Honoring Pierre Trudeau

But they have no power to reject the nomination - unlike the U.S. Senate.

It depends what you mean by power. They certainly have the power to bring a public focus on the nomination, to ensure that the whole nation is aware of the decisions being made. They prevent the PM from operating in secret, and highlight to the public in a transparent way who is being nominated, and why.

That function ultimately does empower voters, who can carry that information, together with all else that know, to the ballot box.

Augmented by all the other deliberative process we have, a tyrannical PM would be exposed a such. It is quite unlikely that we would have a PM who is behaving in line with the interests of the public in every matter other than diabolical judicial appointments.
 
You are both ignorant and incredibly obtuse, in Canada the PM appoints judges, there is no such thing as a nomination hearing or committee of appointment as they have in the US.

As opposed tie the US system where money can buy elections at all levels and people like the Kochs brothers can buy whomever they want.
 
^ post 1800

To be historically accurate you mean this flag:



union-flag-1-460x276.png

RS doesn't care about details. Remember he's a big picture kind of guy.
 
I think he was responding to your claim that the only real check is the ballot box. The CJC is another check.
Only if there is misconduct by the judge after appointment. That is completely different from the questions of Judicial Temperament considered by the U.S. Senate and some State Legislatures.
 
Only if there is misconduct by the judge after appointment. That is completely different from the questions of Judicial Temperament considered by the U.S. Senate and some State Legislatures.

I've actually sat in on discussion this exact matter. It's been found by those who keep track of this time of thing, when federal judges sit, they tend to be very much centred in their decisions. much a result of they can't really been fired by those who hired them.
 
I've yet to heard several people claiming Trudeau was the greatest PM we've had, what I've yet to hear is cited proof of this. Could it be his economic policies? No, wait, that can't be it because his record was abysmal. Was it he ability to draw Canadians together? Nope, he was a divisive force playing one region of Canada against another. Was it his statesmanship? Nope, by t time he put on his world farewell peace tour, he was irrelevant as a world leader and Ronald Reagan had no time for him or his antics. Without Reagan's ear or access to the Reagan White House whatever he did or said was utterly pointless and irrelevant. So what does that leave? Just a whole lot of nothing!! As I said he was a fraud and a failure as a PM.
 
"The state has no right in the bedroom....' I suppose he had this in mind when he yanked citizens out of their homes and bedroom to be locked up without charge or representation do days and weeks. I'll bet those who suffered jail time for no offence cringe going to PET international. The US did not invoke martial law after 911.


They might have if POLITICIANS were kidnapped like they were in Canada to hold the country at ransom.
 
Whatever sins you think PET did, at least he didn't take envelopes of cash in hotels and then sue canada and make the country pay him $1 million for insulting his character.

Mulroney should be a front runner for worst pm for a long time.


The late, great political-economist John Crispo said that Mulroney will be considered one of the greatest prime ministers of all time, and I agree.

The introduction of the GST (a consumption tax that made our exports cheaper) and Free Trade, modernized our economy and protected it from the Omnibus Bill south of the border that would've invoked protectionism to choke our trade with the U.S.

Only a left-winger like you feels that a Canadian like Mulroney shouldn't avail himself of the laws of this country (including our Charter) to defend himself from unwarranted charges.
 
When the leader is elected and his nomination is confirmed by an elected legislature I fully support it.


Ok fair enough (politicians make decisions on our behalf every day without referendum) but when it comes to judges that don't share your political views, you will have to bear it and keep quiet until the next election.