How to cook a good steak!!

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
After years of eating crappy home-made steaks, I finally decided to take action. How does one make a good, restaurant-quality steak? I decided to investigate, using Google, of course.

After lots of research, I found the keys to a great steak. Obviously, a grilled steak is best, but if you only have an oven and a stovetop, that's OK. It turns out that there are several important "secrets" and tips that one must follow in order to make a good steak.

Summary of tips:


Meat selection:
1)Meat selection is very important. Select a steak that is one to two inches thick. Good cuts are ribeye and sirloin. Although tender and expensive, filet mignon is not as flavourful.

2)Look for a lot of marbling (white streaks of fat). As they melt away, these add flavour. But don't choose steaks with thick streaks of fat, as these will not melt.


Seasoning:

1)Season the steak how you wish. Many cooks, however, recommend that you keep the seasoning to a minimum so that you can enjoy the taste of the meat itself.

2)Kosher salt and ground black pepper are the only seasoning recommended, as they add the crust (which makes the steak crisp and flavourful). Regular table salt is fine, but will not add the same crust. Sprinkle the Kosher salt liberally.

3)Coat both sides lightly with oil. Make sure you never use olive oil, as it will burn and leave a bad taste. Sunflower and peanut oil are preferred because they burn at the highest temperatures.


Cooking:

1)Make sure that the steak is at room temperature before you cook. This will allow you to gauge its readiness accurately. Preheat the oven to 450-500 degrees Fahrenheit, and turn the stovetop to "High".

2)Heat a frying pan until it is very hot (use the high setting). Throw on the steak and cook for two to three minutes to develop the crust.

3)Never puncture the steak at any point, this will cause the juices and flavour to leak out. Leave the steak alone!


4)Flip the steak over using tongs, or a spatula. But be gentle so as to not agitate the steak.

5)Sear the other side also for two to three minutes to develop the crust. Now that both sides are seared, the flavours are "locked in."

6)To prevent the crust from burning, the steak must now be cooked in the oven for about five minutes (medium). Less time for a rare steak, more for well done. Actual times may vary depending on steak thickness, etc...

7)Take out the steak and see if it is done (never cut it to check). Simply press the steak with your fingers. If it feels soft/mushy, it is raw/rare, if it firm/hard it is well done. Medium/medium rare will be somewhere in the middle.


Serving

8)Do not eat the steak immediately. This will cause the juices to rush out, causing a mess. To distribute the juices evenly, the steak needs to "rest" for at least three minutes. Place steak on an inverted bowl so that the bottom crust doesn't get soggy from the juices. Also, cover with aluminum so that the steak does not cool down.


Serve on a plate with your favourite sides (fries/potaotoes/rice/salad/etc.). Use steak sauce if you wish.


This nerd on youtube did a pretty good job of explaining most of the points:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yX1Q3x9Cs4


Hope you found this useful. Now you have no excuse for a lousy steak. :)
 
Cooking a steak on/ in anything but a BBQ is blasphemous! :eek:
(charcoal or gas- depending on your personal preference... I wouldn't trade my Napoleon for anything!)
 
Get your steak from a butcher directly. Don't settle for the dog food they sell at the grocery store. They never actually get the good stuff (AAA or better)
 
good steak!

Of course buy from a quality butcher, but here's a tip: when you are at the supermarket check out the reduced items. A steak that is slightly browned doesn't sell as well to the great unwashed, but steaks are best if they are aged. 2 weeks at least in cold temps...

BBQ your meat fuckers. There is no better way...
 
I find Costco has good steaks. I marinate with (a little) olive oil, balsamic vinegar and steak spice and throw them on the BBQ. Perfection!
 
vsailor said:
Man, my mouth is watering more reading this thread than it ever did reading a SP review!!!!!!!...man I must be getting old!!!!...the thought of a good steak gives me a woody over a pussy review....man.....:o

You will remember a great meal far better then you will remember great sex. Not to mention you can have that exact same meal again.
 
You know, I tried Stinky's way one day when I turned on the BBQ, and ran out of gas in the first minute or so. It was just for me, and I didn't feel like going out for another gas cylinder

I had already put on the steak seasonings, and I have one of those cast iron grill pans with the handles. I turned on the oven to 400 F, and turned on the stove top to high. As soon as it was red hot, I plunked on the steak, and turned as soon as it began to smoke for each side. Then it was off the stove top, and into the oven for 4 minutes at 400 F.

Mind you, it was a very good piece of meat to start with, but it came just as nice as a BBQ style steak.
 
a proper steak is done with lov and respect for the meat.. when you are done you must put it in a mouth to have it be savored... hahah dirty minds...
 
BBQ is the only way? Ever hear of Ruth's Chris Steakhouse? Wonder how they prepare their steaks?

BBQ is a style of cooking. What is being referred to, I'm sure, is grilling. Barbecue is a method of slow-cooking, preferred for pulled meats (e.g. pulled pork).

If you want to refer to "BBQ" as the cooking appliance and the manner of grilling a steak, that's fine. Just don't expect respect for doing so.
 
So that's why they use kosher salt

I noticed on the Food network they recommend kosher salt a lot but I thought it might be because the chefs were Jewish. Now I know why - good tip!

I highly recommend using a cast-iron pan to sear the steak. They provide all around even heat and get really hot. Do not use a coated pan or olive oil. With the kosher salt, I'll finally get a nice carmelized crust!

The other thing I want to stress is cooking steaks is about experience - the only way to know how long to cook a steak and keep it medium rare is trial and error. I've ruined enough steaks now to know how to get medium rare every time. I generally sear each side on medium high for 3 minutes, then use 375 degrees for 7 to 10 minutes but I'll try your suggestion of 450 degrees for 5 minutes.

Finally, a steak MUST be eaten with a glass of red wine, which you can use to deglaze the pan to make your gravy.

cheers to the good life
 
b00mzilla said:
Of course buy from a quality butcher, but here's a tip: when you are at the supermarket check out the reduced items. A steak that is slightly browned doesn't sell as well to the great unwashed, but steaks are best if they are aged. 2 weeks at least in cold temps...

BBQ your meat fuckers. There is no better way...

amazed. (no negitivity - just amazed) 3 years and this is your first post. what else are you not telling us? :)
 
Stove Top Cooking

I've tried cooking the steak the other way in terms of use of heating. This requires the use of instant read internal thermometer or an internal probe thermometer

Pre heat the oven to 275 F
Pat dry the meat and make sure there is not moisture present
Salt and Pepper the steak (Kosher salt preferred, as not to melt and cause moisture to leak out)
Insert a
Place the room temperature steak on a wire rack elevated off of a pan
Cook the steak in the oven to the desired internal temperature minus about 10 F (explained later) and the way you like it
Remove the steaks from the oven, and heat a pan on the stove top
Sear the steak just to get the crust
The searing of the steak on the stove top will bring the meat up to the desired internal temperature

I've use this method on pork chops also. Gently heating the meat (either pork or beef) does not allow the muscle fibres of the meat to tighten with the high heat and become tough. This is now the only way I cook meat on the stove top.