Home Schooling

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
Have a friend who is considering homeschooling for their son. Has anyone done this for their children or grew up with the same? More importantly,would you do it again? Is there any place to go to for critique or support of the Ontario guidelines?
 
Have a friend who is considering homeschooling for their son. Has anyone done this fo their children or grew up with the same? would you do it again? Is there any place to go to regarding Ontario guidelines?

This is a bad IDEA IMO! Kids need to develop social skills and not get fcked up through their parents. This will hurt them big time when they become independent, or try to fly on their own. It will hurt them with relationships, trust, and self esteem. This is all my opinion from my outlook on the world but I would not do this unless I really needed to. This is the same principle how I noticed stay at home moms get all fcked up mentally because the are missing the real world interaction, even though there support groups, u still need the real world to develop and maintain sanity.
 
This is a bad IDEA IMO! Kids need to develop social skills and not get fcked up through their parents. This will hurt them big time when they become independent, or try to fly on their own. It will hurt them with relationships, trust, and self esteem. This is all my opinion from my outlook on the world but I would not do this unless I really needed to. This is the same principle how I noticed stay at home moms get all fcked up mentally because the are missing the real world interaction, even though there support groups, u still need the real world to develop and maintain sanity.

All good points, but I don't see the kid lacking social skills with kids of his age, to this point, he has been part of a day care program and gets lot of loving at home. Yes, the parents take on a lot of responsibilities, in the short term and over the next 12 years, not to imprint their personal biases and shortcomings, but you run that risk in a school environment. The son is very bright, not a genius by any stretch, and there is a feeling he will be hobbled by the standard school environment.
 
This is a bad IDEA IMO! Kids need to develop social skills and not get fcked up through their parents. This will hurt them big time when they become independent, or try to fly on their own. It will hurt them with relationships, trust, and self esteem. This is all my opinion from my outlook on the world but I would not do this unless I really needed to. This is the same principle how I noticed stay at home moms get all fcked up mentally because the are missing the real world interaction, even though there support groups, u still need the real world to develop and maintain sanity.

You can socialize a home-schooled kid. You don't have to make him an introvert with no people-skills.

I know two home-schooled geniuses. One was in University at 14. Super chill kid. Got along with everyone. The other started high school at 15 because the University wouldn't accept him - no social skills. He had to do 3 years, bored out of his tree, where he failed to get good grades because he wasn't challanged, all because his parents didn't think socializing was important.
 
I had a friend next door that was home-schooled from grade 1 to 5. Pretty cool guy and he would invite people to his place, we would play road hockey, ride our bikes around, etc. I think he was in the Scouts too. I used to help him with his paper route and seemed normal to me. He moved a few years later so not sure what happened to him. I'm pretty sure he's a normal person and didn't move to a cave in Afghanistan.

I imagine that home-schooling is a lot easier than it once was because of distance learning, social networks, Skype, etc. Just because someone gets schooled at home doesn't mean they are stuck at home. Kids can still join sports leagues, Scouts, etc.
 
My ex-sister in law home schooled all her kids. They are all now teens and are brilliant kids, but all complete introverts. No social skills/ no "street" smarts at all.
 
My ex-sister in law home schooled all her kids. They are all now teens and are brilliant kids, but all complete introverts. No social skills/ no "street" smarts at all.


As mentioned earlier you can gain social skills and street smarts doing organized sports or other off campus activities. i'm beginning to believe more strongly that sport has little unique value in the school environment, taking ever decreasing resources away from studies
 
Homeschooling has nothing to do with socialization, homeschooling is education, skills, know how.

Socializing is human development. Socializing is important, but socializing in the school environment is only one way to socialize.

If the parents are smart enough to realize that there are many areas to balance -such as ethics, values, religion, purpose, efficience, communication skills, social skills and base education to name a few, the boy will be great and fine.
 
My ex-sister in law home schooled all her kids. They are all now teens and are brilliant kids, but all complete introverts. No social skills/ no "street" smarts at all.

Doesn't mean they are stuck like this. Eventually, they'll learn to come out of their shell.
 
Homeschooling has nothing to do with socialization, homeschooling is education, skills, know how.

Socializing is human development. Socializing is important, but socializing in the school environment is only one way to socialize.

If the parents are smart enough to realize that there are many areas to balance -such as ethics, values, religion, purpose, efficience, communication skills, social skills and base education to name a few, the boy will be great and fine.


This.

My cousin and his wife homeschool their five kids. All are well adjusted and happy kids. They are very active in their community and participate regularly in local sports, church, etc. that's the key, IMO. It can't be all about academics.

Their school board also supports homeschooling with coordinated socialization programs (olaydates for younger kids and field trips for older kids).

It's basically the epitome of private school; a completely customized education for your kid. Definitely time consuming and demanding, but if done right, can be enormously successful.
 
Doesn't mean they are stuck like this. Eventually, they'll learn to come out of their shell.
Aha! Introverts must "learn" to socialize - which is an active effort and skill that has to be consciously undertaken. Can happen to homeschooled kids or anyone else. I went to regular school, but I think most of my learning came on my own at an early age, from books and the library and my parents too. The younger years in retrospect really were for making friendships, learning how to talk, joke around, bully and be bullied, daydream and be sent to the principals office, idolize kids in grade eight who are good at baseball/road hockey etc, be chosen first for teams (or at least not last), joining the cool or popular crowd, etc etc etc. I can see how some of these basic skills could be introduced in organized sports or Boy Scouts or Sunday school. Home school might not be bad for the younger kids.

I would hesitate about home schooling in the teenage years tho. Really there are so many factors you just can't get if you aren't in the the environment, especially regarding the opposite sex and social cliques. Gotta learn how to talk to people but also girls in general. (Plus, you need access to stuff like shop class/home economics, chemistry and physics labs, computer equipment, and even gym equipment which might be harder at home - I started working out in Grade 13 on the school Nautilus equipment a late starter). I dunno, home schooling sounds risky at that age...

You can learn to socialize, I'm sure, but can be a lot harder for some people.
 
Homeschooling is always treated as an alternative , something I never quite understood, you can still educate you child outside of school.
 
As mentioned earlier you can gain social skills and street smarts doing organized sports or other off campus activities. i'm beginning to believe more strongly that sport has little unique value in the school environment, taking ever decreasing resources away from studies

I homeschoolled my kids some of the time when they were younger and it worked well. There are massive support systems for home school families now and they have organized social activities to make up for what they lose by not being in school.

If both the parent and the children are into it, it can be extremely rewarding for all, especially if kids don't fit into 'the little box' the public education teaching system requires, whether exceptionally bright, or developmentally delayed.
 
i wasn't home-schooled but i am an introvert according to the MBTI test. so socializing is part of growing as a person. i think part of home-schooling kids is making sure you mix in activities where they can meet and interact with other kids of their age.
 
The most important question around home schooling is whether the parent (or parents) schooling the child have what it takes to provide the proper education. It's not enough to say that a parent has had some education and therefore can pass it along. There is far more to being a teacher than knowing the material. Unless the parents have the appropriate background, they probably put their child at an academic disadvantage.

"Home Schooling" means providing the education outside of a recognized educational institution. It does not mean that the children are blocked from social interaction and the company of their peers; they could easily get this in other ways if their parents are doing a good job.

The question here is WHY home school? Are there special circumstances that make it a good idea? Are the parents so much more qualified than a school full of accredited teachers? In my view, home schooling might work in special circumstances but is probably not a good idea most of the time.
 
I've known a few families who've home-schooled. They were all very quirky parents. There may be a correlation between wanting to home-school and being a quirky parent...

There are groups of homeschooled children and parents that meet on a weekly/monthly basis throughout the city. I would recommend your friend attending some of these get-togethers before deciding.

http://ontariohomeschool.org/ontariogroups/

I personally found the children there to be normal. Most of the parents, on the other hand, were quite eccentric.
 
i wasn't home-schooled but i am an introvert according to the MBTI test. so socializing is part of growing as a person. i think part of home-schooling kids is making sure you mix in activities where they can meet and interact with other kids of their age.

I did a Myers-Briggs test too and found it fascinating. I friend of mine is a MBTI instructor and an amazing public speaker, yet is still an introvert. Chalk it up to years in Toastmasters.
 
Have a friend who is considering homeschooling for their son. Has anyone done this for their children or grew up with the same? More importantly,would you do it again? Is there any place to go to for critique or support of the Ontario guidelines?

My brother is home schooled, they got everything from www.ilc.org it gives all the guidelines and also information on how home school kids can apply for college and university.
 
I think there are two weaknesses of home schooling.

First it depends on the parents to have the time and the mentality to do it right. I'm sure there are parents that can do a good job and others who won't. The school systems has the same problem but the plus is that a kid will have 20+ teachers during the schooling so if a few are sub par, they aren't stuck with them the whole time. I also wonder at people's motivation for doing it and the impact those personality traits have on their kids. Is the thought because they know they can do a good job and enjoy the challenge? Is it because they distrust the system? Is it because they don't want their children exposed to 'those' people? Since the parents are the main contact their kids have, whatever positives and negatives traits the parents have will be magnified with their children. If parents look in the mirror and don't like what they see, they should strongly consider not home schooling.

The second issue is the kids being sheltered. Since the parents are in direct control of all of their kids socialization, children may not get exposed to as wide a variety of people and learn the skills to deal with them. Yes, as with my first concern, I'm sure some parents make a conscientious effort to make up for it but it goes against human nature to allow your kids experience challenging situations.