Holy Fuel Consumption Batman!!!

Lots of almost correct information in this post.

You will always get lower fuel economy in the winter.

Running the heater should not cause a decrease in fuel economy. The heater is more or less a mini radiator that the air flows over and the fan is electric, so there is no drain on the engine.

Running the defroster in GM cars at least also turns on the air conditioning compressor. The reason for this is because the freon is not cycled in the winter as the air conditioning is not used. To get the oil and freon circulating to prevent seals from drying out and oil from settling too much, the compressor is cycled when turned to the defrost setting.

The fuel punp rarely pumps more volume than its designed to. There is also a fuel pressure regulator in the system that limits the high pressure. Usually, if one starts to go bad, the flow decreases.

A leaky injector could cause an excessive fuel consumption problem as it is constantly leaking fuel in addition to opening up at the programmed time. A hookup to a fuel pressure gage is one way to diagnose this problem. If the pressure drops of quickly after the car shuts off, you have a leak. Another way to check is to pull the spark plug after the car has been sitting for a while. If it is wet and smells like fuel, you have a leak.

If your fuel economy drop is excessive, as it seems to be in your case, it might be one or more of the oxygen sensors. This sensors are in the flow of the exhaust gases. In the new cars, (1995 & up) there is one before the catalytic convertor and one after. Some are heated, which makes them last over 100,000 kms. However, being man made, they are subject to failure. Even a hard knock on the exhaust system can cause one to go bad. An O2 sensor performance can deteriorate quite a bit before a code is thrown. Unfortunately the only way to check its condition if it doesn't throw a code is to get your car hooked up to a diagnostic computer and find out the range and rate at which it cycles.

Check the O2 after you have done all the simple and easy things first like air filter, air pressure, new spark plugs, etc.
 
Poorboy:

Not to get into a pissing match or anything but while the actual heat doesn't put any additional load on the engine, running the fan does. But this also happens in the summer. Whenever you increase the load on the electrical system that causes resistance in the alternator and subsequently, it takes more hp from the engine to run it.

BTW: every vehicle I've been in in the past 10 years that had a/c ran the compressor while running the defrost. That's why or how it can clean the windows even when it is as humid as fuck outside.......(or inside for that matter). If you want to test your car, wait for it to warm up and return to normal idle. Make sure the heater switch is off or on heat for yer feet. If you have a tach watch it while switching the heater control to defrost. You should see a momentary drop in engine rpm then it will return to normal. This is the onboard computer compensating for the added load of the compressor. If you don't have a tach, if you listen carefully you will hear the engine rpm drop.

BTW: another factor is we have to run our headlights etc more often now that it is staying darker later, and getting dark earlier. This too adds load to the alternator.......
 
tboy said:
Poorboy:

Not to get into a pissing match or anything but while the actual heat doesn't put any additional load on the engine, running the fan does. But this also happens in the summer. Whenever you increase the load on the electrical system that causes resistance in the alternator and subsequently, it takes more hp from the engine to run it.

BTW: every vehicle I've been in in the past 10 years that had a/c ran the compressor while running the defrost. That's why or how it can clean the windows even when it is as humid as fuck outside.......(or inside for that matter). If you want to test your car, wait for it to warm up and return to normal idle. Make sure the heater switch is off or on heat for yer feet. If you have a tach watch it while switching the heater control to defrost. You should see a momentary drop in engine rpm then it will return to normal. This is the onboard computer compensating for the added load of the compressor. If you don't have a tach, if you listen carefully you will hear the engine rpm drop.

BTW: another factor is we have to run our headlights etc more often now that it is staying darker later, and getting dark earlier. This too adds load to the alternator.......

The alternator load increases, but not enough to cause the type of drop the original poster is experiencing. The blower motor is a small motor. The rear defrost is a huge drain on the system and definately makes the electric system work harder.

Yes the compressor turns on when you turn to defrost, but it's only to cycle the freon. The compressor is there only for the air conditioning system. Cars without air conditioning also have a defrost setting. The humidity disappearing has nothing to do with the compressor, it has to do with the warm/hot air being less dense and allowing the condensation to be suspended in the less dense air.

If your freon is low, the compressor will not cycle as there is not enough pressure in the system to properly lubricate it, but your defrost setting still works.
 
Ummm....

poorboy said:
The alternator load increases, but not enough to cause the type of drop the original poster is experiencing. The blower motor is a small motor. The rear defrost is a huge drain on the system and definately makes the electric system work harder.

Yes the compressor turns on when you turn to defrost, but it's only to cycle the freon. The compressor is there only for the air conditioning system. Cars without air conditioning also have a defrost setting. The humidity disappearing has nothing to do with the compressor, it has to do with the warm/hot air being less dense and allowing the condensation to be suspended in the less dense air.

If your freon is low, the compressor will not cycle as there is not enough pressure in the system to properly lubricate it, but your defrost setting still works.

Running the defroster in GM cars at least also turns on the air conditioning compressor. The reason for this is because the freon is not cycled in the winter as the air conditioning is not used. To get the oil and freon circulating to prevent seals from drying out and oil from settling too much, the compressor is cycled when turned to the defrost setting.

Yes the compressor turns on when you turn to defrost, but it's only to cycle the freon. The compressor is there only for the air conditioning system. Cars without air conditioning also have a defrost setting. The humidity disappearing has nothing to do with the compressor, it has to do with the warm/hot air being less dense and allowing the condensation to be suspended in the less dense air.

No.

The compressor goes on during the defrost for the same reason it goes on during the summer for air conditioning - to remove moistrure from the air.

Most North American car do not allow this option, but it most Euro and Japanese brands you can in fact turn on the defroster without kicking on the compressor. But...notice how poorly it works. Melting the ice and snow is but part of the job...you also have to keep the windows from fogging. And you do that by removing moisture from the air.