how much does a professonal iq test cost?

There is also the effect of life experiences on personality that may appear to affect intelligence.

For example, a highly intelligent young lad may have had to go to places like Cambodia and Rwanda where horror does not even begin the description. His views of people may have become severely distorted. He may appear reclusive, unable to hold relationships with people and seek the company of escorts as an alternative to real relationships.

Generally he appears as a mental fuck-up, but is still good at solving a puzzles.

The total of a human personality is indeed far more than what a single test can reveal.

Perhaps a variation of Helen Keller's quote

"The best and most beautiful things in the world cannot be seen or even touched. They must be felt with the heart."

There are people who do great things with their lives, we feel those positive effects in our lives, their score on a test is irrelevant.
 
There is also the effect of life experiences on personality that may appear to affect intelligence.

Damn if I can remember the conclusion but there have been "nature vs nurture" studies done with identical twins separated at birth who underwent different life experiences and the impact it had on their intelligence and personality.
 
High I.Q.??

The Good...

You get to go through High School without ever owning a note book, studying or handing in a project. That's because you can write a 99% exam hungover like a mofo. You show up two or three days a week and can't believe that they are still trying to figure out the same lame shit that you bailed on three days ago. You get to point out on a final physics exam that the question is wrong and get to watch six teachers try and figure out what to do about it. You get the satisfaction of notising that you were the only one of a thousand to have either the brains or the balls to call them on it. You get to leave a two hour exam after thirty minutes because you're done..

You can figure out most things by thinking about them for ten seconds. They must work this way because there's no other logical way for them to work.. To have a high I.Q meas that 1,3,5,7.. means that the next number is nine for the rest of the world in about three seconds... 3, 17, 34..... would tie them up for a while, you just know what the next number is... and you don't know why you know or how... you just know you're right,,

The Bad..

Stoopid people.. well actually, they aren't stupid, they're just slower than you.. they always have been and they always will be.. you can just damn well get used to waiting for them to catch up.. they never will, but it's fun to watch. Unfortunately, when you're in the 98th percentile of the population.. it means you will wait for pretty much everybody.. always.. you'll have to learn to smile and think nothing while you wait for them to catch up..

The ugly...

Realizing that the chances of finding a SO who actually turns you on AND can keep up mentally with you is virtually zero. You get to reconcile that your best bet in a SO is a fifty watt bulb that you can tolerate long term. You can go to a Mensa mixer and meet a shitload of smart women who wouldn`t know fun if it bit them in the ass and you can meet `regular`women who are an absolute hoot to be around, but haven`t got the grey matter to figure out squat.. but neither one makes you go whoohoo...

In the end, you just settle for other alternatives..

I wouldn`t wish a high I.Q. on my worst enemy, I`m not that cruel...
 
^^^^So a rich man does not care for money and only the poor one craves it?
 
There are lots of things that can dramatically change IQ over time, in either direction. It appears that the main reason most people's IQs are fairly consistent over time is because people's environments are also usually fairly consistent over time, not because IQ is something that isn't heavily influenced by environmental factors.

If you actually look closely at twin studies, you'll be astonished at what qualifies as being "raised apart" (some of the identical twins counted as "raised apart" for the purpose of studies trying to separate environment from genetics went to the same schools growing up!), so they also don't show what some people think they do about the genetic impact on IQ.

OTOH, the Flynn effect pretty conclusively proves that environment is a huge impact on IQ. If you removed the normalization which sets the average IQ at any given time to 100, people's IQs in the industrialized world would be around 20-30 points higher now than they were a century ago (in some countries the differences are even greater).

And, of course, there's the controversy over whether it measures anything terribly important. I kick ass at standardized tests of any kind, including IQ tests, so I wish I could believe they're very accurate measures of a very important characteristic. Unfortunately, I'm too smart to believe that. :-)
 
What does IQ measure?

Here's what IQ measures. You have 100 candidates to fill six vacancies. (All 100 have passed the qualifying exams, or other prelim screening.) So how do you choose which six?

Of course, you will select some duffers, and you will miss some gems, whatever selection criteria you use. But with nearly all selection methods that have been tried, over the years, you might as well draw the names out of a hat. The only selection method known to be statistically better than pulling names out of a hat is to give the same IQ test to all one hundred, and then you select the six with the highest IQ scores.

Some HR managers can't explain their uncanny ability to distinguish between the gems and the duffers - they just know -- managers like that are generally worse then picking randomly - the more sure they are, the worse they are.

What about intensive and lengthy interviews, conducted at great expense?? - you might as well use the hat. The only selection procedure known for actually predicting, between qualified candidates, which will be the more likely to succeed at the job, is the IQ test.

The more intellectual the job, the more accurate the prediction. But it works for all levels of jobs.

What does the IQ test measure? The IQ scores of several candidates correlates, at least roughly, with their ability to succeed on the job. Nothing else is know to correlate, at all.
 
There are lots of things that can dramatically change IQ over time, in either direction. It appears that the main reason most people's IQs are fairly consistent over time is because people's environments are also usually fairly consistent over time, not because IQ is something that isn't heavily influenced by environmental factors.

Besides malnutrition, or some other severe environmental deprivation, what are the things that can dramatically change IQ over time?

If you actually look closely at twin studies, you'll be astonished at what qualifies as being "raised apart" (some of the identical twins counted as "raised apart" for the purpose of studies trying to separate environment from genetics went to the same schools growing up!), so they also don't show what some people think they do about the genetic impact on IQ.

I'm not privy to the details but I'm fairly certain that researchers have either removed this confounding variable or have accounted for it in the studies.

There is other converging evidence from adoption studies where kids who are born to high IQ parents have high IQs regardless of the environment or the IQs of their adoptive parents. Likewise, kids who are born to parents who have lower IQs also have lower IQs even when they're raised in healthy environments and under the tutelage of adoptive parents who have high IQs. Environment is important, but all things being equal, genetics has the final say.

OTOH, the Flynn effect pretty conclusively proves that environment is a huge impact on IQ. If you removed the normalization which sets the average IQ at any given time to 100, people's IQs in the industrialized world would be around 20-30 points higher now than they were a century ago (in some countries the differences are even greater).

IQ score have risen on average by 3 points each decade for the past century, and the reasons remain a mystery. However, this trend appears to have reached a plateau and is either stagnant or falling/decreasing in the industrialized world.

Jensen's hypothesis for the Flynn Effect includes:

1) A greater use of standardized tests and a resultant increased familiarity with test taking
2) Improvements in education and years of schooling
3) Improved nutrition and healthcare
4) medical advances/practices and in inoculations of most children against formerly common childhood diseases

Some researchers have shown that while IQ scores on the tests have risen, it has done so on the tests' specific knowledge content and skills, but not on the g factor.

And, of course, there's the controversy over whether it measures anything terribly important. I kick ass at standardized tests of any kind, including IQ tests, so I wish I could believe they're very accurate measures of a very important characteristic. Unfortunately, I'm too smart to believe that. :-)

I don't think there is much controversy about whether it measures anything important.

I think there is controversy over its predictive power and all the social baggage and ramifications that comes with that, especially when it is used as an exclusive criteria. Although it is the best predictor of group outcomes, there is no way to determine how successful an individual is going to be or what job they are going to have simply by knowing their IQ score. Environment, opportunity, personality all play a role in this and even knowing all these things, we cannot make completely accurate predictions. Predictive power does get stronger on the extreme ends of the Bell Curve. For example, if somebody has an average IQ of 100, I can conclude with a great deal of certainty that they will never become a rocket scientist. I won't say that it's impossible, just highly unlikely. If somebody has an IQ of 80 or less, I can conclude with a great deal of certainty that they will probably struggle with learning in school. Individuals with IQs of 130+ have the raw mental ability to become lawyers, doctors, scientists etc. easier, and therefore you'll find a higher concentration of people with high IQs in those occupations.

IQ scores do not decide if somebody is a good or bad person. Some very evil people have high IQs and some people with the warmest hearts do not.
 
Last edited:
Don't bother with the "professional" IQ tests. Take a couple of the online tests, and you'll get a sense of where you stand.

IQ is not an absolute, perfect measure. It is a relative measure: if your IQ is measured at 105, then it's *likely* that your IQ is higher (whatever that means) than someone whose IQ was measured at 100. And it's even more likely that your IQ is higher than someone whose score came in at 95. But you could score 105 one day, 108 another day, even 101 another day. That doesn't mean your IQ *is* 108, or 101. But there's certainly evidence to the effect that it's somewhere in that general range.

Note, too, that many tools measuring IQ have difficulty differentiating between scores above about 135: if your score is in that range, know that your IQ score is high, but don't get hung up on the exact figure.

And remember, too, that 100 is "average".
 
GotGusto, improving a person's educational environment can produce dramatic increases in IQ. However, since you cite Jensen, showing that you are either too biased to accept the numerous devastating criticisms of Jensen (or perhaps too ignorant to be familiar with them), it's probably pointless to respond further. Really, I shouldn't let myself be distracted so easily; I came upon this thread while trying to do a search for intelligent SPs. If my own IQ tests were as meaningful as I wish they were, I'd have thought I would have at least bothered to check the dates and see this was an old thread which didn't need to be revived, and perhaps realized what a waste of time it would be to get involved even if it had been a fresh thread.
 
GotGusto, improving a person's educational environment can produce dramatic increases in IQ. However, since you cite Jensen, showing that you are either too biased to accept the numerous devastating criticisms of Jensen (or perhaps too ignorant to be familiar with them), it's probably pointless to respond further. Really, I shouldn't let myself be distracted so easily; I came upon this thread while trying to do a search for intelligent SPs. If my own IQ tests were as meaningful as I wish they were, I'd have thought I would have at least bothered to check the dates and see this was an old thread which didn't need to be revived, and perhaps realized what a waste of time it would be to get involved even if it had been a fresh thread.

Post the numerous devastating criticisms of Jensen. It's not a waste of time at all. While you're at it, please define "dramatic increases" in IQ. Is it 1 point, 5 points, 10 points, more? Are these increases sustained or do they virtually disappear after childhood?

Your post is not a rebuttal to what I've written, it's nothing more than a hollow attack.

Sorry Doc, not all people are equal in mental capacity. This is a biological fact of life.
 
The guy asked what does the real thing cost, not something online. Around 200 bucks nowadays, is about right. Contact a nearby psychologist or psychiatrist and ask if he/she administers the test, which will probably be the Wechsler (WAIS-R IV)

It is true that you were probably tested with the Stanford-Binet as a kid, and your score will probably not have changed much.

You need 130 on the WAIS-R, and 132 on the Stanford-Binet, to get into Mensa, which will get you a laminated wallet card and bragging rights. These scores put you in the 98th percentile, or very superior, aka genius range.

There are other, more elite societies for higher scores. For The Triple-Nine Society, for example, you need to be in the 99.9 percentile.

Mensa will test you for 90 bucks, but I'm not sure what test they use. I suspect it's something that they developed themselves. It's only a half-hour long and probably all on paper, and heavily puzzle based.

You can probably shave a point or two by preparing in advance, by being well rested, well fed and caffeinated prior to you appointment.

The story that Karla Homolka had an IQ of 150 is almost certainly bullshit. I've never understood where these super-high (150+) numbers the media comes up with actually come from, since the standard tests barely register in those levels. To be 99.9 in S-B you need 149 and the WAIS-R 146.
 
I seem to still be too dumb to leave this alone. 10+, easily. You are correct that early educational interventions don't have lasting effects, if that's what you're referring to. But that just points to the tremendous importance of environment; put people back in a terrible environment after they were in a good one, and of course their measured IQ drops again. The method that was used to isolate g will produce a result whenever it is applied to a set of variables that positively correlate with one another. Thus, it would still have produced a result if you'd thrown in some additional elements positively correlated with what you already had; say, wealth, height, good looks, prosperous ancestors, high position, good reputation. This new master variable, call it "a" (for "arete," the ancient Greek word for virtue or excellence so extensively discussed by the classical philosophers) would also of course be highly heritable, since many of the characteristics that comprise it are. And voila, you have the traditional justification for aristocracy; some people are just born better than others (having more a), and obviously they should be in charge. The current wealthy and powerful are the current best people (since wealth and power are part of a) and so their rule is legitimate, and because of the high heritability, it only makes sense that their children are the best candidates for who should be in charge after them. But while some of the things apologists for aristocracy point to are of course legitimate points, overall the drawbacks of aristocracy far outweigh the benefits. And while I personally prefer to avoid realist turns of phrase and instead focus on what really matters, given the problems with aristocracy it would be fairly reasonable to say that there's no such thing as arete, even though there are these things that are positively correlated with one another and relatively stable over time.

Still, aristocracy produced some level of political stability. What has g ever produced, other than fraudulent justifications for racism (did Jensen ever acknowledge the problems with his alleged evidence that races differ significantly in intelligence?)
 
I seem to still be too dumb to leave this alone. 10+, easily. You are correct that early educational interventions don't have lasting effects, if that's what you're referring to. But that just points to the tremendous importance of environment; put people back in a terrible environment after they were in a good one, and of course their measured IQ drops again. The method that was used to isolate g will produce a result whenever it is applied to a set of variables that positively correlate with one another. Thus, it would still have produced a result if you'd thrown in some additional elements positively correlated with what you already had; say, wealth, height, good looks, prosperous ancestors, high position, good reputation. This new master variable, call it "a" (for "arete," the ancient Greek word for virtue or excellence so extensively discussed by the classical philosophers) would also of course be highly heritable, since many of the characteristics that comprise it are. And voila, you have the traditional justification for aristocracy; some people are just born better than others (having more a), and obviously they should be in charge. The current wealthy and powerful are the current best people (since wealth and power are part of a) and so their rule is legitimate, and because of the high heritability, it only makes sense that their children are the best candidates for who should be in charge after them. But while some of the things apologists for aristocracy point to are of course legitimate points, overall the drawbacks of aristocracy far outweigh the benefits. And while I personally prefer to avoid realist turns of phrase and instead focus on what really matters, given the problems with aristocracy it would be fairly reasonable to say that there's no such thing as arete, even though there are these things that are positively correlated with one another and relatively stable over time.

Still, aristocracy produced some level of political stability. What has g ever produced, other than fraudulent justifications for racism (did Jensen ever acknowledge the problems with his alleged evidence that races differ significantly in intelligence?)

I'm not an aristocrat, I've never been part of our society's priviledged class, and I still do not belong to it. I was born to two teenagers, lost souls, both from broken homes. I'm NOT a rags to riches story and my position has zero to do with justifying the social status quo. I have far to go before I can eat caviar, golf all day, and pay to fuck several models whenever I choose, and I'm not holding my breathe on achieving that level of financial success in my lifetime.

The results of adoption studies on IQ are at odds with what you've stated. These children were removed from poorer environments and never returned to them. What's left is the minutae of suggesting that there may be pre-natal effects on IQ . I don't discourage those hypotheses, but I also acknowledge that people are born different in all respects and inherent mental ability is no exception to this law of nature.

We can argue about the existence of g all day, however mulitple disciplines in science have been incorporating it for years now. If the topic at hand were unrelated to "intelligence", it would be readily accepted by people like you because the social ramifications would be considered benign, and the mountain of evidence beyond sufficient.

Rather than a series of ad hoc explanations to explain the flipside for what we observe, I have to go with Occam's Razor. I'm always open to new evidence, but there hasn't been a whole lot forthcoming in the past 100 years of research in this area (and note that citing the results of a single study here or there which has never been reproduced falls short of scientific rigor).

Where has the evidence taken you, DocOdd, and what exactly is it that you believe? That given the right environment we can all be math wizzes?

Please detail the problems raised with Jensen that you refer to your in last comment. By whom? The hack named Stephen Jay Gould? Let's stay away from the smear campaigns and the muddying of the waters.

Accepting the natural law that individuals differ intelligence (just as they do in temperament, appearance, and EVERYTHING else), isn't the same as accepting biological or genetic determinism. These things sometimes can and sometimes do change, often more easily observed over generations. And I've also said all along that environment is important.
 
Btw, there are many people smarter than me who have less money than me, and and I'm also more intelligent than many rich people.
 
I do find it ironic to see Gould described as a hack by someone who lionizes Jensen, but no, Gould is not my main source, although he certainly knew more about evolutionary biology than Jensen, and that does seem like something one ought to understand before making lots of claims about genetics. BTW, your confidence that those who conducted the twin studies corrected for any problems with the sample is charming, but no, they didn't. How could they? They'd need a larger data set to reliably identify the biases, and that's exactly what they didn't have. Indeed, a lot of studies in this area seem to fit a pattern of correcting for one or two environmental facts that seemed obvious to the researcher, and then confidently asserting that since after all environmental factors were accounted for there remained a measurable result it must therefore be genetic. But people's environments are a tiny bit more complicated than that. Those who actually study environmental factors seem to have little trouble coming up with factors Jensen and his followers missed; Ogbu had a theory which seems to account for the patterns of racial difference quite well. He could be wrong, but I've never seen any cogent criticism of his take on these matters, and of course even if he's wrong there could be something among the countless environmental factors we either haven't figured out how to correct for yet, or haven't even considered might be important. Indeed, one way in which Gould, for all his hyperbole, is perhaps a useful antidote to the people who are convinced of genetic differences in intelligence between races is that the latter never seem to be even slightly aware of how prima facie implausible their thesis is given what we know about population genetics.

On the Flynn effect, I suppose I lean more toward Flynn's theory than the theories of a hack like Jensen (some of the explanations you cite from Jensen also have experimental data against them, as I wish I were surprised you apparently didn't know). "G-loaded" IQ tests are tests of a variety of abstract reasoning skills, and the modern world gives people more practice in those skills than more primitive ways of life did, so modern people do better on tests of those skills. Again, it might not be true, but it's the most plausible I've encountered.

And I note you gave no examples of these many disciplines in science that have been incorporating g. Which disciplines were they? What have they been using it for? I've encountered statisticians who use it as an example of misuse of statistical methods, and philosophers of science who use it as an example of bad methodology in science, but I assume those weren't the disciplines and uses you were thinking of.
 
I do find it ironic to see Gould described as a hack by someone who lionizes Jensen, but no, Gould is not my main source, although he certainly knew more about evolutionary biology than Jensen, and that does seem like something one ought to understand before making lots of claims about genetics.

Jensen is no hack. He's rated as one of the most eminemt psychologists of the 20th century and anybody familiar with his body of work in the field understands why. http://htpprints.yorku.ca/archive/00000064/

As for Gould, I'll let the criticims of his "The Mismeasure of Man" speak for itself:
Bernard Davis, professor of microbiology at the Harvard Medical School, accused Gould of setting up straw man arguments, as well as incorrectly defining key terms (notably "reification"), choosing data in a "highly selective" manner, and in general being motivated more by political concerns rather than scientific ones.[9] Davis claimed that a laudatory review by Philip Morrison, which appeared in Scientific American, was written because the journal's editorial staff had "long seen the study of the genetics of intelligence as a threat to social justice." According to Davis, the reviews of Gould's book in the popular and literary press were generally very approbatory, whereas, in contrast, most reviews in scientific journals tended to be critical of many aspects of the book. Davis also pointed out that Gould mispresented a study by Henry H. Goddard on the intelligence of Jewish, Hungarian, Italian, and Russian immigrants to America. According to Gould, Goddard found that most members of these groups were "feeble-minded", whereas in reality Goddard explicitly described in the first sentence of his paper that the subjects of the study were not typical members of their groups but rather were selected because of their suspected sub-normal intelligence.[10]

Statistician David J. Bartholomew, of the London School of Economics, wrote that Gould erred in his use of factor analysis[11] and irrelevantly focused on issue of reification and ignored scientific consensus on the existence of the g factor of intelligence.[12] Psychologist John B. Carroll made similar criticisms, arguing that Gould did not understand "the nature and purpose" of factor analysis.[13]

Arthur Jensen, an educational psychologist at UC Berkeley, was heavily criticized in The Mismeasure of Man. In his review of the book, Jensen accused Gould of using straw man arguments, misrepresenting other scientists, and operating from a political agenda, arguing that the book itself is "a patent example" of the biasing influence of ideology on science that it purports to portray. He also faulted Gould for concentrating on long-ago disproven theories instead of addressing "anything currently regarded as important by scientists in the relevant fields".[14]

In an article written for the April 1982 edition of Nature, Steve Blinkhorn, a senior lecturer in psychology at Hatfield Polytechnic, accused Gould of selectively juxtaposing data in order to further a political agenda, describing the book as "a masterpiece of propaganda".[15]

Psychologist Franz Samelson wrote a review in Science, which tended to be critical on a number of counts.[16] Samelson, for example, was critical of Gould's argument that U.S. Army intelligence tests contributed to the Immigration Restriction Act of 1924. According Mark Snyderman and Richard J. Herrnstein, who studied the Congressional Record and committee hearings related to the Immigration Act, "the [intelligence] testing community did not generally view its findings as favoring restrictive immigration policies like those in the 1924 Act, and Congress took virtually no notice of intelligence testing."[17]

In a 1983 review, psychologist Lloyd Humphreys, the then editor-in-chief of American Journal of Psychology and Psychological Bulletin, described The Mismeasure of Man as "science fiction" and "political propaganda". Among other things, he argued that Gould had mispresented the views of Alfred Binet, Godfrey Thomson, and Lewis Terman.[18]

James R. Flynn, an intelligence researcher known for his criticisms of racial theories of intelligence, argued that "Gould's book evades all of [Arthur] Jensen's best arguments for a genetic component in the black-white IQ gap by positing that they are dependent on the concept of g as a general intelligence factor. Therefore, Gould believes that if he can discredit g no more need be said. This is manifestly false. Jensen's arguments would bite no matter whether blacks suffered from a score deficit on one or 10 or 100 factors."[19] Bernard Davis and Jensen himself have made this same criticism.[10][14]

According to psychologist Ian Deary, Gould's claim that there is no relation between brain size and IQ is outdated. Furthermore, he reports that Gould refused to correct this in new editions of the book, even though newly available data were brought to his attention by several researchers.[20]

Psychologist Hans Eysenck was critiqued in The Mismeasure of Man for using a "non-causal" relationship to defend a conclusion that black children have lower innate IQ.[21] Eysenck and Gould debated the book in an exchange of letters to The New York Review of Books.[22][23] Eysenck's review called the book "a paleontologist's distorted view of what psychologists think, untutored in even the most elementary facts of the science." Gould criticized Eysenck's correlation of IQ with EEG evoked potentials by citing Arthur Jensen's own work in Bias in Mental Testing (1980). Jensen could only find "correlations larger than about -0.4 to -0.5" between reaction time and IQ, with typical correlations ranging between -0.3 and -0.4. Jensen wrote: "The AEP average evoked potential and IQ research picture soon becomes a thicket of seemingly inconsistent and confusing findings, confounded variables, methodological differences, statistically questionable conclusions, unbridled theoretical speculation, and, not surprisingly, considerable controversy."[24]

Charles Murray, co-author of The Bell Curve, claimed that Gould misrepresented his views.[25]

Psychologist J. Philippe Rushton, head of the Pioneer Fund—which funds research towards "the scientific study of heredity and human differences"—accused Gould of "scholarly malfeasance" for misrepresenting or ignoring relevant scientific research, and attacking dead arguments and methods.
 
As for this back and forth on IQ, I'm sorry to tell you, but the debate has been over for quite some time. There are a few hold-outs such as yourself, for political and social reasons. Drop the charade already.


BTW, your confidence that those who conducted the twin studies corrected for any problems with the sample is charming, but no, they didn't. How could they? They'd need a larger data set to reliably identify the biases, and that's exactly what they didn't have. Indeed, a lot of studies in this area seem to fit a pattern of correcting for one or two environmental facts that seemed obvious to the researcher, and then confidently asserting that since after all environmental factors were accounted for there remained a measurable result it must therefore be genetic. But people's environments are a tiny bit more complicated than that. Those who actually study environmental factors seem to have little trouble coming up with factors Jensen and his followers missed;

*Rolls eyes*

For goodness sakes, when you develop your own studies and get the opposite results from those gathered from the mountain of studies and converging evidence, let us know. Don't fib the data, as proponents of your side have been caught doing, and please honestly interpretate the findings.

At the very least don't try to overstate the importance of environment. Even Waldman, Weinberg, and Scarr conceded that point when revisiting data on the Minnesota Transracial Adoption Study


Ogbu had a theory which seems to account for the patterns of racial difference quite well. He could be wrong, but I've never seen any cogent criticism of his take on these matters, and of course even if he's wrong there could be something among the countless environmental factors we either haven't figured out how to correct for yet, or haven't even considered might be important. Indeed, one way in which Gould, for all his hyperbole, is perhaps a useful antidote to the people who are convinced of genetic differences in intelligence between races is that the latter never seem to be even slightly aware of how prima facie implausible their thesis is given what we know about population genetics.

Yes Ogbu makes some good points. But, they're not enough to explain the worldwide patterns observed. However, you're going off on a tangent about "racial differences". Let's stick to IQ pure and simple, because it is clearly controversial enough, at least in your eyes.



On the Flynn effect, I suppose I lean more toward Flynn's theory than the theories of a hack like Jensen (some of the explanations you cite from Jensen also have experimental data against them, as I wish I were surprised you apparently didn't know). "G-loaded" IQ tests are tests of a variety of abstract reasoning skills, and the modern world gives people more practice in those skills than more primitive ways of life did, so modern people do better on tests of those skills. Again, it might not be true, but it's the most plausible I've encountered.

Everybody including Jensen accepts your position on environmental influences. However, you seem to reject any significant role of genetics, and that's being intellectual dishonest. Jensen's view about the role of environment and genetics is much more reasonable and in line with evolutionary biology than any environment-only explanation.

Your hero Flynn had this to say in 2007:

"Everyone knows if we only allowed short people to reproduce there would be a tendency in terms of genes for height to diminish. Intelligence is no different from other human traits," he told the Sunday Star-Times.

"A persistent genetic trend which lowered the genetic quality for brain physiology would have some effect eventually."

Statistics show women without tertiary qualifications who had reached their early 40s had produced 2.57 babies each.

In contrast, women with a higher education were producing just 1.85 babies each.

Dr Flynn said at 73 he was too old to worry about offending anyone.
- http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10450313

It goes further. Flynn is a eugenicist now?


And I note you gave no examples of these many disciplines in science that have been incorporating g. Which disciplines were they? What have they been using it for? I've encountered statisticians who use it as an example of misuse of statistical methods, and philosophers of science who use it as an example of bad methodology in science, but I assume those weren't the disciplines and uses you were thinking of.

Research in biology and genetics have found correlates with g.