How much is Ramirez worth?

blueline said:
You guys have it all wrong here.

90% of baseball is half mental.

regards,

Yogi Berra
Yeah, every real baseball fan knows that.
;)
(Oh, and the REAL quote is "good pitching stops good hitting, and vice versa" - Casey Stengel.)
 
Response(s)...

King Elessar said:
Blah blah blah. Same old, tired, wrong cliches. Actually, I know LOTS of "real baseball fans", and not many of them believe that ancient pile of shit.

No doubt the fantasy crowd....

King Elessar said:
When you have good pitchers vs. good hitters, over the long haul they will bring each other to the middle.

Over a season? Yes. Over a 5 to 7 game series? No.

Example: Yankees pretty much every season since 2001.


King Elessar said:
They have two World Series championships (far more than two rings, actually), due to the fact that they've outscored their opponents in those series.

2004: 24-12 composite score over four games - this isn't BIG NUMBER offense?! 6 runs per game?! wtf!?

2007: 29-10 composite score over four games - EVEN MORE RUNS PER GAME!

Perhaps in your attempt to become the king of all things baseball, you might have over looked this - you only need to win a game by one run. Doesn't matter how many YOU score...as long as it is at least ONE more than the opposition.

Meaning...24 to 12 is no better than 16 - 12. And...actually...you could score FEWER runs over a series...and still wins the series.

Baseball is not football. There is no field position, no time of possession. Having a "better offense" (at least as you describe it) is of no value if when you face good pitching it fails to perform.

Here is another nugget for you...good hitters...even very good hitters...tend to pad their stats against average and mediocre pitching. The very best hitters rise to the occasion (and I would put Manny on the list), but guys like Alphonso Soriano will be on a pace to hit 50 home runs...and then go 1 for 20 or whatever in a series. Because...good teams that make it to the playoffs have GOOD PITCHING.

King Elessar said:
But, you've gotta be kidding. In both series, the Boston offense SLAUGHTERED the opposition - 53 runs over 8 games - 6.5 runs per game.
But, it was somehow their PITCHING that was the deciding factor?!
On the contrary, I'd say that if they hadn't won those series, they could have blamed their pitching for not performing like their offense did.

And you would be wrong. They gave up an average of less than 3 runs a game in those series...meaning had they scored as few as 4 runs a game...low for a major league club...they would have still won.

As already explained - baseball is not football. The difference in score in any particular game is not a reflection on the relative strength of the two teams. Not for one single game. MUCH more often, it is a reflection regrading the quality of the pitchers in the game.

You are a stats / numbers guy, clearly, so perhaps you can understand this point: This season (post steroids) not withstanding, you would surely agree that scoring is up in MLB. More runs...more offense, blah blah.

How come then that the BEST pitchers...not average pitchers...mediocre pitchers...the BEST pitchers...still consistently have ERAs under 3.00? Hell...some pitchers during the last decade posted ERAs under 2.00. How can this be...scoring is up...hitters are getting better. How come the best pitchers still pitch lights out?

Because...good hitters fatten their stats against mediocre pitching (which is why a 4.00 ERA is considered "good" now). But top pitchers STILL get hitters out. They still win 20 games...they still have ERAs under 3.00. The gold standard for pitching hasn't changed in 30+ years.

Here is something else for you to think about...it is a bit more complicated, yet subtle, so it might go over your head...

A hitter gets 600 or so attempts a season to "do good". So...even if you do AWFUL against the top 20% of pitching...you get almost 500 more chances to still post numbers.Lets say a guy hits .200 against the top 20% of pitchers...but .350 against the rest of the pitchers in the league. That is a .320 average...pretty damn good...for a guy who can't even hit his weight against one out of five pitchers.

On the other hand, a pitcher only gets 30 to 35 chances to show what he has got. He either wins the game...or he doesn't. The best pitchers win about 2/3 of those games...and they win even though they have to face at least two or three "good hitters" every game. And some games (say against the Rangers), they have to face more.

A "good hitter" can make a very good living hitting only average pitching. A pitcher will never be "good" unless he can consistently get EVERYBODY out...because even if only the "good" hitters light him up, that is good for 3 or 4 runs...and giving up 3 or 4 runs every game will NOT get you 20 wins.

King Elessar said:
(a) Of those two teams you mentioned - the top two in offense this year - HALF of them made the playoffs. This is a good argument for having a good offense, as the percentage of teams who made the playoffs is, in general, much lower than this.

And the "other half" didn't...because their pitching sucked. They out scored every team in the league...but their pitchers couldn't stop even "average" hitters (you figure all the hitters they faced in the season represents a cumulative average) from scoring even MORE runs than that. And so...they lost.


King Elessar said:
(c) Boston - #2 AL offense, #5 defense (by ERA). How come those teams with better ERA didn't finish ahead of them?
(d) Phillies - #2 NL offense, #4 NL defense. Same question.

Umm...I dunno. How come the teams that scored even MORE runs than they did didn't finish ahead of them? Ahh...kids...


King Elessar said:
Both teams offenses outperformed their defenses.

A "ranking" means nothing in this case, but the math required to explain why is not worth detailing here. If you have ever taken a stats class, you should understand. I'll try to simplify it for you with an illustration

a) 900
b) 880
c) 870
d) 860

a) 4.00
b) 3.75
c) 3.50
d) 3.25

Now...if the first list is runs scored on the season...and the second list is team ERA...which team is better? Hmm?


King Elessar said:
How about, instead of trying to say that teams with defenses perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably false), we say that teams that are better OVERALL (combining both offense and defense) perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably true).
And in the regular season.
Of the four teams playing in the League Championships, you had #1 and #3 in runs differential (RS-RA) in the AL, and #2 and #6 in the NL.
Why isn't it the best defensive teams every year?
It's not.
It's the best OVERALL teams.

We can debate all day what "best overall" means. I do know this.

Of the 8 playoff teams, ALL EIGHT of them finished the season in the top 11 in pitching..and the White Sox missed the 10 slot by only .05 runs

On the other hand...only 4 of the top 11 hitting teams even made it to the playoffs. And three of them are already out of it.


King Elessar said:
(We could get into divisional schedules, and ballparks, but there's no need.

True - because I've already shown you that the best pitching wins. Different leagues, different divisions, different ball parks...all the playoff teams had one thing in common - good pitching overall for the season.


King Elessar said:
We could also get into how much freaking luck there is in a five game series, and even a seven game series, but there isn't much point.)

Yeah there is. It is this "luck" that you are speaking of that is the reason why a team with better hitting stats on the season (Phillies) might beat a team with better pitching stats (Dodgers). Of course, it went the other way in the Dodgers - Cub series. And the Rays are about to eliminate the Red Sox...that would be the Rays with the lower team ERA. Angels - Red Sox was a pitching toss up...so you could argue that the Red Sox better hitting is why the won. It isn't helping them against the Rays though. Brewers - Phillies...pitching toss up over the season...so maybe their better hitting was the key there...

King Elessar said:
Neither is CC Sabathia. So?

...or maybe it was because the Brewers pitched Sabathia into the ground at the end of the season...and Sheets couldn't pitch at all in the playoffs.
 
Offense is 1/2 BUT

Offense is not only hitting. Base running, bunting, moving runners over and more is all offense. Manny hits, period. I'd have to weigh in on the side that his productive contributions are less than 1/2 of the total picture based on the fact he doesn't do all the tasks related to offense well, only in pure hitting does he excel. Still, someone will overpay him to do just that. History says so.
 
Sure, but hitting is ALMOST half of offense. Those other things you mentioned really are pretty trivial.
And hitting is closer to half of offense than pitching is to half of defense.
(Edit: MEANT to say - hitting is almost half the game - hitting is closer to half the game than pitching is to half the game - this is because defense (vs. pitching) is worth more to a team's ability to minimize runs allowed than "small ball" (vs. hitting) is to a team's ability to maximize runs scored.)

More pitchers have been overpaid down through the years than hitters. LOTS more.

Didn't the Jays have, BY FAR, the best pitching in the AL this year?
Fat lotta good it did them, with the 11th best offense.
 
Last edited:
King Elessar said:
Sure, but hitting is ALMOST half of offense. Those other things you mentioned really are pretty trivial.
And hitting is closer to half of offense than pitching is to half of defense.
More pitchers have been overpaid down through the years than hitters. LOTS more.

Didn't the Jays have, BY FAR, the best pitching in the AL this year?
Fat lotta good it did them, with the 11th best offense.

Disagree about the ALMOST part. If hitting is ALMOST half of offense then the other parts that must make up MORE than half (the part left over) can't be considered trivial.
 
Yeah, sorry, I misspoke. Hitting is almost half the game, being almost ALL of offense.
How many bunts do you see these days? How big is the running game?
It's better to mash than play for one run - Earl Weaver knew this.

Anyway, it's pretty ridiculous to say that Manny doesn't mean that much to his team, or that the best hitters in the game are shut down by the best pitchers. Didn't Manny just do his best Superman impersonation? Didn't he just SHRED some of the best pitching in the game in the playoffs?
(BTW: Manny Ramirez vs. Pitching: ERA over 5.25 - 1.309 OPS; 4.26<ERA<5.25 - .981 OPS; 3.51<ERA<4.25 - .968 OPS; ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS ... yeah, it really looks like Manny is getting "shut down" by all that great pitching, and not that he's regressing to the mean. lol Sure, he feasted on weak pitching. Who doesn't? But, he still put up awesome numbers against the best pitchers in the game.)

I don't know how much he's worth, but if you're going to say "all he does is hit", that isn't much of an insult. Sorta like saying "all Halladay does is pitch - he doesn't field his position well". ;)
 
Better record than the Rangers...

King Elessar said:
Didn't the Jays have, BY FAR, the best pitching in the AL this year?
Fat lotta good it did them, with the 11th best offense.

...with their top ranked offense and bottom ranked pitching.

Seems to me you proved my point....great pitching carried an average hitting team to a winning record in a VERY tough division. Who know how they would have done if they didn't have to face the Rays, Red Soxs and Yankees an inordinate amount of times.

Rangers...Tigers...Indians...all teams that proved you can't out hit poor pitching. While the Rays very good pitching has taken their average hitting deep into the playoffs. (and would be in the World Series right now if Madden hadn't pulled a brain cramp)
 
I was going to do this long post...

King Elessar said:
Yeah, sorry, I misspoke. Hitting is almost half the game, being almost ALL of offense.
How many bunts do you see these days? How big is the running game?
It's better to mash than play for one run - Earl Weaver knew this.

Anyway, it's pretty ridiculous to say that Manny doesn't mean that much to his team, or that the best hitters in the game are shut down by the best pitchers. Didn't Manny just do his best Superman impersonation? Didn't he just SHRED some of the best pitching in the game in the playoffs?
(BTW: Manny Ramirez vs. Pitching: ERA over 5.25 - 1.309 OPS; 4.26<ERA<5.25 - .981 OPS; 3.51<ERA<4.25 - .968 OPS; ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS ... yeah, it really looks like Manny is getting "shut down" by all that great pitching, and not that he's regressing to the mean. lol Sure, he feasted on weak pitching. Who doesn't? But, he still put up awesome numbers against the best pitchers in the game.)

I don't know how much he's worth, but if you're going to say "all he does is hit", that isn't much of an insult. Sorta like saying "all Halladay does is pitch - he doesn't field his position well". ;)

...but i see you've done my work for me.

"ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS"

So...Manny had an OPS drop of more than 60 points against good pitching. And this is just one hitter...just one season.

Now...show us how those pitchers did against Manny...What was their winning percentage versus the teams Manny played on, versus the winning percentage of Manny's teams versus everyone else? Did Manny's teams do BETTER against better pitching, or worse? Hell...did Manny's teams even have a WINNING RECORD against those best pitchers?
 
Ramirez did all this with nobody hitting behind him, also nobody in front of him was good enough to consistently get on base, every time I saw him hitting the bases were mt, mind you I didn't see every game.

He's like Bonds was a few years ago, nobody wants to pitch to him and fans don't want to miss an at bat just to see what he will do. Argue all you want about bunting and running, he can change the whole game plan of the opposing team with his presenc(s)e. I like him.
 
Manny Rameriez...

BallzDeep said:
Ramirez did all this with nobody hitting behind him, also nobody in front of him was good enough to consistently get on base, every time I saw him hitting the bases were mt, mind you I didn't see every game.

He's like Bonds was a few years ago, nobody wants to pitch to him and fans don't want to miss an at bat just to see what he will do. Argue all you want about bunting and running, he can change the whole game plan of the opposing team with his presenc(s)e. I like him.


...can fucking rake. Absolutely no fucking question. I said that.

But no way Manny by himself is worth the same as say Roy Halliday.

Manny has a two homer 4 RBI game, does his team win? Maybe. Hell..let's say probably. More often so for a good TEAM...less often so for a bad one.

If Halliday gives up only 2 runs over 8 innings do the Blue Jays win? I am guessing yes...about 85% of the time.

Now...which happens more often....Halliday gives up 2 in 8, or Manny hits two homers in a game?

I'd curious to see the winning percentage of the Red Sox / Dodgers in games Manny hit a home run versus the winning percentage of the Jays in games Halliday started... No question the Red Sox are the better team, so they should play better when Manny plays well than the Jays do when Halliday plays well, right?

This is stupid...I don't even know why I bother...only an IDIOT thinks any everyday player has more impact than a pitcher of comparable stature....
 
MLAM said:
...with their top ranked offense and bottom ranked pitching.
Well, the Ranger's offense wasn't as good as the Jays' pitching, and their defense wasn't as bad as the Jays' hitting. So, that pretty much explains why their records were what they were.

MLAM said:
Seems to me you proved my point....great pitching carried an average hitting team to a winning record in a VERY tough division. Who know how they would have done if they didn't have to face the Rays, Red Soxs and Yankees an inordinate amount of times.
I thought your point was the great pitching shut down great hitting? It doesn't. It didn't NEARLY do the job for the Jays, who had BY FAR the best pitching and defense in the league.
I thought you didn't care about league or park? You said so. Changing your mind now? ;)

MLAM said:
Rangers...Tigers...Indians...all teams that proved you can't out hit poor pitching. While the Rays very good pitching has taken their average hitting deep into the playoffs. (and would be in the World Series right now if Madden hadn't pulled a brain cramp)
2007 Rockies, 92/93 Jays, 93 Phillies (just off the top of my head) - all teams that proved that you can outhit poor pitching all the way to the series.
 
MLAM said:
...but i see you've done my work for me.

"ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS"

So...Manny had an OPS drop of more than 60 points against good pitching. And this is just one hitter...just one season.
No, that was MY point. YOUR point was that great pitching SHUT DOWN great hitting. This shows that it most certainly does not. *I* said that the better the pitching, the more great hitters get regressed to the mean, which is EXACTLY what this shows. Manny RAKED against great pitchers.
Fail.

MLAM said:
Now...show us how those pitchers did against Manny...What was their winning percentage versus the teams Manny played on, versus the winning percentage of Manny's teams versus everyone else? Did Manny's teams do BETTER against better pitching, or worse? Hell...did Manny's teams even have a WINNING RECORD against those best pitchers?
Do your own research.
I just proved that great pitching didn't shut Manny down, as you said it would.
Give me some examples of great hitters shut down by great pitchers.
Anything else?
 
MLAM said:
...can fucking rake. Absolutely no fucking question. I said that.

But no way Manny by himself is worth the same as say Roy Halliday.

Manny has a two homer 4 RBI game, does his team win? Maybe. Hell..let's say probably. More often so for a good TEAM...less often so for a bad one.

If Halliday gives up only 2 runs over 8 innings do the Blue Jays win? I am guessing yes...about 85% of the time.
Apples and oranges.
Christ, you really don't know what you're talking about, do you? lol

Halliday (sic) faces 26+ batters over 8 innings, giving up two runs. That's 26+ plate appearances. If Manny has that many plate appearances, and repeats his one-game extravaganza, what do you think the odds are that his team wins three of those four, or four of those five? Pretty good, I'd say. Let's be generous - let's say, they go .600. (Assuming they play even average ball - unlike those terrible Dodgers, who really had no business being in the post-season, but that's divisional play for ya.)
What are the odds of Halladay (examine the spelling) pitches like that? 50/50. The Jays' winning percentage when he started was .606, not 85% - neither did they win every game he pitched like that, nor did he pitch like that every time out.

Does Doc have more of an effect on a game he appears in than a hitter? Of course. But, Manny gets to hit EVERY DAY. Roy pitches EVERY FIVE DAYS. Multiply Manny's in-game value by five to get to his actual value, relative to Doc.

So, if Halladay could pitch EVERY DAY, the Jays would be a .600 team. If Manny could hit in EVERY POSITION, his teams would be FAAAR better than .600. Neither will happen.

MLAM said:
Now...which happens more often....Halliday gives up 2 in 8, or Manny hits two homers in a game?
I don't know. Do you?
The fact is, Manny created more offensive runs than Roy Halladay prevented.

MLAM said:
I'd curious to see the winning percentage of the Red Sox / Dodgers in games Manny hit a home run versus the winning percentage of the Jays in games Halliday started... No question the Red Sox are the better team, so they should play better when Manny plays well than the Jays do when Halliday plays well, right?
All that an offensive player does isn't expressed by hitting homeruns. Manny helps create runs lots of times when he doesn't.

MLAM said:
This is stupid...I don't even know why I bother...only an IDIOT thinks any everyday player has more impact than a pitcher of comparable stature....
Right.
Which is why the MVP almost ALWAYS goes to an everyday player.
:rolleyes:
I guess all the GMs in the majors are IDIOTS.
Next.
 
I am only going to say this...

King Elessar said:
Which is why the MVP almost ALWAYS goes to an everyday player.
:rolleyes:
I guess all the GMs in the majors are idiots

...that if you don't know that the MVP is awarded by writers, not GMs, and WHY pitchers are never chosen, it explains a lot else...

ETA: I'll add this....

"Does Doc have more of an effect on a game he appears in than a hitter? Of course."

That was all I was saying. It seemed to me that someplace else you disagreed with this.

And in a seven game series, if you have two shut down guys, that is a likely 4 wins. We just saw a series where a position players hit like all hell....and it didn't help.

Now, I would try again to explain how the 2004 and 2007 series played out...how only two games out of the eight were won with Red Sox bats (because they needed them to cover up for bad pitching), versus the other six being won with pitching (because the opponent was held to 3 runs or less, meaning nothing was required of the Red Sox bats except what would be an average result from an average hitting team...4 or 5 runs) but you'd say it wa luck or soemthing

Now...you can argue all day and night about playing everyday versus every 5th game, runs contributed versus runs saved, blah blah.

What we know (thanks to your research) is that the Jays have a better winning percentage in games Halladay (Gawd, I SHOULD know that, for reasons I cannot share without outing myself...lol) starts than a better Red Sox team had in games Manny played.

Maybe the disconnect was that you are contending that great hitting helps more in the regular season than great pitching. I dunno. Lets go with "sure"...all day every day stuff etc.

But no way hitting is more valuable than pitching in a short series. If I need to win 4 games out of seven, what I want is any old average everyday MLB lineup....and two A class starting pitchers who are going to hold the other team to 3 runs or less (which I GUESS in your parlance is not "shut them down"...ok, fine) versus the Texas Rangers line up....and an average pitching staff that probably will not be able to keep a very good team from racking up 5 or 6 runs.
 
Another way to look at it

BM (before Manny) the Dodgers had a .500 record. 2 months with Manny they were 6 games over .500. So he made a 3 game per month difference. 18 games over a year ...... how much do you figure that's worth?
 
If he were going to do that for an entire season...

slurp said:
BM (before Manny) the Dodgers had a .500 record. 2 months with Manny they were 6 games over .500. So he made a 3 game per month difference. 18 games over a year ...... how much do you figure that's worth?


...30 mil at least.

On the other hand...

Boston had a higher winning percentage AFTER he left. Using your logic, he cost them wins. Meaning...he should be paying to play, versus the other way around.

Look...the guy can hit. I personally feel he is UNDER rated. He is one of the VERY FEW (maybe half dozen?) guys in the league who truly can hit essentially anybody. As I stated before, most all star type guys with all star number fest on weak pitching and average pitching. Manny (much like Bonds, Puljos, and a VERY few others) can hit anybody, and has proven it over an entire career, versus a few hot seasons.

When he retires, he will have 600+ HR, a .300+ batting average, and has a REALLY good shot at 3000 hits (he has 2400 now...and typically gets 150+ per season). Who else can say that...600HR.... .300 avg....3000 hits? Aaron & Mays. That's it.

But...the man is 36 years old, can't do anything BUT hit (gives you nothing in the field or on the bases), and has a reputation for wearing out his welcome.

He will get a 4 or 5 years deal for more money than any of us will ever see.

But I would be VERY surprised if it is for significantly more than he is getting now, and it might be for less...he might manage to convince some team to give him 5 years at just over 100 million, so he can brag that he is only the second player in history to sign two 100 million dollar plus contracts (geez...the other guy signed two TWO HUNDRED million dollar contracts...mind blowing when you think about it). But more than likely he will only get 4 years...and only for 20 mil a year....if that.

Remember...for each of the last couple years, the red Sox have been trying to unload Manny because they thought he was over paid for what he gave them...at bat...in the field...in he clubhouse. And their were no takers.
 
Last edited:
slurp said:
BM (before Manny) the Dodgers had a .500 record. 2 months with Manny they were 6 games over .500. So he made a 3 game per month difference. 18 games over a year ...... how much do you figure that's worth?

After giving this a bit more thought maybe some of the credit for some wins should also go to Blake ...... the point I was hoping folks would pick up on is that for all his gaudy numbers and wonderful teammate remarks we've heard he didn't help a mediocre team THAT much. And if he had been there all year he most likely would have not been as popular by the end of the season.

There's always some knucklehead owner who will pay (just like Boston did) for that kind of talent and cross their fingers he won't pull any dumb shit on his team. Of course he will, he always does. While they wouldn't trade good players for a chance he will behave, they will fill up a wheelbarrow with money for that chance. At least the owners that have money to burn.
 
Say it ain't so Manny ...........

I can't believe what I am reading in this article (link below). Manny is looking for the highest bidder for his next contract? No way!!!! No way did I think he took on Boras as his agent, or his tank job in Boston, his demand that the two $20 million options be removed from his contract before going to LA, had anything to do with money. I thought he just loved the game and wanted to finish his career in LA as he proclaimed about 2 days after he arrived.

Hmmmm, Manny doing this all for money, go figure. :rolleyes:

BTW, he is talking about six years. There are a few stupid people out there, however, I don't think anyone will be that stupid to give him six years. I say 3 years with an option at $20-22 million.

http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-simers16-2008oct16,0,3929713.column
 
Gas is up

I'm sure you heard the "Gas is up and so am I" comment. I hate to say anything remotely positive about him but it's kind of refreshing to hear an athlete admit he's going to the highest bidder. None of this "Money isn't the most important, blah blah blah" stuff.

As a Sox fan you have to be hoping the Mets outbid the Skankees .............. would suck to have him come back as a visitor with vengeance in his eye. Good theatre, bad if you're the opponent.