Hamas Interior Minister DEAD

gryfin said:
One party has stolen and the other wants to reclaim what they own.

Are you referring to the Jews who had their propety stolen in 1948?

It's true they should be compensated but that is so long ago I think they've largely moved on, as anyone would.
 
gryfin said:
One party has stolen and the other wants to reclaim what they own.

Next?

So we agree the conflict is over money and a result of greed. Frankly who took what from whom is irrelevant unless you are a narrow minded militant. My comment is not on what history will show is a very small conflict, one of many in fact. Rather my comment is based on the whole of human history. Can you understand that or are you still pre-occupied with your little piece of sand?
 
elmo said:
So we agree the conflict is over money and a result of greed. Frankly who took what from whom is irrelevant unless you are a narrow minded militant. My comment is not on what history will show is a very small conflict, one of many in fact. Rather my comment is based on the whole of human history. Can you understand that or are you still pre-occupied with your little piece of sand?

On the contrary, the stealing of money, property or value is what's at the heart of conflict. Remove that and nothing can be understood. Human history cannot be understood.

It's why this conflict exists.
 
gryfin said:
On the contrary, the stealing of money, property or value is what's at the heart of conflict. Remove that and nothing can be understood. Human history cannot be understood.

It's why this conflict exists.

Wow do you ever read? You just said exactly what I said using different words. It's the act, not the responsibility that is important. The responsibility is only a matter of worthless opinion. Try to follow.
 
elmo said:
Wow do you ever read? You just said exactly what I said using different words. It's the act, not the responsibility that is important. The responsibility is only a matter of worthless opinion. Try to follow.

Again, to the contrary. You simply don't want to apply your analysis to the current situation. If you think that who took what from whom is irrelevant, then your theory has no value in allowing us to understand why the various parties respond as they do.

At some point x and y have to have values. Only then is it worthwhile.
 
gryfin said:
Again, to the contrary. You simply don't want to apply your analysis to the current situation. If you think that who took what from whom is irrelevant, then your theory has no value in allowing us to understand why the various parties respond as they do.

At some point x and y have to have values. Only then is it worthwhile.

Please do not presume to tell me what I want to do. The theory is solid without blame as it's the act, not the responsibility that is verifiable. Responsibility is always a matter of opinion. The reason the parties respond as they do is greed...someone else has something I want regardless of how they got it.
 
Well Gryf is half right. There are only two solutions here:

(1) People agree to move on and let bygones be bygones, after all it has been sixty fucking years, and there is nobody who was not hard done by, and the Palestinians by now have received billions and billions in compensation from the world for their losses.

(2) Some sort of big fund is set up to collect money from people who took property and give it to people who lost property

What Gryf does not want to acknowledge is that #2 is going to result in a net payment of money to Jews, but also it would result in a net payment of money to Palestinian Muslims as well.

What should happen more or less to make things right is this:

(1) Arab muslim nations make reparations to Israel for the ethnic cleansing of Jews since 1948, in theory including turning over to Israel large tracts of land representing the real estate they seized illegally from Jews during their purges and pogroms.

(2) Israel takes that land and turns around and makes reparations to Palestinian muslims for the land that was seized from them back in 1948.

Israel would in theory wind up with some extra land under this arrangement but I imagine Israel would be willing to forfeit that, and even give back land to it's 1967 borders, in exchange for a lasting peace.

The issue of couse is that the thiefs in other Arab nations are probably not going to agree to transfer land to Israel (or even to the Palestinian muslims that it should eventually go to).

You have a situation where Jews were forced out of their homes by Muslims, who then went and forced other Muslims out of their homes, as the Muslim and Jewish populations divided themselves into different areas whereas they had previously lived inter-mixed. It was bloody, vicious, and unfair to a lot of people, including BOTH to Israeli Jews and to Palestinian muslims.
 
elmo said:
Please do not presume to tell me what I want to do. The theory is solid without blame as it's the act, not the responsibility that is verifiable. Responsibility is always a matter of opinion. The reason the parties respond as they do is greed...someone else has something I want regardless of how they got it.

Blame is a concept you have introduced, it's not a word I've used. As for responsibility being a matter of opinion, well, again, that's a term you have introduced and used yourself.

I don't mind exchanging views with you, but don't expect me to accept criticisms for terms you have introduced yourself and you now find yourself unhappy with. I have not used these terms at all.
 
gryfin said:
Blame is a concept you have introduced, it's not a word I've used. As for responsibility being a matter of opinion, well, again, that's a term you have introduced and used yourself.

I don't mind exchanging views with you, but don't expect me to accept criticisms for terms you have introduced yourself and you now find yourself unhappy with. I have not used these terms at all.

Actually the concept of blame was the product of others, the parties involved, the media etc. I can't take credit for it. As for the exchange of views, I find the opinions of many posters quite similar, just the point of view seems to vary. You are of course free to accept or reject anything...as am I.
 
fuji said:
Well Gryf is half right. There are only two solutions here:

(1) People agree to move on and let bygones be bygones, after all it has been sixty fucking years, and there is nobody who was not hard done by, and the Palestinians by now have received billions and billions in compensation from the world for their losses.

(2) Some sort of big fund is set up to collect money from people who took property and give it to people who lost property

What Gryf does not want to acknowledge is that #2 is going to result in a net payment of money to Jews, but also it would result in a net payment of money to Palestinian Muslims as well.

What should happen more or less to make things right is this:

(1) Arab muslim nations make reparations to Israel for the ethnic cleansing of Jews since 1948, in theory including turning over to Israel large tracts of land representing the real estate they seized illegally from Jews during their purges and pogroms.

(2) Israel takes that land and turns around and makes reparations to Palestinian muslims for the land that was seized from them back in 1948.

Israel would in theory wind up with some extra land under this arrangement but I imagine Israel would be willing to forfeit that, and even give back land to it's 1967 borders, in exchange for a lasting peace.

The issue of couse is that the thiefs in other Arab nations are probably not going to agree to transfer land to Israel (or even to the Palestinian muslims that it should eventually go to).

You have a situation where Jews were forced out of their homes by Muslims, who then went and forced other Muslims out of their homes, as the Muslim and Jewish populations divided themselves into different areas whereas they had previously lived inter-mixed. It was bloody, vicious, and unfair to a lot of people, including BOTH to Israeli Jews and to Palestinian muslims.

That's two more solutions that I believe exist. I don't see any solution that would be permanent and binding...but hey...it's nice to dream isn't it?
 
elmo said:
So we agree the conflict is over money and a result of greed.

Sorry to disappoint y'all, but we do not agree on this.

This conflict is about a nation of people (or, depending on your viewpoint, TWO nations) who wish to live within safe, secure borders, without the constant threat of terrorism or rocket attacks hanging over their heads.

Lately, the conflict seems to have devolved into a finger-pointing argument over who broke the latest ceasefire.

Unfortunately for Hamas and its supporters, that point will be made moot, as Israel is intent on making sure that the terrorist faction in Gaza is no longer capable of smuggling in and using weapons against its populace.
 
Inferno said:
Sorry to disappoint y'all, but we do not agree on this.

This conflict is about a nation of people (or, depending on your viewpoint, TWO nations) who wish to live within safe, secure borders, without the constant threat of terrorism or rocket attacks hanging over their heads.

Lately, the conflict seems to have devolved into a finger-pointing argument over who broke the latest ceasefire.

Unfortunately for Hamas and its supporters, that point will be made moot, as Israel is intent on making sure that the terrorist faction in Gaza is no longer capable of smuggling in and using weapons against its populace.

You're right...we don't agree, but my comment was to Gryfin.
 
Gyaos said:
Fascism? Like forcing women to wear table cloths on their heads, not allow them to drive cars and vote, as well as massive fuck fests against their will? That's not Gazan fascism created by Ham-ass? Now you don't like the Egyptians? Tough. Learn to live with your neighbors which means Hamas surrenders or dies. I prefer the latter. Hamas dies.

Gyaos Baltar.


waiting for more of your intelligent well thought out discourse there Baruch keep going please, and could you refer us please as to what section of Gazan road and traffic laws forbid women from driving, we would love to know :D
 
scouser1 said:
waiting for more of your intelligent well thought out discourse there Baruch keep going please, and could you refer us please as to what section of Gazan road and traffic laws forbid women from driving, we would love to know :D

Why do your women wear tables cloths on their heads, against their will? Everywhere in Gaza, they are discouraged, sometimes killed. Super majority men. In Saudi Arabia, it's illegal. I think scouser1 and gryfin should do a tongue with each other. The President of Iran supports it.

May the bombing continue until every member of Hamas is killed.

Gyaos.
 
scouser1 said:
waiting for more of your intelligent well thought out discourse there Baruch keep going please, and could you refer us please as to what section of Gazan road and traffic laws forbid women from driving, we would love to know :D


I was unable to find any restrictions about women driving cars in Gaza. However, women are forbidden to drive in Saudi Arabia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_rights_in_Saudi_Arabia

Saudi Arabia's treatment of women has been likened by many to a system of apartheid, analogous to South Africa's treatment of non-whites during South Africa's apartheid era


In Saudi culture, there are severe restrictions upon a woman's freedom of movement. Most scholars and religious authorities have declared it haram (forbidden) for women to drive cars. The reasons women are forbidden to drive in Saudi are declared to be:
1. Driving a car involves uncovering the face which is considered obligatory for women to cover in Saudi.
2. Driving a car may lead women to go out of house more often.
3. Driving a car may lead women to have interaction with non-mahram males, i.e., they can be stopped by policemen at the scenes of traffic infractions.
4. Women driving cars may lead to overcrowding the streets and many young men may be deprived of the opportunity to drive.
There are other decrees that have affected women's mobility in Saudi Arabia:
1. It is forbidden for women to ride bicycles and motorbikes
2. It is forbidden for women to be alone in a car with a non-mahram man.
3. Segregated bus services are introduce.

The point is that nowhere in the Islamic world are women treated as equals.

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2872/is_2_28/ai_86049671/pg_1?tag=artBody;col1

Can’t blame Hamas for the draconian gender apartheid laws. That’s Islam.
 
Cinema Face said:
I was unable to find any restrictions about women driving cars in Gaza. However, women are forbidden to drive in Saudi Arabia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_rights_in_Saudi_Arabia






The point is that nowhere in the Islamic world are women treated as equals.

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2872/is_2_28/ai_86049671/pg_1?tag=artBody;col1

Can’t blame Hamas for the draconian gender apartheid laws. That’s Islam.


ahh the resident expert on Islam aka Cinema Face is right on the scene, and of course if you are losing an argument change the topic, can we please go back to talking about Israel's attempt at murdering as many Palestinians as possible, leave Saudi Arabia for another thread

The day that Zionism and Wahabbism, the two scourges of the Middle East disappear, party at my place :D