Hackland Removes 'Current Term' Reference: Expensive By-Election Probable

Anbarandy

Bitter House****
Apr 27, 2006
11,918
4,664
113
Rob Ford eligible to run in by-election

Toronto Star Published 11 minutes ago
Robyn Doolittle Urban Affairs Reporter


In a huge victory for the administration Mayor Rob Ford is eligible to run in a by-election.

Justice Charles Hackland has agreed to remove a portion of his decision that suggested Ford would be ineligible until 2014.

This news came in a conference call with lawyers for both parties acting in the conflict-of-interest case Friday morning.

Constitutional lawyer Clayton Ruby could not immediately be reached for comment.

In his 24-page decision, Hackland said that Ford must vacate his seat, but there should be no further ramifications “beyond the current term.” On Friday, Hackland agreed to leave out the reference to a term, which city solicitor Anna Kinastowski told council she believes the term ends in 2014.

Ford’s legal team will face an appeal court early in the New Year. Next week, Ford’s lawyer, Alan Lenczner, will ask for a stay of Hackland’s ruling until the appeal is settled. A decision is expected within a month.

If Ford’s appeal is unsuccessful, city council will decide whether to appoint a caretaker mayor or hold a by-election.

The Fords favour a by-election, although a contingency plan is in the works.

On Monday, Hackland’s ruling sent shockwaves through city hall. The mayor has a little more than a week left in office without a stay. Hackland found Ford violated municipal conflict-of-interest legislation when he spoke to and then voted on an item that financially benefitted him.
 
Sorry to hear this. Looks like you might need to ask Ceiling Cat about a new computer


smoking_computer.jpg

1500 plus posts versus 12,000 plus posts.

I believe the shoe more deservedly fits thee, not I.
 
But mine are on more than one subject!

And most of mine are trying to be funny! Not very successfully, evidently, but I assure you most of the time I'm trying to make jokes! Like the smoking picture. You do look fetching in the purple top doncha think?

So are mine.

I have quite a posting and review history in the Toronto SC and MP forums. And afterall, that would be the main driving force behind the the establishment and continued existence of Terb.

I post about what I believe I am most well versed in; that being Stripclubs and their gals, Massage Parlours and their gals; the City of Toronto and it's adminstrative, service delivery and political machinations; and of course the lout that pretends to be mayor.

You won't see me venturing into 'unested' waters as you would see so many other un-named posters.
 
Because the vote was to have him take his own money out of his pocket and pay it back to the donors.

So that means there should have been a vote to have Kyle Ray pay back the $15k of public money he used for his retirement party?

oops...I just remembered, there was no conflict of interest vote requested by the integrity commission on that one.
 
Hey, I'm with you and molsoncanadianeh.

There are people who wanted to get rid of Ford and took this opportunity to do so.

Yep..plain and simple, they said they would get rid of him and they did. It's ford's fault for not using common sense in his defense. Still I'm not sure that anyone could have withstood this onslaught. The fucking star is still going on and on. They have Ford in every section...even sports...lol.
 
Sorry to hear this. Looks like you might need to ask Ceiling Cat about a new computer

You do look fetching in the purple top doncha think?

smoking_computer.jpg

Hahaha... LMAO!!!


Yep..plain and simple, they said they would get rid of him and they did. It's ford's fault for not using common sense in his defense. Still I'm not sure that anyone could have withstood this onslaught. The fucking star is still going on and on. They have Ford in every section...even sports...lol.

I know, it's fun watching their blood boil isn't it. :D

Rob Ford eligible to run in by-election

Yeah, against Shelley Carroll. LOL
 
This is the part I still can't quite comprehend. How does 3 grand to a charity benefit Rob Ford financially in any measurable way? I think he will win on appeal.
That was never the issue. What the guy did wrong was ask for donations from City Hall lobbyists, for his charity—which is operated at arms-length to prevent that sort of thing—and to make it worse, he used his official letterhead, the same letterhead on which lobbyist's boss might get the news that his donation had scored him a big contract. Like a teacher squeezing a co-ed's ass, it may have been a momentary lapse and no harm done, but we can't trust people in authority who think that sorta thing is ok. Especially when they still don't get it.

The piddly amount was what Ford couldn't find, when Council tried to help him make the whole thing go away, if he'd just return the money. Mr. Millionaire said the charity had spent it, and he wouldn't come up with it. Of course a donation from Mr Ford's pocket to the charity was unthinkable, and clearly stopping the drain on his pocket by letting the City buy his business cards and envelopes like every other Councillor but him never crossed his mind. He was too busy trying to save himself the dough to see anything else.

What Hackland's clarification now does is silence the 'democracy should prevail over a judge' noise. Anyone who actually believes it should be clamouring for that by-election. Unless, of course, what they really meant was 'right or wrong, the guy I picked should stay'. Since he can run, there's no reason to wait for another judge or two in an appeal court to frustrate the will of the people.
 
It's gonna be really fuckin funny when he wins again! And after all those who want to challenge him step down from Council, there will be by-elections for their spots and the school board trustees who run for the council spots will have to have by-elections for their spots. All for a few thousand dollars. Well done Toronto! LMFAO
 
Ah, no, asking for modest contributions to charity on your way out the door is not akin to sexual harassment. Very poor moral equivalency skills OJ.

Your post wreaks of self-righteous indignation. Separate your disdain for the individual from the act- he raised 3 grand for a high school football team! No financial benefit to him. No conflict. He certainly shouldn't be required to repay it- he got nothing out of it. Had he said 'hey, give my label company $100,000 in business and maybe we can help out your client", well, that's a conflict.

High School Football is not.

Check your bias at the door. It crowds the room.
Sorry, but Rob was handed a textbook, and offered a seminar on conflict of interest, not just once, but repeatedly, and like the teacher, he formally promised he would conduct himself with scrupulous integrity. Then he sat down at his desk, pulled out his City of Toronto Council letterhead, looked up the name and address of a guy whose whole business purpose is to get City contracts and asked him for money. Not a bit like a 'by the way…' as you go out the door. Not even slightly.

Rob's argument—and yours—that it was trivial is exactly like the lustful teacher, saying his grope was. Could be, but since we only get to find out the squeeze became an exploitive affair after the damage is done, even 'just a little squeeze' is forbidden. As Rob well knew. To imagine him stupid enough not to know, after multiple elections, and warnings is beyond even the most anti-Ford partisan. A learned judge, after all the evidence and clever arguments decided he was wrong.

You and I may take our different oinions of the right or wrong of that to our graves, but Rob is a high official in government, and governments and the people in them must play by the rules, which includes abiding by the decisions of those appointed to judge. Just like the referee on the football field. And so far every single decision has gone against him. He did wrong.

He can stretch the process through appeals as long as he wants (no appeals in football) and deprive us of a full-time Mayor while he does. He might even at last be exonerated. However, I'd bet all he can get, at the very most is 'you were wrong just as Judge Hackland said, you stubbornly ignored the rules and the easy option to end the matter and wasted your time and the City's. But the penalty would be too costly for the City, and you can keep your job. Although you thought the $3,000 was important enough for all this fuss and too much for you to find and pay, this Court says that's stupid. It was trivial.' That would still leave Rob in the wrong, even if it also left him Mayor.

And a good bit of post-decison scotch in chambers afterwards will hopefully wash the bitter taste of uttering those words away. But I hope, because righteous indignation is my middle name, that the appeal court simply says, 'no grounds'.

Then we can get the matter done with, either with Act 2 of the clown show, or a new Mayor. After all, an appeal court saying a wrong-doer can stay in office is just as anti-democratic as a judge saying the wrong-doer must go.
 
Your post wreaks of self-righteous indignation. Separate your disdain for the individual from the act- he raised 3 grand for a high school football team! No financial benefit to him. No conflict. He certainly shouldn't be required to repay it- he got nothing out of it. Had he said 'hey, give my label company $100,000 in business and maybe we can help out your client", well, that's a conflict.
Molson, as I understand it, the size of the donation wasn't the issue here. Rather, it was the way it was done, solicited on Ford's own City Hall letterhead. As OJ explained, and you ignored, a donor had reason to believe that making a donation would improve their chances on city contracts. It's true that the donations didn't go directly to Ford, but they did go to a charity that he indicated was important to him. We can debate whether there was any impropriety there, but you have to admit that there was the appearance of impropriety.