Help me choose a brokerage

chateau

Member
Jul 29, 2007
116
1
18
I was reading the other thread about the guy with a lot of money that he has to hide and i was really impressed by how much financial knowlede people on terb have.

I have never invested in stocks or anything like that, and I wanted to get started. I have done some research and I wanted to know:
a) should I go with a discount brokerage or a full brokerage?
b) What is the best discount brokerage
c) If I do invest my money what is the best way to protect that money from the taxman? (i.e. should i put it towards an rrsp?)
 
..

chateau said:
I was reading the other thread about the guy with a lot of money that he has to hide and i was really impressed by how much financial knowlede people on terb have.

I have never invested in stocks or anything like that, and I wanted to get started. I have done some research and I wanted to know:
a) should I go with a discount brokerage or a full brokerage?
b) What is the best discount brokerage
c) If I do invest my money what is the best way to protect that money from the taxman? (i.e. should i put it towards an rrsp?)


RRSP's are your best bet to reduce taxes, LSIF can be added to your portfolio in your RRSP and offer a 30% tax credit (15% Fed & 15% Prov) on top of the contribution (mind you LSIF are very volitile, especially these days, even if you loose money on them, you have to think that you have gained 30% right off the top)...think long term, because if you are on for a quick buck, go to the bank.

If you leverage your money the interest costs become tax deductible for you as well...;)
 
There are a few things to consider before you invest.

- How much do you have to invest?

- Do you think you will be needing this money in the future? If so when?

- What is your risk tolerance? The higher the risk the higher the possibilities if gain, but the possibility of loss is also greater.

- Are you interested in long term safe gain? There are long slow investments that are pretty safe bets.

- How old are you?

- Do you have time to watch your investment, or do you want a worry free investment?

The first piece of advice I can gve you is to maxout your RRSP and Tax free savings plan. If you are not experienced, get advice and buy very safe stock. Generaly people do not realy know what they are doing until they have at least 5 years of watching and learning and even then you only have an idea of what is going on.
 
Brokrage

For a beginner who is planning to get into series investmen -rather than just a some mutual funds for example, get a broker for some of your money. They give you advice and teach the rules, there a rip for most people but if youir not going to take a course or read some financal books on your own, they can have their purposes. Eventually, depening on time and experience you switch all or some of your money to a discount brokerage which is do itsyourself. BUT, in the present economy you have to be able to spend a hour a day on your stocks - the current market is very viotale. And even with a broker who proably will have you as the least important client you still have to stay on top of things. Regardless so some research.
 
If you really have no idea where to start, then you better stay away from the discount brokerage. There is no way you will avoid making a fatal mistake all on your own. That's not to say a broker may help you make a fatal mistake.
Whether to use a stock broker or mutual funds used to come down to how much money you were going to invest. Buying individual stocks used to mean that you needed about $5000 per stock, but to be diversified you needed 40 to 50 stocks. Now with ETF's you can buy baskets of stocks for very cheap, however you will not get any time or service from a stock broker unlesss you have at least $100 000 to invest.
Best advice is to ask people around you in the same financial position you are in, if they are happy with their advisor. This is actually a great time to ask, because if they are still happy after the greatest stock market meltdown in history, then that advisor must be pretty good.
Choose someone you feel comfortable with. Proximity always helps. He/she will be more likely to visit, or you visit them if they are close by. You should also make yourself easily accesible too. You want them to feel comfortable calling you as well. If they are feeling uneasy about one of your investments, and you are an easy phone call to make, you can be sure you will be one of the first people he/she calls.
 
You'll want to sit down with a couple brokerage firms and find out what the advisor's investment preferences are, for someone in your financial position.

But to start, I would strongly recommend going with (and paying for) the advice of someone who spends their day trying to figure out how to make money in the markets, rather than going with a Discount Brokerage and playing games yourself. If you have some of your own ideas where to put your money, your broker can discuss that with you and put your money there.

My choice of company has been driven by personal relationship with the individual advisor, rather than randomly with the company involved.

There are opportunities with most of the major banks in Canada (BMO, TD, HSBC, etc), which can be good for starting out. Costs tend to be lower, and the products tend to be more straightforward (mutual funds are popular, and good ways to spread the risks).

Going with a full-service independent brokerage firm (Merrill, before their meltdown, typified the class) brings more diversified investment vehicles, but tend to have additional fees to go with it. You see "Edward Jones" in local neighbourhoods, or Canaccord, Raymond James, etc in the big buildings in the downtown core of major centres. Each firm will attract different quality talent to their fold (making it more important to feel comfortable with the individual you're dealing with and paying for).
 
Anynym said:
You'll want to sit down with a couple brokerage firms and find out what the advisor's investment preferences are, for someone in your financial position.

But to start, I would strongly recommend going with (and paying for) the advice of someone who spends their day trying to figure out how to make money in the markets, rather than going with a Discount Brokerage and playing games yourself. If you have some of your own ideas where to put your money, your broker can discuss that with you and put your money there.

My choice of company has been driven by personal relationship with the individual advisor, rather than randomly with the company involved.

There are opportunities with most of the major banks in Canada (BMO, TD, HSBC, etc), which can be good for starting out. Costs tend to be lower, and the products tend to be more straightforward (mutual funds are popular, and good ways to spread the risks).

Going with a full-service independent brokerage firm (Merrill, before their meltdown, typified the class) brings more diversified investment vehicles, but tend to have additional fees to go with it. You see "Edward Jones" in local neighbourhoods, or Canaccord, Raymond James, etc in the big buildings in the downtown core of major centres. Each firm will attract different quality talent to their fold (making it more important to feel comfortable with the individual you're dealing with and paying for).


You have no idea what you are talking about, do you?
 
ang said:
RRSP's are your best bet to reduce taxes, LSIF can be added to your portfolio in your RRSP and offer a 30% tax credit (15% Fed & 15% Prov) on top of the contribution (mind you LSIF are very volitile, especially these days, even if you loose money on them, you have to think that you have gained 30% right off the top)...think long term, because if you are on for a quick buck, go to the bank.

If you leverage your money the interest costs become tax deductible for you as well...;)

I'm not sure you meant this but just to clarify, the interest paid on an RRSP loan is not tax deductible.
 
ang said:
If you leverage your money the interest costs become tax deductible for you as well...;)

Assume you mean for his non-RRSP investments, but be careful as leverage is a double edge sword. Many people with debt have been wiped out this recession and past recessions (remember the Reichmans?).
 
Write down all possible questions you have regarding the market. A good financial advisor should be able to shed some light on most of them. Remember that comissions is what drives the business. Don't try and go out on your own without reading a whole lot of books, watching BNN or CNBC for a while.
 
pokerdude said:
Write down all possible questions you have regarding the market. A good financial advisor should be able to shed some light on most of them. Remember that comissions is what drives the business. Don't try and go out on your own without reading a whole lot of books, watching BNN or CNBC for a while.

I didn't realize that there is such a thing as a good financial advisor:D .

In all seriousness IMHO investing in etfs in a discount brokerage is the best and most cost-efficient way to go. However you really have to know what you're doing.

If the op chooses to go the discount brokerage route nobody is there to hold your hand. As a result the DB account could be blown up quite fast!

The problem with advisors is that they will never tell you about etfs as most etfs pay the advisor no trailer fees whatsoever. Also only 10% of advisors in Canada are licensed to sell etfs. It creates a catch 22 situation for the inexperienced or uninformed investor.
 
pokerdude said:
Don't try and go out on your own without reading a whole lot of books, watching BNN or CNBC for a while.
Don't watch CNBC. If you do watch CNBC, don't buy into what they are saying... Watching CNBC is one of the worse things you can do. :p
 
I am too impressed and thankful by amount financial knowledge on this board.

I am a beginner too. I am seriously considerring entering the market. I am thinking of $5000 (five thousands) to begin with possibly a TFSA account. I think I can do my research on my own. So I guess all I need is a discount brokerage with basic but reliable services. Beacuse, I am going to begin with one (or two) ETF(s) and a few individual stocks from US and Canadian equities.

Since I am starting with not much money, I don't think I will be a frequent trader (like 30 or even 150 trades/Quarter that some brokerage wants as minimum). I am thinking of QuestTrade, but there seems to be endless complains all over internet.

I am hoping to contain the cost about 1%/yr, otherwise I would rather go with Mutual funds (cost about 2%, and I don't have to do alot of reasearch and expose myself to individual stocks).

So anybody have any thoughts?

Thanks,

(p.s. Yes, my id was banned only once before, but I learned my lesson, and hope to stay longer this time...go ahead throw your jokes at....I'm waiting...:D )
 
wooof1984 said:
I am too impressed and thankful by amount financial knowledge on this board.

I am a beginner too. I am seriously considerring entering the market. I am thinking of $5000 (five thousands) to begin with possibly a TFSA account. I think I can do my research on my own. So I guess all I need is a discount brokerage with basic but reliable services. Beacuse, I am going to begin with one (or two) ETF(s) and a few individual stocks from US and Canadian equities.

Since I am starting with not much money, I don't think I will be a frequent trader (like 30 or even 150 trades/Quarter that some brokerage wants as minimum). I am thinking of QuestTrade, but there seems to be endless complains all over internet.

I am hoping to contain the cost about 1%/yr, otherwise I would rather go with Mutual funds (cost about 2%, and I don't have to do alot of reasearch and expose myself to individual stocks).

So anybody have any thoughts?

Thanks,

(p.s. Yes, my id was banned only once before, but I learned my lesson, and hope to stay longer this time...go ahead throw your jokes at....I'm waiting...:D )

With 5 grand you will probably pay around $40 a trade at a discount brokerage...so keep the trade volume down and you should be OK. Not sure what they charge to administer the TFSA...if anything extra. At $40 per trade if you buy and hold an ETF or ETF's the only long term cost you will have is the MER - usually around .5% or so (more or less depending on ETF).

Sticking to a couple or 3 ETFs will give you lots of diversification potential (depending which ones you pick of course...some are not diversified). Even just picking one (for example one that mirrors the TSX) will give you Canadian diversification equal to the TSX. But do your research and get the mix you want.

Good luck.
 
Quest is cheap but their customer service sucks ass. I was with them for a bit but moved my book back to my bank with $9.99 trades. Not worth the hassle to save $5 but if your an active trader then it adds up quick.