Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

I call bullshit. You are implying that terrorism is a valid choice.
Since you are the one who could not supply an alternative to terrorism, it is you who is showing that terrorism is the only choice of an oppressed people. Me, I've gone on record saying I'm against terrorism.


No, I pointed out that the report itself said that, something you tried to sweep under the rug.
Ok, then here's your chance. Tell me now that you believe that it is not acceptable that 10% of the children of Gaza are stunted due to malnutrition.

You should stop saying "shelling of a village", as it was actually "shelling of an army post", which happened to be in a village. Yes, if you shell an army post, you might injure people nearby, such is life.

Which is exactly why Israel kills proportionally more civilians then Hamas, and is therefore closer to fitting your definition of terrorists. Such is life.

Hamas does not target army posts with its inaccurate rockets. I realize they may have said that at some point, but they fire them off in directions where the aren't any army posts, and they celebrate when they kill civilians.

First, you admit that Hamas has said they are targeting army posts, as Israel says, so morally they are on the same footing here. Second, you've previously said it doesn't matter what they say, its the results. But by the results, Israel looks the worse. They continually kill more civilians.

I disagree. Hamas doesn't even try to hit legitimate targets.
You just said that Hamas has said they target legitimate sources. You're contradicting yourself.


You allege they were activists but you have no proof whatsoever that they were. The odds are they were armed militants. We don't know, but for you to go around accusing me of "suppring the killing of a teenager and a senior citizen" when you don't know whether or not they were actually criminals attacking soldiers shows what a propaganda clown you are.

Let's just say that most of the people who were killed were armed thugs attacking soldiers and we don't know for sure whether any innocent bystanders were killed at the same time.
That's the closest you've come to admitting that Israel could have killed innocent bystanders.
But for the record, I base my belief that the people on the flotilla were aid workers because that's what they said they were, they had aid they were bringing, at their own expense and they made sure they were fully inspected for weapons before they left.


Bullshit. Absolute bullshit. You KNOW that I went through the report in detail and refuted his most fundamental points. I can do it again anytime you like the flaws in that report are deep and fundamental.

The short story is his fundamental claim that civilians were targeted relies on broken logic, specifically, that he claims since HE doesn't know why a police station was targetted that this must mean IDF doesn't know either. That point is actually THE FUNDAME"NTAL CLAIM in his report that there were attacks on civilians, it's not some side point.

Of course you wouldn't know any of this because unlike me you haven't actually even fucking read the goddam report, you are just spouting off bullshit as usual.

I've read the report.
Goldstone gave Israel and the IDF a chance to defend themselves against any charges. Israel decided not to. Your defence is that the IDF must have had intel that would make a police station a 'legitimate' target. But you don't know, you are guessing. More importantly, according to your previously posted logic, its not the words that count, its the action. And the IDF clearly, by its actions, targeted multiple police stations.
Here's a quote from the Goldstone report (UNFFMGC_Report.pdf)
of the 1,387 Palestinians who were killed, ....248 were Palestinian police officers, most of whom were killed in aerial bombings of police stations on the first day of the operations.
and
It concludes, however, that the attacks against the police facilities on the first day of the armed operations failed to strike an acceptable balance between the direct military advantage anticipated (i.e. the killing of those policemen who may have been members of Palestinian armed groups) and the loss of civilian life (i.e. the other policemen killed and members of the public who would inevitably have been present or in the vicinity), and therefore violated international humanitarian law.

By both your own previous heinous logic and by the UN's use of international humanitarian law, Israel should be charged for war crimes. And you have actively supported the shelling of police stations?


This is a vague and bullshit claim you're making now, if you want to be refuted (and you will be) be specific. I will say that I have repeatedly criticized some of the settlements that Israel's built, but many of your other claims of ethnic cleansing and such are in fact bullshit claims that you can't support.
Since all of the settlements are in contravention of international law, I expect you to come out and say you are against all settlements.
And, as Gryphin has asked, if you are against ethnic cleansing as you say you are, I expect you to come out and say you support the right of return for Palestinian refugees.

You keep misrepresenting ONE quote, which you yourself failed to understand. Sorry but I'm not responsible for your stupidity. The quote you keep supplying says UNIFIL is responsible for the location of the line, NOTHING ELSE. You keep misrepresenting that as some sort of imaginary sovereignty over the area around the line, which is utter bullshit.

From the UNIFIL site:
UNIFIL is tasked with achieving the following objectives:
# Confirm Israeli withdrawal from southern Lebanon;
# Restore international peace and security;
Partial quote, there is more responsibilities there, but these are two of the relevant ones.

As usual, you are wrong to say that they are only responsible for the location of the blue line. And you are wrong to assume that Israel has no responsibility to honour UNIFL requests.


Israel plainly has some sort of control over Gaza, but it is short of occupation. Specifically, Israeli soldiers entering Gaza would be shot by Hamas, Israel plainly has limited control over events inside the territory. Hamas controls it.

Considering that the UN and just about every human rights organization on the planet refers to Gaza as part of the 'occupied lands of Palestine' you are clearly on thin ice here.


I stand by my statement.
You are a supporter of murder, war crimes and terrorism.
 
The travesty is that they were victims of a brutal and racist ethnic cleansing and that the people responsible are still maintaing that injustice. They are unwilling to have a country with the same values as Canada.

I agree, the Arab countries that invaded Israel were responsible for creating the vast majority of Palestinian refugees and have been maintaing that injustice, so that they can use the refugees as pawns against Israel, ever since.
 
You're conflating two different issues. I'll leave you to your stupid confusion, I've told you what I think, which is that very real wrongs were done to those people and they really do deserve some sort of restitution. I just don't that the destruction of Israel is the appropriate answer.

Only a zionist would consider equality as a threat to a country. Speaks volumes, doesn't it, Fuji Fromage?
 
I agree, the Arab countries that invaded Israel were responsible for creating the vast majority of Palestinian refugees and have been maintaing that injustice, so that they can use the refugees as pawns against Israel, ever since.

I see you are a follower of the Ernst Zundel school of historical methodology.
 
Since you are the one who could not supply an alternative to terrorism, it is you who is showing that terrorism is the only choice of an oppressed people. Me, I've gone on record saying I'm against terrorism.

I supplied you with a long list of possible alternatives for Hamas.

You do know that your constant lying and misrepresentation has caused an increasing number of people to put you on ignore? You may think you can win debates by lying and pretending you didn't hear what the other person said, but in reality, it just costs you your own credibility and causes people to ignore you--literally they are using the ignore feature of this board.

Ok, then here's your chance. Tell me now that you believe that it is not acceptable that 10% of the children of Gaza are stunted due to malnutrition.

I'm going to stand by saying that I think the WHO is a credible authority on this matter and I agree with the conclusions in the WHO report.

Do you think you know better than WHO?

Which is exactly why Israel kills proportionally more civilians then Hamas, and is therefore closer to fitting your definition of terrorists. Such is life.

No it does not fit my definition of terrorism. I have clearly stated on many occasions that it is not terrorism when civilians are killed incidental to an attack on a legitimate military target--like an army base.

You continue to ignore that statement at your own peril--people are going to come to see you as a fucking moron who can't read, can't comprehend, and isn't interested in the truth.

First, you admit that Hamas has said they are targeting army posts

Hamas are plainly lying about that, I've told you why. You KNOW why. Ignoring what either side says it is EVIDENT that Israel goes after legitimate military targets and it is EVIDENT that Hamas goes after civilians. We don't need to listen to what each side says, we can see what each side does.

You just said that Hamas has said they target legitimate sources. You're contradicting yourself.

Nope. I clearly said that I think Hamas is lying, and that what they do is target civilians. For example, the unarmed pregnant woman that they shot.

Your failure to comprehend and your inability to read is not my problem, it's yours.

That's the closest you've come to admitting that Israel could have killed innocent bystanders.

I've said that on practically every post on the subject. I have ALWAYS said that it's correct and proper that Israel killed the violent thugs on board that ship, and that I hoped no innocent bystanders were killed. I'm well aware that many of the people on that ship had clearly non-violent intentions and I see those people as victims of the violent thugs who infiltrated their group.

Just as you might kill some bystanders when you shell an army post, if you start firing off small arms on a crowded ship you might hit someone innocent.

Maybe he was an armed assailant. Maybe he was shot accidentally by IDF. Maybe he was shot accidentally by the Turkish thugs with the weapons they seized from their hostages.

But for the record, I base my belief that the people on the flotilla were aid workers because that's what they said they were, they had aid they were bringing

Some of them were but you are a fool if you think they all were, the video evidence is CONCLUSIVE, there is nothing to debate.

I've read the report.
Goldstone gave Israel and the IDF a chance to defend themselves against any charges. Israel decided not to.

Yes and unless you are a complete blithering idiot you recognize the difference between "decided not to" and "is guilty".

Your defence is that the IDF must have had intel that would make a police station a 'legitimate' target. But you don't know, you are guessing.

So is Goldstone and the principle that applies here is "innocent until proven guilty". Lack of information is not proof.

Q.E.D.

More importantly, according to your previously posted logic, its not the words that count, its the action. And the IDF clearly, by its actions, targeted multiple police stations.

Yes they clearly did. Why did they target those police stations? What intelligence did they have? Were the police stations actually full of Hamas militants? Or not? What did IDF know, or think it knew?

Unless you know the answer to those questions--which Goldstone explicitly admits he does not know--you CANNOT draw any conclusions as to whether it was a war crime. The MOST you can state is, "requires further investigation" because you lack proof of some of the essential elements of the crime.

Since all of the settlements are in contravention of international law, I expect you to come out and say you are against all settlements.
And, as Gryphin has asked, if you are against ethnic cleansing as you say you are, I expect you to come out and say you support the right of return for Palestinian refugees.

I don't know that this is true. Do settlements in Hebron contravene international law? What if it's Jewish people returning to homes they were ethnically cleansed from. Does that contravene international law? If so how do you ever justify a right of return for anyone on either side, is it only acceptable for Palestinians to return?

It's my view the settlements should be stopped and that in some cases they are clearly illegal. It's not clear in every case though and the issue is significantly more complex than you let on.

From the UNIFIL site:

I agree with your UNIFIL site that it is responsible for confirming Israeli withdrawl. What has that got to do with what Israel does on Israeli territory? NOTHING.

As usual, you are wrong to say that they are only responsible for the location of the blue line. And you are wrong to assume that Israel has no responsibility to honour UNIFL requests.

If UNIFIL requested them to leave Lebanese territory, sure, but UNIFIL cannot and does not have any say over what Israel does on its own side of the line. Unless UNIFIL claims that Israel crossed the line Israel is free to do ANYTHING it pleases.


Considering that the UN and just about every human rights organization on the planet refers to Gaza as part of the 'occupied lands of Palestine' you are clearly on thin ice here.

Again it's a practical reality that Israel does not exercise control over Gaza. Its soldiers would be shot by Hamas if they attempted to do that. That's just a fact.

On the other hand I agree with the ICRC that since Israel controls the borders of Gaza it has a responsibility to ensure an adequate flow of goods.

So plainly Israel has some responsibility there, but it is not complete responsibility over everything that happens inside Gaza, because Israel simply has no control over that.
 
Only a zionist would consider equality as a threat to a country. Speaks volumes, doesn't it, Fuji Fromage?

You're confused. The Palestinian refugees are not citizens of Israel. Why would non-citizens be entitled to equality with citizens?
 
You're confused. The Palestinian refugees are not citizens of Israel. Why would non-citizens be entitled to equality with citizens?

Oh, but they are. They were ethnically cleansed.

It's only zionists who are stopping them from returning to their homes.

The milk of human kindess seems to be based on ethicity to you.
 
Even some Israeli soldiers can't stomach this anymore. You won't see any zionist organization revealing this story. A 19 year old sports reporter on Israeli Army Radio lays responsibility for the Hebron deaths at the feet of the racist settlers:

"For sure they don’t murder those who are innocent. Only those who burn their fields and slaughter their sheep…
You [the settlers] don’t build [settlements] because they murder [a reference to the price tag policy which proclaims new outposts in response to acts of Palestinian terror]. They murder because you build. Keep building and they will keep murdering. Just don’t come to us with claims that the occupied ["conquered"] and robbed people lacking human rights seeks to battle against you on its land."

http://www.richardsilverstein.com/t...in-a-twist-over-new-idf-facebook-controversy/
 
No they weren't. Their grandparents were. That's different.

No, they are. The UN supports it. It is recognized in international law.

Also, you should too, shouldn't you?

If we enforce your definition (without regard to ethnicity or religion), then almost no Jews have a right to go to Israel. But they do, because Israel enforces an racist citizenship policy.
 
I don't know that this is true. Do settlements in Hebron contravene international law? What if it's Jewish people returning to homes they were ethnically cleansed from. Does that contravene international law? If so how do you ever justify a right of return for anyone on either side, is it only acceptable for Palestinians to return?

That has to be one of the most racist lines of reasoning I've read on here. Do you seriously believe that because a jew owned something it is the right of any other jew to have it. That it then becomes the collective property of jews?

This line of reasoning is the reasoning of the most racist and hateful zionists. You read it everywhere as a justification by settlers. And now you espouse it. What an incredibly primitive outlook on people and humanity.
 
That has to be one of the most racist lines of reasoning I've read on here. Do you seriously believe that because a jew owned something it is the right of any other jew to have it. That it then becomes the collective property of jews?

Is it therefore your position that there is no "right of return" for Palestinians, in cases where their original property no longer exists?
 
No, they are. The UN supports it. It is recognized in international law.

It's wrong. It makes no sense that there is one set of rules for Palestinians, and a different set of rules for everybody else in the world. It's stupid, and it's wrong.


If we enforce your definition (without regard to ethnicity or religion), then almost no Jews have a right to go to Israel. But they do, because Israel enforces an racist citizenship policy.

Nope. Countries have the right to set their own immigration policies.
 
You mean Paramilitaries don't you? The settlers have more than 500,00 guns.

So do Canadians and Americans, but just because someone has a gun at home that doesn't make them a legitimate military target. To be a legitimate military target you have to be organized into a militia and currently actively participating in it.
 
I'm going to stand by saying that I think the WHO is a credible authority on this matter and I agree with the conclusions in the WHO report.

So you still support policies which have lead to 10% of the children of Gaza to suffer permament damage from malnutrition?
By the way, there is a report saying that in the 60% of the West Bank controlled by Israel, things are even worse then Gaza. So much for the 'if only they didn't elect Hamas' argument.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2010/06/201062916845576597.html


I have clearly stated on many occasions that it is not terrorism when civilians are killed incidental to an attack on a legitimate military target--like an army base.
...... We don't need to listen to what each side says, we can see what each side does.

Here's where I can't understand your total lack of logic on this matter.
Yes we can see what each side does, and according to the records, Israel kills proportionally more civilians.
Israel has infinitely better weapons and intelligence, yet Hamas manages to still avoid killing civilians better then Israel.
Your argument that Hamas targets civilians more then Israel, certainly in light of the Goldstone report, is blatantly wrong.

I have ALWAYS said that it's correct and proper that Israel killed the violent thugs on board that ship, and that I hoped no innocent bystanders were killed. I'm well aware that many of the people on that ship had clearly non-violent intentions and I see those people as victims of the violent thugs who infiltrated their group.

You have repeatedly said that you believe that Israel only killed militants. When confronted with the knowledge that one of the people killed was a 19 year old high school student, shot four times in the head, and another a 61 year old electrician, shot four times, you stuck with your story, that it was 'correct and proper' that they were killed. You are only now admitting the possibility that Israel killed innocent bystanders faced with how both ludicrous and sick you sound.


So is Goldstone and the principle that applies here is "innocent until proven guilty". Lack of information is not proof.

Goldstone has never implied they are 'guilty until proven innocent'. I thought you said you read the report? He said that to the best of his research, Israel violated international law and should be tried for war crimes. He did not pronounce guilt and assign a sentence. He only recommends that they, along with Hamas, should be tried for war crimes.

Unless you know the answer to those questions--which Goldstone explicitly admits he does not know--you CANNOT draw any conclusions as to whether it was a war crime. The MOST you can state is, "requires further investigation" because you lack proof of some of the essential elements of the crime.

No, the most you can state is, given the evidence found, it is worth pressing charges, as Goldstone recommends.


I agree with your UNIFIL site that it is responsible for confirming Israeli withdrawl. What has that got to do with what Israel does on Israeli territory? NOTHING.
When the area in question is in 'disputed territory' where its on record that there is 'confusion' over the borders, Israel is under a duty to respect UNIFIL's requests.


On the other hand I agree with the ICRC that since Israel controls the borders of Gaza it has a responsibility to ensure an adequate flow of goods.

So plainly Israel has some responsibility there, but it is not complete responsibility over everything that happens inside Gaza, because Israel simply has no control over that.

Israel is responsible as the occupier under international laws. There are no qualifications on that.

You are still a supporter of war crimes, murder and ethnic cleansing.
 
So you still support policies which have lead to 10% of the children of Gaza to suffer permament damage from malnutrition?

If the WHO says that's acceptable that's what I think too--I'm just going to go with whatever the WHO says, which seems to be that the WHO thinks it's acceptable.

Here's where I can't understand your total lack of logic on this matter.
Yes we can see what each side does, and according to the records, Israel kills proportionally more civilians.

Which is irrelevant. You plainly don't understand the law in this case. I've explained it to you repeatedly, I'm rapidly coming to the conclusion that you are simply too dumb to understand.

Here's your last chance, if you don't at least show that you are grappling with the right issues I'm going to ignore your further responses on this topics on the grounds that you are too stupid to be worth talking to:

What matters is (a) what you were trying to hit and (b) whether you tried to do it in a way that minimized casualties.

It doesn't matter how many Israelis versus how many Palestinians were killed. What matters is in each action independently of all other actions how are those two questions answered?

Your argument that Hamas targets civilians more then Israel, certainly in light of the Goldstone report, is blatantly wrong.

Nope.

You have repeatedly said that you believe that Israel only killed militants. When confronted with the knowledge that one of the people killed was a 19 year old high school student, shot four times in the head, and another a 61 year old electrician, shot four times, you stuck with your story, that it was 'correct and proper' that they were killed. You are only now admitting the possibility that Israel killed innocent bystanders faced with how both ludicrous and sick you sound.

I believe that Israel only shot at armed militants. I don't know who killed these people--could have been killed by the Turks. Could have been killed accidentally by IDF, but is by far most likely that they were shot by IDF intentionally because they were armed aggressive thugs.

Goldstone has never implied they are 'guilty until proven innocent'. I thought you said you read the report? He said that to the best of his research, Israel violated international law and should be tried for war crimes. He did not pronounce guilt and assign a sentence. He only recommends that they, along with Hamas, should be tried for war crimes.

Yes he did. He clearly implied guilty until proven innocent. He said he didn't know why they attacked the police station and therefore he assumed they were guilty. It's retarded and incredibly biased, but then, that's Goldstone--he's a biased individual, the report was NEVER going to be fair. He has a long history as an anti-Israeli activist nobody expected him to write a fair report.

No, the most you can state is, given the evidence found, it is worth pressing charges, as Goldstone recommends.

So now you are backing off the claim that a war crime was committed, and only saying that MAYBE one was?

I agree that it would be useful to have some more investigation into the matter--but not conducted by someone like Goldstone, conducted by someone unbiased, who goes in with a presumption of innocence.

Just to clear the air really, I don't believe any crime will be uncovered, I would fully expect there were good reasons to target that police station--like perhaps all the "police" in it were really Hamas militants. I don't know, but I bet IDF knows why they decided to attack that target.

When the area in question is in 'disputed territory' where its on record that there is 'confusion' over the borders, Israel is under a duty to respect UNIFIL's requests.

The area in question was not disputed territory. UNIFIL has said so.

Israel is responsible as the occupier under international laws. There are no qualifications on that.

I disagree.