Hi-Value Manufacturing

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
Exactly!!! I was having a debate with someone over just this thing the other day. He wanted tariffs and closed markets to bring back our manufacturing sector. Ugh!!! I can't stand it. We need to be MORE competitive with the global market, not less. Relying on what amounts to subsidies to produce low value widgets is NOT what we should be doing.

So when I saw this article I thought it was bang-on the mark.

http://www.thestar.com/business/eco...g_in_ontario_must_be_different_than_past.html

http://mowatcentre.ca/wp-content/uploads/publications/83_ontario_made_summary.pdf
 
Well, going global, to lower your costs is fine Keebler. But the Canadian manufacturing sector has to comply with certain rules and regulations, health/safety and environmental standards that their counterparts in other parts of the world don't have to comply with. Now, workers wages aside, by skirting such laws that we hold dearly in worker safety and the environment, they can lower their costs quite easily. Is this ethically right, by exploiting these countries by skirting the same laws that govern them in the countries where they have their head offices and make the lion's share of their sales, in order to maintain their bottom line, or the huge bonuses that their top execs make?

Is this being more competitive or just not wanting to comply with the government regulations that are in place in Canada, Europe and the US, because this costs money?
 
As Angela Merkel said (I'm paraphrasing here) "Better, not cheaper."

Could not agree more and I totally admire those teutonic bastards for their drive, engineering prowess, and the quality of what they build. Some of the most expensive labour in the world, but sought after products.

Canada would do well to study the Germans and how they do things.
 
Your choice, do you want to go back to the days of the $1200 VCR and the $800 air conditioner? That was the price when they were built here in North America. As far as low quality goods, this is the fault of the importers. If you are paying a buck at the dollar store, what do you think the importer is paying for the product?
 
The problem is 2 fold, small population and high wages. The high wages is not as much as a detriment as having a small population in Ontario and in Canada. Our small population means there will be limited scales of economies to leverage towards manufacturing, and almost anything that is made in Ontario would probably have to incur significant transportation costs to get the product to the target market.

High tech or low tech, unless Ontario's population balloons to that of California we have a 0 chance, and even then it would still be an uphill battle.
 
Could not agree more and I totally admire those teutonic bastards for their drive, engineering prowess, and the quality of what they build. Some of the most expensive labour in the world, but sought after products.

Canada would do well to study the Germans and how they do things.

Ah yes, when they made the Leica M4-P camera and 50 mm Summicron F2 lens in Midland, Ontario. Napoleon Barbecues in Barrie. Should I go on?
 
Exactly!!! I was having a debate with someone over just this thing the other day. He wanted tariffs and closed markets to bring back our manufacturing sector. Ugh!!! I can't stand it. We need to be MORE competitive with the global market, not less. Relying on what amounts to subsidies to produce low value widgets is NOT what we should be doing.
Exactly. Value-added manufacturing as opposed to trying to build industry behind tariff walls. In theory, a protected market is supposed to help build up infant industry, but we're not starting from scratch here. Unfortunately, this government has made us far too reliant on an unsustainable (in the long-run) commodity/resource-based economy.
 
As somebody who has been in the Canadian Mfg. sector all my career I find this thread very interesting. There are some valid reasons to reintroduce tariffs and there are a lot of good reasons not to.
But the real story is being missed entirely. The real story here is that most Chinese companies DO NOT MAKE MONEY! This will come to light very soon as they start to fail. (First one went down recently) There will be many more to come. The Chinese government has built a corporate house built on debt that they may or may not be able to continue funding.

THINK ABOUT THIS; You can buy a DVD player for $40. The retailer will make a 5 dollar profit. One plant in China will make various models for various Japanese companies and brand them accordingly. The Japanese company will make there 5 dollars per unit. It will cost $1 or $2 to ship it here. For the manufacturer to make a $4 profit, they would have to be able to make it for about 24 dollars. The parts alone exceeds this easily. Even if their labour was 0 (which it isn't). Even if their overhead was 0 (which it isn't) They are losing money.

What I find hilarious is that people in the Western world have been buying items like this for such ridiculous prices and they don't think that something is seriously OFF.
 
The problem is 2 fold, small population and high wages. The high wages is not as much as a detriment as having a small population in Ontario and in Canada. Our small population means there will be limited scales of economies to leverage towards manufacturing, and almost anything that is made in Ontario would probably have to incur significant transportation costs to get the product to the target market.

High tech or low tech, unless Ontario's population balloons to that of California we have a 0 chance, and even then it would still be an uphill battle.
But we used to have a strong mfg. base!
 
As somebody who has been in the Canadian Mfg. sector all my career I find this thread very interesting. There are some valid reasons to reintroduce tariffs and there are a lot of good reasons not to.
But the real story is being missed entirely. The real story here is that most Chinese companies DO NOT MAKE MONEY! This will come to light very soon as they start to fail. (First one went down recently) There will be many more to come. The Chinese government has built a corporate house built on debt that they may or may not be able to continue funding.

THINK ABOUT THIS; You can buy a DVD player for $40. The retailer will make a 5 dollar profit. One plant in China will make various models for various Japanese companies and brand them accordingly. The Japanese company will make there 5 dollars per unit. It will cost $1 or $2 to ship it here. For the manufacturer to make a $4 profit, they would have to be able to make it for about 24 dollars. The parts alone exceeds this easily. Even if their labour was 0 (which it isn't). Even if their overhead was 0 (which it isn't) They are losing money.

What I find hilarious is that people in the Western world have been buying items like this for such ridiculous prices and they don't think that something is seriously OFF.

That's a very dire prediction. If China fails now, it will take the whole world back 20 years.
 
Clearly you didn't read either document. Fail.


Umm, yes I did.

What regulations do you think they talk about. China and other emerging manufacturing centers, do not have the same restraints with regards to the environment that Canadian industry have. And the don't have the same workers insurance policies in place that are mandated here. China and other emerging manufacturing centers do not require the same safety standards that are required by law here in Canada. There is no EI benefits paid by the employer there....

keep telling yourselves that "high-tek" is the way to go... people are better educated in China or India... and they can do "hi-tek" cheaper

Exactly.

We can go after high end R&D sector jobs, but there are going to be fewer of them. Question, when the same countries that have the factories also have highly educated and skilled people of their own, why have your R&D sector so far from the factory?
Besides, with the lax rules and regs in those countries pertaining to all of which I stated above and more, why go anywhere else.
And, those highly educated workers work for less pay and benefits over there.

But we used to have a strong mfg. base!

Yes we did.

It's all about the bottom line though, as companies squeeze every penny into their profit margins that they can.
 
As somebody who has been in the Canadian Mfg. sector all my career I find this thread very interesting. There are some valid reasons to reintroduce tariffs and there are a lot of good reasons not to.
But the real story is being missed entirely. The real story here is that most Chinese companies DO NOT MAKE MONEY! This will come to light very soon as they start to fail. (First one went down recently) There will be many more to come. The Chinese government has built a corporate house built on debt that they may or may not be able to continue funding.

THINK ABOUT THIS; You can buy a DVD player for $40. The retailer will make a 5 dollar profit. One plant in China will make various models for various Japanese companies and brand them accordingly. The Japanese company will make there 5 dollars per unit. It will cost $1 or $2 to ship it here. For the manufacturer to make a $4 profit, they would have to be able to make it for about 24 dollars. The parts alone exceeds this easily. Even if their labour was 0 (which it isn't). Even if their overhead was 0 (which it isn't) They are losing money.

What I find hilarious is that people in the Western world have been buying items like this for such ridiculous prices and they don't think that something is seriously OFF.

You are trying to make a point with an extreme case of one product that is the lowest cost item a factory might have. The same way that GM, Ford and Chrysler use to make money on the mid sized and luxury cars, and lost money on their economy cars. ( Ford use to bring in Aspire cars at a loss to meet CAFE standards ) The Chinese plants make money on the middle priced and high end electronics. An electronics factory that has a lower end line where they make small margins can keep their employees working when they have a large supply of higher end manufactured goods. This is good supply management. There even be further reductions in price when the Chinese cut out the Japanese middle man.
Years ago buying a Gold Star Korean VCR was buying at the lower end, now the same company LG has a good reputation for quality. People are buying reputation when they buy the Sony branded DVD player, in the future they might go for the Chinese Wang Chung DVD player instead and know they are getting the same product.

You have also taken politics out of this equation. The super powers will never let the situation go back to where it was.
 
You have also taken politics out of this equation. The super powers will never let the situation go back to where it was

Good point CC, but who then supplants the super powers? The new manufacturing giants in these countries?
 
As somebody who has been in the Canadian Mfg. sector all my career I find this thread very interesting. There are some valid reasons to reintroduce tariffs and there are a lot of good reasons not to.
But the real story is being missed entirely. The real story here is that most Chinese companies DO NOT MAKE MONEY! This will come to light very soon as they start to fail. (First one went down recently) There will be many more to come. The Chinese government has built a corporate house built on debt that they may or may not be able to continue funding.

THINK ABOUT THIS; You can buy a DVD player for $40. The retailer will make a 5 dollar profit. One plant in China will make various models for various Japanese companies and brand them accordingly. The Japanese company will make there 5 dollars per unit. It will cost $1 or $2 to ship it here. For the manufacturer to make a $4 profit, they would have to be able to make it for about 24 dollars. The parts alone exceeds this easily. Even if their labour was 0 (which it isn't). Even if their overhead was 0 (which it isn't) They are losing money.

What I find hilarious is that people in the Western world have been buying items like this for such ridiculous prices and they don't think that something is seriously OFF.


Did anyone else notice that this analysis builds assumes PROFIT into the costing and then concludes that bankruptcy is inevitable? Lol.
 
We can go after high end R&D sector jobs, but there are going to be fewer of them.

Not necessarily. If it only takes 5% of workforce to do the production because of efficiency and automation, I dont see why not have 70% work in R&D to design better products and distribution logistics, and 25% in service and support.
 
It's stupid people are so hang up on manufacturing jobs. We should celebrate the freedom from repetitive manual labour. There are so many more interesting work to be done such a finding cure for diseases, designing more energy efficient cars , explore space etc. It's a good thing to lose factories to cheaper Chinese and one day robots.
 
Good point CC, but who then supplants the super powers? The new manufacturing giants in these countries?

Politics today is not like it was 100 years ago, back then Henry Ford or Thomas Edison could have made a few whispers into the ear of the President or a congressman and changed the course of history. Today even the most wealthy of people do not have such power, especially in China. While China is no longer communist, it certainly is not capitalist in the way the west is. It is a hybrid of communism evolving into capitalism. Only in the protectionist oligopoly of Russia can such influence exist.