How Much Power Do The Lower Courts Have?

drlove

Ph.D. in Pussyology
Oct 14, 2001
4,895
329
83
The doctor is in
I was thinking we may not have to wait for a SCOC hearing... That is, if someone were to launch a challenge it would be heard by a lower court first, by default. After examining the case and the laws, taking into consideration the ruling on Bedford, what's to prevent a lower court from declaring the new law unconstitutional, and denying any appeals by the government? If that's possible, that would be one way to get the new law struck down expediently. Thoughts?
 
That's exactly what happened in the Bedford ruling. It was appealed by the govt and the law stayed in place. It went to the Ontario Court of Appeal and they upheld the lower court ruling. It was appealed to the SCC and the ruling was upheld again. The SCC kept the laws in place for 1 year to give the Govt time to come up with new legislation. The process took 5 years. I don't think there's any way around the appellate process
 
A lower court ruling would only be valid in the province in which it was made. It would have weight in other provinces, but that's about it. A Court of Appeal ruling would still only be valid in the province in which it was made but would hold considerably more weight in other provinces.

Like in Bedford, for a law with such broad implications, any decision would likely be stayed pending appeal. Either party has the right to appeal, all the way to the Supreme Court.
 
To answer your questions, any question of the constitutional validity of the law would be usually start at the Superior Court of Justice. They have the authority to strike down the law as they did in the Bedford decision. This would be binding on the government unless they were granted a stay on the ruling as in the Bedford case. They would almost always grant a leave to appeal their decision to the court of appeal where the matter before them is a question of law alone. This is the case here.
 
Very good question. Even if the laws remain on the books, the judicial precedent set by a lower court ruling still has reverberations throughout the justice system. For one, it's almost impossible for other trials to continue when the law may not be constitutional; many matters are stayed, pending the outcome of a higher-court ruling. Additionally, if a lower court strikes down a law for constitutional reasons, it can impact the amount of resources put towards enforcement of the law. For example, shortly after the OCA ruled on the Bedford case, Toronto Police ended "street sweeps" designed to entrap clients under the S.213(c) Communicating Law:

http://www.torontosun.com/2012/05/13/cops-put-john-sweeps-on-hold

(That's particularly interesting because the OCA actually found the Communicating Law to be constitutional with a 3-2 split, overruling the original decision, before the SCC reversed the OCA's decision and struck it down. So, TPS actually stopped enforcing a law that was constitutional at the time, even though the SCC didn't rule it unconstitutional for another 21 months.)

The difference here might be that the new laws are very similar to the old laws, and a lower court might take issue with the obvious attempt of the federal government to circumvent the decision. It's not clear if they'll grant a stay pending an appeal as they did last time, especially if the laws are shown to have a direct, harmful impact on those in the business. Also, even though the validity of the decision might be limited to the province in which it is rendered, courts in other provinces take note of such decisions, and can use them as precedent when deciding other cases.

Lastly, courts of law are supposed to be free from influence by the court of public opinion, but in reality, they're quite attuned to what's going on outside their chambers. A law like this, which is very unpopular around the country, might garner a different response than the original laws did.
 
I was thinking we may not have to wait for a SCOC hearing... That is, if someone were to launch a challenge it would be heard by a lower court first, by default. After examining the case and the laws, taking into consideration the ruling on Bedford, what's to prevent a lower court from declaring the new law unconstitutional, and denying any appeals by the government? If that's possible, that would be one way to get the new law struck down expediently. Thoughts?

Yes, a lower district court ruling, if it comes to that, could stop this in its tracks. Even if the law was stayed granting an appeal, LE wouldn't put too much effort into prosecuting under a law that might not pass Charter muster. This is what happened last time. Charges under the laws struck down by the Supreme Court stopped almost as soon as the District Court judge struck the laws down. If you're old enough to remember lap dancing, it took one district court judge to decide it was legal and clubs all over Ontario started offering lap dancing. Unfortunately that ruling was eventually overturned, but it's very unlikely this one would be.