How Bad is Star Trek: Discovery?

kkelso

Well-known member
Apr 27, 2003
2,466
28
48
My nephew and I have worked our way through all of the Star Trek series, just finishing Enterprise. It's the only show we watch together, and something we looked forward to.

The next logical step would be Discovery, but I've heard so many dreadful things about it that I'm tempted just to leave our warm memories intact and be satisfied, rather than have Star Trek ruined for us.

I'd love to hear feedback from my fellow Trekkies.

KK
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kanadier
I like all Sci-Fi and that started with Star Trek. When Discovery came I struggled through the first season but I couldn't endure much more and dropped out the second season. The plot seemed to leave plausible sci-fi and I haven't seen it since. It actually devalued the entire franchise for me. If you really like Star Trek - I suggest you stay away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: y2kmark
I like all Sci-Fi and that started with Star Trek. When Discovery came I struggled through the first season but I couldn't endure much more and dropped out the second season. The plot seemed to leave plausible sci-fi and I haven't seen it since. It actually devalued the entire franchise for me. If you really like Star Trek - I suggest you stay away.
More of a trekkie than I to make it through the whole first season, I barely made it through the first episode!😩(n)...
 
star trek discovery promotes biology denying gender ideology
 
I've loved the Star Trek franchise throughout my life. Of the films, The Wrath of Khan, The Voyage Home and First Contact are worth watching. Star Trek: Picard wasn't bad, I wasn't expecting an almost 80 year old actor to save a floundering franchise.

I didn't watch Enterprise, after Voyager I figured the franchise had played itself out. St: Discovery was decent enough until they killed off Captain Lorca, S2 was a ridiculous dirge, I couldn't be bothered with S3. Also Anthony Rapp is by far the worst actor to ever be in a Star Trek Series. It's probably politically incorrect to say it - I can't stand the sight of him. He sucks the energy out of every scene he's in.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: csmitting
As for The Great Shat. He may not be the best actor but he has massive charisma and never lacked confidence.

 
I love Star Trek. I used to come home from school and watch TOS on Channel 29 out of Buffalo. I've seen TOS so many times, I can recite lines from various episodes. I am also a big fan of TNG.

Less so DS9 and Voyager, though I did like Enterprise quite a bit.

But I find Discovery unwatchable. I forced myself to watch Season 1 and 2. FORCED myself.

Both seasons were fucking terrible.

I agree with Von that Anthony Rapp is a terrible actor. But IMHO Michelle Yao is even worse. There isn't a single character on it that I find interesting. Not one. In addition, the writing is just awful. I call it "new age sci-fi". It's all about conflict between the main characters. Whereas Star Trek up until Discovery was more about adventure in space, it was character driven and the episodes were largely stand alone, Discovery is a character conflict soap opera set in space.

They say it improves in Season 3. I don't care. It's such puke, that I'm not going to waste any more time on it.

Oh, and they needlessly changed the Klingons and made them unrecognisable and bizarre.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bumguy
Reminds me of a question one of my platoon asked our sergeant when I was in the militia...in my youth. The guy asked how we rated against the other platoons in our company. He replied. "Let me put it this way. If you lined up 4 pieces of shit side by side in a line, you would be the best piece of shit."
 
It all went downhill after 6 of 9 left.
Mind you she did return briefly on Picard.

But for Discovery, I found it better if you just disregard the whole franchise and try not to think of it as a part of it. Watch with a fresh open mind.
 
It can not be as terrible as Deep Space 9 was

I enjoyed DS9, it was a very good show, it had a darker edge to it than the other shows.

A lot of online rankings have it consistently in top 2.



 
  • Angry
Reactions: TeeJay
Discovery has teething problems but gets much better. I’ve watched all the Star Trek series. It’s good.

Be prepared: Everyone is gay/trans in the future. There are no straight white men.
A dystopian vision then. What's next, Borg Universe?...
 
Like all of the series post-TOS, they've all had a rocky start. The series improved after they found their show legs and established consistency within their respective shows. Now they are all much-loved entities of the Star Trek Universe.

IMHO, Classic Star Trek fans should know a few things:
1) Discovery's target audience may not necessarily be them. Paramount is attempting to build a new fan base to carry it through the 21st century.
2) IDIC - Gene Roddenberry's vision of a peaceful, knowledge-driven, inclusive society has more emphasis within Discovery (rather than the subject of one episode), which may not be appealing to older viewers (see #1). Every series has been a reflection and/or represents the era it was developed in. Those individuals who think there is too much in the way of ethnic, cultural, sexual, and gender diversity may have missed the whole point of what Roddenberry intended Trek to be.
3) Discovery is the first Trek series to be written as a serial, rather than episodic - a popular format with shows on cable (ie: Game of Thrones, The Sopranos & House of Cards), with Star Trek: Picard following suit. (From what I understand, in 2022, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds will return to the episodic format.)
4) There is some ret-conning in Discovery, which may rub fans the wrong way, but to be fair, there was ret-conning with every series (even within the three seasons of TOS), some more egregious than others.
5) Like it or not, it's canon. (There, I said it.)

There are always going to be issues from fans whenever a new spin-off of their favourite show hits the screen (I'm sure when Strange New Worlds comes out, guaranteed some fans are going to lose their shit), but there's a good percentage of fans that actually enjoy Discovery, that's why it keeps getting renewed. Also, if it weren't for Discovery, there would not be renewed interest and development of new shows.

I've been a Trekkie since it became syndicated in the 70s. Since then, I've seen all the series and movies several times, and enjoyed them (warts and all).

Live Long and Prosper.


star trek united naacp legal defense fund billboard.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Nathan 88
I'd say that we liked all of the four series, with DS9 given a slight edge, due to its grittier view. Enterprise started so slow, by the last season they were really cooking - too late.

As to the rest of the feedback, I'm very glad I asked. I'd heard of the whole "everyone is gay or trans and it's the defining characteristic of the role" thing. Is it true that the series takes place before TOS, and that the ship is for some reason huge?
 
2) IDIC - Gene Roddenberry's vision of a peaceful, knowledge-driven, inclusive society has more emphasis within Discovery (rather than the subject of one episode), which may not be appealing to older viewers (see #1). Every series has been a reflection and/or represents the era it was developed in. Those individuals who think there is too much in the way of ethnic, cultural, sexual, and gender diversity may have missed the whole point of what Roddenberry intended Trek to be.

Interesting points. I'm an original fan, having seen the original show live. Having read a good bit about Roddenberry's vision, much of it in his own words, I think I understand what he was trying to get at, and how he was trying to get at it.

In TOS, like much of the subsequent series and movies, there was Hikaru Sulu, amazingly competent officer, kick-ass fighter, inspirational leader, funny, good friend, botanist - who happens to be asian (and later in the movies, gay). That was a very positive message for the times, "asian people are just like everyone else only asian". That's a very different message than someone being Asian, and everything else flowing from that single character aspect.

KK
 
Theres a lot of whispering, and crying, and people talking in slow motion about their feelings, then crying again, but the special effects are the best of all the series.

I hope the upcoming strange new worlds with Captain Pike is a bit more like the old series

So far during lockdown I’ve watched all 7 season of TNG, and am now simultaneously watching Discovery, TOS, and Enterprise, currently mid way through season 2 of each. I gave DS9 a try but that and voyager are the only 2 of the old series that they couldn’t remaster so the picture quality is really bad.

I find TOS the hardest to binge watch but fun 1 episode at a time. Enterprise is surprisingly good and I think a lot of people unfairly wrote it off because of the theme music.
 
Last edited:
I enjoyed DS9, it was a very good show, it had a darker edge to it than the other shows.

I have not watched most of the newer series but my take on DS9 was very negative (esp back in the time)

Original Star Trek was ok. It was to me nothing at all special but I found it mildly entertaining, esp in the context of how old the show was. The spin off movies were (overall) a mess though.

Star Trek Next Generation was far better. Yes still tons of issues but vs original it was so much better and is probably still my fav ST series to date. The series ran too long and both later seasons and later movies def jumped the shark. As well a new competitor had emerged...

And that brings us to the B5 vs DS9. Not only was the alternate Babylon 5 far better than anything ST produced, most people (incl myself) saw DS9 as a cheap attempt to rip off a far more popular Sci Fi show. The CGI was not as good, the storylines and costumes were way worse, and the majority of new race types were total cheese (Ferengi in particular were just dumb).
Warner settled the lawsuit quickly and quietly but as they had the B5 promo materials over a year before DS9 was ever announced and with so many similarities the plagiarism is obvious.

ST themselves eventually stopped promoting DS9 to focus on Voyager which was ok but again not as good as STNG

Never watched Enterprise or onwards
 
Last edited:
I'd say that we liked all of the four series, with DS9 given a slight edge, due to its grittier view. Enterprise started so slow, by the last season they were really cooking - too late.

As to the rest of the feedback, I'm very glad I asked. I'd heard of the whole "everyone is gay or trans and it's the defining characteristic of the role" thing. Is it true that the series takes place before TOS, and that the ship is for some reason huge?


Discovery (2255-2259) is set 10 years before TOS (2265-2269), and almost a century after Enterprise (2151-2161).

Using the series versions of the ships (spoiler), Discovery (Crossfield-class science vessel) has a larger secondary hull (probably to accommodate the spore drive and other scientific equipment) and longer engines than Enterprise (Constitution-class heavy cruiser), but the saucer sections are comparable in size.

*Note: These images are most likely fan-made, so the information may be close, but not entirely accurate (but being Trekkies, they try).


e822zdmefpv11.jpg
7289f8f6669a0e2040080e4c7d1985d8.jpg
 
Last edited: