Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

You have repeatedly tried to justify it. You say things like, Hamas has no other alternative, and all settlers are valid military targets. You're a disgusting worm who justifies terrorism.

No, I've asked what alternatives they have. That is not justifying terrorism they way you justify murder, ethnic cleansing and 'crimes against humanity'.
When you and Basketcase say they have alternatives, but refuse to list or talk about them without resorting to calling me a terrorist, it just solidies the case that there is no policy that can bring peace for Gaza.


When I quoted the UN report about stunting, you said you agreed with the UN, that 10% of children Gaza being stunted was acceptable. Nice try taking that back.
I can bring back the reports on food insecurity and malnutrition, if you like.

You supported the shelling of a village. If Israel's weapons are not accurate enough to hit just the army post, and they apparently aren't since there are reports of damage and injury to civilians including the mayor, then they are no more justified in shelling the village with innacurate weapons then Hamas is in using their innacurate rockets. Israel is as guilty as Hamas for use of innacurate weapons in populated areas.

You supported the killing of a teenager and a senior citizen who you 'allege' were militants, and you have no proof to back this belief. Until Israel releases all video footage they've stolen, that's the best you can do.

You have only accused Goldstone of bias, you have not seriously countered any of the conclusions in his report. You are just whining. When shown reports, like the 71 page report on White Phosphorous, you just ignore them and continue whining about bias.

You have never once come out and said Israel's slow process of ethnic cleansing and turning into an apartheid state is wrong. I know you'll just deny that its happening, but will you come out and say ethnic cleansing is wrong, and say apartheid is wrong? Until that happens, you are implicitly supporting these policies.

As for UNIFIL, you repeatedly stated that Israel is not bound to honour any requests from UNIFIL, despite given quotes to the opposite.
You squirm and squiggle to avoid admitting that the Gaza strip is an occupied land, as it is called by the UN, in order to try to avoid honouring the Geneva Conventions.
You ignore calls for Israel to honour UN resolutions, acting as if Israel is above the law.

You, sir, are a supporter of terrorism, ethnic cleansing and war crimes.
 
Hey flub in your opinion which of those things you listed is as reprehensible as what Hamas did?

Mock air raids, in your opinion, equal to shooting pregnant women?

Oh yeah, mock air raids that were in direct response to an act of war as Lebanon, and were meant to demonstrate what would happen if Lebanon did not cease their attacks.

Most of the rest of what you wrote is bullshit and/or grossly misrepresented by you.
This has been discussed ad nauseum, Of course what Hamas did was disgusting. So was Israelis invasion of Gaza(13 israelis killed, mostly soldiers, 1300 Gazans killed, mostly civilians) and the Israeli blocade of Gaza. I dont pretend to know what the solution is(except for a single state), but I do know that the continued Israeli encroachment on Palestinian lands will be a peace plan killer.

Fuji, do you for a minute believe that israeli force is going to solve this problem?? What will happen when there is a truly independent iraq(without 50,000 American "advisors" It is most assuredly in Israel's interest to solve this problem before that happens.
 
Nope.



You have repeatedly tried to justify it. You say things like, Hamas has no other alternative, and all settlers are valid military targets. You're a disgusting worm who justifies terrorism.



I don't think you're capable of following logic.



I don't believe that.



It's the WHO that believes that, you provided the link to the report that said so, remember?



I do support that: It was a reasonable and essentially non-violent way to demonstrate to Lebanon the likely futile consequences of continuing with its acts of war.



Correction, shelling an army post in a village.

This is why I call you a propaganda clown: Even after you know the truth of a situation you continue misrepresenting it.



Nope, I only support the killing of militants who attack soldiers.



The Goldstone report has no credibility whatsoever and should be ignored by thinking people.



I've never done that.



I've never said that.



Nope, though you have repeatedly shown you fail at understanding those rules. You haven't got the first foggiest clue about any of those things. You really know nothing.

Unless you support the right of return regardless of religion or ethnicity, you most certainly support ethnic cleansing.
 
No, I've asked what alternatives they have. That is not justifying terrorism

I call bullshit. You are implying that terrorism is a valid choice.

When I quoted the UN report about stunting, you said you agreed with the UN, that 10% of children Gaza being stunted was acceptable. Nice try taking that back.

No, I pointed out that the report itself said that, something you tried to sweep under the rug.

You supported the shelling of a village. If Israel's weapons are not accurate enough to hit just the army post, and they apparently aren't since there are reports of damage and injury to civilians including the mayor

You should stop saying "shelling of a village", as it was actually "shelling of an army post", which happened to be in a village. Yes, if you shell an army post, you might injure people nearby, such is life.

What's your suggestion, don't shell army posts? Rubbish.

then Hamas is in using their innacurate rockets

Hamas does not target army posts with its inaccurate rockets. I realize they may have said that at some point, but they fire them off in directions where the aren't any army posts, and they celebrate when they kill civilians.

You have been told this REPEATEDLY, stop sweeping it under the rug.

Israel is as guilty as Hamas for use of innacurate weapons in populated areas.

I disagree. Hamas doesn't even try to hit legitimate targets.

You supported the killing of a teenager and a senior citizen who you 'allege' were militants, and you have no proof to back this belief. Until Israel releases all video footage they've stolen, that's the best you can do.

You allege they were activists but you have no proof whatsoever that they were. The odds are they were armed militants. We don't know, but for you to go around accusing me of "suppring the killing of a teenager and a senior citizen" when you don't know whether or not they were actually criminals attacking soldiers shows what a propaganda clown you are.

Once again you show yourself ready to jump to conclusions when it makes Israel look bad, but when there's any doubt about the other side you deny anything until you're confronted with proof, at which point you hide.

Let's just say that most of the people who were killed were armed thugs attacking soldiers and we don't know for sure whether any innocent bystanders were killed at the same time.

You have only accused Goldstone of bias, you have not seriously countered any of the conclusions in his report.

Bullshit. Absolute bullshit. You KNOW that I went through the report in detail and refuted his most fundamental points. I can do it again anytime you like the flaws in that report are deep and fundamental.

Unfortunately that post has expired off the forum, but I went through section by section and outlined what was wrong with it.

The short story is his fundamental claim that civilians were targeted relies on broken logic, specifically, that he claims since HE doesn't know why a police station was targetted that this must mean IDF doesn't know either. That point is actually THE FUNDAME"NTAL CLAIM in his report that there were attacks on civilians, it's not some side point.

Of course you wouldn't know any of this because unlike me you haven't actually even fucking read the goddam report, you are just spouting off bullshit as usual.

You have never once come out and said Israel's slow process of ethnic cleansing and turning into an apartheid state is wrong.

This is a vague and bullshit claim you're making now, if you want to be refuted (and you will be) be specific. I will say that I have repeatedly criticized some of the settlements that Israel's built, but many of your other claims of ethnic cleansing and such are in fact bullshit claims that you can't support.

As for UNIFIL, you repeatedly stated that Israel is not bound to honour any requests from UNIFIL, despite given quotes to the opposite.

You keep misrepresenting ONE quote, which you yourself failed to understand. Sorry but I'm not responsible for your stupidity. The quote you keep supplying says UNIFIL is responsible for the location of the line, NOTHING ELSE. You keep misrepresenting that as some sort of imaginary sovereignty over the area around the line, which is utter bullshit.

Again, this is just your stupidity and inability to read.

You squirm and squiggle to avoid admitting that the Gaza strip is an occupied land

No, I'm accurate: Israel plainly has some sort of control over Gaza, but it is short of occupation. Specifically, Israeli soldiers entering Gaza would be shot by Hamas, Israel plainly has limited control over events inside the territory. Hamas controls it.

How many times do I need to correct your propaganda? Maybe YOU will pretend I haven't shown you to be a fool but everyone reading this can see it, they all have eyes to see. You can go on denying the truth but you only make yourself look stupid.
 
Hamas does not target army posts with its inaccurate rockets. I realize they may have said that at some point, but they fire them off in directions where the aren't any army posts, and they celebrate when they kill civilians.

I disagree. Hamas doesn't even try to hit legitimate targets.

What, are you trying to win the "I'm the naivest bunny on the block" Award, Fuji Fromage?

Hamas routinely targets military installations but the Israeli's will never admit that a Hamas rocket hit an installation or even came near it for fear of giving them targeting information. But, on the other hand, Israel has no problem giving Hamas targeting information about schools and daycares. Israel routinely announces when a Hamas rocket lands near a school or a playground. Yet, despite this targeting information, Hamas rarely strikes any of these targets. That must mean they are not aiming at them.
 
Keep on lying Gryfin. If that were true they wouldn't celebrate in the streets when they kill a civilian or call the murderers of a pregnant women heroes.

They are disgusting people, and so are you for supporting them.

After all you DO support the killing of Israeli civilians by Palestinians.
 
Keep on lying Gryfin. If that were true they wouldn't celebrate in the streets when they kill a civilian or call the murderers of a pregnant women heroes.

They are disgusting people, and so are you for supporting them.

After all you DO support the killing of Israeli civilians by Palestinians.

Can we also assume you are in support of the right of return for Palestinians, since you don't support ethnic cleansing?
 
After all you DO support the killing of Israeli civilians by Palestinians.

Nobody, other then you, has ever said they support the killing of anyone.
You called the killing of a 19 year old high school student and a 61 year old electrician, 'correct and proper'.
 
Can we also assume you are in support of the right of return for Palestinians, since you don't support ethnic cleansing?

I'm curious, gryfin, do you support a right of return for the 850,000 Jews (http://www.hsje.org/forcedmigration.htm) that were forced out of Arab countries?

Also curious to know what your views are on how Palestinians refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated by the host countries? Would you agree that the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated as pawns by the Arab countries? Would you not agree that it is a travesty of human rights and justice that Arab countries have denied the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, the even most basic of human rights and the ability to become productive members of society in those countries?
 
I'm curious, gryfin, do you support a right of return for the 850,000 Jews (http://www.hsje.org/forcedmigration.htm) that were forced out of Arab countries?

Also curious to know what your views are on how Palestinians refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated by the host countries? Would you agree that the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated as pawns by the Arab countries? Would you not agree that it is a travesty of human rights and justice that Arab countries have denied the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, the even most basic of human rights and the ability to become productive members of society in those countries?

Perhaps you should not take such sites at face value. Here's a first hand account by an Oxford Professor as he reviews Michael Gilbert's "In Ishmael’s House: A History of the Jews in Muslim Lands". He himself is one of the individuals you reference.

Here's a sample:

"In the course of this war, the name Palestine was wiped off the map and 726,000 Palestinians became refugees. In its wake, around 850,000 Jews left the Arab world, mostly to start a new life in the newborn State of Israel. For Gilbert, these Jews are simply the other half of the “double exodus” and he persistently refers to them as “refugees”. With few exceptions, however, these Jews left their native lands not as a result of officially sanctioned policies of persecution but because they felt threatened by the rising tide of Arab nationalism. Zionist agents actively encouraged the Jews to leave their ancestral homes because the fledgling State of Israel was desperately short of manpower.

So, unlike the Palestinians who were driven out of their homes, we were not refugees in the proper sense of the word. But we were truly victims of the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Despite all its shortcomings, Gilbert’s book is an illuminating and a moving account of the history of the Jews in Arab lands. But he is psychologically hard-wired to see anti-Semitism everywhere. The picture he paints is consequently unbalanced.

By dwelling so persistently on the deficits, he downplays the record of tolerance, creative co-existence and multi-culturalism in Muslim lands which constitutes the best model we have for a brighter future."

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/8ae6559c-b169-11df-b899-00144feabdc0.html
 
Nobody, other then you, has ever said they support the killing of anyone.
You called the killing of a 19 year old high school student and a 61 year old electrician, 'correct and proper'.

You're unfamiliar with the history around here, but it's been apparent on many threads that in fact Gryfin really does actively and positively support the killing of Israeli civilians by Palestinians.

To wit: Gryfin if you disagree feel free to deny it. Do you support the killing of Israeli civilians by Palestinians? I'll take your silence as a resounding yes.
 
Can we also assume you are in support of the right of return for Palestinians, since you don't support ethnic cleansing?

I support some sort of reconciling of the harm done to people by the ethnic cleansing done on both sides in the 1940's and 1950's. I don't think that the correct answer is a new big migration of people, but I think both the Palestinian and the Jewish victims of ethnic cleansing in that war are owed something for the harm that was done to them.
 
Nobody, other then you, has ever said they support the killing of anyone.
You called the killing of a 19 year old high school student and a 61 year old electrician, 'correct and proper'.

I called the killing of armed thugs who were attacking Israeli soldiers correct and proper.

It's likely that includes those two, it remains possible that they were innocent bystanders caught in the crossfire.
 
Perhaps you should not take such sites at face value. Here's a first hand account by an Oxford Professor as he reviews Michael Gilbert's "In Ishmael’s House: A History of the Jews in Muslim Lands". He himself is one of the individuals you reference.

Here's a sample:

"In the course of this war, the name Palestine was wiped off the map and 726,000 Palestinians became refugees. In its wake, around 850,000 Jews left the Arab world, mostly to start a new life in the newborn State of Israel. For Gilbert, these Jews are simply the other half of the “double exodus” and he persistently refers to them as “refugees”. With few exceptions, however, these Jews left their native lands not as a result of officially sanctioned policies of persecution but because they felt threatened by the rising tide of Arab nationalism. Zionist agents actively encouraged the Jews to leave their ancestral homes because the fledgling State of Israel was desperately short of manpower.

So, unlike the Palestinians who were driven out of their homes, we were not refugees in the proper sense of the word. But we were truly victims of the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Despite all its shortcomings, Gilbert’s book is an illuminating and a moving account of the history of the Jews in Arab lands. But he is psychologically hard-wired to see anti-Semitism everywhere. The picture he paints is consequently unbalanced.

By dwelling so persistently on the deficits, he downplays the record of tolerance, creative co-existence and multi-culturalism in Muslim lands which constitutes the best model we have for a brighter future."

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/8ae6559c-b169-11df-b899-00144feabdc0.html

Also curious to know what your views are on how Palestinians refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated by the host countries? Would you agree that the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated as pawns by the Arab countries? Would you not agree that it is a travesty of human rights and justice that Arab countries have denied the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, the even most basic of human rights and the ability to become productive members of society in those countries?
 
So, unlike the Palestinians who were driven out of their homes, we were not refugees in the proper sense of the word. But we were truly victims of the Arab-Israeli conflict.

You're naive. Jewish homes were burned, people were massacred, property seized, people were stripped of their rights, beaten in the streets, forced out of their homes. That some of them were simultaneously proud to help found a new country in Israel does not in any way lessen the crimes committed against them in Arab countries.

Not all of them went to Israel, either, quite a lot of the Jewish refugees from Arab countries fled to Europe and America.

As for people fleeing because they were encouraged to by their leaders rather than because of persecution that was true on BOTH sides: Zionists encouraged Jews to flee to Israel, but simultaneously you had Arab leaders encouraging Palestinians to flee Jewish controlled territory. At the time the Arab leaders thought they were making a statement, that anyone who accepted Jewish rule was treasonous to the Arab cause. It turned out to be a big blunder but at the time that's what they said and did.

So a good number of Palestinians left Israel not because of persecution, but because of the urgings of Arab leaders, just as many Jews migrated to Israel at the urging of Zionists. It's also true that there were massacres and persecutions committed by both sides during that war, so it's a mix of people fleeing outright persecution, and people following the urgings of political leaders, on BOTH sides.

It's a remarkably similar story on both sides actually, except for what happened later--Israel integrated its refugees, Arabs ostracized them.
 
I support some sort of reconciling of the harm done to people by the ethnic cleansing done on both sides in the 1940's and 1950's. I don't think that the correct answer is a new big migration of people, but I think both the Palestinian and the Jewish victims of ethnic cleansing in that war are owed something for the harm that was done to them.

In other words, you don't support the right of return for Palestinians, but you do support automatic citizenship and entry for Jews who ever never been their or have no relationship other than having the righ religion.

So, you support the zionist version of ethnic cleansing. More Fuji Fromage.
 
In other words, you don't support the right of return for Palestinians, but you do support automatic citizenship and entry for Jews who ever never been their or have no relationship other than having the righ religion.

So, you support the zionist version of ethnic cleansing. More Fuji Fromage.

No, Gryfin, I mean what I wrote, not what you wrote. I think what was done to people back then was wrong, and that some restitution is in order. I just disagree with you on WHAT restitution is in order.

You in your hatred insist on restitution that would amount to the destruction of Israel because as a hateful person that's what you want. Me, I merely want wrongs righted and people made whole for what they lost.
 
Also curious to know what your views are on how Palestinians refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated by the host countries? Would you agree that the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, have been treated as pawns by the Arab countries? Would you not agree that it is a travesty of human rights and justice that Arab countries have denied the Palestinian refugees, and their successive generations, the even most basic of human rights and the ability to become productive members of society in those countries?

The travesty is that they were victims of a brutal and racist ethnic cleansing and that the people responsible are still maintaing that injustice. They are unwilling to have a country with the same values as Canada.
 
No, Gryfin, I mean what I wrote, not what you wrote. I think what was done to people back then was wrong, and that some restitution is in order. I just disagree with you on WHAT restitution is in order.

So, you don't believe that those who were ethnically cleansed should have the right of return but you don't have any problem with any quantity of migration if it's done by Jews going to Israel. Ethnicity is the deciding factor for you in whether they should have the right of return.

Again, the zionist version of ethnic cleansing. More Fuji Fromage.
 
So, you don't believe that those who were ethnically cleansed should have the right of return but you don't have any problem with any quantity of migration if it's done by Jews going to Israel.

You're conflating two different issues. I'll leave you to your stupid confusion, I've told you what I think, which is that very real wrongs were done to those people and they really do deserve some sort of restitution. I just don't that the destruction of Israel is the appropriate answer.