Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

There you go again--justifying terrorism. You are disgusting, repulsive, and morally bankrupt.
Are acts of war that target civilians and acts of terrorism that target civilians equally morally bankrupt? If not then why not?
 
There you go again--justifying terrorism. You are disgusting, repulsive, and morally bankrupt.

And you are an idiot.
How am I justifying terrorism.
Basketcase said Hamas has other choices, I'd like to hear what they are.
 
Why the rockets? Because Hamas are terrorists, obviously.

The rockets aren't terrorism, according to your very own definition.
According to Hamas they aim them at army posts. But because they are home made tin can rockets, they're not very good.
But give them a break, Fuji, they're doing the best they can. Now it would be terrorism, according to your rules, if they aimed them at civilians, but they don't. So they're not terrorists, only poorly armed fighters.


I of course think shooting rockets at anyone is wrong, and think shooting chemical weapons even worse.
 
And you are an idiot.
How am I justifying terrorism.
Basketcase said Hamas has other choices, I'd like to hear what they are.

There you go again, justifying terrorism. Again. Of course they have other choices besides shooting innocent pregnant women you worm.
 
The rockets aren't terrorism, according to your very own definition.

They're meant to kill civilians.

According to Hamas they aim them at army posts.

That's utter bullshit, they throw street parties when they kill children and there are army posts within easy reach of Hamas if they wanted to attack a legitimate target.
 
Why the rockets? Because Hamas are terrorists, obviously. And since when does the Israeli military blend with civilians????

They are all over Israel. If Israel was as efficient at killing the Hamas rocketeers as you claim there would be no rockets. But they are not, and the rockets keep flying, and they get bigger and more powerful as time goes on....
 
They're meant to kill civilians.



That's utter bullshit, they throw street parties when they kill children and there are army posts within easy reach of Hamas if they wanted to attack a legitimate target.

No point in attacking the border posts, they are small targets, gotta go after the bases. What Hamas is doing is called "interdiction" in military terms. Since they do not have pin point accurate weapons, they only means to attacking Israels war fighting infrastructure is through mass attacks. You can't really complain about it. Israel has the best weapons available yet they cause huge amounts of civilian casualties when attacking hamas targets.

Here is a pic of some Israeli collateral damage.

http://www.notmytribe.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/gaza-buried-child-casualty.jpg
 
I'd like you to list some of their other choices please.
Lets start with peace - that's a no go because the US and Netanyahu have excluded Hamas from the latest peace talks

Why do you keep repeating this garbage? The only reason Hamas isn't at the peace talks is because they refuse to accept peace with Israel.
How about attacking soldiers - well, the soldiers aren't in Gaza anymore, can't do that
How about attacking the wall - well, they can't get within 1500m without being shot by automated guns
How about getting a day pass so they can get out and attack some army posts - well, they aren't allowed out of Gaza very easily, that's no good.
How about aiming their missiles at army posts - well, their homemade tin can missiles have no guidance systems or range, so maybe they are already and just can't hit anything with them

The rest of this post fails the smell test simply because of the first point. HAMAS REFUSES TO MAKE ANY LASTING PEACE WITH ISRAEL. It is their choice to take violence over peace. If Hamas was willing to accept a permanent peace with Israel, Israel would have no excuse but to make peace (and Netanyahu wouldn't have been elected in the first place).

Accept it. Hamas targets civilians because they want to target civilians.


How about protesting peacefully - well they do that regularly, but they still get shot at
When was the last time Hamas protested peacefully? Their movement is based completely on violent resistance.

How about a voluntary one sided ceasefire - they did that for the last year, didn't help much, did it
Oh, you mean the 'ceasefire' where rockets were still fired from Gaza on a regular basis?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_rocket_attacks_on_Israel,_2010
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rocket_and_mortar_attacks_in_Israel_in_2009
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rocket_and_mortar_attacks_in_Israel_in_2009

Ok, Basketcase, what would you suggest Hamas do?
Quite simple. They need to accept the fact that they can't destroy Israel and sit down to negotiate a peace deal.
 
...
According to Hamas they aim them at army posts. But because they are home made tin can rockets, they're not very good.....

If you believe this, I have a bridge to sell you.

It might do both you and notty some good to read this report.
http://www.hrw.org/node/84868
None of these rockets can be reliably aimed. Under international humanitarian law applicable to the fighting between Palestinian armed groups and the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), such weapons are inherently indiscriminate when directed towards densely populated areas. The absence of Israeli military forces in the areas struck by the rockets, as well as statements from the leaders of Hamas and other armed groups, indicate that many of these attacks are deliberately intended to strike Israeli civilians and civilian structures. Individuals who willfully authorize or carry out deliberate or indiscriminate attacks against civilians are committing war crimes.

To say that Hamas does not target civilians is an outright lie.
 
They are all over Israel. If Israel was as efficient at killing the Hamas rocketeers as you claim there would be no rockets. But they are not, and the rockets keep flying, and they get bigger and more powerful as time goes on....

So, you were trying to use this as an excuse for Hamas using human shields. I'd like you to shed some light on when you think it's acceptable to use human shields, apparently you think that it is somehow a good idea for Hamas to put innocent Palestinians in harms way. Can you elaborate?
 
No point in attacking the border posts, they are small targets, gotta go after the bases

Going after the border posts is legitimate. Shooting pregnant women is not.

No-one said Hamas get to win the war, they're probably going to lose. Losing the war does not mean you get to switch and target civilians. Have the fucking good graces to surrender with your honour intact, or find a way to carry the fight to the enemy.

By the way, if Hamas is actually trying to hit military basis and the only reason they hit civilians is inaccuracy, then answer me a few questions:

1. Why do they fire off rockets in directions where there are only civilians and no military targets?

2. Why do they celebrate in the street when they kill a civilian?

3. Why do they send gunmen to shoot pregnant women?

The plainly target civilians you have to be pretty fucking stupid not to see that. That's why so many nations have at this point recognized that Hamas is a terrorist organization.
 
Absolutely. I bolded the key word.
When Iraq's infrastructure was bombed and then the country was put under UN sanctions, who was targeted?

Did the participants really expect that Saddam Hussein would be the first to starve or suffer dysentery?
 
When Iraq's infrastructure was bombed and then the country was put under UN sanctions, who was targeted?

Did the participants really expect that Saddam Hussein would be the first to starve or suffer dysentery?

Infrastructure is a legitimate target, power, communications, trasportation systems are all legitimate targets. Hospitals, schools, shopping malls, places of worship are not legitimate targets, setting up weapons in such areas to make use of the non target status makes them targets.

As to Hussiens welfare , the hope was that he would get to emulate Musselini in 1945
 
It might do both you and notty some good to read this report.
http://www.hrw.org/node/84868

Hey Basketcase, congratulations for looking at Human Rights Watch, maybe there's hope for you.
And since you're willing to accept their work, I'm sure you'll be happy to support their call to enforce the results of the Goldstone report, including charges of war crimes on both Hamas and Israel. Correct?

And for ending the blockade as well, I'm sure you'll happily support that as well.
 
When Iraq's infrastructure was bombed and then the country was put under UN sanctions, who was targeted?

The military and the infrastructure necessary to sustain it were what was bombed.

As for the UN Sanctions, they were a nice try, and it was worth trying, but they were carried on for YEARS longer than they should have been. I have always advocated that Iraq should have been invaded much, much earlier. If it was going to happen sooner or later, sooner's better than later as the way it was done merely lengthened the suffering of civilians.

However there's a huge gulf between the sanctions being tried too long and a war crime--never attribute to malice what can be attributed to stupidity.
 
Hey Basketcase, congratulations for looking at Human Rights Watch, maybe there's hope for you.
And since you're willing to accept their work, I'm sure you'll be happy to support their call to enforce the results of the Goldstone report, including charges of war crimes on both Hamas and Israel. Correct?

And for ending the blockade as well, I'm sure you'll happily support that as well.

Absolutely I do.

The only problem is that until Israel can be reasonably sure that Hamas will stop attacking Israeli civilians, I doubt they plan to give Hamas the chance.
 
Is it your view that war has to be fair? You're weird.

It depends on the context of fairness. What of the fairness in war on civilians? All civilians? Is the large disproportionate number of killed Pal. civilians compared to Israel, an unfairness you have no problem with? If it is, who's weird here? I have a big problem with this. And its my main beef here. All civilian lives are equal no matter which side they're on. Killing many to save a few is not treating civilian lives equally. Israel targets Hamas with the full knowledge that large numbers of civilians will be killed. But its Pal. civilians. If that was Israeli civilians instead you can be sure those targets would be treated differently. When Hamas targets Israel they hit civilians. Its disgusting. But Israel has knowingly killed civilians too and far more and with little remorse. Is it because those civilians are on the other side? War is hell and fairness is rare, but in times of war the lives of ALL civilians should be treated with fairness.
 
Not sure what your point is. My point is that Hamas has viable military targets. My point's been proven while you seem to be off topic.

And I'm saying Hamas has few viable military targets to attack. The kidnapping resulted in a terrible loss on Gaza. It resulted in Israel invading, bombing civilian infrastucture and killing 100 or so Palestinians. Is that your idea of a meaningful success? My point is proven. Yours is not.