Home Theatre System Question

Well 'resident smartass', ye ask and ye shall receive.
As a matter of fact I am not only an Audiophile, but an avid vinyl collector and listener for the past 30 odd years. Yes dude, back when an amp was an amp, a preamp was a preamp and in the 70s a low-fi device called a 'receiver' came along. I have a belt driven Well Tempered Reference turntable, Koetsu cartridge, as a nice anologue front end with tube phono preamp, tube preamp and tube mono blocks that are part of my reference grade 2 channel system. It creates a holigraphic soundstage with height, depth and pinpoint placement of the intruments, voices and the speakers disappear. By the way, some mono recordings will also blow your mind, if you are into vinyl you should check some of these out.

Keeping audio and video in their native resolutions is key, not only in the audio realm, but the video as well. I don't want to bore everyone to tears but upconverting your 480i DVD to 1080i (dont dare think it is 1080p) is not different than using sound effects that take 2 channel stereo and process it to Dolby Pro logic fake surrond. You state that you enjoy fake 1080p, why couldn't you enjoy fake 5.1? Obviously neither are as good as the true original, but it doesn't mean you couldn't enjoy a movie made in 2 channel, faked out to 5.1. Did you ever go to a movie theater in the 80s or 90s and enjoy the surrond sound experience, not saying it isn't way better today, but if the source isn't available it is much better than just 2 channel for movies.

Oh when you go to a concert do you just hear the first order reflections of the music or is there any chance that some of what you hear at a live concert may reflect off the back wall, roof, sides...hmmmm.

Back to you tboy, good banter is good banter
 
Obviously neither are as good as the true original,

thank you, which was my point all along.........

To answer your questions:
No, I don't really enjoy "simulated" surround, it just doesn't sound right to me. I can enjoy an upconverted DVD almost as much as a tru Blu Ray because I'm partially colour blind and my eyesight isn't what it used to be. But my hearing is just fine.
When I go to a concert I HATE hearing echos off the side and back walls because that is just 'interference'. The best places in the city to see a concert are: Massey Hall (saw U2 there), Molson Amphitheatre, Roy Thompson Hall (they did their best to remove the reflective surfaces), and the theatre at Canada's Wonderland. That way, you don't hear any interference from the sides or back. You only hear the musicians and their instruments.
Holigraphic Sound: I hear ya brother. I first heard that achieved back in the 70s too and it blows the mind. I just hope that some sound engineers can get their act together and create that for concert DVDs. Surround sound attempts this but I haven't heard one yet that can achieve it as well as the old stuff can. I've heard close, but no cigar.

Not that it was the "best" or anything but I cannot even remember where my rega planar II turntable is. I haven't seen that thing for years. As for the cartridge, heck, I remmber paying $400.00 for it (can't remember the name) and that wasn't an expensive one then.....oh the days of warm vinyl lol......I remember "tweaking" speakers by putting various materials behind and underneath them to eliminate reflected sound and the harmonics associated with sound transfer through the bottom. I also remember experimenting with zorbathane to isolate various components....spent too many saturdays in various stereo shops talking to waveheads.....
 
Never said there weren't hall effects, just that they were undesireable. Considering I did sound for quite a few bands back in the day we'd strive to eliminate those sounds because they were undesireable because they interfered with what the musicians were producing.

Hence why Roy Thompson hall spent millions trying to correct a poor design.

If hall effects were desireable, why do they put sound absorbing materials on studio walls? If they "wanted" sound bouncing off the walls wouldn't they just leave them bare?

Go into any high end audio preview room and they will:
1) remove ALL other speakers
2) have all kinds of sound absorbing panels on the walls
3) have carpet on the floor

All the above to prevent these hall effects you are describing.

Just like driving a ferrari with the hand brake partially on: just because it happens doesn't mean it should.

So, let me ask you: distortion happens during live performances too, I suppose you're going to try and tell me you want that too?

How about singers singing off key? You want that too?

Or how about the people behind you singing along with the band so loud you can't hear the musician?

Hell, if you want all that why don't you just buy a 20 yr old home made cassette recording....

But then again, you probably buy pirated DVDs of first run movies that were recorded with a hand held camera in thailand.....because hey, that's what it would be like live eh?
 
Read the Dolby Pro Logic definitiions again...

DPL performs 2 completely different functions
1) it decodes 4 channel encoded Dolby Surround tracks (there is nothing "simulated" about this function. There is just some loss of quality in the encoding since you cannot send the full range of each of the 4 channels over 2 channels)
2) Or, it processes normal stereo signals into 5 channels (this is the "simulated" function )

So, back to the OP question, if you do not have Dolby Surround selected as your surround mode for your TV input on your AVR, you will not decode Dolby Surround stereo tracks that came with the movie back into 4 channels for the proper surround.
If the soundtrack is not a Dolby Surround encoded 4-channel signal , then the Dolby Pro Logic on your AVR will "simulate" surround.

Don't confuse these 2 features
 
tboy, sorry it doesn't sound as if you really know what you're talking about.

Roy Thompson Hall is still one of the crappiest sounding rooms in the city. Check out the Four Seasons for comparison.
To make a hall sound good you need to work on a few different things (this applies to small rooms with home theatres, too).
You need to make the room as quiet as possible, get rid of fridges, quiet down the hvac, check for noisy lighting....(check out the room within a room of Four Seasons)
You need to SIM out the room, which is a process in which you check for even dispursion, and resonances within the room.
Resonances are frequencies which will pop out and sound too loud, quite often you get them with parallel walls, where the the walls create a chamber that resonates at one fixed pitch.
You need to properly place your speakers to assure that all seats here equal level and then delay the speakers so the sound reaches as many of the seats at the same time as possible.

The amount of reflection of sound off walls should be adjusted towards the type of music in the hall. Control rooms in studio's try to deaden all reflections to hear only what is coming out of speakers, halls like Massey and Four Seasons have lots of non-parallel surfaces for even reflections that create a long, pleasant reverb suitable to the music.

Dolby is a process that inherently uses some compromises to achieve multi channel sound. If you're really an audiophile, buy some SACD cd's and compare.
 
Please......STOP with the insults.....as per the new rules and regs you might find yourself banned.

You basically said the same thing I did. Studios don't want to hear ANYTHING but the muscians. TYVM for argeeing with me. WHY? Because that is a pure source with no influence by the location in which you're listening to them which IS what good halls strive to do.

Insult me all you want, but the PERFECT room to listen to audio is a DEAD room with no reflective surfaces. Now some halls realize this is impossible so they do their best to prevent or minimize the effects and as you say, make adjustments so that the interference is pleasant.

You might think the 4 seasons is great, more power to you. Massey Hall (the old one) IS perfect in my opinion with NO reverb from the walls or back of the theatre. I saw a number of concerts there back in the day (U2 being one of them) and believe me, it is just about as perfect as you can get. Probably why it was used for opera for so many years......

Sorry to say this, but you are DEAD wrong about studios. They don't listen to music OUT OF SPEAKERS, they listen to music produced by INSTRUMENTS only. With no reflection, room influence, whatever. GASP, why do they do this? Because they want the purest sound possible to create a pure recording. If YOU want the room to influence the music, more power to you but I'll stick with what the professionals strive for and that is an accoustically dead or neutral room.

BTW: resonant frequencies are frequencies that produce UNWANTED sounds from objects located in the room. For eg: your system produces the resonant frequency of the light fixture which creates a buzz because the fixture starts to resonate or vibrate due to those frequencies. Walls can do the same thing. Resonant frequencies should be avoided at all costs because they INTERFERE with the original sounds being reproduced by the system. Unless of course you're designing your speaker's baffle board/enclosure to resonate at a certain frequency.....but then you want to isolate the speaker from any surface because the vibrations caused by these resonant frequencies will add unwanted noise. (hence why we used zorbathane).

As I said, for all you that want a noisy room? More power to you.....I just hope someday you get to visit a real studio to find out exactly what you are missing......
 
HAHAHA.. how old are you people?

"Does a home theater system use the surround sound speakers when watching regular TV?"

Simple answer i:s yes it should if encoded in surround sound (like Simpson), or if it's not you can simulate the surround using your many modes on your receiver.

I won't get into what's better or not - as it's a personal preference. Do what you think sounds good to you. There's no right or wrong (as a true person with passion for music will tell you), not a technical audiophile that enjoys arguing more than enjoying the music and appreciating it.
 
Please......STOP with the insults.....as per the new rules and regs you might find yourself banned.

You basically said the same thing I did. Studios don't want to hear ANYTHING but the muscians. TYVM for argeeing with me. WHY? Because that is a pure source with no influence by the location in which you're listening to them which IS what good halls strive to do.

Insult me all you want, but the PERFECT room to listen to audio is a DEAD room with no reflective surfaces. Now some halls realize this is impossible so they do their best to prevent or minimize the effects and as you say, make adjustments so that the interference is pleasant.

You might think the 4 seasons is great, more power to you. Massey Hall (the old one) IS perfect in my opinion with NO reverb from the walls or back of the theatre. I saw a number of concerts there back in the day (U2 being one of them) and believe me, it is just about as perfect as you can get. Probably why it was used for opera for so many years......

Sorry to say this, but you are DEAD wrong about studios. They don't listen to music OUT OF SPEAKERS, they listen to music produced by INSTRUMENTS only. With no reflection, room influence, whatever. GASP, why do they do this? Because they want the purest sound possible to create a pure recording. If YOU want the room to influence the music, more power to you but I'll stick with what the professionals strive for and that is an accoustically dead or neutral room.

BTW: resonant frequencies are frequencies that produce UNWANTED sounds from objects located in the room. For eg: your system produces the resonant frequency of the light fixture which creates a buzz because the fixture starts to resonate or vibrate due to those frequencies. Walls can do the same thing. Resonant frequencies should be avoided at all costs because they INTERFERE with the original sounds being reproduced by the system. Unless of course you're designing your speaker's baffle board/enclosure to resonate at a certain frequency.....but then you want to isolate the speaker from any surface because the vibrations caused by these resonant frequencies will add unwanted noise. (hence why we used zorbathane).

As I said, for all you that want a noisy room? More power to you.....I just hope someday you get to visit a real studio to find out exactly what you are missing......

Just for fun, I'll agree with one thing, tboy. Massey Hall is a great sounding room, but I'll disagree on why. Its got good even reflections creating a smooth and not to strong reverb, its got excellent reflections for sounds on stage (music) and moderate rejection for what's off stage (audience). Its not dead at all.

As for studio's, control rooms are non-reflective and tuned to not have standing waves that resonate with frequencies in the music playback. Recording rooms in modern studio's are set with a variety of parameters, dead for voiceover's and vocals, moderate or slight reflections for larger rooms for larger ensembles, and sometimes reflective for drums. In studio's they will listen to the sound of the instrument, adjust a mic, then move back into the control room to hear the sound over speakers/headphones to hear what is being recorded. If they listened only to the instruments live, they would have no idea what they are recording.

Otherwise I quite agree with all Garrett says, imagine Neil Young trying to start now, nobody would let his vocals out without being killed by autotune. Also, ears distort at certain sound level, with corresponding drop in ability to discern pitch discretion, which is why sometimes singers sing out of tune at loud shows and you can't tell until you hear it back, recorded. Their ears, and yours are distorting and you literally can't hear whether they are in tune anymore. Correspondingly, you'll also be experiencing hearing damage.

I quite enjoy these 'arguments', tboy. Its quite fun watching you stuff your foot farther into your mouth each time.
 
I'm not twisting and turning to "try and be right". If YOU want hall effects, as I've said before, more power to YOU. Personally, and professionally, I want an accoustically dead room that has little to no influence on the music the producers and musician tried to create.

Nice try on the "barb" about downloading, in Canada, we pay a premium on recordable media to offset the "theft" or reproduction of recorded music etc. In addition, I also purchase media that supports musicians, NOT distributors. (ie: I purchase direct from the musician as opposed to buying at a retail outlet). But frankly, there hasn't been anything produced in the last couple of years that I'd want to purchase anyways. Most these days is just crap. But that's a whole 'nother thread.

Hmmm funny, in the following document, in a refernce listening room, they state that they want "no coloration, no flutter echos" and " ,-10 db of reflections....sounds to me like they are saying as little to none room influence as possible....

look in 6.2.2 for the table I'm referring to.

Either way, you can tout your own horn as much as you like. You go publish your papers, I'll go listen to music the way I like to listen to it TYVM.

But you and your ilk so remind me of the arrogant 'tards I used to run into all the time. Their way or the highway and everyone else is wrong. I personally think "hall effects" ruin a piece and is one of the reasons I don't go to concerts anymore.

As for a musician's vocal style, that's one thing. The only musician that, in recent times, can sing off key and get away with it is Neil Young.

As for distortion: if you're talking about the various effects you can put on an electric guitar, that's one thing. But distortion in the amplified signal is NOT injected. Distortion can RUIN a speaker by overheating the flux around the magnet and effectively "blow" the speaker. Further to that, if the originating "sound" for lack of a better term, produced by the guitar, and electronically "distorted" the signal in and of itself is not "distorted".

As I said, you go off and listen to your hall effects, distortion, and sound bouncing all over your room. I'll go enjoy listening to music the way I like.
 
So you don't buy music and you don't go to concerts?

As for distortion, there is also good and bad distortion. I can't count the number of plugins buitl around modelling 'pleasing' analog distortion there are, and yes they are distorting the sound. Speaker distortion is almost universally bad, even guitar distortion is built around distortion in the preamp or power amp stage, not at the speaker. I do agree with that.

Anyways enjoy listening to your old recordings, tboy.
 
So you don't buy music and you don't go to concerts?

As for distortion, there is also good and bad distortion. I can't count the number of plugins buitl around modelling 'pleasing' analog distortion there are, and yes they are distorting the sound. Speaker distortion is almost universally bad, even guitar distortion is built around distortion in the preamp or power amp stage, not at the speaker. I do agree with that.

Anyways enjoy listening to your old recordings, tboy.

what part of
(ie: I purchase direct from the musician as opposed to buying at a retail outlet).
don't you understand?

And I don't go to concerts because they universally sound terrible. If you are ok with forking out hundreds of dollars to listen to crappy music, then more power to you. There are a few places I go semi-regularly to listen to live MUSIC in smaller venues where it isn't ruined by the location.

Why can't you people just accept the fact that while you enjoy listening to it your way, and I like to listen to it how I like to listen to it?

Actually, I came up with a good analogy for how garret likes his rooms to sound:

It is like drifting. Tire and auto makers spend BILLIONS of dollars designing tires and cars so they GRIP the road and turn on a dime. Then along come drifters whose soul purpose is to overcome that grip.
 
Do Xbox 360 games take advantage of surround sound?

My system supports 5.1 and is set up for HDMI. The surround sound works for the blu-ray movie I was playing. Have yet to experience surround sound with regular TV (although I'll check Survivor in HD tonight) or Xbox 360 (although I've only tried one game so far).
 
Actually, I thought the original question was about the connections and how they related to the sound that comes out of the speakers.. Since the present method of connection wasn't given, here are some generaliies to go by..

When you say the sound from cable is diferent from that of the BluRay, well, of course it is.. You'd be pretty dissapointed if it wasn't lol.. But that leads to the question of wiring. Every component wants ( usually according to it's instructions ) to be plugged into the TV, and the tvs' instructions tell you the same thing, usually.. BUT, your receiver will tell you to plug everything into the receiver and then to the tv so that the receiver acts as a switching block. So where you are at on this may depend on a combination of the following. How many inputs on the TV, how many inputs on the receiver, and what type, and last but not least, how many devices are you hooking up?

If you run the cable box signal into the tv via co-ax and then run the audio out from the tv back to the receiver, the signal may be getting processed by the tv and then again by the receiver. If you run the component audio right from the cable box to the receiver, it's only processed once.

See what I mean? and it goes on like that for every component you plug in..

What model TV and how many and what type of inputs, what kind of receiver and available inputs and it's options ( dolby, dolby pro logic, etc... ) This information would probably help the audio buffs to offer some sound suggestions to optimize your audio experience.
 
Keep twisting :-)

tit for tat my friend, tit for tat.....


Of course, it is all about personal taste. It is also a personal choice to remain ignorant. A few people have confirmed my viewpoint, and added to it, yet you want to resort to the "ilk of 'tards" insults. Anyway, enjoy what you enjoy, but you may want to cool the advice to other people until you actually know what you are talking about. However, I won't hold my breath on that one. You are pretty much the Cliff Clavin of terb.

It is also a personal choice to remain arrogant. Funny, how you have to justify your opinion based on other's agreeing or disagreeing with you.

As for giving advice, I give mine based on my experience in sound engineering, mixing, and concert production. As for your "credentials", your post here is worth about the same as a pinch of raccoon shit. You get paid to listen to music, I get paid to build home theatre rooms and install systems. BFD. I set up and design rooms to please my customers and I have yet to have an unhappy customer.

As for the neutral sound rooms, that is from YOUR link my friend. Maybe you should read more of your own stuff.

As for me being CLiff Claven, RIGHT. Nice try, how about you acting your age not your show size? But what can one expect from an arrogant "tard......as I said before: I have come across literally HUNDREDS of 'tards such as yourself saying: no you're wrong, you MUST listen to music the way I say you should. How DARE you even THINK about listening to it any other way?

If a customer comes to me and says: make my room noisy as hell with all kinds of hard surfaces, I do it. If that is what THEY like? More power to them. If they want a nice quiet room with little or no room influence? I'll do that for them too. If they want to purchase and install a $200.00 HTIB? I'll install it and make it sound as good as possible. If they have a $10,000.00 system? I'll do the same.

Sorry, I NEVER say to ANYONE this is what you MUST do as I say, (except where building codes and safety come into play), only arrogant 'tards do that.

Just in case you don't remember this lesson from your childhood: if 500 kids jump off a bridge, does that mean YOU should too? ie: just because you "say" you have all this documentation as to how a room should sound, doesn't mean everyone has to like it THAT way.

The beauty about living in a free country? People have the freedom to make their own decisions and like what they like.........
 
Hey tboy, Garrett is right again.

I'm only going to harp on a couple of errors.
First, a neutral room is not a dead room, its a room that has good frequency response, in that there are no big humps in the SIM, or big resonances. Also, the reflections will be balanced through all parts of the room, and probably won't be too reflective.

Second, noise in the room is not related to reflective surfaces. Those are two separate issues, noise in the room refers to background noise, ie HVAC, buzzing lights, street traffic, noise from outside the room etc. Reflectiver surfaces control the amount of short echoes that added together create the reverb of the room. Most DAW's (digital audio workstations) have modeled or impulse response type reverbs of actual rooms, as well as algorithmic reverbs. If you play around with them you can really understand the difference between dead and live, good and bad ambiences. Give it a try. All us 'tards love it.
 
Getting back to the main question. My experience with 5.1 and broadcast has been that I get my HD signal over the air from an antenna and the quality of sound from NBC is great in 5.1. It is not with every program but most primetime programs are great in their sound production. The sound from NBC olypmic coverage of the opening ceremonies was great in 5.1 while CTV's was not great in stereo. Can't say about cable but you get 5.1 with OTA pickup but not with every show. I have found NBC really pays attention to their sound quality.
 
I actually unsubscribed from this thread but made the mistake of coming back...this'll teach me:

I refer to a dead room as one with no real influence on the quality of sound being produced. ie: colouring it, reflecting it, etc.
I refer to noise as the sounds created when the reproduced sound hits the various objects. ie: tables rattling, light fixtures tinkling, drywall vibrating and bouncing the various signals off the various surfaces (ie: echos from the backwall etc)......

See, the thing about reflected sound waves (ie: echo) is that if a musician wanted his notes to echo, he would have put them in during production.
 
not again, sigh.

Ok, your dead room definition is close enough to mine now, that I'll take it.

But your definition of noise is quite wrong. You've described two phenomena, sympathetic resonance - where the frequency produced by the music, live or recorded, and the item vibrated share the same frequency. So a pitch at 100hz might cause a snare drum to rattle, while a pitch at 30hz might cause the drywall to rattle. And the second phenomena is echo or reflection or reverb (though those are slightly different they all are similar) where the sound bounces off a reflective surface. If its one bounce it sounds like echo if its lots of bounces it sounds more like reverb. Neither of those are called noise by musicians, producers or engineers.

As for recording, if a musician wants reverb on a recording he has two choices. One, record in a room with the ambience or reverb he likes, like a church or two add in production, where he can add reverb or delay in the mix. But talk to say, Talisker about whether they like room with what you call noise and they'll say no, but ask if they like a dead room or a live room and they'll tell you they like the church they play in for its live, very rich reverb.
 
1) THD is total harmonic distortion which is measured at the amplifier stage. Zero THD is not desirable or 'good' sounding.
2) Dead room sounds to me like you are describing an Anechoic Chamber which is great for measuring speakers, but horrific to listening to music.
3) This tread has confused 3 different discussions with many different concepts a) 2 channel music, b) live music c) multichannel music
4) Great listening rooms combine an engineered solution that takes into account for room size, diffusion, absorption and reflection.. please read this before we go any further.. http://www.ethanwiner.com/acoustics.html
5) A great source of audio and video information and Q&A is http://www.avsforum.com/

Whether you have a $200 HTIB or $200K audiophile system and room, grab your favourite drink and sit down and enjoy the beauty of music cause that is priceless.