Yeah, every real baseball fan knows that.blueline said:You guys have it all wrong here.
90% of baseball is half mental.
regards,
Yogi Berra
(Oh, and the REAL quote is "good pitching stops good hitting, and vice versa" - Casey Stengel.)
Yeah, every real baseball fan knows that.blueline said:You guys have it all wrong here.
90% of baseball is half mental.
regards,
Yogi Berra
King Elessar said:Blah blah blah. Same old, tired, wrong cliches. Actually, I know LOTS of "real baseball fans", and not many of them believe that ancient pile of shit.
King Elessar said:When you have good pitchers vs. good hitters, over the long haul they will bring each other to the middle.
King Elessar said:They have two World Series championships (far more than two rings, actually), due to the fact that they've outscored their opponents in those series.
2004: 24-12 composite score over four games - this isn't BIG NUMBER offense?! 6 runs per game?! wtf!?
2007: 29-10 composite score over four games - EVEN MORE RUNS PER GAME!
King Elessar said:But, you've gotta be kidding. In both series, the Boston offense SLAUGHTERED the opposition - 53 runs over 8 games - 6.5 runs per game.
But, it was somehow their PITCHING that was the deciding factor?!
On the contrary, I'd say that if they hadn't won those series, they could have blamed their pitching for not performing like their offense did.
King Elessar said:(a) Of those two teams you mentioned - the top two in offense this year - HALF of them made the playoffs. This is a good argument for having a good offense, as the percentage of teams who made the playoffs is, in general, much lower than this.
King Elessar said:(c) Boston - #2 AL offense, #5 defense (by ERA). How come those teams with better ERA didn't finish ahead of them?
(d) Phillies - #2 NL offense, #4 NL defense. Same question.
King Elessar said:Both teams offenses outperformed their defenses.
King Elessar said:How about, instead of trying to say that teams with defenses perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably false), we say that teams that are better OVERALL (combining both offense and defense) perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably true).
And in the regular season.
Of the four teams playing in the League Championships, you had #1 and #3 in runs differential (RS-RA) in the AL, and #2 and #6 in the NL.
Why isn't it the best defensive teams every year?
It's not.
It's the best OVERALL teams.
King Elessar said:(We could get into divisional schedules, and ballparks, but there's no need.
King Elessar said:We could also get into how much freaking luck there is in a five game series, and even a seven game series, but there isn't much point.)
King Elessar said:Neither is CC Sabathia. So?
King Elessar said:Sure, but hitting is ALMOST half of offense. Those other things you mentioned really are pretty trivial.
And hitting is closer to half of offense than pitching is to half of defense.
More pitchers have been overpaid down through the years than hitters. LOTS more.
Didn't the Jays have, BY FAR, the best pitching in the AL this year?
Fat lotta good it did them, with the 11th best offense.
King Elessar said:Didn't the Jays have, BY FAR, the best pitching in the AL this year?
Fat lotta good it did them, with the 11th best offense.
King Elessar said:Yeah, sorry, I misspoke. Hitting is almost half the game, being almost ALL of offense.
How many bunts do you see these days? How big is the running game?
It's better to mash than play for one run - Earl Weaver knew this.
Anyway, it's pretty ridiculous to say that Manny doesn't mean that much to his team, or that the best hitters in the game are shut down by the best pitchers. Didn't Manny just do his best Superman impersonation? Didn't he just SHRED some of the best pitching in the game in the playoffs?
(BTW: Manny Ramirez vs. Pitching: ERA over 5.25 - 1.309 OPS; 4.26<ERA<5.25 - .981 OPS; 3.51<ERA<4.25 - .968 OPS; ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS ... yeah, it really looks like Manny is getting "shut down" by all that great pitching, and not that he's regressing to the mean. lol Sure, he feasted on weak pitching. Who doesn't? But, he still put up awesome numbers against the best pitchers in the game.)
I don't know how much he's worth, but if you're going to say "all he does is hit", that isn't much of an insult. Sorta like saying "all Halladay does is pitch - he doesn't field his position well".![]()
BallzDeep said:Ramirez did all this with nobody hitting behind him, also nobody in front of him was good enough to consistently get on base, every time I saw him hitting the bases were mt, mind you I didn't see every game.
He's like Bonds was a few years ago, nobody wants to pitch to him and fans don't want to miss an at bat just to see what he will do. Argue all you want about bunting and running, he can change the whole game plan of the opposing team with his presenc(s)e. I like him.
Well, the Ranger's offense wasn't as good as the Jays' pitching, and their defense wasn't as bad as the Jays' hitting. So, that pretty much explains why their records were what they were.MLAM said:...with their top ranked offense and bottom ranked pitching.
I thought your point was the great pitching shut down great hitting? It doesn't. It didn't NEARLY do the job for the Jays, who had BY FAR the best pitching and defense in the league.MLAM said:Seems to me you proved my point....great pitching carried an average hitting team to a winning record in a VERY tough division. Who know how they would have done if they didn't have to face the Rays, Red Soxs and Yankees an inordinate amount of times.
2007 Rockies, 92/93 Jays, 93 Phillies (just off the top of my head) - all teams that proved that you can outhit poor pitching all the way to the series.MLAM said:Rangers...Tigers...Indians...all teams that proved you can't out hit poor pitching. While the Rays very good pitching has taken their average hitting deep into the playoffs. (and would be in the World Series right now if Madden hadn't pulled a brain cramp)
No, that was MY point. YOUR point was that great pitching SHUT DOWN great hitting. This shows that it most certainly does not. *I* said that the better the pitching, the more great hitters get regressed to the mean, which is EXACTLY what this shows. Manny RAKED against great pitchers.MLAM said:...but i see you've done my work for me.
"ERA<=3.50 - .939 OPS"
So...Manny had an OPS drop of more than 60 points against good pitching. And this is just one hitter...just one season.
Do your own research.MLAM said:Now...show us how those pitchers did against Manny...What was their winning percentage versus the teams Manny played on, versus the winning percentage of Manny's teams versus everyone else? Did Manny's teams do BETTER against better pitching, or worse? Hell...did Manny's teams even have a WINNING RECORD against those best pitchers?
Apples and oranges.MLAM said:...can fucking rake. Absolutely no fucking question. I said that.
But no way Manny by himself is worth the same as say Roy Halliday.
Manny has a two homer 4 RBI game, does his team win? Maybe. Hell..let's say probably. More often so for a good TEAM...less often so for a bad one.
If Halliday gives up only 2 runs over 8 innings do the Blue Jays win? I am guessing yes...about 85% of the time.
I don't know. Do you?MLAM said:Now...which happens more often....Halliday gives up 2 in 8, or Manny hits two homers in a game?
All that an offensive player does isn't expressed by hitting homeruns. Manny helps create runs lots of times when he doesn't.MLAM said:I'd curious to see the winning percentage of the Red Sox / Dodgers in games Manny hit a home run versus the winning percentage of the Jays in games Halliday started... No question the Red Sox are the better team, so they should play better when Manny plays well than the Jays do when Halliday plays well, right?
Right.MLAM said:This is stupid...I don't even know why I bother...only an IDIOT thinks any everyday player has more impact than a pitcher of comparable stature....
King Elessar said:Which is why the MVP almost ALWAYS goes to an everyday player.
I guess all the GMs in the majors are idiots
slurp said:BM (before Manny) the Dodgers had a .500 record. 2 months with Manny they were 6 games over .500. So he made a 3 game per month difference. 18 games over a year ...... how much do you figure that's worth?
slurp said:BM (before Manny) the Dodgers had a .500 record. 2 months with Manny they were 6 games over .500. So he made a 3 game per month difference. 18 games over a year ...... how much do you figure that's worth?