, the plaintiff would lack the ability to judge his distance from the defendant in the critical moment when he began crossing the street. Nor would he have had the ability to assess the defendant’s speed properly.

In the end, the motorist was found 20 per cent liable and the cyclist was found 80 per cent liable. The judgment is replete with references to the impact of alcohol on a cyclist’s ability to ride. Certainly, without the involvement of alcohol the accident might not have happened. Perhaps that is speculative, but beyond the actual occurrence of the accident, it is obvious from the reasons for judgment that the cyclist was not on a level legal playing field as a result of his impairment.




Even if it weren't against the law, a person is a moron to operate a bicycle while impared, and should be taken off the road before they harm themselves or some one else.