Home Depot vs Rona?

tboy said:
OOPS, forgot to add: the local mom and pop home hardwares NEVER have what I want so I don't even go anymore...the only one I frequent that is reasonable is New Canadians on DuPont...and for cheap good quality hardwood I go to central fairbank (though they don't have the selection of products that homo depot has)

Fairbank is great for moldings and trim.

Also, they have some really nice cedar for decks and cedar siding that I can't find anywhere else.

Etobicoke Building Supply is also pretty good, can't remember the name of the street it's on - Norseman, or one of those off Kipling.

The Ronas can also vary quite a bit. The one on Martin Grove has a pretty good lumber selection, as does the one on Dundas around Royal York.
 
If your buying a large quanity of any one material I would not go to either one but look for a place that deals with that material i.e. lumber. Typically you get better quality and save money in the long run. I just rebuilt 170' of fence and had to reject 180 boards from Rona due to quality. HD isn't any better. If I had it to do over I'd take more time to handle it as a project which means sitting down and scoping it out and listing all the materials and then finding the best price and best quality rather then just picking one of the "big names".
 
One thing I'd like to add:

When you're going to ANY of these stores and reach into one of those little bins and look at a product? PUT IT BACK INTO THE RIGHT FUCKING BIN!!! I can't tell you how many times I need 10 1/2" UNC coarse nuts and go home with 9 1/2" and 1 9/16"......man, the POX on anyone who puts the things back in the wrong spot.....
 
Can't comment on Rona but...

bee eh said:
You've all but nailed it there...you have to be firm but fair. If you let them know what you need, and you have the right employee...then they'll do everything in their power to meet your needs.

Rona just doesn't do that for me anyway.
***********************************

I have a Home Depot and a Home Hardware within 2 minutes of me.

Home Depot has product then try and find an employee. And if you do you wait while the four other customers get their needs taken care of.

Home Hardware is the opposite. You get help immediately. Product range is smaller but they can order anything.
 
I've used HD, Rona and Home Hardware in many locations, each has had its own good points and bad. Air miles leads me to Rona more often, specific products carried by HD, and its closer proximity, lead me there when I need something only the big box stores carry. I find lumber yards beat any big box store hands down for lumber, much better selection and much easier to load out in the yard.
 
Personally don't see a big difference

Ownership-both are publicly traded. I have HD stock but I am CDN so whats the diff?
Service-Varies store to store and depends on the individual store and employee knowledge & attitude
Selection-Usually I have better luck at HD but I have found a few things at Rona that nobody else carried.

Interesting note...when Rona opened a store in my area the CEO showed up and preached how they support local suppliers.... and I went in and made three major purchases, all mfg'ed in China??
 
Greekster said:
By the way, I went to Home Depot yesterday and asked if there was any way to construct a nice backdoor entrance. But my phrasing wasn't very clear, and my question wasn't fully understood, so I got a semi-clear answer as a result. But the answer was definitely not a no. To me this is good news. I won't be giving up on HD any time soon :)
I don't pay much attention to my back door and have only been using it as an exit. I don't think this will change any time soon. My neighbour has a very attractive back door but every time I approach it she says to come around to the front.
 
Yep...

tboy said:
Well, we'll see how Lowe's is when they get here.....and they're coming.....
******************************

Construction underway. Will open in Newmarket it less than 6 months.
 
How about that Builders Box or what ever it is called near the north east side of warden and eglinton it has the green hammer dude
 
Robio said:
How about that Builders Box or what ever it is called near the north east side of warden and eglinton it has the green hammer dude
That store is now a Rona - strange as another Rona is just around the corner south of Eglinton on Warden.
 
I use both stores, but I spend 95% at Rona, 5% HD, Rona will match HD pricing, and often will beat it .
I like the staff at My rona better then HD, and it's more convenient for me
 
My personal preference is Rona. Part of that is geography, being only 1 km from home. But, I know the layout of the store and can get in and out quickly. It is not too big, something most Home Depots are. I also find the staff at Rona better, if you avoid the kids. My local Rona has some old timers that really know there stuff, and can offer great advise. I find that harder to get at Home Depot.

And how is it that a small (2000 sq. ft.?) Home Hardware in a tinier town can carry items and more selection than any of the biggies.

As for Loew's, I have heard some horror stories about their Canadian head office as they can get set up. Hopefully the stores are better.
 
The problem with my Home Depot products is that they have an expiration date of October of this year unless they really, really outperform. If not, then I don't know what to do with it after that.
 
Greekster said:
The problem with my Home Depot products is that they have an expiration date of October of this year unless they really, really outperform. If not, then I don't know what to do with it after that.

Give it a full and proper test right away. Find out immediately what features it has. Use it the way it is supposed to be used and you may come away a satisfied customer. If that fails, the Depot will take it back, and you still have time to locate another, even if you only need it for a month. With those time constraints, what have you got to lose?
 
Greekster said:
The problem with my Home Depot products is that they have an expiration date of October of this year unless they really, really outperform. If not, then I don't know what to do with it after that.
You could get the performance if you follow the directions. You are probably one of those people who ignores the directions.
 
skypilot said:
You could get the performance if you follow the directions. You are probably one of those people who ignores the directions.

Excellent advice. Also, Greekster, I like the idea that you have set the agenda by putting a firm date that you would accept below par performance.

Good Luck.
 
LateComer said:
I don't pay much attention to my back door and have only been using it as an exit. I don't think this will change any time soon. My neighbour has a very attractive back door but every time I approach it she says to come around to the front.
Perhaps your neighbour's back door needs some adjustment or she is just not accustomed to people using her back door. I am pretty handy with tools ... if I could have your neighbour's address I will gladly stop by and check her back door for her. Sometimes just a little lubricant can make it work better.
 
I'm just worried that, despite using the best power-drill and lubrication, Home Depot's pipe in the plumbing section is either too thin or was made only as an out-valve. I asked an employee whether she has any experience in the plumbing section, but I'm not sure she knew I was referring to that specific section. For certain, the next time I go to HD, I will try to take a sneak peak at the plumbing section to see if there is an in-valve available.
 
Sometimes people don't know how to answer your questions. Some of the staff will pretend to have the answers just to keep you interested. You just have to try it for yourself. Send the unit back if it doesn't work.

As an example; if I wanted to tap a new hole, or try a new reamer for instance, and went to HD for the works, I would expect that what I got there would work. If it didn't, I would take it back and maybe even check out RONA. This is your project, get what you need, or find some place that has it.

Good Luck.