Hot Coffee on HBO

rld

New member
Oct 12, 2010
10,662
2
0
HBO is airing a documentary about the famous (infamous) Stella coffee burn case against MacDonalds.

I saw it last night and it is really well done. They interview jurors, show videos from depos, and do an in depth review of the political fall out.

If you have an interest in this issue you really should see it.
 
HBO is airing a documentary about the famous (infamous) Stella coffee burn case against MacDonalds.

I saw it last night and it is really well done. They interview jurors, show videos from depos, and do an in depth review of the political fall out.

If you have an interest in this issue you really should see it.

Damn Bell!
 
I watched it.. interesting, but the real focus wasn't on the McDonalds case at all. One question I have never heard answered is why did McDonalds insist on keeping its coffee unusually, undrinkably hot?
 
According to Wikipedia, McDonald's research showed that many drive through customers didn't start drinking their coffee until they arrived at their destinations. They heated it up to be the right temperature once someone got to where they were going.
In case Wikipedia does not mention it. An important issue was that McDonald's was "on notice" i.e. other customers had complained of being burned by the coffee, hence McDonalds "couldn't" say "we didn't know people could be burned like that."
 
In case Wikipedia does not mention it. An important issue was that McDonald's was "on notice" i.e. other customers had complained of being burned by the coffee, hence McDonalds "couldn't" say "we didn't know people could be burned like that."

People spill hot coffee all the time.. and in many of those cases, they (or someone else unlucky enough to be close by) gets burned by it.
The real question - and maybe this was addressed at the trial, I don't know - was did McDonalds make the connection between the temperature of their coffee and the severity of the burns suffered? That is, did they realize that by having their coffee at a higher temperature, it would cause much worse injury, and that it was a real problem.. but chose not to do anything about it?
 
People spill hot coffee all the time.. and in many of those cases, they (or someone else unlucky enough to be close by) gets burned by it.
The real question - and maybe this was addressed at the trial, I don't know - was did McDonalds make the connection between the temperature of their coffee and the severity of the burns suffered? That is, did they realize that by having their coffee at a higher temperature, it would cause much worse injury, and that it was a real problem.. but chose not to do anything about it?
Well I realize I'm going to be sharp, but did you read what I posted above (#9)? Did you look at the program?
 
Finally watching this documentary now.

All I can say is that I'm glad I live in Canada where the court system is somewhat less corrupt and less corruptible than the system in the U.S. The buying of judges, judicial elections and interference of legislatures (bought by big business) to whittle away at tort law is disturbing. One hack for the corporations (a Chamber of Commerce flack) suggested that torts be eliminated by consumers contracting with sellers.

Hmmm... So let's see. The half of people who are below average who won't fully understand the nature and impact of the contracts put before them will limit or reduce their ability to recover for harms against them for dangerous products (this is just one example). Sure that sounds good. Way fairer than the issue being decided by an impartial body after the fact with all the evidence presented before a court right?

The case of that poor kid who was injured by the errors of his mother's doctors and who now must rely on the tender mercies of the state (and become a public burden) rather than have the docs and their insurers pay for the damages they inflicted by their tortious actions was rather unpleasant. So far as I know, this does not happen in Canada in this way.

It sometimes amazes me how things are so different in the States...