Harper: if you commit serious crime, you will do serious time ?

maryland

Banned
Nov 18, 2004
280
0
0
Ladies and gentlemen of the TERB species,


Harper just said:

If you commit serious crime, you will do serious time.


What did he refer to ?

1. TERBites and the poor French girls from Montreal ?

Does that qualify as serious crimes ?

I can only think of that as interpretation to Harper's comments.

Am I correct ?
 
During the last election, the CBC's Reality Check carried a discussion about crime and punishment. The costs of building more prisons and incarceration in general must be part of any discussion concerning mandatory sentencing. Here's why:

http://www.cbc.ca/canadavotes/realitycheck/crimetime.html

..."But there is a substantial difference in the cost of incarceration versus house arrest. In Ontario, it costs the provincial government approximately $1,600 a year to supervise an inmate under house arrest, double that if the inmate is being monitored electronically. That same inmate in a provincial jail would cost about $52,000 a year. The Conservative proposal to eliminate conditional sentencing for drug offences and those involving violence could put an additional 6,000 offenders every year behind bars. If they stayed there for a year, it would cost an extra $300 million just to incarcerate them.

The Conservative plan to increase mandatory minimum sentences by as much as six years will also add to significant increases in the cost of administering the federal criminal justice system. It costs Corrections Canada $110,223 to keep a male inmate in a maximum-security institution for a year ($150,867 for a woman). Medium- and minimum-security inmates cost more than $70,000 a year.

But that is not where the money stops. Federal and provincial institutions are already filled to capacity. The Conservative proposals would inevitably spark a wave of new prison construction, and prisons are not cheap to build. The last provincial jail built in Ontario was a "no-frills" superjail in Lindsay that cost almost $79 million in 2002, and is designed to house about 1,100 inmates. Constructing new jails just for the 6,000 inmates who would have previously been out under house arrest would cost Canadian taxpayers about $400 million. Would that investment make our communities safer? Most of the evidence indicates that the answer to that question is no."


BTW, the Reality Check series is an excellent source of information on most of the issues facing Canada. This series was part of Canada Votes 2006 so you have to search for it. But the articles are still there for the time being. Maybe the CBC is keeping it alive because they expect another election during 2006....
 
I'm concerned about the environment but I really hope Harper has the good sense to scrap the Kyoto accord. He probably won't because he only has a minority. Maybe he can stall it's implementation.

Kyoto is not about the environment. It's just a mega tax grab and a multi-billion dollar boondoggle.

Kyoto will be a huge disaster.
 
Slowpoke, since you’re so concerned about economics of law enforcement. What are the costs of keeping a murderer or a rapist on the streets? Maybe we should do a cost/benefit analysis and if it is cheaper just to let people murder each other, then we shouldn’t lock people up for murder.


The fear of punishment should be greater than the joy of the crime.

You’re also forgetting about the deterrent affect of punishment. Being soft on crime increases crime because potential felons have a lack of respect for the law. They expect they will get away with the crime and if they get caught, they will get a slap on the wrist and they’re back on the street.

I’m sure that the costs of incarceration could be reduced by getting rid of the spa days and stupid perks like that. Prison should be a place that one would want to stay out of.
 
It's interesting that Harper seems to be ignoring an increasing and perhaps greater problem, white collar crime. But I guess we shouldn't be surprised given all the investment bankers in his cabinet.
 
Cinema Face said:
Slowpoke, since you’re so concerned about economics of law enforcement. What are the costs of keeping a murderer or a rapist on the streets? Maybe we should do a cost/benefit analysis and if it is cheaper just to let people murder each other, then we shouldn’t lock people up for murder.


The fear of punishment should be greater than the joy of the crime.

You’re also forgetting about the deterrent affect of punishment. Being soft on crime increases crime because potential felons have a lack of respect for the law. They expect they will get away with the crime and if they get caught, they will get a slap on the wrist and they’re back on the street.

I’m sure that the costs of incarceration could be reduced by getting rid of the spa days and stupid perks like that. Prison should be a place that one would want to stay out of.

Hey! I've given you some information. Why don't you just read it? BTW, how can you say: "You’re also forgetting about the deterrent affect of punishment"? I haven't "forgotten" anything. I simply passed along some much needed information about this issue and my only comment was this: "The costs of building more prisons and incarceration in general must be part of any discussion concerning mandatory sentencing." Where am I claiming to have complete answers? I didn't even claim that I had all the facts so don't tell me I've forgotten anything. OK?

You've just stated:

"Being soft on crime increases crime because potential felons have a lack of respect for the law. They expect they will get away with the crime and if they get caught, they will get a slap on the wrist and they’re back on the street."

But the article I linked to says this:

..."Not surprisingly, mandatory minimum sentencing led to a dramatic increase in both the number of Americans incarcerated, and the cost of building and maintaining prisons in states where those laws applied. In 1999, approximately 6.3 million adults-3.1 per cent the U.S. adult population-were under correctional supervision (that is, incarceration, probation, or parole). Drug offenders accounted for 21 per cent of the State prison population in 1998, up from 6 per cent in 1980. That number continues to grow, despite an overall drop in the crime rate.

Many supporters of mandatory minimum sentencing point to the decrease in crime as proof that the program works. But several studies have cast doubt on whether these laws really keep hardened criminals off the street and deter others from committing crimes, and there appears to be no significant difference in crime rates in states with mandatory minimums and those without. Most experts attribute the falling crime rate to demographic and economic factors that have nothing to do with sentencing.

Serious questions have also been raised about the use of mandatory minimums as a weapon in the war on drugs. In 1993, U.S Supreme Court Justice William Rehnquist noted that mandatory minimum sentences tended to allocate scarce prison space to low-level criminals (the "mules" in the drug trade) rather than those higher up the chain of command. A study by the Rand Corporation concluded that minimum sentencing has done little to keep illegal drugs off America's streets, and that the money spent locking up people for drug possession and trafficking would have been better spent on treating drug users."...