How will C-36 affect Porn production?

themexi

Eat the Weak
Jun 12, 2006
1,273
41
48
If you wanted to film a porn for public distribution or private, would this now fall under "sexual acts" that they can charge you for? Are male porn actors criminals under the law because they're having sex with someone being paid or are the producers the criminals since they're the ones paying? What if the porn actor is the producer? For that matter, are the female performers also criminals because the males are getting paid as well?

They seem to have completely neglected to address the inclusion of a camera in a paid sex act.
 
Interesting question…

Like all the various laws that attempted to define obscene speech so it could be criminalized without running afoul of Free Speech protections, this law seems rife with inconsistent logic-chopping that at best you might call a good effort but one that doesn't really do the job. Which means judges trying real cases will have to accomplish—or try to—what Sanctimonious Stevie and Pious Pete were trying for. If they didn't just call this whole legal schlmozzle as unconstitutional as its predecessor.

Because sex for pay used to be legal, and 'art' got sort of a pass under obscenity laws, there wasn't much the law could do about tidy, well-run porn production back then, but this law makes any sort of payment for sex a crime, and Free Speech only kicks in after you make the speech/video, so it looks like hiring actors to fuck could indeed be a crime.

Who can say what a judge might do if the Crown couldn't produce evidence of any such contract and everyone testified there was none because the sex was voluntary and ad lib.? Or if they all—men and women both—said they were only pretending to have sex, just going through the motions—and even the first take was no fun, never mind Take 6. Anyway none of them were paying so none of them could be johns, while the producer couldn't be a pimp or a john because she was paying but not getting any.

Laws that exact severe criminal penalties for nebulously defined 'crimes' that depend in the end on what 'everybody knows when they see it' inevitably have bits declared invalid until all that's left is the sort of public consensus about what's acceptable that has little if anything to do with the laws on the books.

More or less like how we have been managing the sex industry in these parts until now. But there's always some fool in Parliament who imagines the votes he needs are more important than what the people need or want. Why he might imagine he could succeed in legislating away exploitation and prostitution where all have failed for millennia goes under many names. Moron and Megalomaniac come up very early.
 
Those enforcing the laws will use it selectively to fit their own agenda and in response to whoever makes the most noise.
This means the heaviest crackdown on the poor and marginalized in society, the easiest targets on the street and backpages. Porn won't be an easy target and they keep to themselves not bothering the neighbours.

But you never know, all it takes is one person to change this into a higher priority.
 
Porn would still be allowed. The logic would flow from the American Supreme Court case which protects porn production under the right to free speech. You as the porn producer pay the actors to perform sexual acts with each other. The actors don't exchange money to each other so no law is really being broken. The product is released to the public to be consumed as "media" which is really a method of communication.

Banning this would not make much sense at all. A lot of movies are shot in Canada - many of which have sex scenes (albeit less graphic). Is harper going to arrest these movie stars too?