Hi Terbies. Need some vehicle purchasing advice. Please help.

vyrguy

New member
Sep 15, 2008
364
0
0
Hey guys

My lease is up for renewal and due to the recent alignment of earth with Uranus I find myself in the enviable position of being the proud owner of a BMW X5. But there's a catch ( isn't there always). The car sustained hail damage sometime last year according to the dealer (certified pre-owned dealership) and a claim was done for $9800 against the car. The panelbeater over-quoted (insurance claim rip-off) since they didn't even do any paint work. Nevertheless, the claim is now a matter of record and I am a bit concerned about how that will affect the resale value.

So the question is does anyone know with any degree of certainty whether the claim would affect the resale.

Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks
 
Well I can't claim any certainty, but I know what my take would be on it.... Would I be willing to pay the same for a car that has sustained damage than I would for one that didn't? Of course not.
 
sorry for being the bearer of bad news but it certainly will affect it
 
lets see.
car A, mint condition, reasonable mileage. well cared for has a value
car b , looks mint condition, reasonable mileage, appears to be well cared for. has been branded for hail damage. it has a value
Car A will have more value than car B. but as long as it's factored into your purchase price, and you're happy with the car, it shouldn't be an issue for you (knowing that on resale you won't likely get the same as Car a would have fetched.

Friend bought a sports car several years ago, had been in a major collision, was documented the air bags weren't operational. price was substantially less than a pristine or mint car. He accepted the fact that the car was "less than mint" . When he sold it, it was a factor of the selling price as well, but he enjoyed the car for about 5 years, and paid a lot less than a mint car would have cost him. for all intents and purposes, the car, to the average person looked as good as any.
 
OK. Let me expand a bit. This deal is awesome.

It's an '08 model. It has every convievable package BMW has to offer (seriously). It is priced @ '07 prices. It has less than 20000km on the clock. The car is in excellent condition and you would never that there was any hail damage unless somebody told you. The ONLY thing that stopped me from signing on Saturday already is this hail claim thing!
 
It's an '08 model. It has every convievable package BMW has to offer (seriously). It is priced @ '07 prices. It has less than 20000km on the clock. The car is in excellent condition and you would never that there was any hail damage unless somebody told you. The ONLY thing that stopped me from signing on Saturday already is this hail claim thing!

I would highly recommend running your own car proof report to ensure their is no additional hidden damage.
 
Thanks for your responses guys. I think i'm gonna go ahead and get this one. I think that with the discounts (almost $6000) + all the packages included it should offset any potential shortfall from
the claim in the long term.

Do people really still need to do a carproof/carfax assesment when you buy from an authorized dealer!?!

Thanks again.
 
I would highly recommend running your own car proof report to ensure their is no additional hidden damage.
Listen to him, get a carproof report. It will save you the head aches or any regrets later, esp. if you try to sell it later. People usually stay clear of damaged cars and selling a car which has some black markers in the past is very hard or people will low ball you like crazy
 
Do people really still need to do a carproof/carfax assesment when you buy from an authorized dealer!?!

Thanks again.

If the dealer can show you the report, then you have covered that base.

If you plan on re-selling, the same issue you are facing will come into question. If you plan on driving it into the ground, then grab yourself a BMW at a good deal and enjoy.
 
Thanks for your responses guys. I think i'm gonna go ahead and get this one. I think that with the discounts (almost $6000) + all the packages included it should offset any potential shortfall from
the claim in the long term.

Do people really still need to do a carproof/carfax assesment when you buy from an authorized dealer!?!

Thanks again.

A couple of things. The dealer should provide you the carproof report, but these are not foolproof either.

I would read the fine print of BMW certified series warranty....I think it explicitly states that it warrants no major accidents have occurred (otherwise it does not get BMW's stamp of approval).

BMW Certified Series are good cars....I would think the $6000 savings mitigates the hail damage especially since you will keep the vehicle for at least 3-4 years, ie. the length of the CPO warranty. After that, the normal depreciation will reduce the value of the car significantly anyway.

Have fun and good luck.
 
If the dealer can show you the report, then you have covered that base.

If you plan on re-selling, the same issue you are facing will come into question. If you plan on driving it into the ground, then grab yourself a BMW at a good deal and enjoy.
There's the catch, vyrguy; the next guy's gonna do the same search or rely on the same honesty from you as you got from the dealer. The car's resale value has already been affected, which is why you're getting it cheap.

It's all about how much info about the damage you plan to pass along when you sell.
 
Thanks for all the subsequent advice and feedback. Terb is such a good resource for info and advice. Terbies are great.