Hi-Value Manufacturing

We should celebrate the freedom from repetitive manual labour.
Those 'factory' jobs helped build up this country's (post-war) economic base and have allowed a lot of people to retire comfortably with separate CPP and union pensions.
There's a reason boomers hold the bulk of wealth in our society.
 
Those 'factory' jobs helped build up this country's (post-war) economic base and have allowed a lot of people to retire comfortably with separate CPP and union pensions.
There's a reason boomers hold the bulk of wealth in our society.

And serfdom helped to build European civilization. Times change, get on with the program. Or not, there is always welfare.
 
And serfdom helped to build European civilization. Times change, get on with the program. Or not, there is always welfare.
We associate repetitive, manual labour today with low wages, no benefits or job security, and no union representation. If you put those things back into the mix (as they used to be), it is a different scenario entirely.
 
We associate repetitive, manual labour today with low wages, no benefits or job security, and no union representation. If you put those things back into the mix (as they used to be), it is a different scenario entirely.


You mean give unions more power and give higher wages and more benefits? Ever heard of a little something called inflation? We've been through that. I didn't care for it. Evolution applies to economies as well as animals.
 
You mean give unions more power and give higher wages and more benefits?
Ever heard of a little something called inflation?
Yes, it was called a 'standard of living'. Double-edged sword I know, and no shortage of complaints against union activity, but the alternative is now an army of workers precariously employed on a temporary basis with low wages and no benefits or job security whatsoever, performing the same work that would have been done by a unionized worker less than 20 years ago. You need gainfully-employed workers to build a healthy economy - workers that can contribute to society by exercising purchasing power, rather than 'take' from it by instead requiring welfare, EI benefits, old-age income supplements, etc.

As for 'inflation', I have news for you: we are in deflationary environment right now.

See any correlation?
 
I agree we should pay workers fair wages no matter what kind of jobs including manual labour, so long as there is a REAL NEED. But there is no point protecting redundant jobs that can be either replaced by machines or cheaper labour elsewhere.

During the change there is always pain because a lot of older workers don't have the ability to learn new skills for new career, then they should be taken care of by social security. It would be more useful for a 50 year old laid off factory worker to say do community work or volunteer at a church than keeping a money losing factory running.
 
Yes, it was called a 'standard of living'. Double-edged sword I know, and no shortage of complaints against union activity, but the alternative is now an army of workers precariously employed on a temporary basis with low wages and no benefits or job security whatsoever, performing the same work that would have been done by a unionized worker less than 20 years ago. You need gainfully-employed workers to build a healthy economy - workers that can contribute to society by exercising purchasing power, rather than 'take' from it by instead requiring welfare, EI benefits, old-age income supplements, etc.

As for 'inflation', I have news for you: we are in deflationary environment right now.

See any correlation?

Yes, in fact! Farming out production to low cost producers = deflation. Is that what you're complaining about?

i agree that we need a healthy middle class for a healthy economy. Poverty does not make for a healthy economy, or country. But the answer is NOT false industry created by propping up inefficient enterprise. We are an economy in flux. The world is changing. We just have to figure out where we will fit in. No one is arguing that we don't need to employ our citizens in meaningful, well paying jobs. The question is, what should those jobs be? This, I submit, is where the lefties go off the rails. We need to work with business people, and those who can help raise or allocate capital.

It doesn't matter if you're socialist or capitalist at home. The world as a whole works on free enterprise.

Btw, inflation does not improve standards of living. It's just makes things more expensive, by definition.
 
it has been proven many times, the most efficient way for a govt to protect or intervene in a sector is by subsidies. One great way to do this is cheap power. China does it with cheap labour, money and shipping. Ontario has blown to pieces its cheap power advantage while at the same time the Canadian dollar has risen. Cheap power for industrial use, offer really cheap power for nighttime manufacturing since we now have a surplus at that time.
 
This the spiral into total loss of independence.

When the Offshore markets were cheaper at making crappy stuff, we switched to factories that made quality stuff. In a few years, the offshore factories improved their quality and we further shut down plants and switched to even more sophisticated stuff.

We are now almost at the point where the offshore factories can make just about anything we can and they make it well enough to make us unnecessary. The only difference is that they do it at a fraction of our cost because they don't have to pay the costs of human rights and environmental responsibility.

We have two options:

  1. Get out of the manufacturing business. We've already closed many of our facilities and we manufacture a small fraction of what we used to. The articles suggest we move into R&D which is fine...but it's not manufacturing.
  2. Block the import of any products to Canada that are not made in an environment where workers are treated fairly, safety is respected, and the environment is preserved. I have no doubt that the Canadian can be competitive; however, they have to be playing by the same rules as the competition. Since we're not willing to drop down to their level, we have to exclude those that won't rise to ours.

The articles are misleading because they suggest that there is a tier of manufacturing that western countries will always be better at than off-shore factories. This is a false hope. Manufacturing is a mass production process. If a factory North America could make make an iPhone cheaper than in Asia, Apple wouldn't be sending their flagship product off-shore to be built. Apple phones are famously "Designed" in the USA. If the off-shore factories can make an iPhone they can make most mass produced products to a reasonable quality level. This makes almost all factories in North America useless; or soon to be so.
 
IPhone's are made by foxcon in China. If stuff made in China are all crap, why are you shelling out $1000 to buy your iPhone5?

Apple still keeps majority of profit because they designed it and the whole ecosystem around their products. Asians are incapable of doing that yet. Apple not only created thousands of engineering jobs to directly working on iPhone's but think how many service jobs it created when these filthy rich employees spent their money? So yeah the best we can do now is to expand R&D and service industries. Only factories making military hardware may survive here.
 
Sure there is more interesting work to be done... again, why would any multinational company pay someone in North America to do that work when highly educated people in China or India can do the work for much less.

Yes a lot of simple computer programming jobs have already been offahored to India and Malaysia, but there still tons of jobs requring human presence such as IT support and such. For example, would a bank offshore a database administrator to its sensitive financial record to someone in India they do not meet face to face? There is a trust and accountability issue you cannot get around by telecommuting which is why most white collar workers in Toronto still have to sit through traffic to get to office everyday.
 
Blue-Spheroid.

+1 A very informative response.

As well as doing the primary manufacturing, these countries also manufacture the knock-offs, which are also gobbled up all over the globe. A great way to get in on the same market, with the goods you're manufacturing,
 
People are turning green with envy over the $10 apple pays workers in China to make each iphone/ipad, but our government makes $50-$100 bucks in sales tax on each iphone/ipad. I think Canadians are generally getting a much better deal out of offshore manufacturing than they think they are getting. The real outrage to me is when multinational corporations like apple are able to move money around and avoid paying taxes.
 
it has been proven many times, the most efficient way for a govt to protect or intervene in a sector is by subsidies. One great way to do this is cheap power. China does it with cheap labour, money and shipping. Ontario has blown to pieces its cheap power advantage while at the same time the Canadian dollar has risen. Cheap power for industrial use, offer really cheap power for nighttime manufacturing since we now have a surplus at that time.

Cheap/free power at night for industry is a good idea, you might run into issues where companies are just using night time power to charge up big batteries and then use the power during the day, this might also create a big industry in Ontario for producing hydrogen gas through electrolysis for hydrogen fuel cells. Maybe this, plus a few other incentives would work wonders. But in summer when it gets hot, ontario no longer has any power surplus as every drop of power is sucked up by Air conditioning.
 
...........................
The only difference is that they do it at a fraction of our cost because they don't have to pay the costs of human rights and environmental responsibility.......

Negligence of human rights and environmental responsbility
are issues of concern. Rectification of these issues wouldn't
necessarily result in significant change in the disparity in
standard of living between China and the west the major
factor contributing to the low cost of manufacturing there.
Vast majority of Chinese factory workers do not own a house
or drive a car. And that disparity has little to do with human
rights violation.
 
Last edited:
This the spiral into total loss of independence.

When the Offshore markets were cheaper at making crappy stuff, we switched to factories that made quality stuff. In a few years, the offshore factories improved their quality and we further shut down plants and switched to even more sophisticated stuff.

We are now almost at the point where the offshore factories can make just about anything we can and they make it well enough to make us unnecessary. The only difference is that they do it at a fraction of our cost because they don't have to pay the costs of human rights and environmental responsibility.

We have two options:

  1. Get out of the manufacturing business. We've already closed many of our facilities and we manufacture a small fraction of what we used to. The articles suggest we move into R&D which is fine...but it's not manufacturing.
  2. Block the import of any products to Canada that are not made in an environment where workers are treated fairly, safety is respected, and the environment is preserved. I have no doubt that the Canadian can be competitive; however, they have to be playing by the same rules as the competition. Since we're not willing to drop down to their level, we have to exclude those that won't rise to ours.

The articles are misleading because they suggest that there is a tier of manufacturing that western countries will always be better at than off-shore factories. This is a false hope. Manufacturing is a mass production process. If a factory North America could make make an iPhone cheaper than in Asia, Apple wouldn't be sending their flagship product off-shore to be built. Apple phones are famously "Designed" in the USA. If the off-shore factories can make an iPhone they can make most mass produced products to a reasonable quality level. This makes almost all factories in North America useless; or soon to be so.

Great post. This is the phase of global economic evolution that we are entering right now. Ethical sourcing is the next wave, and it is critical to sustainable global prosperity.


Negligence of human rights and environmental responsbility
are issues of concern. Rectification of these issues wouldn't
necessarily result in significant change in the disparity in
standard of living between China and the west the major
factor contributing to the low cost of manufacturing there.
Vast majority of Chinese factory workers do not own a house
or drive a car. And that disparity has little to do with human
rights violation.

Yeah, it might have something to do with the fact that China is still a communist nation.....
 
As somebody who has been in the Canadian Mfg. sector all my career I find this thread very interesting. There are some valid reasons to reintroduce tariffs and there are a lot of good reasons not to.
But the real story is being missed entirely. The real story here is that most Chinese companies DO NOT MAKE MONEY! This will come to light very soon as they start to fail. (First one went down recently) There will be many more to come. The Chinese government has built a corporate house built on debt that they may or may not be able to continue funding.

THINK ABOUT THIS; You can buy a DVD player for $40. The retailer will make a 5 dollar profit. One plant in China will make various models for various Japanese companies and brand them accordingly. The Japanese company will make there 5 dollars per unit. It will cost $1 or $2 to ship it here. For the manufacturer to make a $4 profit, they would have to be able to make it for about 24 dollars. The parts alone exceeds this easily. Even if their labour was 0 (which it isn't). Even if their overhead was 0 (which it isn't) They are losing money.

What I find hilarious is that people in the Western world have been buying items like this for such ridiculous prices and they don't think that something is seriously OFF.

Good post.
 
Yeah, it might have something to do with the fact that China is still a communist nation.....


I'll use 'developing world' in lieu of communist nation. Compared
with other developing world China's economy is overdevloped
in some areas (and hence the vast gap between the wealthy and
the general population). Central planning does help a bit with allocation
of resources to its export industries and perhaps thats where
communist may apply. But overall China is still pretty much
a developing country and the Chinese still has a long way
to go for their standard of living to catch up with the western
world. In fact the trend seems to be that manufacturing of
cheaper goods will eventually be shifted from China to
poorer nations like Bangladesh.
 
The broader question that no do-gooder, we're all people of earth philanthropist wants to consider is - what happens if we all enjoy the same high standard of living? Can the earth sustain that? I think not. We (first world, western nations) need to roll back as the third world move forward.....