Harper the control freak?

scroll99

New member
Jan 17, 2004
1,257
0
0
Re: "PM vows to avoid 'biased' media in Ottawa" (May 25)

What gives Prime Minister Stephen Harper the right to control press conferences?

He should, as a democratic leader who claims to know what is best for the country, be readily able to answer any questions presented by members of the press or the public.

His decision to answer only government prepared questions -- ergo with government prepared answers -- is a huge misuse of power and abuse of press and public.

His secret agenda continues to govern his behaviour and our country without our involvement or support.

The Canadian "majority" that he is attempting to woo must not give him the support he is so arrogantly seeking when he should be democratically representing the majority of Canadians, their wishes and needs.

http://www.hamiltonspectator.com/NA...9&call_pageid=1020420665036&col=1112876262536
 
HARPER'S HIDDEN AGENDA

Harper was crystal clear in matters of ethics, as applied to the corruption of the liberals. Now in the Prime Minister Office he lures a former liberal minister to a ministerial post and puts in the Senate a patronage friend as minister, not accountable to Parliament. He has shown the contempt of the Office of the Prime Minister for the Commissioner of Ethics, appointed by Parliament where the Conservatives voted in favor of the nomination of the Commissioner.

The above is nothing. A known lobbyist selling armaments to our Armed Forces was appointed Minister of Defense and he has sent our troops to head crimes of war in Afghanistan, initiated by Bush on false representation to the Senate, the Congress and the peoples of the World. Mr. Harper has joined the many heads of State that are reporting to Washington, under the command of Bush, and other criminals of war in that Capital. Never in the history of Canada, have our troops been sent to such a shameful and degrading mission. Bush has spoken; Harper has delivered. Our noble soldiers, heroes of past global conflicts, are being forced by Harper to join and lead an international horde of hooligans and assassins. Our military personnel deserve respect, not this form of contempt and global humiliation from our fascist government.

Canada highly respected all over the world has become another aggressor of the Arab Oil. Our cities – for the first time – are in peril because of the subservience of Harper to the supreme criminal of war, George W. Bush, who is repudiated by a large majority of the American people.

His new Ambassador to the White House, Mr. Wilson, speaks of negotiating the lumber issue, when Washington is robbing our lumberjacks and the five billion stolen should be already paid, or we should put reciprocal tariffs in our trade to the USA. The Free Trade Agreement was unilaterally broken by Washington, and it is now null and void because of that action.

Parliament has not met yet since the election, but the Prime Minister has already betrayed Canada worst than Mulroney. At the end of his minority mandate, we may become officially the 51st State. What would happen if he was re-elected with a majority government?

The only party that offered a representative democratic government was the NDP, on a proven record of democratic service to Canada. Where were we that could not hear something so simple, democratic and clear? Multinational money talked loud in our TV, and the fascist propaganda drowned democracy in Canada.

http://maritimes.indymedia.org/news/2006/03/12050.php
 
The Liberals

sent the troops to Afghanistan. Only an idiot would attack a trading partner that is responsible for more than 70% of your exports. How would the NDP be any better? We saw how they goverened Ontario. How they democratically cut the pay of public servsnts and brought in Rae days. I wonder if we could survive Layton days. I like how it was stated that Harper wooed a Liberal to cross the floor. Maybe he was bribed, he wouldn't have been the first crooked politician.



X
 
Top Ten Countries with which the U.S. has a Trade Deficit
For the month of December 2005



Country Name of U.S. $ ( in millions)

China -16,299.29
Canada -8,039.45
Japan -6,800.21
Federal Republic of Germany -4,516.52
Mexico -4,262.76
Venezuela -2,425.65
Nigeria -2,207.04
Malaysia -2,197.09
Saudi Arabia -1,607.61
Ireland -1,507.39


China is among the biggest US trading partner , does it mean they are in agreement on all the world issuues or they are enjoying the best relationship ?

it's not an excuse for anyone to become Bush's lapdog or become another US state
 
4 in 10 Americans support annexing Canada: Poll

Updated Mon. Oct. 14 2002 1:01 PM ET

Canadian Press

MONTREAL -- Should Canada become the 51st American state? Four out of 10 Americans answered "sure" in a recent poll conducted by Leger Marketing of Montreal.

While 38 per cent of respondents said they would be "in favour of Canada being annexed to the United States," 49 per cent disagreed. Another 13 per cent said they did not know or refused to answer.

But those who follow Canada-U.S. relations closely said Canadians should not panic.

"I wouldn't worry about the army coming," said Christopher Sands, director of the Canada Project for the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C.

"I don't think there's any manifest-destiny thinking much in the United States anymore. People don't want to just acquire territory."

Sands said he was somewhat puzzled by the "high minority" of Americans who said Canada should be annexed. However, he speculated the responses were an indication of goodwill and welcome towards Canadians should the government ever decide on its own that it wants to join the United States.

Canadians are no longer the strangers to Americans they once were, added Sands. So Americans are now more accepting of the cultural and political differences between the two countries than they were in the past and they aren't in a rush to launch a takeover of their neighbours to the north.

Harold Waller, who teaches U.S. politics at McGill University in Montreal, said Canadians should view the poll result as more of a curiosity than a real window on how Americans see us.

"I doubt if the average American knows enough about Canada to make a reasoned assessment, what the pros and cons might be," said Waller. "There's really an abysmal level of ignorance about Canada in the United States so I don't know what conclusions you can reach."

Waller said Americans likely didn't express overwhelming enthusiasm for annexation because they didn't see any obvious advantage to them.

From a historical perspective, there hasn't been a real push by Americans for annexation since the 19th century, he added.

Leger interviewed 1,000 Americans between Sept. 19 and Sept. 29 for the poll provided to The Canadian Press. The margin of error is plus or minus 3.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.

Leger also compared these results to a similar survey of 1,508 Canadians in early September 2001.

On the question of annexation by the United States, 19.9 per cent of Canadians said at that time that they would be in favour, while 76.5 per cent rejected the proposition. Another 3.6 per cent said they didn't know or refused to answer.

For this year's survey, the pollsters also asked Americans if they would be "in favour of Canada adopting the U.S. dollar as its national currency."

Fifty-eight per cent of respondents said "yes," while 28 per cent said "no" and 15 per cent said they didn't know or refused to answer.

In last year's poll, 39.9 per cent of Canadians said they'd be in favour of the switch, while 55.1 per cent were opposed and five per cent said they didn't know or refused to answer.

Sands said the wording of that question could have been interpreted by Americans as Canadians asking for permission to adopt the U.S. dollar after already deciding it was the best move for Canada.

"I'm sure the average American doesn't think, 'Gee those low Canadian dollars give them an export advantage,' " said Sands. "I don't think it's about imposition. I think it's about 'Well, yeah, we don't mind.' "

Waller said it wouldn't make a difference to the average American if Canada started using the U.S. dollar, noting Panama already uses the currency.

"I can't imagine the average American having a clue about the Canadian dollar, or what it means, or what its value is, or how it fluctuates."

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/1034541784098_126/?hub=Canada
 
scroll99 said:
What gives Prime Minister Stephen Harper the right to control press conferences?
Looks like Harper is forging his relationship with the media using the Bill Davis handbook. Brampton Bill (one of the kinder names the press bestowed on him) escorted ;) Ontario through some of it’s most prosperous years,. Mr. Davis had a rather tumultuous relationship with the media often just ignoring them all together.

.
 
Canada's First War President: All Hail Chief Harper

PEJ News - C. L. Cook - That Stephen Harper hates Canada: It's wet insistence on social safety nets; healthcare; public education; and lame Peacekeeping traditions, is manifest in speeches to his right wing think tank pals in the United States, and many publicly expressed disaffections with the country of his birth. Preaching for the end of the Canadian Social Democratic experiment, and rabble-rousing Red State righties is one thing when in opposition, but its quite another when sitting at the helm of the nation.

The first minister of the government must think beyond the political confines of his caucus, his party, and even too his closest supporters. It is the Prime Minister's duty to govern for the whole country, recognizing that not all Canadians share her vision. As the leader of all of Canada, the PM must respect both the subleties of the multi-cultural, mult-racial, pan-political nature of Canada, while too respecting its traditions

Fortunately, as with his political role models, Richard Nixon, and the George's Bush, Harper's inherent contempt for the popular will, and disdain of the precepts of democracy, will undo him too. Now, it's up to the marginalized media in Ottawa, and the rest of the country, (CanWest Goebbels excepted) to dispel Mr. Harper's facade, revealing to the citizenry the disaster he, and his Liberal Party supporters pose the nation.

We've all witnessed the terrible ascension of the killers of democracy these last awful years. The fall of decency at the apex of America, Britain, Australia, Canada, and a host of more minor collaborators, all utilizing the terrific, open-ended possibilities the 'War on Terror' provide to justify horrific abuses of power. The writing, writ large on the world's burgeoning new walls says: The battlefield is everywhere. The war is to preserve "our freedoms," etc.

http://www.pej.org/html/modules.php...=article&sid=4744&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0
 
fries with that?

Tragically_Glib said:
Looks like Harper is forging his relationship with the media using the Bill Davis handbook. Brampton Bill (one of the kinder names the press bestowed on him) escorted ;) Ontario through some of it’s most prosperous years,. Mr. Davis had a rather tumultuous relationship with the media often just ignoring them all together.
I remember Davis as a manipulator rather than an antagonizer of the press. He was an old-fashioned red Tory, good to business, but not, like the neo-cons, savagely antagonistic to the middle and working classes. The core misanthropy and paranoia of Mike Harris, Stephen Harper, and their American string-pullers was absent from Davis.

MW
 
maxweber said:
I remember Davis as a manipulator rather than an antagonizer of the press. He was an old-fashioned red Tory, good to business, but not, like the neo-cons, savagely antagonistic to the middle and working classes. The core misanthropy and paranoia of Mike Harris, Stephen Harper, and their American string-pullers was absent from Davis.

MW
Yes, I really liked him too.


.
 
scroll99 said:
Canada's First War President: All Hail Chief Harper

Fortunately, as with his political role models, Richard Nixon, and the George's Bush, Harper's inherent contempt for the popular will, and disdain of the precepts of democracy, will undo him too. Now, it's up to the marginalized media in Ottawa, and the rest of the country, (CanWest Goebbels excepted) to dispel Mr. Harper's facade, revealing to the citizenry the disaster he, and his Liberal Party supporters pose the nation.

We've all witnessed the terrible ascension of the killers of democracy these last awful years. The fall of decency at the apex of America, Britain, Australia, Canada, and a host of more minor collaborators, all utilizing the terrific, open-ended possibilities the 'War on Terror' provide to justify horrific abuses of power. The writing, writ large on the world's burgeoning new walls says: The battlefield is everywhere. The war is to preserve "our freedoms," etc.

http://www.pej.org/html/modules.php...=article&sid=4744&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0

When they're saying things like this about you, you really know you're going places. I predict a glorious future for Harper.
 
Truncador said:
When they're saying things like this about you, you really know you're going places. I predict a glorious future for Harper.

Agreed, when the pinko media and their friends get their panties in a knot you know you are on the right track.
 
Harper's media relations show 'selective accountability'

Prime Minister Harper’s refusal to answer to the media on his government’s Accountability Act is blatant hypocrisy, says MP Mark Holland, Ajax-Pickering.

“This is yet another example of the Prime Minister’s selective idea of accountability,” charges Holland, the Liberal Associate Critic for the Treasury Board. “He believes accountability applies to others, but not to him. The media plays an essential role in holding a government to account. For Mr. Harper to answer just two questions in the press conference on this major bill, and then to sulk off is inexcusable.”

Holland says it’s clear that Harper wants to control the media by choosing which reporters get access to him and limiting contact. At the news conference, the Prime Minister attempted to hand pick which reporters could ask questions in defiance of the tradition of letting the press gallery organize the questioners.

“This Prime Minister’s attitude towards the media is that of a tin pot dictator,” charges Holland.

The incident is by no means the first confrontation the Harper government has had with the media. Harper issued muzzle orders to cabinet ministers and senior officials, who now must clear their statements through the Prime Minister’s Office – referred to by some backbench Conservatives as “the Kremlin.”

Harper has also broken the tradition of announcing cabinet meetings to reporters in advance and allowing ministers to take questions afterwards. Now the meetings are held at secret times and locations.

Hostility to the media is endemic throughout the Conservatives, Holland notes, pointing to the example of Colin Mayes, the MP for Okanagan-Shuswap, who wrote a column saying members of the media who “twist information” should be “hauled off in handcuffs” to jail. Faced with negative publicity, Mayes issued a short statement withdrawing those remarks.

“I certainly support greater accountability in government,” says Holland, “but accountability must also apply to the Prime Minister. He needs to be accountable to the Canadian people through the media.”

http://www.markholland.ca/news/2006/060412harpermedia.htm
 
All of this is rather moot.

Harper obviously never heard the old saying: "Never pick a fight with someone who buys ink by the barrel."

It will come back to haunt him.
 
sometimes I think the only thing Harper has going for him (considering his childish behavior and do as a say not as I do ethics) is the way the media tries to degrade and villify him. with so many legitimate complaints that can be argued why go with the "he's gonna make us all American's!" route? it just makes the legitimate arguments seem equally silly.
 
Tragically_Glib said:
Looks like Harper is forging his relationship with the media using the Bill Davis handbook. Brampton Bill (one of the kinder names the press bestowed on him) escorted ;) Ontario through some of it’s most prosperous years,. Mr. Davis had a rather tumultuous relationship with the media often just ignoring them all together.

.

The Press should be ignored as much as possible. They always have an agenda and their agenda is to "get" the dirt or spin the story to suit the bias inherent in Leftist newsrooms.

Harper would be wise to continue telling the Ottawa crybabies to fuck off.

Posguy
 
The PM is copying George Bush's tactics with his allegation of `liberal media bias,' says Linda McQuaig

Despite being the longest-serving member of the White House press corps, Helen Thomas almost never gets to ask George Bush a question.

That's because Bush controls who asks the questions and he doesn't like the kind of tough, doubting questions that she asks. Given a rare chance recently, she pointedly asked him: If the Iraq war wasn't about oil, what was it about?

If Bush hadn't had such tight control over the media, his plan to invade Iraq might have come under the kind of public scrutiny it so badly needed.

Canadian prime ministers have traditionally been more accessible to the media, which has obliged them to submit to a basic level of public scrutiny. Stephen Harper wants to change this. Like Bush, he wants to select who gets to ask the questions.

Reporters who want airtime and prominence will quickly learn not to be like Thomas. They'll learn just to type down the Prime Minister's words.

Harper insists the Ottawa press gallery is biased against him. He's trying to use the allegation of "liberal media bias" just as Republicans use it to intimidate the U.S. media.

In reality, virtually all major Canadian media outlets are large corporations that view much of Harper's agenda favourably. The media co-operated with Harper's election strategy of presenting himself as a moderate, allowing him to shed his image as an ideologue who once headed the ultra-right National Citizens Coalition. The Globe and Mail helped him out right before the election with a banner front-page headline: "Harper says he's evolved."

Harper now accuses Ottawa reporters of taking on the role of opposition. In fact, they have simply been asking questions, including questions the Prime Minister might prefer not to answer.

This is essential. Although elected with a weak minority, Harper is taking the country in some radical directions. Who will hold him to account? The Liberals are leaderless and the NDP seem more focused on stealing ground from the Liberals than challenging Harper.

What this country needs is a whole press gallery full of doubting Helen Thomases.

Harper's unwillingness to submit to freewheeling media questions suggests an anti-democratic tendency.

His political views have been heavily influenced by Leo Strauss, a political philosopher at the University of Chicago who spawned the U.S. neo-conservative movement.

Strauss's ideas have been cultivated in Canada by the so-called Calgary school — a right-wing political clique at the University of Calgary — with which Harper and his mentor Tom Flanagan have long been associated.

Strauss was deeply suspicious of democracy. He argued that the public isn't capable of making intelligent political decisions, and so should be kept pacified rather than informed. The real decisions should be left to an elite.

With the elite making the decisions for a docile, dim-witted public, who needs the media — except to type down the Prime Minister's words?

http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/Co...842&call_pageid=968256290204&col=968350116795
 
Posguy said:
The Press should be ignored as much as possible. They always have an agenda and their agenda is to "get" the dirt or spin the story to suit the bias inherent in Leftist newsrooms.

Harper would be wise to continue telling the Ottawa crybabies to fuck off.

Posguy

Well this a good way to remain ignorant for the rest of your life. Leftist newsrooms, hmmm let see

1) Toronto Sun
2) The National Post
3) Global TV News
4) Any rag in Alberta

Get a grip - if it wasn't for the News media, right and left then we would be left to the tender mercies of the self serving, self richeous, left or right politician.

Real problem here for people like yourself and Mr. Harper is that your just wrong on most issues that are important to Canadians and can't handle the tough questions.

Hell Trudeau managed to deal with a media he found hostile - as did Clark and Mulroney - the point is that politicians in power don't want their activities looked closely at - that's the real issue here
 
I believe Harper...

is right on a lot of issues. The reason Trudeau did well with the media is that most of them fawned over him. I think Harper is a bit peeved with most of the media who had been taking shots at him. He could have handled it better. If I remember correctly, Martin and Chretien were also control freaks.


X