When people try to evaluate what is good looking, the first question they have to ask is "to who"? There is a WIDE variety in what people think is attractive. I'll grant that if you average preferences out, you might be able to figure out what characteristics would most often be found to be attractive. The natural following thought is, however - would you want to be what most people find attractive?
Put another way, would you be attracted to the women who hold the most common point of view as to what is attractive? Go to a concert of some male "heartthrob" sometime. Have a look at the women in the audience who are beside themselves with adulation. Are they your type of gal, or the farthest thing from it? Speaking for myself, I'm not jealous of the type of women these guys attract (at least not in 99% of the cases)! Yet, these guys would all be labeled as conventionally attractive.
The most meaningful evaluation of attractiveness is whether you, as an individual, attract the type of person that you find attractive. If you do, you are as attractive as you need to be. If you don't, you need to improve your attractiveness in some way, or reevaluate your perspective or expectations.