Normally I wouldn't post something as obvious as this, but your thread calls for it - Is is possible that you and she just aren't a good match?
Most of the guys I know who date less than they'd like make the simple mistake of only approaching women who fit some pre-determined mold of who they would be "proud" to be with. Of course, that approach fails to take into account the two most important considerations: 1) what kind of woman would really make them happy, and 2) what does the particular woman desire most in a boyfriend/companion?
I see two inexplicable phenomenon again and again.
1. Unattractive, uninteresting, unentertaining, unaccomplished men who wouldn't think of dating a woman unless she looked liked a runway model or porn star. Why do these guys think such women are the best match for them?
2. Perfectly nice, attractive, entertaining, accomplished men who have some flaw (back hair, small penis, birth mark, whatever) and therefore do not approach attractive women because they assume that if some (or many) women would find this attribute unattractive then all attractive women would. Of course, this is incorrect. Attractive women do not all have the same list of undesirable or desirable features that they're measuring men by.
The bottom line is that you've only missed out on something if the two of you would have been a good match. Chances are that her rejection of you tells you that there's something about you that doesn't appeal to her. No big deal. You'd only want to be with someone who was genuinely attracted to you anyway.
There are lots of "strategies" to improving your success with women. However, in my opinion, they're all a waste of time because they require you to act like someone other than who you are. They may get you laid more often, but you could accomplish the same thing by hobbying (without the bullshit and hit/miss factor).
I don't believe in "persistence" either, because even if it works it sets the wrong premise for a relationship where there needs to be equality of power.
If you think you know why women are rejecting you, and it's something you'd like to change about yourself, that's a different matter. That's about being the person you wish to be.