Highway Tolls

Aug 23, 2008
2,526
206
63
the break where I surf
Now, I know that someone of you on here are proud car driving commuters, but with all of the discussion about subways do you guys think it would be a good idea to toll the DVP/401 in order to create funding for TTC and even upgrading the highways?? I know that studies have shown that tolls do not lessen the traffic/users on highways but I think it would be a new step forward considering that other cities have instilled them to create funding
 
I hate highway trolls. It's bad enough that they are on the Internet, but now the highways too. Hee, hee, hee.
 
It is bad idea to give the governement these type of suggestions.

Maybe they will "harmonize" the Gardiner, DVP, 403, 401 with the 407
 
Now, I know that someone of you on here are proud car driving commuters, but with all of the discussion about subways do you guys think it would be a good idea to toll the DVP/401 in order to create funding for TTC and even upgrading the highways?? I know that studies have shown that tolls do not lessen the traffic/users on highways but I think it would be a new step forward considering that other cities have instilled them to create funding

The maintenance of highways is a provincial matter and is paid for with the taxes on the sale of gas. The City of Toronto already gets a portion of the provincial gas tax. Why can't they use that more responsibly to fund they own transit initatives?

Putting a toll on the DVP and 401 the two main expressways into downtown and through the city is idiotic at best. Most people that do drive into the City would take public transit if was convenient and cost effective for them to do so. The mayor who can cut the waste at City hall and get their financial books in order, then create a better transit system will be hailed as the best thing to happen to Toronto since its inception.

Cheers
 
On the one hand, tolling 905-ers who clog up the DVP/Gardiner would be a great revenue generator to build subways as 416-ers' property taxes help maintain & pay for these roads.

But on the other hand, putting up those tolls would cause havoc on arterial streets & neighbourhoods on the Toronto border who would be innundated with 905 commuters avoiding the tolls. And everyone (905 + 416-ers) already pays enough in taxes.

I say we cancel the new federal $16 billion fighter jet program & build subways in Toronto with some of the money. Or we take away every politician's pension, regardless of political party, to build the subways as punishment for not doing it when they were in control.

Finally, we declare Alberta's & Nfld's oil as federal property & instill revenue-generating federal royalty payments to pay for a national urban transit strategy. (Ooops, did I just say that? That was quite Trudeau-ian of me. But maybe the fucker had a point....)
 
Tolls are crap . The 407 is way overpriced and should never have been built as a toll road in the first place . If the government really needs the extra revenue then justify it publically and raise the taxes . Toll roads and almost all user fees are the government just trying to hide their spending .

Boo
 
Here's a new concept make people who pay - benefit more from a service actually pay...

PVT - imposed on drivers helps city balance budget but penalizes drivers only
Water rates - the more you use the more you pay - that's fair

TTC riders only pay for ~40% of the cost of ridersship (I think) why not up the rates (taxes and subsidies pay rest) - drivers on the DVP aren't using transit; why should they pay more.

Here is one way to ding 905 who benefit from TTC but don't contribute as much because they don't pay 416 taxes. If you live in the 416 area then you would get a rebate on ticket purchases - a 905er would have to pay more.
 
Is it possible that the only solution to these cretins have is to take more of our money? We already pay enough taxes, here's a novel idea, try spending LESS on crap we dont need or want! As far as the funding the TTC, have them open thier books show us how they piss away millions of dollars yearl. Remember its not a revenue problem the TTC and government as a whole have, its a spending problem. As far as road tolls go, not a chance I help pay for those roads everytime i buy gas. You want to take the ttc pay for it yourself!
 
Tolls are crap . The 407 is way overpriced and should never have been built as a toll road in the first place . If the government really needs the extra revenue then justify it publically and raise the taxes . Toll roads and almost all user fees are the government just trying to hide their spending .

Boo

It wasn't. Ontario sold it. They coulda raised taxes; they coulda run it as a toll road themselves, but Harris prefferred doing a bad deal for fast cash.

Always amazes me how vehemently anti-socialist free market conservatives argue for free roads paid for by taxes collected from everyone, not just the users. User pay is the libertarian way.
 
User fees are not a good thing in this case. What people fail to realise is that we ALL use the roads in one way or another - even if you do not drive on them. When you buy groceries - they get to the stores by trucks on the roads, when you use public transit - the bus drives on the public road... many more examples I'm sure.
 
Here's a new concept make people who pay - benefit more from a service actually pay...

PVT - imposed on drivers helps city balance budget but penalizes drivers only
Water rates - the more you use the more you pay - that's fair

TTC riders only pay for ~40% of the cost of ridersship (I think) why not up the rates (taxes and subsidies pay rest) - drivers on the DVP aren't using transit; why should they pay more.

Here is one way to ding 905 who benefit from TTC but don't contribute as much because they don't pay 416 taxes. If you live in the 416 area then you would get a rebate on ticket purchases - a 905er would have to pay more.

Drivers are heavily subsidized, taxes from everyone pay for them. Much more than the TTC.
They don't pay for the full damage they cause, the death and injuries, the environmental toll, the destruction of farmland due to urban sprawl, the wars fought for their oil.
Did you notice there was an oil spill in the Gulf? Put that cost on the tab.
 
It wasn't. Ontario sold it. They coulda raised taxes; they coulda run it as a toll road themselves, but Harris prefferred doing a bad deal for fast cash.

Always amazes me how vehemently anti-socialist free market conservatives argue for free roads paid for by taxes collected from everyone, not just the users. User pay is the libertarian way.
Not True. The 407 was built as a toll road, paid for by the taxpayers of Ontario. The proposed payback was estimated at 25 years, at which time the tolls would end. Considering the higher usage, that payback would have been achieved much sooner.
Yes Harris was an idiot for selling out way too cheap, screwing all those who needed to use it.
The tolls on the 407 are just highway robbery.
 
I have no problem with tolls on the city expressways (DVP, Gardiner, and Allen) as long as they actually go to pay for transportation infrastructure including roads and TTC. Let the 905ers pay for some of the roads that they use on a daily basis.
 
how about put in end to urban sprawl? here is an example in king township along king road and jane street between teston road and king road there are big ads for new houses and estate houses which means there would be more traffic in the area and on the 400 all thst farm areas which grow food and have cattle eating grass(beef cattle i think) think will be lost forever.
 
Much smarter increase the competitiveness of Mass Transit (trains, street cars, subway, buses) by heavily subsidizing fares, than by attempting to penalize drivers through tolls.
 
I would like to see governments spend way less money. But that is another debate. Given that they need lots of money at the moment, much better to get it with road tolls, which have a benefit beyond money collected (reduced congestion). Otherwise they do it with income taxes that reduce hard work and employment. But taxing gasoline is a more effective way of taxing driving, you don't just shift the cars to other roads. So I say increase gas taxes dramatically, and match that by reducing income tax and eliminating EHT and other things that reduce employment.
 
...do you guys think it would be a good idea to toll the DVP/401 in order to create funding for TTC and even upgrading the highways?? I know that studies have shown that tolls do not lessen the traffic/users on highways but I think it would be a new step forward considering that other cities have instilled them to create funding
Absolutely not. The govt would just divert that money to its slush fund, just as it has diverted the 14cents per litre tax on gasoline that was supposed to support that purpose.