How's your French?

toughb

"The Gatekeeper"
Aug 29, 2006
6,730
0
0
Asgard
"Will Canada be able to be a real bilingual country? I'm absolutely agreed with 91% from a new poll commissioned by Radio-Canada, who said, that the prime minister should be able to speak both English and French. I believe that 2 languages are necessary for all our federal officials. Now only 16% of Canadians outside Quebec are bilingual. What to do with 84%?"
 
we should be teaching Chinese in the schools,French is a small percentage,and not necessary.Chinese will be a huge asset in the work place.
 
Question Value of French as an Official Language

Given the current or foreseeable global economic developments, we should question the value and role of French as an official language for Canada.

If one wants to preserve and maintain a unique identity for the country, then expanding the use of French will support that type of direction.

If one wants to fully participate in the economic boom in India and China, then I question the value in diverting scarce educational resources to teaching and learning French. We should be putting our educational resources into learning languages that enhance our commercial competitiveness in India and China.
 
Bilingualism has been a failure and a waste of money... especially when it is not promoted in Quebec

Quebec is far from bilingual.. especially street signs!!.. French is not necessary outisde of Quebec & anyone who wishes to speak it perhaps should go to Quebec.

I think there is more Asians in Canada than there are french folk.... perhaps Canada needs a few more official languages?
 
Last edited:
Papi Chulo said:
Quebec is far from bilingual.. especially street signs
For many years, it has seemed highly ironic to me that traffic signs on the 401 in eastern Ontario are bilingual while traffic signs throughout Québec are entirely unilingual.

Can you say one way street in French?
 
The problem is and always will be that English Canadians don't 'get it'. It's made worse by recent immigrants who could care less about Canada other than it's a better place to live in than where they are from. Canada is country founded on two peoples - the English and French. Not the Chinese, not the Pakastanis, not the Indians or Nigerians, or whatever. Sure they are a valuable human resource and contributor now, but to be Canadian is to speak your founding languages (with much apologies to the Native Indians) and that is English and French. Should you want to speak Chinese, Italian, Hindu, Urdu, Talagong, whatever extra, all the power to you. We Canadians need to be Canadian first not whatever nationality we fled to immigrate here from.
 
Aardvark154 said:
For many years, it has seemed highly ironic to me that traffic signs on the 401 in eastern Ontario are bilingual while traffic signs throughout Québec are entirely unilingual.

Can you say one way street in French?

Little do you know that there are Quebec Language laws and while I do not believe it is illegal to have signs in english it IS illegal to have any sign that is billingual to have the English copy above, the same size or larger than the French copy.

I always found it terribly hypocritical for these laws to say that all of Canada except for Quebec has to be billingual.

Canada has two official languages: English and French. Speaking both will only help someone not hinder them and IMHO any person entering Canada should be able to pass a basic English verbal test and or take classes in order to pass it.
 
Aardvark154 said:
For many years, it has seemed highly ironic to me that traffic signs on the 401 in eastern Ontario are bilingual while traffic signs throughout Québec are entirely unilingual.

Its a joke.

The majority of Canada's French speaking population is in Quebec, and the majority of those French speaking Canadians in Quebec want to seperate.

Only in Canada would we cater to them.
 
Papi Chulo said:
I think there is more Asians in Canada than there are frogs.... perhaps Canada needs a few more official languages?

Getting past your derogatory comments for a moment,

Persons of whole or partial British (including Irish) origin make up about 28% of the total population; those of whole or partial French origin (centered mainly in Québec, where they constitute some 80% of the population) make up 23%. Other European groups account for 15% of the total populace. About 26% of the population are from mixed backgrounds. Others, mostly Asian, African, and Arab, make up about 6% of the population.

http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/Americas/Canada-ETHNIC-GROUPS.html
 
tboy said:
Little do you know that there are Quebec Language laws.
Actually I'm quite aware of the Québec language laws (Bill 101)

tboy said:
I do not believe it is illegal to have signs in English it IS illegal to have any sign that is billingual to have the English copy above, the same size or larger than the French copy.
That is true for signs on storefronts - but I was writing regarding official signs along highways.

tboy said:
Canada has two official languages: English and French. Speaking both will only help someone not hinder them. . .
That is indeed a valid argument, and it is always helpful to be bilingual or multilingual, but that wasn't the point I was posting about. By analogy I was writing of how Québec has basically a French only policy, while the rest of the country kisses up and says officially that bilingualism is good.
 
Does the CBC poll state how many people in Quebec are Bilingual? You can only be taught in an English speaking school unless one parent was taught in an English school. There are other aspects to the maw I'm not certain of..but I would be curious to see outside of the metropolitan areas what the bilingual ratio is.
 
Addendum...

toughb said:
"Will Canada be able to be a real bilingual country? I'm absolutely agreed with 91% from a new poll commissioned by Radio-Canada, who said, that the prime minister should be able to speak both English and French. I believe that 2 languages are necessary for all our federal officials. Now only 16% of Canadians outside Quebec are bilingual. What to do with 84%?"
********************

Per a pole of Quebecers last week - Harpers' French is easier to understand that Dions' English.

Who's more tolerant? What if that was reversed?
 
learning a second language is always an asset, no matter which one you learn.

Learning French is easier than any other language when you already speak English. Learning Chinese takes another alphabet and this is very challenging.

Now choosing a second language is also about identity as it was said; unless you want to be the whore that goes where the money is - don't be surprised about your image then.
 
tboy said:
Little do you know that there are Quebec Language laws and while I do not believe it is illegal to have signs in english it IS illegal to have any sign that is billingual to have the English copy above, the same size or larger than the French copy.
C'mon tboy. Take a trip to Que, learn the facts.