Hyper-violent U.S.A.

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Apparently, the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that Americans can enjoy as much violence in their movies, videos, computer games and other entertainment venues as they can stomach:(. (However, you still cannot show one solitary frame of a female nipple on TV.)
 
Source???
 
Source???
It was on BNN and/or CP24 earlier to-day. Most likely BNN as I remember the commentators saying that all the stocks of violent computer game makers soared on the news. Probably good news for gun manufacturers and undertakers too.
 
Before the typical TERB b.s. starts. This was a free speech case and was decided by a 7-2 majority (the two dissenting Justices were Thomas and Bryer, an unusual combination). The State of California will undoubtedly attempt to tweak the law in light of the U.S. Supreme Court decision. This new law will likely itself be appealed up to the U.S. Supreme Court this may happen two or three times before California manages to enact a law which the U.S. Supreme Court holds to be Constitutional.
 
Before the typical TERB b.s. starts. This was a free speech case and was decided by a 7-2 majority (the two dissenting Justices were Thomas and Bryer, an unusual combination). The State of California will undoubtedly attempt to tweak the law in light of the U.S. Supreme Court decision. This new law will likely itself be appealed up to the U.S. Supreme Court this may happen two or three times before California manages to enact a law which the U.S. Supreme Court holds to be Constitutional.

Ah no, this means its over, the ruling was very clear and 7 to 2 was very strong. We got free speech here and kids have it also. They can't tweet it anymore and the supreme court won't take it up again for many of years.

This was as big as Roe v. Wade in 1973 and look how long that ruling has stood. This is where its not like Canada, sometimes things are decided for good, like it or not.

by the way I'm proud to be from the USA, a first in many many years, lol This is better than Obama getting in, ha ha
 
Apparently, the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that Americans can enjoy as much violence in their movies, videos, computer games and other entertainment venues as they can stomach:(. (However, you still cannot show one solitary frame of a female nipple on TV.)

Ah, that will be re visited next term. Lets see that happens a year from now. The best part is the media isn't even talking about it much. If the ruling went the other way they would have had non stop coverage.............

The U.S. Supreme Court, accepting a case that will reshape the speech rights of broadcasters, agreed to decide whether federal regulators are violating the Constitution by imposing fines for on-air profanities and nudity.

The justices today said they will review a lower court’s conclusion that the Federal Communications Commission’s indecency policy is unconstitutionally vague. The dispute stems from expletives uttered on two Fox network award shows and from a scene with a naked woman on ABC’s “NYPD Blue.”

Two appeals court rulings “preclude the commission from effectively implementing statutory restrictions on broadcast indecency that the agency has enforced since its creation in 1934,” the Justice Department said in its appeal.

The case gives the high court a chance to issue a sweeping decision. News Corp. (NWSA)’s Fox and Walt Disney Co. (DIS)’s ABC say the court should overturn decades-old rulings that give the FCC more authority to regulate programming on broadcast stations than on cable or satellite.

“We are hopeful that the court will affirm the commission’s exercise of its statutory responsibility to protect children and families from indecent broadcast programming,” Neil Grace, an FCC spokesman, said in an e-mail.
Speech Rights

“We are hopeful that the court will ultimately agree that the FCC’s indecency enforcement practices trample on the First Amendment rights of broadcasters,” Scott Grogin, a Fox spokesman, said in an interview.

The lower court “correctly decided that the FCC’s current indecency enforcement policies are unconstitutional” and the episode of NYPD Blue was not indecent, Julie Hoover, a spokeswoman for ABC, said in an interview.

One of the Supreme Court rulings the networks are attacking is a 1978 decision that said the FCC could take action against a radio station for airing comedian George Carlin’s “Seven Dirty Words” monologue during the afternoon. The court said FCC regulation was warranted because broadcast television and radio had a “uniquely pervasive presence in the lives of all Americans” and were “uniquely accessible to children.”

The justices announced they will hear the case as they took the bench to issue the final opinions of their current nine- month term. They will consider the FCC case in the term that starts in October.
Temporarily Revived

The case centers on First Amendment issues that the high court opted not to resolve when it temporarily revived the FCC’s anti-expletive policy in 2009. Justices in both the majority and dissent in that case pointed to free-speech concerns about the crackdown.

The agency began cracking down on broadcasters after celebrities used vulgar language on three live awards shows in 2002 and 2003. Regulators said in 2004 that for the first time they would punish broadcasters for so-called fleeting expletives.

Two of the incidents involved Fox. In one, at the 2002 Billboard Music Awards, Cher referred to critics of her work by saying, “F-- ‘em. I still have a job and they don’t.”

Nicole Richie used expletives as a presenter on the same show a year later. “Have you ever tried to get cow s--- out of a Prada purse?” she said. “It’s not so f---ing simple.”
Indecency Rules

The FCC concluded that the broadcasts violated its indecency regulations, though the agency said it wouldn’t impose a fine because the incidents took place before the change in policy. Federal law lets the FCC impose fines of $325,000 on each station that airs indecent material between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York said last year that the FCC had been inconsistent in the way it applied its rules. The panel pointed to the FCC’s decision not to take action over ABC’s airing of “Saving Private Ryan,” a movie that repeatedly uses the same words.

The appeals court said broadcasters “are left to guess” whether the use of an expletive will be permitted.

In the “NYPD Blue” case, the FCC is attempting to impose penalties totaling $1.2 million on more than 40 ABC-affiliated stations. The disputed episode showed a woman’s buttocks while she was in the bathroom and then, when a young boy inadvertently walked in, a frontal view as she covered her breasts and pubic area.

The 2nd Circuit voided the ABC fine in a separate ruling in January.

The case is Federal Communications Commission v. Fox Television Stations, 10-1293.

To contact the reporters on this story: Greg Stohr in Washington at gstohr@bloomberg.net; Todd Shields in Washington at tshields3@bloomberg.net.
 
The court voted 7-2 to uphold an appeals court ruling that declared the law contrary to free speech rights enshrined in the US Constitution.

Video game publishers challenged the 2005 measure, which never took effect because of legal proceedings.

Supporters argued the law was needed as violent games could harm children.

Speaking at the Supreme Court on Monday, Justice Antonin Scalia said: "Our cases hold that minors are entitled to a significant degree of First Amendment protection.

"Government has no free-floating power to restrict the ideas to which they may be exposed."


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-13933670

There is no freaken way this rulling can be overturn or even twisted around. The ruling UPHELD a lower appeals court ruling

So how the heck can these little state law makers do shit when the appeal courts ruled against them. Any new law would be laughed right out of court and it will not be heard by the busy appeal courts.

The state gamble and lost, big time. They got greedy, should have stop with rating stickers that 80% of the kids parents would not have allowed in their homes, now these kids can talk back and say its their right to buy and play those games.

If i was a little underage punk, I would go to wal mart and demand the meanest games they likely keep way up, hard to reach, if I could not reach for it myself.
 
I find this issue kind of silly, in the sense that what everyone is concerned about is the effect on kids.

Parents - don't let the kids have/buy them if you don't like them! Honestly, parents are such wimps nowadays, no parental authority at all, afraid to say no to their kids.
 
Teenagers will download/share or even buy games that parents will not know about.
It is messed up that violence is so allowed in media, but not sex.
 
Ah no, this means its over, the ruling was very clear and 7 to 2 was very strong.

Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association (go to page 3)

Yes, the ruling was clear, that doesn't mean that California will not attempt to enact a law which will pass Constitutional muster. There was already talk about it in Sacramento yesterday. However, given the decision I entirely agree with you that this will be difficult to do.


Also to say the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled a particular way is not great precident they are overturned by the Supremes more than any of the other circuits.
 
I still don't get the connection to 'free speech' which as we all know has very very few limits. This seems to be a really convenient fall back position far too often. It's not a free speech argument in my mind. I listen to the various discussions and see this as more a case of a badly constructed law, written in haste, too narrow, and then argued badly when challenged. The premise holds up to in my mind.
 
The disputed episode showed a woman’s buttocks while she was in the bathroom and then, when a young boy inadvertently walked in, a frontal view as she covered her breasts and pubic area.

They should re-shoot that scene with the frontally naked woman FIRING AN AK-47 at the young boy. Violence is now protected by the First Amendment.
 
They should re-shoot that scene with the frontally naked woman FIRING AN AK-47 at the young boy. Violence is now protected by the First Amendment.

Firing an M1A4 rifle you mean. You wouldn't want to be accused of being a communist or a terrorist.