Greece

I am not sure that they would be out of the EU, maybe just out of the common currency. Greece could refloat the Drachma, which would quickly slide into a collapse in value. This would possibly be followed by severe inflation and a significant reduction in the standard of living for most Greeks. However, that would be a good thing for the Greek government. They could pay back debt for pennies on the dollar. This is really their only reasonable course of action. If they stay in the Euro the whole currency is probably threatened. The European Central Bank is not a real central bank. It has no treasury and fewer powers than a real cb would have. They will probably have to kick Greece out to save the currency. (If it can be saved. A famous economist once predicted when the Euro was launched that it would not survive its first serious crisis.)

The current state of affairs is unsustainable. Greece continues to borrow. It's citizens avoid taxes where possible. It has far more national holidays than other European nations. Civil servants can retire at 57 on a generous pension and its workers are relatively unproductive. It has been living off of borrowed money for some time and the bill is now coming due. And the Greeks don't want to pay it. They're screwed.

And through it all, they've been around for what 4,000 years?

I somehow doubt that they are going to sink into the sea.

Never the less, they need to do a serious overhaul of how they do business.
 
No, they are not screwed. They played this game before. I read in the papers a couple of weeks ago, that since they won independence from the Ottoman Turks 200 years ago, they have declared bankrupcy 4 or 5 times. They know how to game the system. Next question, what about the rest of the PIGS?

Are you going to loan them money next time? Germany won't want to.

You make it sound as if they can just go bankrupt and stiff the money lenders at no cost. If a country has a major sovereign debt default there will usually be inflation and devaluation of the currency, probably higher unemployment and a reduced standard of living for some time during the process. The poor and working class of the country will fare poorly for quite a number of years as much of peoples savings will be wiped out. Pensioners will be hurt the most. It will be quite painful but the country and the people will still exist at the end of it.
 
The Dutch city of Rotterdam with a population of just over 600 thousand contributes more to the EU budget than Greece does. That tells you how important that country is to the EU.
 
Police find huge cache of explosives hidden by terrorists in Greece. Is Greece now just another "failed state"?
 
Originally Posted by Mia.Colpa said:
Merkel did an about face, now she says Germany will loan money to Greece at a lower than market rate, damn, sure screwed me, I have been short the Euro for weeks and looking for it to go to 1.30 US, now it jumped up to over 1.3650 today on her surprise annoucement, that really hurt.


It's trending down again below 1.36. I think as the other nations will want their aid package also you will see the Euro dropping again.

Euro hovers around 1.33 again

People I know in Greece are telling me that they are taking money out of Greece and into Greek Cyprus for safety. I don't know why, but that is what some people are doing now.
 
Heard there was a 24 hour strike by public sector workers in Greece to-day. Wonder if that country would be better off if they didn't have a public sector?
 
Actually you're correct in that Greece is about to screw the world up the arse, if they fall economically. The world is going to be GREEKED royally.

You are actually not too far off here.

btw, I feel sorry for the Greek people. They have been accustomed to avoid (cheat) on paying taxes for decades. It's in their culture, it is a way of life and they don't particularly see
anything wrong with it, especially if everybody is doing it. They also were oblivious to the consequences.
The problem is that the government has let it gone on for too long and are now screwed. They are now trying to clamp down with draconian measures, too late.
 
Euro hovers around 1.33 again

People I know in Greece are telling me that they are taking money out of Greece and into Greek Cyprus for safety. I don't know why, but that is what some people are doing now.

The Euro just broke 1.27, it's crashing!!! Don't know where the end is, it's just ugly, great for a European vacation if you don't get caught in riots.

Reason people are moving their money out of the country is that the Greek banks have been downgraded and they have no confidence that the government can insure their money, so they fear losing their money.
 
If the EU forced Greece onto its own currency, then the government would be facing instant financial collapse of the countries economy.

I'm not sure I agree with this. I think the problem is in part that they have not had their own currency.

If they had their own currency the effect of their policies over the past twenty years or so would have been massive inflation of their currency. Instead of reaching a crisis point, as they have now, their buying power in the would would have been progressively eroded by inflation of their currency. They would have been forced to change their ways by their lack of buying power--but it would have happened gradually and the adjustment would be easier for them to make. Investors in greek debt would be just as screwed as now--the inflation would devalue the debt, which amounts to the same loss in value in the long run as a default, just slower and presumably easier to manage.

Now if they switched to their own currency today it would be different--the pent up crisis would result in an instant devaluaing of their currency which could be pretty destabilizing, rather than the long slow slide they would have had if they'd had a currency of their own all along. However it's not clear to me that a sudden devaluation is actually worse than simply running out of Euros--which is what is happening to them now since their economy is not large enough for their problems to significantly inflate the Euro.

If no-one bails them out they simply run out of cash, at which point they'll start out defaulting on their debt, but if they're still running a deficit after that at some point they also run out of Euros to make payroll and provision basic services. It seems to me that's far worse than hyper inflation.
 
They would have been forced to change their ways by their lack of buying power--but it would have happened gradually and the adjustment would be easier for them to make. Investors in greek debt would be just as screwed as now--the inflation would devalue the debt, which amounts to the same loss in value in the long run as a default, just slower and presumably easier to manage.

So it would be better to have a slow death rather than a quick one????:eek:
 
If they had their own currency the effect of their policies over the past twenty years or so would have been massive inflation of their currency. Instead of reaching a crisis point, as they have now, their buying power in the would would have been progressively eroded by inflation of their currency. They would have been forced to change their ways by their lack of buying power--but it would have happened gradually and the adjustment would be easier for them to make. Investors in greek debt would be just as screwed as now--the inflation would devalue the debt, which amounts to the same loss in value in the long run as a default, just slower and presumably easier to manage.

Any solution will result in a significant decrease in the standard of living in Greece. Bankruptcy has a way of doing that to people. Fiscal responsibility may suck, however it does give a more consistent standard of living.

The results of psychological studies are interesting. People respond well to inflation, because you don't actually take money away from them. As such, the best option for Greece would be to have never entered the "Euro-Zone." It is too late for that option now, because eliminating the Euro would lead to an immediate hyper-inflationary collapse in the Greek currency.

If you are going to have a correction, as it looks like will happen in Greece, then the psychological studies say to "make it sharp and quick." This can either be implemented by either legislation, or by an external force like a hyper-inflationary collapse of the currency. The advantages of the "sharp and quick" approach are:
1. People are adapted to natural disasters. We can handle calamitous events. Also, if the cutting is over, then you can look forward to rebuilding.
2. For businesses, and for future financial planning, it is necessary to have a stable regulatory and financial environment. If all the drastic changes are over quickly, it is easier to rebuild.
3. Some people are naturally profligate, and are used to "ups" and "downs". These people are used to sharp downturns in their standard of living.
4. Other people like planning and order, and will hate the cuts. However, if the cuts are quick, then they can start planning and assembling a "order" in their lives again.
5. For the adaptable, and the people that like change, it does not really matter how the cuts are made.

Businesses are aware of the above, and that is part of the reason why money is fleeing Greece, and why the S&P has downgraded Greece's debt to junk status.
 
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article7118458.ece

The Greek Parliament has passed a crucial austerity Bill to raise taxes, cut pensions and attempt to stop national debt spiralling as thousands of protestors massed outside the building.

The vote in favour of the stringent measures was needed to secure £93 billion in loans from the International Monetary Fund and other European states and came the day after similar protests turned violent, resulting in the deaths of three people.

A simple majority of 151 voted in favour, enabling the Bill to pass through the 300-member Parliament. The governing Socialist party has 160 seats, but three of its deputies abstained.

Greek workers say that the conditions of the three-year rescue package, which will result in £30 billion of cuts to public spending, are too severe and are designed to make the most vulnerable pay for the errors of the rich.

Salaries will be slashed by 25 per cent for civil servants, pensions will also be reduced and the age of retirement increased.

Demonstrations against the cuts turned violent yesterday and three people, including a pregnant woman, were killed when a petrol bomb was thrown into a bank.

The bank workers, two women and one man, died in the blaze. Their deaths were the first in protests in Greece for 20 years.

As the vote was returned protesters remained peaceful this afternoon.

In a heated debate before the vote, the Prime Minister and Finance Minister said the rescue package was the only hope for the country to avoid bankruptcy.

“Today things are simple. Either we vote and implement the deal, or we condemn Greece to bankruptcy,” George Papandreou, the Prime Minister, said.

The rescue loans are aimed at containing the debt crisis and keeping Greece’s troubles from spreading to other countries with vulnerable state finances such as Portugal and Spain.

Fears of Greek default have undermined the euro, and while the current package should keep Greece from immediate bankruptcy its long-term prospects are unclear. Its growth prospects are weak and the population’s willingness to accept cutbacks may wane, leading some economists to predict debt restructuring.

George Papaconstantinou, the Finance Minister, said that the Government had no choice but to impose the austerity measures, which were being rushed through Parliament as urgent legislation because the country was two weeks away from default, with $8.5 billion worth of bonds maturing on May 19.

“The state’s coffers don’t have that money,” Mr Papaconstantinou said. “Because today ... the country can’t borrow it from the international market. And because the only way for the country to avoid bankruptcy and suspension of payments is to take the money from our European partners and the International Monetary Fund.”

It seems that one of the main reasons Greece has a problem is the Greek aversion to paying taxes. How will increased taxes cure this?
 
What are these protesters after? Retribution for their own mistakes? Or is it the fact that the rich once again come out better than the poor? These measures HAVE to pass, or Greece goes into depression. Protesting is just hurting everyone now. Time to buckle down or hit the road.
 
EU is going to get fucked in the ass and they deserve it - Greece was in bad shape when they let them in. The EU was a good concept - a type of 'United States' with a common currency and the removal of the trade barriers to make an economic power house similar to the US. It's when they stated bringing in the cancer economies that things went south. The US is not a great ticket now but I doubt their largest holder of their debt - China- will let them go under. :-)
 
Greek debt/GDP ratio is around 100% Japan debt to GDP ratio is 170%!!!! Of course the Japanese finance their own debt through a high savings rate, but this is becoming less and less sustainable. If Japan implodes.. MAN!! That would be UG....LY!!! In case you think that is impossible.. the yen has been quitely falling as pressure increases on Japans fiscal pressure. Britain is also a real basketcase.. not that much better then Greece. Spain has much lower debt to GDP, but it has 20% unemployment!!!! some HUGE risks out there.
 
Greek debt/GDP ratio is around 100% Japan debt to GDP ratio is 170%!!!! Of course the Japanese finance their own debt through a high savings rate, but this is becoming less and less sustainable. If Japan implodes.. MAN!! That would be UG....LY!!! In case you think that is impossible.. the yen has been quitely falling as pressure increases on Japans fiscal pressure. Britain is also a real basketcase.. not that much better then Greece. Spain has much lower debt to GDP, but it has 20% unemployment!!!! some HUGE risks out there.

Canada's debt/GDP ratio is worse than the US. I think it was 78% in 2009. But no one seems that concerned about our debt, probably because the other factors contributing to our ability to pay off the debt are strong.
 
It appears that the EuroZone countries have put up $40billion to bail out Greece. (BTW I don't think Greece is too big to fail.)

With the world economy so intimately intertwined, let Greece fail and there will be another world wide economic melt down. There will always a Greece without a bust. Visiting Greece will always have a place in history. LOL!!!
 
I feel sorry for the Greek people. They have been accustomed to avoid (cheat) on paying taxes for decades.

Hey, does this mean that if the Greeks move to Canada they can avoid taxes here because it is part of their culture and we must be culturally sensitive?