MLAM said:
...no. It is at best one third.
Offense is ONE-THIRD of baseball?!?
Watch a game. Offense is half the equation, defense the other half. That has to be obvious. Right? So, you're only argument could be that hitting isn't half of offense - that it is "at best" two-thirds of offense, with the other third being ... running?
ROTFL
No, nobody believes that. Nobody who studies the game, that is.
MLAM said:
And, as anyone who is a real baseball fan will tell you, good pitching will shutdown good hitting.
Blah blah blah. Same old, tired, wrong cliches. Actually, I know LOTS of "real baseball fans", and not many of them believe that ancient pile of shit.
This has been proven wrong so many times it's painful.
When you have good pitchers vs. good hitters, over the long haul they will bring each other to the middle.
MLAM said:
The Red Sox have two World series rings thanks to timely and clutch hitting (not necessarily big numbers) and Josh Beckett, Curt Schilling, Dice K and Jon Lester.
They have two World Series championships (far more than two rings, actually), due to the fact that they've outscored their opponents in those series.
2004: 24-12 composite score over four games - this isn't BIG NUMBER offense?! 6 runs per game?! wtf!?
2007: 29-10 composite score over four games - EVEN MORE RUNS PER GAME!
MLAM said:
Between the 4 of them they surrendered FOUR earned runs during the 2007 World Series. In the 2003 World series, you had 8 shutout innings from Pedro Martinez and Derek Lowe, along with the famous "bloody sock" performance from Schilling. Out of those eight World Series wins, I'd say only one...Game 1, 2003...was won with the Red Sox bats.
You mean 2003, right?
But, you've gotta be kidding. In both series, the Boston offense SLAUGHTERED the opposition - 53 runs over 8 games - 6.5 runs per game.
But, it was somehow their PITCHING that was the deciding factor?!
On the contrary, I'd say that if they hadn't won those series, they could have blamed their pitching for not performing like their offense did.
MLAM said:
The Chicago Cubs were second in the Major League in scoring this year...what did it get them? A quick exit from the playoffs. The Texas Rangers were first...900+ runs..more than 5.5 a game. What did it get them? A losing record.
I mean, if you can't see the answers to these questions more clearly, you're not trying hard enough. Baseball is HALF OFFENSE, HALF DEFENSE.
(a) Of those two teams you mentioned - the top two in offense this year - HALF of them made the playoffs. This is a good argument for having a good offense, as the percentage of teams who made the playoffs is, in general, much lower than this.

(b) Rangers - first in offense, last in defense. That sounds pretty much like a middle of the road club, and that's what they were - 79-83.
(c) Boston - #2 AL offense, #5 defense (by ERA). How come those teams with better ERA didn't finish ahead of them?
(d) Phillies - #2 NL offense, #4 NL defense. Same question.
Both teams offenses outperformed their defenses.
How about, instead of trying to say that teams with defenses perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably false), we say that teams that are better OVERALL (combining both offense and defense) perform better in the playoffs (demonstrably true).
And in the regular season.
Of the four teams playing in the League Championships, you had #1 and #3 in runs differential (RS-RA) in the AL, and #2 and #6 in the NL.
Why isn't it the best defensive teams every year?
It's not.
It's the best OVERALL teams.
(We could get into divisional schedules, and ballparks, but there's no need. We could also get into how much freaking luck there is in a five game series, and even a seven game series, but there isn't much point.)
MLAM said:
And let me remind you that Manny Ramirez will NOT be playing in the World Series this year....
Neither is CC Sabathia. So?