Wired For Sound said:
What follows below was taken from the very CDC 2001 report you've made your case on. He discusses the report's findings and the CDC itself.
www.fumento.com/bandplays.html
The Band Plays On Good News on AIDS - Why the Silence?
By Michael Fumento
Yes, I read that column, as well as most of Fumento's other columns. BTW, that column was written in Sept 2001 and the CDC report I quoted was published in 2002. I've covered the issue of "epidemic" above.
It seems to me that we disagree on these points:
1) You initially appeared to reject all data from the CDC because of their need to get more grants. You've said the following, in chronological order:
"This is pure manipulation of the numbers by those who are looking for more grant money."
"I never said I reject "out of hand" data from the CDC. "
"Hidden agenda = All data MUST be Suspect"
If I'm reading you correctly, you seem to think because the CDC has a bias, that all the CDC data is suspect but not necessarily entirely wrong. Your first statement made me think that you were rejecting all the CDC data, but it looks like you didn't mean to go that far. Is that correct?
I think that almost all the CDC data is sound but that because of bias, almost all of their interpretations of that data have been wrong.
I think we agree that the early CDC interpretations of their data were wrong. We probably agree that most of the CDC data is correct, the difference is that you think some of the CDC data has been manipulated and I think very little to none of the CDC data has been manipulated. If there is a disagreement, it must be on the degree of manipulation. I think on the statistical data, almost zero. I think you think it's not zero.
If that is a fair summary of what we each think, then we can agree to disagree on this point.
But I would further say that if you're going to disagree with the CDC's data, you have to be more precise than a general statement that all their data is suspect. I would be interested in some specific examples from you that shows that the CDC data was systematically biased or incorrectly collected. It's your turn now to show evidence that supports you apparent contention that the CDC's data is at least partially corrupt. But only referring to quotes from Fumento that only dispute the CDC's INTERPRETATIONS of that data is not sufficient.
Do you have any links or any hard data that indicate the CDC has engaged in a systematic bias in their actual collection of statistical data about HIV? If you don't, then I would claim that your original contention that the CDC manipulates its data is unsupported by any hard data.
2) What I was debating was the idea that heterosexual transmission of HIV was "virtually impossible". My belief is that one infection per 3000 people does not mean "virtually impossible".
Fumento's articles have all said that there is no epidemic of HIV among the heterosexual population and I have always agreed with that. However, AFAIK, Fumento has never said that there are *no* instances of HIV infections among heterosexuals, which is an entirely different matter.
Dave in Phoenix has said that there have been virtually no documented cases of female to male HIV transmission without other circumstances, like IV drug use. I claim that the CDC data shows otherwise.
I disagree with Dave in Phoenix on that point and I look forward to see how he responds. As far as you and I are concerned, we may simply have to agree to disagree on the definition of "virtually impossible" and let the debate between us halt at this point.
To me, the CDC data is pretty clear, the chance of heterosexual transmission of HIV is obviously not zero and clearly not impossible. I don't think anyone could look at the 88,000 cumulative cases of heterosexually transmitted HIV cases and claim otherwise.
Whether or not you believe that 88,000 cases means that heterosexual transmission of HIV is "virtually" impossible or is of "no concern" appears to be an individual decision on how you define "virtually" and how you label various levels of risk.
You and I appear to be arguing about language, which is not where I want to discuss this issue. I would much rather find out if you have data that supports Dave's assertion that there have been no documented cases of heterosexual HIV transmission.
If you want to continue this debate, I would like to see you present hard data or evidence that the CDC's data collection methods are suspect or incorrect.
However, we should move away from discussions about language and into the area of hard numbers. I don't see how the issue of the meaniing of "virtually" or "no concern" can ever be resolved.